Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask school to not let DD choose friends for this?

162 replies

FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 13:43

DD is 8, Y4.

She has a medical condition which means when it’s cold, or damp or she has a mild cold she has to stay inside in the warm or she can’t walk due to the pain or if she falls she could seriously damage her legs.

This is all documented in an EHCP and in the schools own Individual Education Plan (which runs alongside the EHCP and basically tells the school day to day whose doing what and when).

Obviously, the last few months due to it being winter it’s been extremely cold, or very wet. Some days she goes to lunchtime clubs but these don’t run everyday so on days when she can’t go on the playground without a club she’s allowed to choose up to 2 other children from the class to stay inside with her – the teacher encourages her to choose different children each time but theres only around 5 children in the class she considers a friend, so those 5 children are rotated between in either different pairings or 1 at a time – although often those children volunteer themselves to stay inside (which I don’t blame them for when it’s freezing outside!).

Others in the class have caught onto this, and when it’s been very cold have been asking DD to choose them. I am fine with this as is the teacher who has encouraged DD to branch out with friends but she always wants one of these 5 whether she chooses someone else from the class or not – these are not necessarily the 5 children she sits with at school but ones a relative of hers (from her dad’s side) and the rest are various friends who she does out of school activities and goes the parties of.

Some of the parents whose DC don’t get regularly chosen by DD have also caught onto it, and have tried to become friends with me/DD and when that’s not worked, they’re now saying that DD “is the teachers favourite” and that everyone should be given the same chance to be inside and they will say it loudly as they walk passed us or ask their child loudly “So who did the teachers favourite choose to stay in with her today?” It’s getting awkward for DD and she’s now trying to go outside even when school or I deem it unsafe (I am allowed to email school and say I don’t think the conditions are appropriate for playground time today and they keep her inside).

Obviously if she can be on the playground DD is on it and as we go into spring and summer she’ll be on it more often than she is inside, but she did spend most of Autumn term 2 and all of Spring Term 1 inside, this is a safeguard for both DD and the school because apparently if she has a serious fall or injury when they knew about her condition it’s a legal minefield. So I now want to ask school to stop letting DD chose a friend and instead let those friends volunteer, or ask them to do a rota with the whole class so DDs not allowed but everyone gets a fair chance to be inside.

WIBU to ask this? Or are these other solutions?

This has come up again today as school have called me to say she wants to go out in the snow but they don’t believe she did so kept her inside.

OP posts:
Abraxan · 10/03/2023 21:28

But someone must be supervising the children outside - why can't they move inside with the children ?

When outside we can have 3 members of staff supervising 180 children playing out for 15 minutes, stood in strategic positions around the playground to allow for us to see the whole space between us.

You can't put all those children into just 3 or 4 classrooms for 15 minutes to play, the rooms, not even the hall, are big enough. It would take double the staff. More if they could choose inside or outside.

Obviously when it's a wet break duty we do have to cover it the best we can but this doesn't happen very often and it often means staff losing their break time.

JennyDarlingRIP · 10/03/2023 21:20

As a parent surely you would assume there is a good reason a particular child has to stay in. Or amazes me none of them have put two and two together and actually come up with 4. It's logical that this isn't just teachers picking favourite FFS! I'm sure there are plenty of times your daughter would love to be outside running about but can't.
If DS asked me why does Johnny stay in at lunchtime, I'd say there must be a good reason, we don't need to know everything about everyone. The fresh air is good for you, so don't worry about not being inside.
That would be the end of it.

ASundayWellSpent · 10/03/2023 21:13

Have only read the first page, but as a parent of a girl the same age, and also as a teacher: no, they don't need to be told the reason behind it. I teach slightly younger children and they are perfectly capable of understanding that "fair means that everyone gets what they NEED in order to be successful, not that everyone gets the same." They need to suck it up, let your DD get on with her day and they get on with theirs. If its that cold that they are freezing then thats a school problem, not a problem for you or your DD

saraclara · 10/03/2023 21:10

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/03/2023 20:57

Get some auxiliary staff in specifically to cover breaks.

