Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you not to run around if caught in snow- exercise cools you down

210 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 09:06

I am quite alarmed at the level of ignorance shown about this, so just in case anyone here gets caught in snow today

Please don't exercise to warm up - or tell your children to - this cools you down and leaves you vulnerable to hypothermia

Insulate yourself as well as you can, and huddle as close together as you can instead.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:32

This used to be normal general knowledge when I was a school.

There was a terrible incident when a group of teens were canoeing in rough water, and most of them capsized, and ended up clinging to their canoes and each other waiting rescue, and their instructor told them to kick their legs to stay warm and most of them died of hypothermia

It was a long time ago, but there was a lot of upset at the time, as everyone knew the instructors advice had killed them, and at the time, this was just general knowledge. People knew not to exercise if you were trapped in a situation in danger of hypothermia

I expect a lot of people on Mumsnet are too young to remember that particular tradgedy

OP posts:
Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:32

Polis · 09/03/2023 10:26

It doesn’t mean that exercising in the cold is more likely to cause hypothermia than sitting still in the cold.

This study seems to suggestsotherwise.

You’re cooler than you think! Hypothermia may go unnoticed when exercising in the cold

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/08/210819102728.htm

If you go out in the cold or the rain, you risk hypothermia.

If you exercise, your body temperature goes up, but your body can only generate so much heat. If you don't generate enough, you will still be cold. You are cold because you are in a cold environment, not because you are exercising.

Your body generates heat when it moves. Exercise fundamentally absolutely does not cause "the body to cool".

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/03/2023 10:30

"when you exercise your skin gets hot, because it is dumping heat from your core. So you might feel hot. But you are cooling down."

You are dumping heat from your core because your core has got too hot! Because exercise generates heat!

Havanananana · 09/03/2023 10:29

Fundamentally - as the OP tried to claim - the body absolutely does not "cool" to a temperature lower than a body's usual resting temperature as a result of exercise.

In normal conditions, this is correct.

But the OP is describing extreme snowy or cold winter conditions (albeit that these conditions are unlikely to arise in the UK) and the advice is correct in these conditions. "Stay dry" and "seek shelter" are the fundamentals of survival in extreme conditions. Everyone seems to have missed the sentence about "getting caught in the snow" - which I interpret as extreme snow conditions where you might be "caught" for a few hours. This is not the same as going for a run, ski, or play around in the snow for an hour in the park before going home to a warm house and a cup of hot chocolate.

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:28

LookingOldTheseDays · 09/03/2023 10:25

Totally agree with this. Standing still in the cold is a recipe for hypothermia.

well, obviously, if you are within walking distance of home, then you are not trapped, are you!

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:27

I am not talking about stopping children having fun in the snow, I am talking about a situation in which you are stuck outside in the cold - it will happen to lots of people today, it has already happened to a friend of mine and her daughter on a railway platform.

It is just important in those situations, not to run around to keep warm, rather to huddle up and conserve your heat. And I am highly alarmed at the number of people on mumsnet who think the best thing is to run around and get warm.

when you exercise your skin gets hot, because it is dumping heat from your core. So you might feel hot. But you are cooling down.

YOu might be stuck today, or another snow day - and incidentally rain causes hypothermia too, so it might not even be a snow day

You could be stuck in a car, or on a railway platform, or locked out in the front garden, or lost on a walk, who knows?

I just want people to understand, that "running around to keep warm" is not a good option in these circumstances, and will make the situation worse.

I also don't think people realise how easy it is to get hypothermia, particularly children - I see it on school trips, maybe not every year, but it isn't that unusual, and I am talking about big events in cities, not out in the wild somewhere.

The last time I saw it was a teenage girl from a different school who had come litter picking in a city park on a cold rainy day without a coat. At the time I saw her she was fairly coherent, and I walked her over to a member of staff from her school, who arranged transport back to her school for her, but she deteriorated while waiting for the transport, and an ambulance was called

OP posts:
Polis · 09/03/2023 10:26

It doesn’t mean that exercising in the cold is more likely to cause hypothermia than sitting still in the cold.

This study seems to suggestsotherwise.

You’re cooler than you think! Hypothermia may go unnoticed when exercising in the cold

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/08/210819102728.htm

LookingOldTheseDays · 09/03/2023 10:25

Snoken · 09/03/2023 10:08

It really depends on the situation. I live in Sweden and were I grew up we have minus 15 to minus 25 from November to end of March roughly, and I would die of hypothermia if I went outside and just stood still in the garden for a couple of hours, however if I instead went cross country skiing for a couple of hours I would be warm and fine. I would feel cold when I came home or stopped exercising though. If you are stranded a 30 minute walk from home you are better off walking home than huddling close together by the car.

Totally agree with this. Standing still in the cold is a recipe for hypothermia.

Chickenly · 09/03/2023 10:25

Summerhouse2013 · 09/03/2023 10:01

"When exposed to cold temperatures, your body begins to lose heat faster than it can be produced. Exercising in cold, rainy weather increases the risk of hypothermia. Older adults and young children are at greater risk."
Mayo Clinic.org/fitness

I did a quick google search and found this.

🙄It means that exercising in the cold is more likely to cause hypothermia than exercising in warm weather. It doesn’t mean that exercising in the cold is more likely to cause hypothermia than sitting still in the cold.

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:24

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:20

It's kind of arguable, although not sure what the OP actually means.

When I was running I used to go out in all weathers with just a t-shirt, flimsy running gear. I could run in freezing rain, snow, the lot.

The issue becomes if you have to stop for any reason, injury or other. Then you will freeze. I was injured once, but that was in summer. If it had happened at night in the winter in freezing rain I would have had to knock on someones door to phone for a taxi because there would have been no way to get back without freezing to death. Maybe sensibly (?!) I never used to run out in the freezing cold when there were no people/houses around, always round the suburbs where there was a place to go for help if things went wrong.

