Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"It's their birthright"

38 replies

Bucketheadbucketbum · 09/03/2023 11:52

YABU - not everyone is born equal

YANBU - the concept of anything (other than basic human rights) being predetermined at birth is beyond entitled

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fifi0000 · 12/03/2023 11:52

Aristocracy and titles need to go. The idea that someone is more worthy because they were born from someone's privileged loins is ridiculous.
I understand life is unequal some people have more wealthy parents etc , but you wouldn't bow or have to show respect because someone is rich. It's sad I like the history of the RF but it's not relevant to 2023 everyone is equal.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 12/03/2023 11:45

Bucketheadbucketbum · 09/03/2023 11:57

Yes i agree the reality is sadly thus.

I'm talking ideologically though. How can you lay such aggressive claim via concept of "birthright" whilst trying to promote yourself as a modern woke. It stinks.

Exactly. The hypocrisy is off the charts.

CandleInTheStorm · 12/03/2023 11:38

I don't think this is just about the royal family. Isn't it a case in some religions that the first born son is the "head" of the family after the father? Even if they are born after many females?

shattered25 · 12/03/2023 11:27

I think it's all stupid. The whole wealth equals power is just an illusion modern society indoctrinates people into. And rather than thinking rich countries feel entitled to basics such as shelter/healthcare... it should be every human right, we raise the bar not lower it. No one made developments and advancements for humanity thinking hmm only that country can have it, it was done for evolution of our species as a whole. It's just pockets of people on a power trip decided to use it as leverage against the people which is quite sick.

In my view the people who are born privileged rather than being who has money or status, is who has the genetics designed to propel us further, the lack of genetic defects in DNA, the best genes from each diverse nation etc. realistically in a cataclysmic event they are more likely to survive adversity and money will at that point be redundant.

Jimboscott0115 · 12/03/2023 10:46

Every single person on this thread benefits from birthright. Noone chooses to acknowledge it but being born in the west already puts you at a big advantage over 80-90% of the rest of the world.

Yes there's disparities within wealthy country's but we all effectively won the gene lottery already by being where we are. I get this isn't really the debate here but globally it's exactly the same thing, we're all but the absolute poorest in our societies, extremely privileged and have huge advantages over billions of others across the world.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/03/2023 10:31

Maybe Americans will just laugh and not acknowledge the titles.

Valeriekat · 12/03/2023 10:13

The child is a US citizen and resident.
The USA is a republic
They shouldn't use the title.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 09/03/2023 13:18

People are of course equal. Some are more advantaged than others, it's not 'entitled' to have something someone else doesn't have. Am I 'entitled' because I own a car and some people can't afford one?

Also, it is literally their birthright, isn't it. Literally something that is their right because of being born. An inheritance isn't a birthright, it could all get left to the cat's home and to assume or demand it would be entitled. But a hereditary title is definitely a birthright.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 09/03/2023 13:07

People aren't born equal. Never have been.

SweetFarmKitty · 09/03/2023 13:06

Whenever I read these H&M threads I imagine a whole table of women in their 20s and 30s choosing similar sounding usernames and tapping away in an open plan office somewhere in Montecito, being paid by the hour to support H&M.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 09/03/2023 13:02

@ReneBumsWombats

'in that that's the system and how it works'

but didn't 'they' create the system for themselves by invading / fighting centuries ago and claiming ownership of the country?
(and the foreshore,)
(and the swans,)

🤔

pishkashante · 09/03/2023 12:47

The system is very unfair, but I think we are socially engineered to believe in primogeniture or at least children inheriting from parents.

scatterolight · 09/03/2023 12:47

I have to say I found the use of that phrase by the Royal Wokenesses highly amusing. They are completely tone deaf.

What's amazing about them is they live so comfortably in this cognitive dissonance. On the one hand the Royal Family is an outdated institution with laughable customs like curtseying for the monarch but on the other these (presumably meaningless?) titles are a birthright of their children. They are utterly bizarre.

ReneBumsWombats · 09/03/2023 12:44

Focusing on H and M is weird and fixated. The whole royal family work in this basis

Yes, but the others don't complain about how terrible it is and stop working as royals and move across the Atlantic...while still insisting on using titles and capitalising on it.

They're pretty upfront about accepting how it works and doing their duty, such as it is. And Edward and Anne, who could have used prince and princess titles for their children, chose not to (I know Anne didn't have the same automatic right as Edward but she's spoken about it and been clear she could have had it as an option, but didn't).

