Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you not to run around if caught in snow- exercise cools you down

210 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 09:06

I am quite alarmed at the level of ignorance shown about this, so just in case anyone here gets caught in snow today

Please don't exercise to warm up - or tell your children to - this cools you down and leaves you vulnerable to hypothermia

Insulate yourself as well as you can, and huddle as close together as you can instead.

OP posts:
Youpillock · 09/03/2023 11:40

LookingOldTheseDays · 09/03/2023 09:20

Exercise does warm you up though.

The problems come when you run out of energy and have to stop exercising. The warmth you generate is your body burning its fuel (food), so the underlying source of the warmth is the fuel.

Having sweets on you, or some other energy dense food, will help keep you fuelled, active and warm.

I can confirm that i am constantly equipped for life and death scenarios then...

Youpillock · 09/03/2023 11:36

AgnesNaismith · 09/03/2023 09:17

I’m shocked, shocked to my ice cold core.

For God sake then, don't exercise!!

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 11:36

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 11:07

If you exercise to the point of generating excess heat, you sweat. In a situation where hypothermia is a risk, then it's unlikely you are going to be able to exercise hard enough for any length of time to actually generate heat.

OP is basically confusing two issues.

Firstly, exercise fundametally heats the body. It doesn't cool it. The OP claiming otherwise is just bullshit of the highest order.

Secondly if you are at risk of hypothermia the key thing to do is to remove yourself from that situation, find shelter of some sort and conserve heat, but this is enterely seperate from this batshit suggestion that exercise cools you down.

Maybe you mean sweat rather than heat in your first paragraph ?

I agree exercise generates heat. Whether or not it is the most efficient use of energy to maintain core body temperature is another question that I dont know the answer to. My guess is that shivering is a better way of maintaining core body temperature than exercise under certain conditions, but there are multiple variables/scenarios so it is complex.

I agree that exercise generates heat, but it may not necessarily be the best survival strategy either, which I think is the general point that the OP is arguing.

I think issues like how well you are clothed/heat loss rate, expectation time to rescue/ultimate objective (to survive a very cold temperature for a short time or a less cold temperature for a long time) all have a bearing on the best strategy to use.

If ultimately the objective is to ensure that all the available energy is used to preserve the core body temperature for as long as possible, it's not clear to me that exercise is the best option, and exercising to the point of sweating certainly does not feel to me to be a good idea.

Aweebitpainful · 09/03/2023 11:33

Err… b

QueenCamilla · 09/03/2023 11:25

A game.
Would you rather....
a) cuddle your neighbour naked
or
b) burn an original Picasso in your fire
to stay warm.

*Picasso apparently did burn his own works in Paris during the war.

I'd rather exercise but OP has taken that option off the list...

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 11:19

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:49

My guess is the answer to which is the best course of action is, it depends.

If you are trying to stop hypothermia for a short time it's almost certainly better to run around.

If you are trying to stop it for a long time then probably better to stay still.

From a purely energetic perspective, it is better for your body to use energy to keep itself warm than it is to move itself about, but that doesn't take into account that you need to keep your core temperature above a certain level.

If you are huddled up in relatively warm clothes it is probably better to use the energy to shiver and keep warm. If you are not in warm clothes then the immediate issue is keeping your body temperature up and the only way you can do that is to move around.

So IMO it's arguable.

A person who thinks they will be rescued quickly in thin clothing needs to move quickly to keep themselves alive until the rescue takes place, otherwise their core temperature will drop and they will die.

A person who wants to survive the longest in warm clothes is probably better huddling up and using their energy to shiver to keep themselves warm as long as possible in the hope rescue may occur. Energy is better used for shivering than running around in circles.

I would say that someone trapped in thin clothing needs to concentrate on shrinking their surface area as far as possible

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 11:16

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/03/2023 10:56

The last time I saw it was a teenage girl from a different school who had come litter picking in a city park on a cold rainy day without a coat. At the time I saw her she was fairly coherent, and I walked her over to a member of staff from her school, who arranged transport back to her school for her, but she deteriorated while waiting for the transport, and an ambulance was called

surely it was the lack of coat which caused the hypothermia here, not the gentle exercise of walking round picking up litter.

