Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you not to run around if caught in snow- exercise cools you down

210 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 09:06

I am quite alarmed at the level of ignorance shown about this, so just in case anyone here gets caught in snow today

Please don't exercise to warm up - or tell your children to - this cools you down and leaves you vulnerable to hypothermia

Insulate yourself as well as you can, and huddle as close together as you can instead.

OP posts:
Lastnamedidntstick · 09/03/2023 10:50

So IMO it's arguable

what’s is not arguable though is o/p’s assertion that exercise cools you down do the point of hypothermia.

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:49

My guess is the answer to which is the best course of action is, it depends.

If you are trying to stop hypothermia for a short time it's almost certainly better to run around.

If you are trying to stop it for a long time then probably better to stay still.

From a purely energetic perspective, it is better for your body to use energy to keep itself warm than it is to move itself about, but that doesn't take into account that you need to keep your core temperature above a certain level.

If you are huddled up in relatively warm clothes it is probably better to use the energy to shiver and keep warm. If you are not in warm clothes then the immediate issue is keeping your body temperature up and the only way you can do that is to move around.

So IMO it's arguable.

A person who thinks they will be rescued quickly in thin clothing needs to move quickly to keep themselves alive until the rescue takes place, otherwise their core temperature will drop and they will die.

A person who wants to survive the longest in warm clothes is probably better huddling up and using their energy to shiver to keep themselves warm as long as possible in the hope rescue may occur. Energy is better used for shivering than running around in circles.

icypompoms · 09/03/2023 10:48

To suggest putting trousers on to go out in the snow http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4759014-to-suggest-putting-trousers-on-to-go-out-in-the-snow

Here's the argument op had yesterday.

Sassyfox · 09/03/2023 10:48

I guess it also depends on how long you are going to be stranded.

You want to keep your blood circulating but you don’t want to lose the fat that’s insulating you or the electrolytes that help keep you alive.

This is really interesting to me as I don’t actually know the right answer.
I’m guessing it will probably be in the middle and be light exercise or something.

Scaevola · 09/03/2023 10:46

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:40

kicking their legs increased the rate their bodies cooled until they were so badly affected by hypothermia that they could no longer hang on to their canoes.

They should have been told to hold their legs together to reduce the surface area exposed to the cold water, and conserve heat

If they had not kicked their legs, they might have survived long enough to be rescued. Possibly. No one will ever know. But half the group survived, so there it is likely that those who were lost, if they had held on a bit longer, might have survived too

I'm afraid that is unlikely in cold water.

After (maximum)10 mins, the amount of limb motion under voluntary control is so sharply reduced it would make no material difference. It's very, very rapid irrespective of attempted movement. The advice to surface float/hang on to something is not because it makes any difference to rate of cooling, but because you don't have full control of limbs within minutes and could end up doing something counterproductive (leaving you face down in water and unable to turn back over)

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:45

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:40

kicking their legs increased the rate their bodies cooled until they were so badly affected by hypothermia that they could no longer hang on to their canoes.

They should have been told to hold their legs together to reduce the surface area exposed to the cold water, and conserve heat

If they had not kicked their legs, they might have survived long enough to be rescued. Possibly. No one will ever know. But half the group survived, so there it is likely that those who were lost, if they had held on a bit longer, might have survived too

They died because they were in a cold river.

Kicking their legs or not would have made fuck all difference to that.

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/03/2023 10:44

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:40

kicking their legs increased the rate their bodies cooled until they were so badly affected by hypothermia that they could no longer hang on to their canoes.

They should have been told to hold their legs together to reduce the surface area exposed to the cold water, and conserve heat

If they had not kicked their legs, they might have survived long enough to be rescued. Possibly. No one will ever know. But half the group survived, so there it is likely that those who were lost, if they had held on a bit longer, might have survived too

I'm sorry but you are just plain wrong.

You've not provided any scientific evidence for what you are claiming.