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

a) where is the money going to come from?

b) where are those people going to come from, who are going be prepared to travel into work to cover and be paid to supervise a 15 minute morning break and then go home again?

This has to be one of the most ridiculus suggestions I've ever seen on Mumsnet

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/03/2023 21:05

Abraxan · 10/03/2023 20:59

Get some auxiliary staff in specifically to cover breaks.

And the funding for this comes from where?
School budgets are already incredibly tight and schools are running in empty as it is. They can't afford to pay for extra staff to cover children not wanting to be outside because it's a bit cold or wet.

We need a government who are committed to funding education properly.

But someone must be supervising the children outside - why can't they move inside with the children ?

Abraxan · 10/03/2023 20:59

Get some auxiliary staff in specifically to cover breaks.

And the funding for this comes from where?
School budgets are already incredibly tight and schools are running in empty as it is. They can't afford to pay for extra staff to cover children not wanting to be outside because it's a bit cold or wet.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/03/2023 20:58

Nobody needs more details than that. Reality it will be news for a day or two then everyone will move on.

No, it won’t. Not with people being a dickish as they currently are.

It’ll continually come up, be dissected and discussed until everyone is happy their child is getting a “fair” turn to stay inside - which will be the 12th of never

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/03/2023 20:57

Abraxan · 10/03/2023 20:55

Where does the staffing come for this?
The teaching staff are entitled to a break. We need to be able to go to the toilet at some point, or grab a quick drink!

Get some auxiliary staff in specifically to cover breaks.

Sugarfree23 · 10/03/2023 20:56

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 20:01

Because DD doesn’t want to.

The DD doesn't really understand that it just looks like favouritism that she never has to go outside in the cold.

All the secrecy is going to end up causing her more issues than just saying she has a health issue.

Nobody needs more details than that. Reality it will be news for a day or two then everyone will move on.

Abraxan · 10/03/2023 20:55

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 09/03/2023 17:33

The school should have an indoor option for everyone in adverse weather. It's ridiculous to expect the children to go out in the cold and wet. That would avoid having to single out anyone with a disability.

Where does the staffing come for this?
The teaching staff are entitled to a break. We need to be able to go to the toilet at some point, or grab a quick drink!

redbigbananafeet · 10/03/2023 20:50

nilsmousehammer · 09/03/2023 15:42

Who did the teacher's favourite choose

Direct discrimination against you and dd on the grounds of her disability. Right there.

School need to shut this down firmly and hard, and they had a duty to be proactive and see this coming before you and dd were exposed to it. They need to get on it now, and sort this out, and yes the 'choosing' needs to be taken off dd's shoulders. Instead she can make a quiet list with the teacher of who she'd like to invite to play, and the teacher can select from the list daily to offer those children. Which is only mediating what dd would do if she was free to be outside playing. Chronic pain and disability is no privilege, this needs making very clear to those parents and children.

They don't know she's disabled so hey aren't discriminating against her due to her disability.

Abraxan · 10/03/2023 20:50

saraclara · 09/03/2023 15:08

If the parents and the rest of DD's classmates don't know that she has a disability, then of course they're going to question why she gets to stay in on cold wet days when other kids don't. No wonder they think it's favouritism.

I'd suggest a chat with your DD to explain this to her, and point out the downside of her wanting to keep it to herself. She shouldn't have to tell others but in this scenario she can't really have it both ways.

I don't think the other parents, or children tbh, need to be given the reason.

I am more surprised that those parents, if not the children, didn't realise that the op’s dd clearly has a medical (or other specific) reason for not being outside. Are the parents really so dad as to think it's because it's fsvouritism on the tescher’s part? Confused I seriously doubt it, it's pretty obvious the]at there'll be a valid reason.

redbigbananafeet · 10/03/2023 20:46

What do you say to the parents when they say these things within earshot of you and your child? What have management said about their behaviour? Has a meeting been held with these parents?

saraclara · 10/03/2023 20:43

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 20:17

The school can’t sort out the other parents, what are they meant to do???

