Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you not to run around if caught in snow- exercise cools you down

210 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 09:06

I am quite alarmed at the level of ignorance shown about this, so just in case anyone here gets caught in snow today

Please don't exercise to warm up - or tell your children to - this cools you down and leaves you vulnerable to hypothermia

Insulate yourself as well as you can, and huddle as close together as you can instead.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LookingOldTheseDays · 11/03/2023 08:49

It is - but you said you were wondering if the OP's claims were true. Hence my questions, because a basic understanding of the science is enough to tell you that the OP's description is nonsense..

The heat you generate through movement is 'new' heat. Moving your muscles converts stored energy in your body (which you get from food) into kinetic energy and heat energy.

Your body will only start trying to cool itself down if it gets too hot, at which point it will start to sweat etc. That's homeostasis. But it will never continue trying to cool itself once it's back down to a safe temperature. When it drops below approx 37 degrees, it will start trying to warm itself (shivering, retracting blood vessels).

If you get wet with sweat, or exhausted through exercise (use up all your stored reserves), you may risk hypothermia. But movement is never going to cool you down.

DarkNecessities · 11/03/2023 08:34

LookingOldTheseDays · 11/03/2023 08:26

@DarkNecessities When you exercise and feel warm - where do you think that heat comes from?

Do you understand that the movement of muscles actually creates the heat (as a by-product)?

Or do you think that your body has a finite supply of pre-existing heat, which is now just throwing out, leaving it in short supply?

Surely keeping moving and exercising to stay warm is the aim if you’re cold though? Within reason obviously.

LookingOldTheseDays · 11/03/2023 08:26

@DarkNecessities When you exercise and feel warm - where do you think that heat comes from?

Do you understand that the movement of muscles actually creates the heat (as a by-product)?

Or do you think that your body has a finite supply of pre-existing heat, which is now just throwing out, leaving it in short supply?

DarkNecessities · 11/03/2023 06:55

….. although it does make me wonder if the OP’s claims are true

DarkNecessities · 11/03/2023 06:51

Lastnamedidntstick · 10/03/2023 07:24

how did you not know?

surely if o/p’s assertion hold you must be very familiar with children regularly getting hypothermia from exercising in the cold?

I have never had a child suffer from hypothermia whilst under my watch and have never heard of it amongst colleagues 🤷‍♀️

It’s something I will be wary of in future, especially with the current weather situation.

BadNomad · 10/03/2023 16:43

Exercise warms you up. Sweating cools you down. Keep moving to keep warm, but don't do cardio.

I'm guessing the OP read something like "exercising in the cold increases your risk of hypothermia" and took that to mean it is the exercising that causes the hypothermia rather than the cold.

QueenCamilla · 10/03/2023 12:23

The advice that was given to us at schools (and everywhere else) in a country that had -20 Celsius snowy, icy winters:

Never stay put (as in, move! )

Don't drink alcohol to stay warm or if heading outside

Whatever you do, don't get wet feet and/or hands

Only step on frozen lakes once ice turns heavy and opaque

Due to under-ice streams it's never quite safe to step on frozen rivers

Look up. Stay away from trees and structures heavily coated in snow and ice - will be fatal if the ice and snow falls

Don't jump in the snow heaps from higher structures. There might be an old fence or a bench, or anything else underneath that will spear you. We used to jump anyway.

And the best one:
Don't pee on electrical junction boxes during the big freeze: cold air conducts electricity very well and a tourist got electrecuted by doing just that.

QueenCamilla · 10/03/2023 12:01

Don't get full-on sweaty but other than that - move! You'll be warm as long as you move.
Distance skiers don't get hypothermic.
I didn't get hypothermia as a small child playing outside in the snow for hours and hours non-stop. Had spare gloves and socks with me, as getting wet in the cold was the main scare, not the cold itself!

Shivers are literally your body trying to create some heat via micro-movements. If you shiver, move! Your body wants you to.

BourbonBon · 10/03/2023 11:58

ManchesterGirl2 · 10/03/2023 11:49

Uh, the op is wrong, so please don't apply their advice in your childcare setting.

Christ it’s scary how gullible some people are. One person comes on a forum with some bullshit “advice” and this poster swallows it and is ready to implement it into her childcare setting no questions asked 🤦‍♀️

Saschka · 10/03/2023 11:58

Nimbostratus100 · 09/03/2023 09:15

people die of hypothermia in cities, and I am honestly quite shocked at the level of ignorance on MN about it.

Children suffer from hypothermia in city parks, you know

In the UK? Seriously, can you point to a single case where a child was stranded in the snow in a UK park, ran around to warm up and tragically died?

I used to live in Toronto and the only people who died of hypothermia in winter were drunks, and homeless people. Children were not dropping like flies in parks. And it was -20. This is not a concern for the vast majority of people.

XelaM · 10/03/2023 11:53

Had he been moving around, he would have been ok

XelaM · 10/03/2023 11:53

Someone who gets stuck in the snow and walks for an hour or two to access the nearest shelter/town etc. will be far less likely to suffer from hypothermia than someone who sits still and awaits rescue.