Exercising causes carbohydrates in your body to be converted into muscle movement and heat. As posters have said, it may lead to other risks, like getting sweaty and hence cooling faster when you stop exercising. But fundamentally, exercise warms you up.

moonpixel · 09/03/2023 10:44

Ok, I am wondering why OP isn't providing any evidence? A story about people dying of hypothermia in cold water isn't going to cut it.

Is there any actual evidence?

Sassyfox · 09/03/2023 10:44

If you have spare clothing, roll around in the snow naked to absorb water from your skin.

From Bear Grills himself.

Not sure I’d recommend doing this if you’re only a 5 minute walk from home though.

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:44

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:37

It's not always convenient to "dress appropriately" when you are subjecting yourself to such different conditions.

The only foolproof option is to equip for the worst case scenario which would be to run with a rucksack on your back full of clothes to put on in case you were hurt or had to stop - and I was running for 10 years and would have never needed them in all that time. With this probability of occurrence, I'd take my chances having to knock on someones door.

Well, yes, but going out in all weathers in inappropriate clothing is clearly not a good idea.

If it's cold, just put an extra layer on and take it off if you need to - tie it around your waist or dump it behind a hedge or something and collect it on the way back, or just roll up the sleeves of a long sleeve top. I do that without needing to carry a full change of clothes in a bag.

And all this is besides the point that what the OP is trying to claim is nonsense.

Lastnamedidntstick · 09/03/2023 10:44

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:35

yes. Just yes.

No and yes.

you are “cooling down” because exercise has caused your body temp to rise above normal, so it utilises cooling mechanisms to bring it back down to normal.

once your body reaches normal temp again it will stop it’s cooling mechanisms- you stop sweating, skin capillaries contract etc.

what will not happen is that the body continues losing heat until you’re hypothermic. Your temp will stabilise at 37 degrees and no further. If you get colder- ie you’re wet, it’s freezing then your warming methods will kick in, you’ll shiver, blood flow to extremities will shut down etc

if the body kept cooling itself post exercise it would happen regardless of the weather and we’d be seeing hypothermic marathon runners and swimmers all over the place. People would be sweating profusely hours after their spin class.

Aweebitpainful · 09/03/2023 10:42

Thanks for this OP

Chickenly · 09/03/2023 10:42

Polis · 09/03/2023 10:26

It doesn’t mean that exercising in the cold is more likely to cause hypothermia than sitting still in the cold.

This study seems to suggestsotherwise.

You’re cooler than you think! Hypothermia may go unnoticed when exercising in the cold

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/08/210819102728.htm

That is not what that study is suggesting. We need more focus in life on scientific literacy and reading comprehension.

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:40

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/03/2023 10:35

The story is very sad. But kicking their legs did not worsen the hypothermia. The cold water caused the hypothermia.

kicking their legs increased the rate their bodies cooled until they were so badly affected by hypothermia that they could no longer hang on to their canoes.

They should have been told to hold their legs together to reduce the surface area exposed to the cold water, and conserve heat

If they had not kicked their legs, they might have survived long enough to be rescued. Possibly. No one will ever know. But half the group survived, so there it is likely that those who were lost, if they had held on a bit longer, might have survived too

OP posts:
NomadicSpirit · 09/03/2023 10:40

OP, you're getting your science confused a bit I'm afraid.

When you exercise / move, your body uses stored energy to do so. This release of energy warms up your body. It does not take this heat from a finite store of heat that you have internally. It does pump blood around the body and if you are foolish enough to be running around in the snow in a pair of shorts then you will lose this heat quickly and when you stop exercising / running, you will continue to lose heat. This can lead to hypothermia as your body is now losing more heat than its producing. The issue is that you are not dressed adequately for the conditions and your body is losing heat to the environment

However, if you are wearing appropriate layers and are in the cold, then you should move around to generate heat which is retained by the layers and it keeps you warm. If you don't then your body will reduce blood flow to its extremities to preserve warmth and you will be at risk of frostbite.