Yes they can. It’s an ‘adjustment’ for DD under the Equality Act 2010. It concerns DD, her parents and the school. Nothing to do with anyone else. What are the parents meant to do ? Mind their own bloody business and give a disabled child a break.

She's not disabled. She has a condition that is affected by the cold. And the parents are entirely unaware of that.

The school simply cannot tell the other parents that the chold has a medical issue, because they have a duty of confidentiality.

Basically this thread can be summed up in two sets of two words.

People suck
Confidentiality matters

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 20:17

Eyerollcentral · 09/03/2023 22:55

Teachers are up to their eyes. Of course other parents are asking why their child can’t stay inside when one can. All that has to be said is she has a medical condition and that’s it. It’s actually making it more of a big deal the way it’s being dealt with now and I’d wonder how much the child has come to terms with her condition if she can’t bear to have people apart from five know, how healthy is this for her. The school can’t sort out the other parents, what are they meant to do???

The school can’t sort out the other parents, what are they meant to do???

Yes they can. It’s an ‘adjustment’ for DD under the Equality Act 2010. It concerns DD, her parents and the school. Nothing to do with anyone else. What are the parents meant to do ? Mind their own bloody business and give a disabled child a break.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 20:15

cansu · 10/03/2023 17:40

I am also not sure why the fact that your dd has a medical condition is a secret. The nature of the medical condition is of course private but simply saying that X is staying in due to an illness should just shut down all this favouritism thing. I am pretty sure the kids know anyway.

Why are people not getting it? This young girl does NOT want her disability or health condition disclosed. It’s between the school, DD and her parents. In the same way, when she starts work, the disability will be between the HR dept and her immediate line manager, and any adjustments that need to be made because of the Equality Act 2010 are between her and her employer. Her work colleagues are no more entitled to know why the adjustments are being made than the parents who are kicking up a fuss now. It’s private, it’s protected by law, and it’s nobody’s business but their own.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 20:08

saraclara · 10/03/2023 19:05

I've not said anything at all abut forcing. In fact I said in a previous post that maybe OP could have a gentle chat with her DD to talk about how she feels and te pros and cons of each action to see what she thinks.

It is ABSOLUTELY the child's choice and no way should the school say a word. I have never indicated otherwise. I am passionate about privacy.

My posts were addressing the posters who seem to think that everyone should just understand and be kind. Sadly life isn't like that (I've seen it both from the teacher perspective and with my own children) so I think one has to be paragmatic, accept that these thick and unkind people exist, and talk with the child about where to go from here (if indeed she wants to change anything at all).

And if I was the parent of a child who was being bullied by thick parents who don't know why she's kept in (because she looks absolutely fine) I'd encourage my kid to be a bit more open so that it could be spelled out to them that it's NOT favouritism. Until everyone in the country has enough brain cells not to be stupid, saying ' Well they ought to know better' is no help to the child.

This is what you said, and what I responded to. DD doesn’t want to disclose her condition. That’s the end of it. And ‘well they ought to know better’ is of no help to the child, I agree. But neither is encouraging her to be ‘more open’ until she’s ready to, and she’s obviously not. This is just another example of able bodied people wanting to get in on something that should be specific and exclusive to someone with a disability or health condition. It needs to be shut down and it needs to be stressed that if this young girl is not ready to disclose her disability, rude, thoughtless people shouldn’t be allowed to force her into doing so. It’s none of their business.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 20:01

Sugarfree23 · 10/03/2023 16:58

Yes some people are capable of putting 2+2 together to get 4,
Same kid never goes out, must be a health reason

Others end up with 5
Some of the girls stay in, never the boys must be a favourite.

Seriously what is wrong with clearing it up kid needs to stay in for health reason.

Because DD doesn’t want to.

saraclara · 10/03/2023 19:05

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 16:42

Nope. It’s not the job of those with a disability or health condition to educate everyone else. There’s something called the Equality Act 2010 that does that. The school are complying with that, and that’s all that matters. You absolutely do not force a child to disclose a health problem before they’re ready, just to satisfy rude, intrusive and immature nosey Parkers.