Exactly! As I said above,I know one person who died of hypothermia when he fell asleep at a bus stop waiting for a bus in the Russian winter

ManchesterGirl2 · 10/03/2023 11:49

DarkNecessities · 10/03/2023 05:55

Thank you OP

i work outside with groups of children, mostly exercising, and I didn’t know this

Uh, the op is wrong, so please don't apply their advice in your childcare setting.

LookingOldTheseDays · 10/03/2023 10:32

And the Lyme Bay disaster definitely wasn't caused by the victims being told to kick their legs. The water would have conducted their heat away whether they moved or not.

LookingOldTheseDays · 10/03/2023 10:31

The thing is there is a tiny grain of truth in what the OP says, but the OP has misunderstood the full picture.

Sweat cools you down. Getting your clothes wet with sweat will accelerate cooling. Running out of energy will also stop your body being able to warm itself.

But the action moving your muscles quite literally converts stored energy in your body into heat energy. That heat wouldn't otherwise be generated if you sat still - it would remain as stored energy. So yes, your body will throw out some heat if you move about, but that's because it is generating additional heat.

Provided you aren't making yourself sweat, or exhausting yourself with extremely vigorous exercise, movement will warm your body and help keep you alive in the cold.

Someone who gets stuck in the snow and walks for an hour or two to access the nearest shelter/town etc. will be far less likely to suffer from hypothermia than someone who sits still and awaits rescue.

Frabbits · 10/03/2023 09:11

NashvilleQueen · 10/03/2023 07:50

Why are people so quick to scorn and ridicule on here?

There is a huge difference between walking briskly/playing in snow into a heated building where your body will cool down without risk and being trapped outside in snow for extended periods where (as this thread shows) instinct may suggest we move around a lot to keep warm. If you then stop but are still in the freezing cold then it's not impossible to see that can impact on your health is it?

People are quick to ridicule because the OP posted some batshit crazy ignorant nonsense after starting their post "I am quite alarmed at the level of ignorance shown about this...."

Doesthepopeshitinthewoods · 10/03/2023 08:23

You’d hope, or they’re rather stupid.

Emmamoo89 · 10/03/2023 08:23

I think this is a troll

Topseyt123 · 10/03/2023 08:17

Exercise warms you up because it increases your circulation. You haven't provided a shred of evidence to say otherwise and you haven't provided it because it only exists in your imagination.

Your "advice" is nonsensical, fictitious bollocks which I will not be following.

Lastnamedidntstick · 10/03/2023 08:15

NashvilleQueen · 10/03/2023 07:50

Why are people so quick to scorn and ridicule on here?

There is a huge difference between walking briskly/playing in snow into a heated building where your body will cool down without risk and being trapped outside in snow for extended periods where (as this thread shows) instinct may suggest we move around a lot to keep warm. If you then stop but are still in the freezing cold then it's not impossible to see that can impact on your health is it?

because the o/p’s assertion that “exercise cools you down” is quite plainly ridiculous.

do you really agree that if you exercise you cool down?

everyone has agreed that exercising to keep warm isn’t always the best choice, but exercise to cool down is physiologically impossible.

NashvilleQueen · 10/03/2023 07:50

Why are people so quick to scorn and ridicule on here?

There is a huge difference between walking briskly/playing in snow into a heated building where your body will cool down without risk and being trapped outside in snow for extended periods where (as this thread shows) instinct may suggest we move around a lot to keep warm. If you then stop but are still in the freezing cold then it's not impossible to see that can impact on your health is it?

NashvilleQueen · 10/03/2023 07:43

I have absolutely no skin in this game but the OP interested me so I googled it. I'm not sure how people thought every source undermined what the OP says and I sure as hell don't know for certain one way or another. But this advice on what to do if caught outside tends to support. I guess the issue here is that we rarely have a lot of snow to the extent that we get stuck (without a vehicle) so it's not such a huge risk.

To tell you not to run around if caught in snow- exercise cools you down
Lastnamedidntstick · 10/03/2023 07:24

DarkNecessities · 10/03/2023 05:55

Thank you OP

i work outside with groups of children, mostly exercising, and I didn’t know this

how did you not know?

surely if o/p’s assertion hold you must be very familiar with children regularly getting hypothermia from exercising in the cold?

CosyFanTucci · 10/03/2023 07:05

There’s a very good explanation of the process in Outside magazine: nieman.harvard.edu/stories/peter-stark-and-as-freezing-persons-recollect-the-snow-first-chill-then-stupor-then-the-letting-go/
Which includes the phenomena of people trying to strip off when hypothermic because they feel like they’re burning up. Which isn’t great.
But basically exercise brings blood to the surface where it cools more rapidly. Alcohol does the same thing and is also a bad idea in the cold.

XelaM · 10/03/2023 06:52

Huh?!? So why do you get warm when skiing but really cold just standing around? I actually know someone who died of hypothermia - they fell asleep at a bus stop (in winter in Russia). How do you explain that OP?