I am sure it was! All I was saying here is that hypothermia happens, in common situations, and can happen very fast, and it is dangerous. It wasn't snowing that day!

OP posts:
QueenCamilla · 09/03/2023 11:15

@Sassyfox in the treacherous survivalist-tough weather conditions the OP is experiencing, no hot drink could be sustained hot. You'd be sucking on icicles whilst huddling naked in a sleeping bag with your neighbour. I hope your neighbours like you enough to keep you alive 😂

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 11:11

That thing about hot drinks cooling you down is a myth.

Sassyfox · 09/03/2023 11:10

I think the exercise argument doesn’t work in this situation as I think you’d need to be out in it for a long time and be exercising vigorously non-stop to have any negative effects.

But I do wonder if your theory could work on hot drinks?

They say to drink a hot drink when it’s hot because it cools you down, so I wonder if the same could be said for drinking cold drinks in the cold weather and whether drinking a hot drink could actually make your internal organs colder?

Moonicorn · 09/03/2023 11:08

We don’t live in the Himalayas, OP Confused

Frabbits · 09/03/2023 11:07

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:57

Well it could do.

Exercise makes you sweat. The whole point of sweating is to get rid of excess energy through the evaporation of water.

If you are trying to stay alive in the cold, you don't want to get rid of energy, you want to preserve it solely to maintain your body temperature.

It's better to shiver than to sweat.

If you exercise to the point of generating excess heat, you sweat. In a situation where hypothermia is a risk, then it's unlikely you are going to be able to exercise hard enough for any length of time to actually generate heat.

OP is basically confusing two issues.

Firstly, exercise fundametally heats the body. It doesn't cool it. The OP claiming otherwise is just bullshit of the highest order.

Secondly if you are at risk of hypothermia the key thing to do is to remove yourself from that situation, find shelter of some sort and conserve heat, but this is enterely seperate from this batshit suggestion that exercise cools you down.

ladyforallseasons · 09/03/2023 11:06

Moraxella · 09/03/2023 09:19

@Freshstarts22 think OP has just got signal on the way back down from base camp or something

Brilliant 😂

QueenCamilla · 09/03/2023 11:04

QueenCamilla · 09/03/2023 10:56

Where I'm from, at 8 years old we used to go by ourselves to the local parks and woods and Strand ourselves in knee deep snow in -22 Celsius playing for 4 hours straight.
Arrived back home sweaty, heaps of snow inside the boots and dangling from our butts. Happy and red-cheeked.
Ah, the good times!

And I also remember taking some lemonade with us in a 1.5l bottle to drink and it was frozen through in an hour, so nothing to drink. We used to suck on icicles in those situations.

People are weird here.
I thought the British liked their winter-short-wearing tough image?

Sassyfox · 09/03/2023 11:04

Here's the argument op had yesterday.

I think wearing trousers in the snow or cold is a very sensible thing to do.

You’re meant to be trying to preserve your body heat which is exactly the reason why costs, gloves and hats etc were even invented.

Lastnamedidntstick · 09/03/2023 11:01

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:57

Well it could do.

Exercise makes you sweat. The whole point of sweating is to get rid of excess energy through the evaporation of water.

If you are trying to stay alive in the cold, you don't want to get rid of energy, you want to preserve it solely to maintain your body temperature.

It's better to shiver than to sweat.

That still doesn’t address the theory that exercise cools you down.

it doesn’t. It may waste energy, but it does so by wasting heat. Exercise does not in itself cause your body temperature to drop below normal, however much you sweat.

Chickenly · 09/03/2023 11:01

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:57

Well it could do.

Exercise makes you sweat. The whole point of sweating is to get rid of excess energy through the evaporation of water.

If you are trying to stay alive in the cold, you don't want to get rid of energy, you want to preserve it solely to maintain your body temperature.

It's better to shiver than to sweat.

And it’s better to move than to shiver. Which is what OP is explicitly saying not to do.

Chickenly · 09/03/2023 10:59

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:32

This used to be normal general knowledge when I was a school.

