Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Maintenance

65 replies

Dinosaureally · 08/03/2023 23:53

My ex & I have been divorced for a decade & our daughter has decided to live with her father & step mum as its closer to her school (she’s 15)…all fine however he has now decided to apply for child maintenance. She lived with me up until now & he did contribute to her living expenses but nowhere near enough but I did not push that..I’m fuming that he’s applied as we are amicable so he could have asked. AIBU?

OP posts:
davegrohll · 09/03/2023 10:49

So because you're a woman you think you don't need to pay towards your child... when they're living with their dad ? Double standards that some women have this is. I can imagine sd mum thinking the same way to be honest !

Starlitestarbright · 09/03/2023 10:40

Just because your female doesn't mean you not financially responsible. By your attitude I can see why he went straight to cms. I'm gobsmacked by your attitude tbh.

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 10:40

You don't think it weird to say'no I don't want maintenance ' then instead put in a claim for maintenance (when the next step anyway is to then approach the parent to agree maintenance informally?)

Why wouldn't you just say 'yes I would like maintenance. Let's use the cms calculator or agree an amount between us'?

Do words not have meaning? no is yes?

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 10:38

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 10:36

It's weird that he refused your offer of maintenance then went direct to cms instead, but there's nothing much you can do. Just calculate how many nights she will be with you (is she staying with you all school holidays for example?) and pay whatever it says. It's an after pension contribution so don't just put in your gross salary when working it out.
Have you decided what to do about the child benefit claim as really that should move across but he probably isn't entitled if he earns over 60k

Why is it weird?

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 10:36

It's weird that he refused your offer of maintenance then went direct to cms instead, but there's nothing much you can do. Just calculate how many nights she will be with you (is she staying with you all school holidays for example?) and pay whatever it says. It's an after pension contribution so don't just put in your gross salary when working it out.
Have you decided what to do about the child benefit claim as really that should move across but he probably isn't entitled if he earns over 60k

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 10:33

You said in your OP that he paid you maintenance but 'no where near enough', then later you say he paid a substantial amount and you saved most of it each month?

None of this makes sense. You were entitled to claim CM, its a normal thing to do, its part of the process. He is now entitled to do the same, whats the matter with him doing that?

They will work the amount out and then its a formal arrangement with a neutrally calcualated amount

rothbury · 09/03/2023 10:31

I’m wondering if the ex paid a big lump sum directly to the DD or some such oddness?

It just doesn’t make sense as described, but yes OP, YABU to make it difficult as you said.

MamaCanYouBuyMeABanana · 09/03/2023 10:29

He paid for school, and enough in expenses that you could save 80% of it despite being on a low income?

Now you don't want to pay what you're due towards your dd because he is loaded?

You're completely wrong, and I understand why he's taken this route considering your attitude on here, best to get it sorted out legally so you all know where you stand.

Pay for your kid.

londonrach · 09/03/2023 10:27

Works both ways...if she living with him you need to pay maintenance. His girlfriend has no effect on this. She not the mum you are. Can't you use some of the money he gave you for maintenance you saved.

Yousee · 09/03/2023 10:23

Dinosaureally · 09/03/2023 00:27

He paid for her school fees but that doesn’t cover her cost of living, that wasn’t enough however he did contribute towards her lifestyle

Would it be a reasonable assumption that your DD spent a fair amount of time at her Dad's? I'm imagining she must have done if she felt comfortable deciding off her own bat to live there and it's closer to her school?
So her Dad has covered her school fees and contributed to her lifestyle up to now. Not sure exactly what your understanding of her "cost of living" is but if you mean things like the cost cost of her bedroom (mortgage/rent/CT/energy etc) then he will have had those same expenses at his house too. Do you pay for her food at your home and he paid for phone and subscriptions and things like that (lifestyle?)
If you then saved 80% of it he's been paying alot of money towards his child in your home, his home and school.
You need to contribute. If that's £100 per month instead of the thousands he's been paying then fair enough.

Knitterofcrap · 09/03/2023 10:15

I can’t understand what has happened here, can you be more specific?

It sounds like you made some weird arrangements with XH and didn’t follow normal protocol which is to agree a regular periodic payment for XH to pay TO YOU for the benefit of your dd.

He is now following correct protocol so no, you have nothing to complain about. You should probably pay him around 15% of your net pay each month if that helps to understand what the norm is.

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/03/2023 10:10

Just pay the CMS figure. Of course you can afford it, it’s a percentage of your income.

He clearly paid you plenty if you could afford to save it for her rather than using it to pay for the costs of housing, clothing and feeding her.

You’re annoyed she’s chosen to live with him, fair enough, but that doesn’t mean you can get out of paying.

Given the tone you’re using I can see why he’s going down official channels - I think you mean CMS not DWP - rather than trying to do it between you.

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/03/2023 10:05

You are contradicting yourself.

You say it wasn't enough but then say you managed to save 80%. They can't both be true.

Just use the calculator. You'll save far more with your DD not living with you as child maintenance is a pittance.

Forensix · 09/03/2023 09:55

*did

Forensix · 09/03/2023 09:55

Dinosaureally · 09/03/2023 00:06

He has gone to DWP for it which I’m angered by as he could have contacted me directly

He dis contact you directly, you offered an amount that wasn't enough so now he's going through the proper channels instead.

Forensix · 09/03/2023 09:53

That money he gave you wasn't for savings it was to raise her. So you say he never gave you enough but you managed to save 80% of it. Just use what you saved to pay him now.

ibuymeownflowers · 09/03/2023 06:17

You say you put money into a savings account after expenses- so the expenses are the maintenance? And he paid school fees too? I'm genuinely not sure how he hasn't been paying you maintenance.

Pleaseaddcaffine · 09/03/2023 06:16

Just go to the calculator its really easu to work out ans he shouldbt accept less as thats the minimum amount.
My son is only 4 and with me all the tine and his self employed dad gives me 75 a month... If my son 3ver lived with him full -(god forbid) time mine would be 600 or so as im a high earner. But its the rules, you pay for your child.

ibuymeownflowers · 09/03/2023 06:14

I'm a bit confused about the money he gave you. But you can't expect to not pay maintenance. Have you used the CMS calculator to work out how much they'll charge you? If you do it without getting them to collect and pay then he gets more money so might be worth mentioning that to him.

Mexicola · 09/03/2023 06:09

Can you imagine if it was a man that said he didn’t want to pay for his child? He’d rightly so get his arse handed to him on a plate and given a knife and fork!!

you’re contradicting yourself- you said he didn’t contribute enough then said he paid a lot and you were able to save it?

I think reading between the lines your annoyed he didn’t just speak to you about it but went “behind” your back and made a claim.

just pay whatever the CSA amount says and be done with it.

Ponderingwindow · 09/03/2023 05:00

Why are you angry? Applying for maintenance is a completely normal, neutral action.

If it bothers you, it could have been preempted by going online and using the calculator to determine your minimum legal obligatory payments. Then you could have started sending at least that minimum as soon as the custody arrangement changed.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/03/2023 04:56

Why did you save 80%? That was for you to provide for your dd. Use some of that money to pay maintenance if necessary.

Mortimercat · 09/03/2023 04:28

I can’t make much sense of this. If she is living with him now, why shouldn’t he apply for child maintenance? I also don’t understand why you say he didn’t pay enough maintenance when you were RP but also that you saved 80% of it. You shouldn’t have saved it, it was child “maintenance” not child savings.

Starlightstarbright1 · 09/03/2023 03:58

Well he did pay maintenance. Have you put your figures in cms calculator? That is the legal minimum you will be expected to pay regardless of what he did or didn’t pay tbh.

The none resident parent pays child maintenance..

ChildcareIsBroken · 09/03/2023 03:31

If you were able to save 80% of what he paid then clearly that was enough? Otherwise why didn't you use that money?
Don't worry, CMS shouldn't be more than you can afford. It's not good communication on his part, he should have talked to you first.