Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thinking toddler would be better in childcare

61 replies

Wfdg · 09/03/2023 12:08

Toddler (2) does 2 days a week in nursery and seems to really enjoy it and be happy and settled. Rest of the time is with me and it’s a different story. He just doesn’t seem to enjoy our days much at all and if I’m honest neither do I. Problem is there’s a dire shortage of childcare available and can’t afford it anyway. So have to wait at least a year … not sure what others might suggest?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SkyandSurf · 10/03/2023 08:36

If you're not enjoying it, I'd try to get him more time in childcare and increase your days at work to pay for it.

MumOf2workOptions · 10/03/2023 08:28

Mooshroo · 09/03/2023 13:34

I have no advice just joining in solidarity as my kid would rather be at nursery than at home with me too 🤣

Both my kids were better "occupied"
I put them in childcare 3/4 days and had a day at home then the weekends I think I'd have struggled with more.

I understand what your saying about nurseries some have closed near here too I thinking owing to utility and rent if premises going up and minimum wage will also go up too so they have probably been re-assessing things.

I used a mix of a Childminder and a nursery which worked well and a childminder is cheaper aswell. Are you using the tax free childcare this gives 20% off the bill aswell which is a huge help.

Isthisexpected · 10/03/2023 08:21

Hi OP, to be honest I read your posts as though the issue isn't necessarily with him but how you feel actually. Is it possible you're depressed and that's why you're seeing him as unhappy? If you're low he'll pick up on this through your voice and facial expressions if not your behaviour too so it'll be a vicious cycle. He can't be happy if you're not.

Theelephantinthecastle · 10/03/2023 08:18

1AngelicFruitCake · 10/03/2023 06:38

I also agree with you about the sleep. My two woke at 5 for a few years and in the end I just went with it because they couldn’t get back to sleep! Slowly it sorted itself out and they now sleep in…until 6! I’m an early riser so it doesn’t bother me.

I agree. But I would add that the one thing that did very gradually help the early risings a bit was the gro clock plus tonie box combo. We set the gro clock initially for very early and encouraged DC to put on a Tonie to listen to and then very gradually moved the gro clock to 6/6:30. I think it worked for mine because of the element of independence, being able to choose a story etc

SimplySipping · 10/03/2023 08:12

"Tried earlier bedtimes and later bedtimes and tweaking the nap … none of it works, the Gro clock doesn’t work (if you say it is still night time he cries!) I’m hoping the clocks going forward will help, but the thing is I think emotionally it’s just kind of easier if I don’t stress about it as it probably will change and life will get easier."

I get this. But he's changing all the time and even if it didn't work last time, the same thing might work again in the future. We started a groclock with a 5am wake up so she never had to wait long. It was agony committing to that every day 😭 but well worth it.

I'm basically an emptied out husk when my wake up time starts with a 5. Anything 6 and upwards and I can function.

1AngelicFruitCake · 10/03/2023 06:38

I also agree with you about the sleep. My two woke at 5 for a few years and in the end I just went with it because they couldn’t get back to sleep! Slowly it sorted itself out and they now sleep in…until 6! I’m an early riser so it doesn’t bother me.

1AngelicFruitCake · 10/03/2023 06:32

I think you need to work on him playing on his own for short bursts. So you get out his toys and say ‘Mummy's doing x’ and keep busy even if he cries for a few minutes. Lots of praise when he does it. Try to build it up. This advice was from A family member to me and it was the best advice otherwise the expectation is you’re constantly entertaining.
Mine used to love washing plastic toys, playing with boxes, playing with pots and pans as well as toys.

YukoandHiro · 10/03/2023 06:23

Have you tried things that replicate what they might've been doing at nursery but with a bit less mess? Like water painting books or tray tables of toys on a theme eg a farm?