There was a terrible incident when a group of teens were canoeing in rough water, and most of them capsized, and ended up clinging to their canoes and each other waiting rescue, and their instructor told them to kick their legs to stay warm and most of them died of hypothermia

It was a long time ago, but there was a lot of upset at the time, as everyone knew the instructors advice had killed them, and at the time, this was just general knowledge. People knew not to exercise if you were trapped in a situation in danger of hypothermia

I expect a lot of people on Mumsnet are too young to remember that particular tradgedy

Even if this were true: water is a conductor, air is an insulator. That’s why if you’re in a room where the air is 10’c and you put your hand into water that’s 10’c then the water feels colder. The opposite is true if the water is warmer than body temperature. It’s why warm-blooded creatures do better on land and cold-blooded creatures do better in water.

If you cared so much about keeping people safe, you’d prioritise being accurate and giving correct advice.

Porkandbeans1 · 09/03/2023 10:57

What a strange thread. Movement is recommended as a way of preventing hypothermia. Strenuous exercise to the point of sweating is not. Not that the exercise cools you down, but sweating does.

GasPanic · 09/03/2023 10:57

Lastnamedidntstick · 09/03/2023 10:50

So IMO it's arguable

what’s is not arguable though is o/p’s assertion that exercise cools you down do the point of hypothermia.

Well it could do.

Exercise makes you sweat. The whole point of sweating is to get rid of excess energy through the evaporation of water.

If you are trying to stay alive in the cold, you don't want to get rid of energy, you want to preserve it solely to maintain your body temperature.

It's better to shiver than to sweat.

QueenCamilla · 09/03/2023 10:56

Where I'm from, at 8 years old we used to go by ourselves to the local parks and woods and Strand ourselves in knee deep snow in -22 Celsius playing for 4 hours straight.
Arrived back home sweaty, heaps of snow inside the boots and dangling from our butts. Happy and red-cheeked.
Ah, the good times!

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/03/2023 10:56

The last time I saw it was a teenage girl from a different school who had come litter picking in a city park on a cold rainy day without a coat. At the time I saw her she was fairly coherent, and I walked her over to a member of staff from her school, who arranged transport back to her school for her, but she deteriorated while waiting for the transport, and an ambulance was called

surely it was the lack of coat which caused the hypothermia here, not the gentle exercise of walking round picking up litter.

Ottersome · 09/03/2023 10:53

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 10:32

This used to be normal general knowledge when I was a school.

There was a terrible incident when a group of teens were canoeing in rough water, and most of them capsized, and ended up clinging to their canoes and each other waiting rescue, and their instructor told them to kick their legs to stay warm and most of them died of hypothermia

It was a long time ago, but there was a lot of upset at the time, as everyone knew the instructors advice had killed them, and at the time, this was just general knowledge. People knew not to exercise if you were trapped in a situation in danger of hypothermia

I expect a lot of people on Mumsnet are too young to remember that particular tradgedy

They would likely still have caught hypothermia if they'd remained still in the water.

I'm a winter hiker and climber. I have a number of friends in the mountain rescue. One story that sticks in my mind is a friend that had a winter callout, two separate groups had become stranded in whiteout conditions in the same group of hills in winter. One of the parties hunkered down together and waited for rescue, the other party continued to walk in a loop throughout the night, they knew they weren't going anywhere but they kept moving. The party who walked all night survived and all members of the other group died. Maybe the first party would have survived also had they managed to dig a bunker for themselves in the snow to shield themselves from the elements, but it's not as simple as just saying 'don't exercise if you're caught in snow or freezing conditions' and what you're saying could potentially be incredibly dangerous to people caught in situations like this.

NannyR · 09/03/2023 10:53

Whereabouts was the kayaking tragedy? I'd like to Google it and see what happened. I've found a similar incident in Lyme Bay in the early 90's, the reports into the incident mentioned lots of shortcomings from the instructors but kicking legs wasn't mentioned.

doadeer · 09/03/2023 10:52

I don't understand this.... Pushing the pram fast in this weather makes me sweat under my big coat I feel warm.

(Incidentally no snow in London to get stuck in... It's just cold and wet)