Ceryneianhind · 09/03/2023 12:42

Mochudubh · 09/03/2023 11:59

Is this another H&M thread?

oh FFS

MartiniFlan · 09/03/2023 12:28

What I don't understand is how Harry can complain that 'there's a hierarchy within the royal family' (duh) while simultaneously either not realising or not caring that there's also a hierarchy outside the royal family that the royals are at the top of. So it seems he's someone who only resents hierarchy when he (or his children) are not right at the top. And I'm not sure how actively choosing to use titles (which I know they have the right to do) gels with 'linked not ranked' etc. It's almost like he knows he doesn't really have any talent or USP outside of being royal, so he has to cling onto the emblems of the thing that he professes to hate, has ruined his life, etc. I completely believe that life inside the royal family might be awful and would totally understand someone wanting to separate themself from it. But banging the 'royal family is so awful' drum at the same time as playing the 'but please use my title and acknowledge my status that stems from that awful thing' pipe is a bit odd.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 09/03/2023 12:27

AND this is why we need to get rid of these parasites - all of them. The idea that Charles is head of state because of his birth is fu King ridiculous.

Prettybutdumb · 09/03/2023 12:24

Makes me think about all the anti-immigration sentiment. ‘You can’t come to this land - only people who were actually born here are allowed! It’s their birthright!!!’

‘the concept of anything (other than basic human rights) being predetermined at birth is beyond entitled’ - not quite, is it?

mondaytosunday · 09/03/2023 12:21

I'm not sure every one is equal. Not talking about royalty - I don't believe they have any more entitlement than anyone else. And I suppose at birth we start out as equal, even if not given the same opportunities.
But as grown people I do value more those, in the same society, who do more, whether that's being a good parent, a great teacher, or running a decent business that employs people, as opposed to those who do not much by way of contributing to the world and moan about their lot in life.

boingboingboingboing · 09/03/2023 12:19

It is their birthright though - that's literally what the word means.
Like my birthright is to have the surname of my parents.

Focusing on H and M is weird and fixated. The whole royal family work in this basis AND
The royal family are just the most visible part of a whole system where the rich and powerful pass on titles and property to their descendents.

Now, whether it's legitimate that some people have more inherited wealth and power than others is fair is a different question.
Of course that's not fair - but it's been the same since we were cavemen.
On an evolutionary level women select mates that have more resources or appear to be able to gain them (strong tall fit etc) - in order to provide for their offspring.
Men select women who appear to have good fertility characteristics.

Comedycook · 09/03/2023 12:16

Who cares?! Seriously. It's does not affect you one jot. Chill out and stop getting angry at random shit that doesn't matter because the media is telling you to.

RichardHeed · 09/03/2023 12:15

Greensleeves · 09/03/2023 12:11

I disagree. This isn't a thread specifically about the RF, it's about the principle of inherited power/status/wealth, and could refer to the HoL or other non-elected institutions, or the system of inheritance generally. It's also a poll, which means AIBU.

I hope MNHQ don't move it, that would be weird.

Of course it is. She even linked to an article about H&M. OP thought she was being clever and not outright mentioning what the fucking hell she was flapping her gums about, but it was screamingly obviously and some of us are sick to the back teeth of the insane amount of chatter about these people. It doesn’t behove MN to have their most popular board filled up with RF chat no matter how you dress it up.

x2boys · 09/03/2023 12:14

ItsHannahBackwards · 09/03/2023 12:03

The Royal Family should be got rid of, it’s a ridiculous and outdated concept.

Having an issue with only Harry and Meghan is stupid though.

This ,the I can't stand the hate over H&M and the fawning over wi!liam and Kate and their kids ,get rid of all of them but why just pick onH&M?

Kitchenette · 09/03/2023 12:13

H&M are as interested in distancing themselves from the Royal Family as I am in distancing myself from Vincent Cassel. Their whole selling point is the Royal Family.

Greensleeves · 09/03/2023 12:11

VictorStrand · 09/03/2023 12:01

I've asked MN to move your thread to the relevant section. This isn't it.

I disagree. This isn't a thread specifically about the RF, it's about the principle of inherited power/status/wealth, and could refer to the HoL or other non-elected institutions, or the system of inheritance generally. It's also a poll, which means AIBU.

I hope MNHQ don't move it, that would be weird.