The thing to remember is they do need constant interaction at this age, they don't really play with toys independently for very long - and it can definitely be hard to get anything done at home

Siameasy · 10/03/2023 06:21

My DD was the worst sleeper ever but at that age she really sought out increased risk/danger.
When she was 2.5 I got her the Kuhn Rikon knife set so she could start chopping up veg. She also started getting into science experiments which mainly involved bicarb and vinegar with food colouring. I used to follow “Imagination Tree” for ideas.
I made a play shop and post office in the living room. She loved that, playing with toy money. Obv I had to “join in” but at least it was sitting down with a cup of tea whilst doing so. We also used to get all the cushions off the sofa and bring a small mattress down so she could leap about.
Another favourite was to sit in the kitchen sink bowl and play with stuff altho you say he doesn’t like baths.

aloris · 10/03/2023 06:19

My oldest was similar to this. Never slept, didn't play with toys, grumpy often, difficult to entertain at home, loved preschool. I would say a couple things. First, it is indeed good to have a rough schedule in terms of meals and snacks, just so the day has some structure. Some children at this age find that their nighttime sleep is impacted if they take long naps in the daytime, so his lack of naps may be something you just have to accept. You do have to figure out how to work around it in terms of maybe having a rest time in the middle of the day so that even if he doesn't nap, he at least is laying down and clearing his thoughts, if you see what I mean. Gentle music might be helpful here and once you find something he likes you just play it every single time and it becomes part of his routine.

My kid also was one of those who just pulled all the books off the bookshelf. In retrospect, it was because disorder is easier for a small child to achieve than order. He found any ordered activity to be very difficult (eventual ADHD diagnosis) because it involved motor control and making decisions and so on. You also say he doesn't play with toys. Again this could be because he doesn't have an internal script for that and needs some sort of input from you to build that script. In other words he may want to play WITH you rather than near you. For example, with the books, you can "play a game" where you pick up the books and stack them. This way he can practice the motor skill of picking up books (rather than sweeping them off the shelf).

Do you get stimulation yourself? I found with my child who was like this, that I had to be getting some mental activity in order to come up with things to do with him. Bear in mind, you don't have to always do traditional kid activities. I had a change of perspective when I made friends with a woman who listened to her own favorite music with her toddler! In other words, following your own interests can help.

He may also just need a lot more outdoor time, to work off his energy which again could be a cause of the sweeping of books off the shelf etc.

I know it's hard, when you are up with a small child from that early and they do not nap easily, you get pretty tired by the end of the day.

autienotnaughty · 10/03/2023 05:43

My son needs a structured routine. It went roughly like this-

6am - wake cuddles in our bed with cartoons on telly
7 am breakfast/ read books/nursery rhymes
8am- get dressed
9am playgroup/park/visit family
1130 am play toys or garden (I had to play too)
1230pm - lunch
130pm - nap
330pm - walk to local park
5pm - tea
6pm - read books /play games
630 pm - get ready for bed
7pm - bed

I'd use nap time to do housework and prep tea.

But as others said I wouldn't worry too much about enjoying nursery more. He probably does enjoy playing with the kids and whilst he probably likes it he will still have his moments there too.

When he turns 3 you should get the 30 hours which might help a bit.

Username24680 · 10/03/2023 05:31

How old is your DS @Wfdg? just turned 2 or closer to 3?
It might just be your wording but you’ve said you “managed to get him to nap”...is it an effort to get him down? I only ask because mine turned into a nightmare to get down for his nap. Once he was down he’d sleep for a good couple of hours but to get him down was a bit of a battle. Stopped trying to get mine to nap and only put him down if he asked for one and our days are 100x better. He’s still an early riser but more 6am than 5am and he doesn’t very often wake during the night now. I know you said you’ve tried tweaking the naps etc but could worth a shot!

I think the playing with toys just comes with time tbh, or finding that thing that he loves 😬 Mine is also 2 (28months) and some toys hold his attention for a minute or 2 and other stuff he will sit and play with for 20 mins.
Obviously they’re all different but mine absolutely loves anything he can build/make - MagnetTiles, Duplo, Kinetic Sand, PlayDoh etc. He also loves role play type toys like his toy kitchen & food, doctors set, toy hoover/cleaning set and dolls house. I get it being lonely though, really, I do! DH works offshore so for 3 weeks at a time it’s just DS and I at home and I can feel a bit like a kids entertainer at the end of the day 😅 I also fall into the trap of feeling like he needs to be entertained 100% of the time. Like if he’s not laughing and being silly then he must be miserable 🙈 but I’m sure that’s just my own insecurity talking and me wanting to be the “perfect mum”.