If you're still convinced I'm wrong, then provide a link and I'll take a look at it

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:39

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:35

yes. Just yes.

You are talking shite.

When you exercise, it isn't your skin which warms. It's your muscles. The body isn't actually all that efficient at turning calories into movement - about 80% of the energy used to contract a muscle is wasted as heat. That heat is distributed around the body by your circulatory system and radiates onto your skin.

Sweat cools your skin. Your skin doesn't generate heat.

I know this because I actually have studied biology. You clearly haven't.

icypompoms · 09/03/2023 10:39

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 09/03/2023 09:11

I can honestly say, hand on heart, I have NEVER 'run around' when caught in any snow. And neither has anyone I know.

Confused What a strange thread.

It follows on from a thread yesterday when OP was trying to insist a boy of 12 wear trousers in a car journey to football practice incase he got hypothermia.

Scaevola · 09/03/2023 10:39

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/03/2023 10:35

The story is very sad. But kicking their legs did not worsen the hypothermia. The cold water caused the hypothermia.

Cold water exposure is a very different thing

If you survive the gasp reflex, then you need to try to get to something to help you float and await rescue, within about 10 minutes, because that's about how long you have before further physiological responses deprive the limbs of circulation (ie blood diverted to core organs) making it hard to impossible to move much. Hypothermia, whether you are still moving or not, kicks in at about 30 minutes.

IHateLegDay · 09/03/2023 10:38

Bear grylls literally says that to stop getting hypothermia, you need to exercise.

Sassyfox · 09/03/2023 10:38

When you are hot your skin turns red as the blood vessels widen and blood is going to the surface to cool down and you sweat which acts as a way to cool you down.
This means less blood is around your vital organs.

When you are cold your blood vessels narrow and moves blood away from your skin in order to keep your internal organs warm (which is your skin turns pale and lips turn blue and why your fingers and toes are first to succumb to frost bite).
You also shiver, have goosebumps and hairs stand up to insulate you.

So yes in theory you are completely right OP.

I don’t actually know what the professional advice would be and I’d probably find myself walking around just to keep myself warm but it would probably be best to get out of the wind and do anything you can to keep your body heat in.

CloudPop · 09/03/2023 10:37

vodkaredbullgirl · 09/03/2023 09:14

Thanks for the heads up 🙄

This

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:37

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:24

It's not arguable at all.

If you go out running in the cold, your body warms up. If you stop, then you get colder. The answer is to wear appropriate clothing - generally it's a good idea to go out wearing 1 layer too warm and remove clothing if necessary.

It's not always convenient to "dress appropriately" when you are subjecting yourself to such different conditions.

The only foolproof option is to equip for the worst case scenario which would be to run with a rucksack on your back full of clothes to put on in case you were hurt or had to stop - and I was running for 10 years and would have never needed them in all that time. With this probability of occurrence, I'd take my chances having to knock on someones door.

ManchesterGirl2 · 09/03/2023 10:35

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:32

This used to be normal general knowledge when I was a school.

There was a terrible incident when a group of teens were canoeing in rough water, and most of them capsized, and ended up clinging to their canoes and each other waiting rescue, and their instructor told them to kick their legs to stay warm and most of them died of hypothermia

It was a long time ago, but there was a lot of upset at the time, as everyone knew the instructors advice had killed them, and at the time, this was just general knowledge. People knew not to exercise if you were trapped in a situation in danger of hypothermia

I expect a lot of people on Mumsnet are too young to remember that particular tradgedy

The story is very sad. But kicking their legs did not worsen the hypothermia. The cold water caused the hypothermia.

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:35

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:33

"when you exercise your skin gets hot, because it is dumping heat from your core. So you might feel hot. But you are cooling down."

No. Just no.

yes. Just yes.

OP posts:
Frabbits · 09/03/2023 10:33

"when you exercise your skin gets hot, because it is dumping heat from your core. So you might feel hot. But you are cooling down."

No. Just no.

Swipe left for the next trending thread