It's not arguable at all.

If you go out running in the cold, your body warms up. If you stop, then you get colder. The answer is to wear appropriate clothing - generally it's a good idea to go out wearing 1 layer too warm and remove clothing if necessary.

Chickenly · 09/03/2023 10:22

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:20

It's kind of arguable, although not sure what the OP actually means.

When I was running I used to go out in all weathers with just a t-shirt, flimsy running gear. I could run in freezing rain, snow, the lot.

The issue becomes if you have to stop for any reason, injury or other. Then you will freeze. I was injured once, but that was in summer. If it had happened at night in the winter in freezing rain I would have had to knock on someones door to phone for a taxi because there would have been no way to get back without freezing to death. Maybe sensibly (?!) I never used to run out in the freezing cold when there were no people/houses around, always round the suburbs where there was a place to go for help if things went wrong.

Then the advice would surely be “dress appropriately for snow” not “if you’re stuck in snow, stay still”. OP’s “logic” (or lack thereof) was clearly explained…and entirely incorrect.

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:20

It's kind of arguable, although not sure what the OP actually means.

When I was running I used to go out in all weathers with just a t-shirt, flimsy running gear. I could run in freezing rain, snow, the lot.

The issue becomes if you have to stop for any reason, injury or other. Then you will freeze. I was injured once, but that was in summer. If it had happened at night in the winter in freezing rain I would have had to knock on someones door to phone for a taxi because there would have been no way to get back without freezing to death. Maybe sensibly (?!) I never used to run out in the freezing cold when there were no people/houses around, always round the suburbs where there was a place to go for help if things went wrong.

Chickenly · 09/03/2023 10:20

As a former science teacher, these kinds of threads demonstrate why teaching is an utterly pointless profession at this point.

Doesthepopeshitinthewoods · 09/03/2023 10:19

W0tnow · 09/03/2023 09:09

You’re a penguin, aren’t you!

Must be. All this ‘don’t run around’ is just jealousy because of her three-inch penguin legs.

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:16

People generally feel cold after exercise for 2 reasons:

  1. They are still wearing damp, sweaty clothes, which generally isn't a problem if the weather is that cold as the body won't produce that much sweat compared to going out on a hot day. To solve this, you just change clothes or you wear clothing designed to wick sweat away from your skin.

  2. They haven't cooled down properly and have just come from a cold environment with an elevated HR to a warm environment with their HR dropping rapidly.

Fundamentally - as the OP tried to claim - the body absolutely does not "cool" to a temperature lower than a body's usual resting temperature as a result of exercise.

gogohmm · 09/03/2023 10:14

@Snoken

Well put.

Jessbow · 09/03/2023 10:12

What is probaby more adviable if caught out, is to try and stay dry if you can, wet clothes will chill you far faster than dry.

seek shelter, stay dry

BiddyPop · 09/03/2023 10:12

Wearing proper clothing is more inorganic though - layers, with waterproof and wind proof outer layer but that allows any sweat to escape, wearing a hat, preferably wearing no gloves, not getting wet feet, etc - are more important than exercise.

BiddyPop · 09/03/2023 10:10

There's probably a difference of perception.

Heavy exercise leading you to sweat will cool you down. Which counteracts the benefits of movement.

But lighter exercise, getting you moving, will keep blood moving around the body - yes brings it to the surface which is cold but you need that heat generated by moderate movement. As well as keeping blood flowing to extremities.

gogohmm · 09/03/2023 10:10

As I sea in a town by the sea k do not get "caught in snow" in 49 years of living in Britain I've never been caught in fact because we simply don't have much snow.

The best health advice for travelling in snowy conditions is to carry emergency supplies including foil blankets, water and food. A small power bank is a good idea too.

When I exercise I definitely get warmer though!

Snoken · 09/03/2023 10:08

It really depends on the situation. I live in Sweden and were I grew up we have minus 15 to minus 25 from November to end of March roughly, and I would die of hypothermia if I went outside and just stood still in the garden for a couple of hours, however if I instead went cross country skiing for a couple of hours I would be warm and fine. I would feel cold when I came home or stopped exercising though. If you are stranded a 30 minute walk from home you are better off walking home than huddling close together by the car.

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/03/2023 10:08

Yeah that mayo clinic quote appears to be saying that "cold weather cools you down". No shit, mayo clinic.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 09/03/2023 10:07

When I exercise I sweat as I'm warm, so my body tries to cool me down.

After exercise if I don't shower and change asap, then I get extremely cold.

Whilst I'm exercising I'm fine

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:06

Summerhouse2013 · 09/03/2023 10:01

"When exposed to cold temperatures, your body begins to lose heat faster than it can be produced. Exercising in cold, rainy weather increases the risk of hypothermia. Older adults and young children are at greater risk."
Mayo Clinic.org/fitness

I did a quick google search and found this.

That, obviously, is a consequence of being outdoors in cold, rainy weather.

When you move, especially enough to get your heart rate up, you generate heat. This is basic biology.

Lastnamedidntstick · 09/03/2023 10:04

Summerhouse2013 · 09/03/2023 10:01

"When exposed to cold temperatures, your body begins to lose heat faster than it can be produced. Exercising in cold, rainy weather increases the risk of hypothermia. Older adults and young children are at greater risk."
Mayo Clinic.org/fitness

I did a quick google search and found this.

Surely most people know not to go out in the freezing pissing rain or snow, get soaking wet clearly being dressed inappropriately, and expect to keep warm?

that’s nothing to do with exercise cooling you down, of course you increase the risk of hypothermia going out to exercise in those conditions.