With getting him involved with the chores etc, mine did take a bit of practice. The first time I tried to Hoover with him helping he screamed the whole time because he just wanted to stand and hold it 😅🤣 Now, we take turns lol or he uses his toy one while I use the big one. Laundry, he’ll “help” hang it up, or he’ll load/unload the washing machine. He gets a dry cloth while I’m cleaning/dusting and I give him something to clean while I quickly wizz round doing the rest 😅

Mine actually isn’t a great lover of the swing park etc. We do go but he much prefers finding sticks and stones and just generally messing around outside. We tend to do more “toddler led” walks rather than anything else so I just let him lead the way and we do whatever he wants tbh...it might be finding sticks, drawing in the mud with a stick, finding puddles to jump in, throwing stones in the water etc.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/03/2023 20:43

12-2.30 is the perfect nap time and length imo.

Wfdg · 09/03/2023 20:35

Mine is stubborn with naps. I managed to get him to sleep at 12 today which is an early nap by our standards and he slept until 230. Long nap but in a MUCH improved mood when he woke!

OP posts:
Flangeosaurus · 09/03/2023 20:32

Oh the early rising is soooo bloody hard! Nothing at all I tried cracked it until mine turned 4, went to school and was so knackered he started sleeping until 6am ish. He has been allowed to come down, get cereal and watch TV from 4yo. When he was smaller we just absolutely rigidly took it in turns to get up. No skiving your go, no split morning, just get up and keep him quiet until 7.30am. Each of us knew we would have an uninterrupted midnight to 7.30am every other night and it helped such a lot with energy levels and enthusiasm for activities. I just used to stick the telly on and doze on the sofa, he mainly ate toast and sat on my legs.

One thing I did find quite helpful was giving him a Power Nap of 30/40 mins around 9am before we started the day. I did nothing fun apart from drink coffee and mooch my phone prior to 7.30, then would read books or watch something with him after that for a bit, more breakfast and pop him down for a nap. Once he was up he was less whingey and tired and we could do some activities before another nap around lunchtime.

Wfdg · 09/03/2023 20:20

Today was an exceptionally crap day (it did get better) and I think I was in a very negative mood.

He does wake early but for some reason this past week it has been as someone rightly said the middle of the night! I’ve honestly tried so many things I’ve seen suggested on here. If you treat it as a night wake up he just cries (hysterically!) until you get him up. I know some people would say leave him to cry but as well as feeling a bit mean (he doesn’t know the time) it wakes the other parent up, and it’s so so SO much better if DH and I can split the morning, so parent 1 does a 5-630 run and parent 2 630-8.

Tried earlier bedtimes and later bedtimes and tweaking the nap … none of it works, the Gro clock doesn’t work (if you say it is still night time he cries!) I’m hoping the clocks going forward will help, but the thing is I think emotionally it’s just kind of easier if I don’t stress about it as it probably will change and life will get easier.

It’s not as bleak as I painted and we do have nice times, we do toddler groups, we do the usual stuff of feeding ducks and parks and I have braved the library although it sent him a bit manic - he didn’t want to read books with me (enjoys it at home!) and sometimes we will go to a wildlife park or national trust or something. He does enjoy it, I think. I just wish I could relax and BE with him more. It’s lonely - we did actually see a friend this afternoon and he was so well behaved it made me Blush at this moany thread.

I am sure he’ll get better at playing with toys. Truth is toddlers are tough going and i think it helps other parents if they read this because there are days you feel like a rubbish mum and like your toddler doesn’t like being with you and it’s not, just a bad day.

OP posts:
Starlightstarbright1 · 09/03/2023 20:13

My Ds was pretty much a very limited sleeper. I had him in my bed watching Tv whilst I dozed..

what I would say is remember the summer is coming ( it definitely doesn’t feel like it) parks outside play are on the way.

LapinR0se · 09/03/2023 19:55

^ that was for
@Forgooodnesssakenow

LapinR0se · 09/03/2023 19:55

Yes. If you are a highly responsive parent all day and at bedtime, then an hour alone in the morning does no harm. Especially if you explain that everyone sleeps until the sun comes up and you have to be quiet…a groclock can help to reinforce that visually.

likeafishneedsabike · 09/03/2023 19:49

thing is, how do you know that he’s any happier at nursery than he is with you? He does sound a bit fed up in general.
Having said that, my youngest didn’t enjoy home days when he was a tot. He loves constant company and now spends all weekend with friends as a pre teen. He’s a deeply sociable person.
So as a pre schooler we did play dates literally every day he wasn’t at nursery . Not necessarily at home but anywhere - as long as we were with a crowd he was happy as Larry. He found me deeply boring one to one as he likes a vibe. It all makes sense now that I know his personality better.

pear6782 · 09/03/2023 19:47

This isn’t helpful advice but I just wanted to say I understand what you mean. Once mine started full days at nursery, they got really bored on their days at home with me. I had activities lined up, walks outside, groups - and they had each other…but it wasn’t the same, it was expensive and exhausting for me (so much mess!) and I eventually caved and put them in for more days. My friends didn’t understand what I meant at the time and implied I wasn’t doing enough at home. Until you experience it, it’s hard to explain. Mine even ask to go to nursery at the weekend, even though we plan things (although that is getting more and more expensive...). Just wanted to share what I went through because I felt awful at the time and thought I must be doing something wrong.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/03/2023 19:04

Wfdg · 09/03/2023 14:18

Tha is so much. I just feel he doesn’t enjoy the activities I try to do with him, they inevitably end up with him demanding something and tears.

He doesn’t enjoy baths and tries to get out as soon as you put him in. He doesn’t seem to enjoy very much in all honesty Sad

Probably because he is overtired. I'd start a thread for sleep advice. Well rested kids generally have a happier demeaner in the daytime - not for 100% of the day but enough so they aren't huffing all the time.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/03/2023 19:03

Wfdg · 09/03/2023 14:18

Tha is so much. I just feel he doesn’t enjoy the activities I try to do with him, they inevitably end up with him demanding something and tears.

He doesn’t enjoy baths and tries to get out as soon as you put him in. He doesn’t seem to enjoy very much in all honesty Sad

So my eldest I'd take to playgroups and he'd try to leave the building, so we went to the park and hed leave the playground to wander through the trees, so we wandered through the trees.

I take them both to the library, neither sits and has a story read to them, they look at the covers and moved the books about (all acceptable in the toddler are of our library) and I justanage and keep them quiet and they DO enjoy it just not necessarily how I'd want them to enjoy it.

Softplay my eldest especially loved as he could just be super active and throw himself about and current 18 month old is starting to enjoy it too.

Try not to feel you need a BIG activity, do you have a ball pool or a tent? I used to blow up a few balloons while odlest was napping and chuck them in the tent and that'd keep him happy half an hour. Or chuck some towels on the kitchen floor and let him wash his plastic bowls in the washing up bowl. Activities only hold their attention 15 mins or so so easy set up and cleanup is key.

Also nursery you'll only be getting the highlights, there'll be grumpiness nd meltdowns there too they're just so normal the staf won't mention them

dawoosh · 09/03/2023 19:03

Also came to say do 4 half days, or even 5 if you can stretch to that. Then it’s a routine of going every single day, but also not for too long that it starts to be detrimental? You would get some time back for yourself then too

Forgooodnesssakenow · 09/03/2023 18:59

LapinR0se · 09/03/2023 13:21

Do not get up at 4.50 are you mad. Yes he’s awake yes he’s crying but put earplugs in and leave him until at least 6. You can’t be doing entertaining parenting in the middle of the night!!

What? Just leave the kid to cry for over an hour because you're not ready to get up yet?

Swipe left for the next trending thread