I've not said anything at all abut forcing. In fact I said in a previous post that maybe OP could have a gentle chat with her DD to talk about how she feels and te pros and cons of each action to see what she thinks.

It is ABSOLUTELY the child's choice and no way should the school say a word. I have never indicated otherwise. I am passionate about privacy.

My posts were addressing the posters who seem to think that everyone should just understand and be kind. Sadly life isn't like that (I've seen it both from the teacher perspective and with my own children) so I think one has to be paragmatic, accept that these thick and unkind people exist, and talk with the child about where to go from here (if indeed she wants to change anything at all).

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 10/03/2023 17:40

Seriously what is wrong with clearing it up kid needs to stay in for health reason.

Because it’s not their business.

Plus idiots who jump to favouritism rather than the obvious aren’t going to be happy with “health reasons”

Its simply going to push their bitching and gossiping to the type of health reasons. Then the seriousness of health reasons.

Then even if you tell them that your child has to stay in because they’ve got one leg, one arm and a partially decapitated head they’ll be mithering on about how their friend’s neighbour’s sister’s dog’s previous owner has a child with no legs and a totally decapitated head but they still go out at playtime because they use their arms so it’s obviously still favouritism…

Giving information doesn’t stop these people

cansu · 10/03/2023 17:40

I am also not sure why the fact that your dd has a medical condition is a secret. The nature of the medical condition is of course private but simply saying that X is staying in due to an illness should just shut down all this favouritism thing. I am pretty sure the kids know anyway.

Sugarfree23 · 10/03/2023 16:58

Yes some people are capable of putting 2+2 together to get 4,
Same kid never goes out, must be a health reason

Others end up with 5
Some of the girls stay in, never the boys must be a favourite.

Seriously what is wrong with clearing it up kid needs to stay in for health reason.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 16:42

saraclara · 09/03/2023 17:08

Have you not noticed that there are LOADS of people out there who are thick as mince? Unfortunately if you don't want them to be obnoxious about a hidden disability, you have to at least spell it out to them.

Sometimes, irritating though it is, you have to be pragmatic. And if I was the parent of a child who was being bullied by thick parents who don't know why she's kept in (because she looks absolutely fine) I'd encourage my kid to be a bit more open so that it could be spelled out to them that it's NOT favouritism. Until everyone in the country has enough brain cells not to be stupid, saying ' Well they ought to know better' is no help to the child.

Nope. It’s not the job of those with a disability or health condition to educate everyone else. There’s something called the Equality Act 2010 that does that. The school are complying with that, and that’s all that matters. You absolutely do not force a child to disclose a health problem before they’re ready, just to satisfy rude, intrusive and immature nosey Parkers.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 16:39

saraclara · 09/03/2023 17:11

No, I wouldn't make that assumption.

But given that I know that there are some seriously stupid people out there who will (and malicious ones who will airways look for the explanation that allows them to think the worst of people) I would always aim for an action that cuts them off.

And if that action forced your DD to do something she didn’t want to do, and disclose her disability before she was ready, or had come to terms with it herself ? What then ? She is the priority, not stupid, immature parents who can’t think beyond their own limitations.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/03/2023 16:36

saraclara · 09/03/2023 17:08

Have you not noticed that there are LOADS of people out there who are thick as mince? Unfortunately if you don't want them to be obnoxious about a hidden disability, you have to at least spell it out to them.

Sometimes, irritating though it is, you have to be pragmatic. And if I was the parent of a child who was being bullied by thick parents who don't know why she's kept in (because she looks absolutely fine) I'd encourage my kid to be a bit more open so that it could be spelled out to them that it's NOT favouritism. Until everyone in the country has enough brain cells not to be stupid, saying ' Well they ought to know better' is no help to the child.

I agree with a lot of what you’re saying, but it’s also of no help to the child if you disclose her disability before she’s come to terms with it herself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread