Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child Maintenance

65 replies

Dinosaureally · 08/03/2023 23:53

My ex & I have been divorced for a decade & our daughter has decided to live with her father & step mum as its closer to her school (she’s 15)…all fine however he has now decided to apply for child maintenance. She lived with me up until now & he did contribute to her living expenses but nowhere near enough but I did not push that..I’m fuming that he’s applied as we are amicable so he could have asked. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SchoolQuestionnaire · 09/03/2023 13:46

You’re getting a hard time op but the general gist is right. You need to pay cm. Yes he should have spoken to you first, yes he should understand that you can afford what you can afford but he isn’t really wrong for wanting this to be all above board.

I wouldn’t worry about cms as the amounts awarded are generally pitiful - as a pp said it’s the bare minimum. But insignificant or not, you do need to pay it. If only so you can look your dd in the eye and tell her that you contributed to her expenses.

FlippyFloppyShoe · 09/03/2023 13:40

I could understand it if you had needed more of his cm...say for example you earn £2000 and you get CMS of £500 so you get a mortgage based on £2500 income which might mean your payments were quite high and your house is the same whether your DC live there or not, so heating, electric, water fuel would not be amazingly different, but these are what cm would contribute too. Then council tax is unaffected but is a static cost too...maybe OPs fixed costs take up most of her earnings and losing the £500 on top of them having to pay out cm means it is unaffordable. You could be looking at a £1000 change in income....only the very rich wouldn't notice that.
OP I would use what is saved to give back to him as a top up and that yourself for being prudent. I know it's not what you want for your DC but it is being used correctly.

Tinkerbyebye · 09/03/2023 13:36

Just tell him the money he sent is in an account on your child’s name and he needs to access that

Flamingogirl08 · 09/03/2023 13:29

This post makes zero sense to me but if I understand it correctly her dad paid you an amount of which you spent 20% on expenses and saved 80% and he also paid her school fees so that's quite alot!

Now your daughter is living with him full time but you're annoyed about having to pay maintenance 🙄

My DH paid maintenance for DSD but she recently has been living with us 5/6 days a week due to her Mums new job. DH told her mum that maintenance would be stopping and she was outraged. He hasn't suggested claiming child benefit or getting maintenance off her just said that of course he won't be paying maintenance if DSD is with us most of the time. The behaviour out of her has been shocking just complete entitlement. I am getting the same vibe here.

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 13:08

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 09/03/2023 12:28

From what OP wrote it could have been
OP’s ex: « I have checked the calculator and maintenance should be around x »
OP: « I can’t afford that, I’ll give you y max »
OP’s ex goes « this is not enough » and goes to CMS.

What I mean is OP’s « he declined » doesn’t necessarily mean the ex declined to receive any money, it could mean declining the offer. TBH when it is men wanting to pay only the CMS amount they are told that it is the bare minimum, so not sure why OP thinks paying even less is acceptable.

Maybe.
Op is unclear on quite a lot.
She does say several times that he could have approached her directly and asked.

Maybe op will update at some point ....

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 09/03/2023 12:39

I get the feeling OP’s been on to a good thing for years and now the tables have turned she’s throwing her toys out the pram! Time to act like a big girl and support yourself and your child.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 09/03/2023 12:28

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 10:40

You don't think it weird to say'no I don't want maintenance ' then instead put in a claim for maintenance (when the next step anyway is to then approach the parent to agree maintenance informally?)

Why wouldn't you just say 'yes I would like maintenance. Let's use the cms calculator or agree an amount between us'?

Do words not have meaning? no is yes?

From what OP wrote it could have been
OP’s ex: « I have checked the calculator and maintenance should be around x »
OP: « I can’t afford that, I’ll give you y max »
OP’s ex goes « this is not enough » and goes to CMS.

What I mean is OP’s « he declined » doesn’t necessarily mean the ex declined to receive any money, it could mean declining the offer. TBH when it is men wanting to pay only the CMS amount they are told that it is the bare minimum, so not sure why OP thinks paying even less is acceptable.

MelchiorsMistress · 09/03/2023 12:05

It doesn’t matter if you can’t afford as much as he could afford. If he’s gone through CMS they will assess your income and you will be ordered to pay what they think you can afford.

This is normal for NRPs. Why do you think you’re any different?

PeekAtYou · 09/03/2023 12:01

Using the CMS rather than accepting a random amount from you reduces the awkwardness around discussing money and will help him accept what a fair figure from you is. CM is set as a percentage of your income so it's not the same amount that he used to pay you. If you're nervous about not knowing the final figure, use a CM calculator online to see how much you will likely have to pay. I don't think it's unreasonable to want to use the CMS. Some people don't want to have to discuss money and using the CMS is a way to keep that kind of thing businesslike. They calculate a figure deemed fair so there's no negotiating.

Do you understand what CM is for? You say you didn't receive enough but saved 80% of it? CM is your ex's contribution to the cost of raising your dd on the days that she's with you eg food and clothes. You and her dad can save for her too but it doesn't have to be out of the CM amount.

Sirzy · 09/03/2023 11:51

Dinosaureally · 09/03/2023 00:27

He paid for her school fees but that doesn’t cover her cost of living, that wasn’t enough however he did contribute towards her lifestyle

If you were lucky enough to be able to save significant amounts of what he gave then you can’t argue he didn’t provide enough.

uou need to pay towards your daughter

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 11:47

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 11:33

But its clear he wants to go through the formal channels, as I woud. As most women do. Whats the problem with that and why would you be upset about it?

Me personally?

God I'd be horrified if my relationship with my ex was so bad that we couldn't just have a chat and sort something out.

I'd actually take that as quite an insult to our co parenting relationship and our social skills. It would never happen, so that's fine, we are adult enough to work things out between us without needing the government to step in.

That's me though, and not as such relevant to the op, although I do think her posts are less about the money and more about the informal (when he was supposed to pay) vs formal (when she is supposed to pay) route and how she feels it reflects on their amicable/otherwise status.

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 11:33

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 11:02

The op says in the first post and several other posts that he could have just asked and she is specifically upset that he chose to put in a formal request rather than just ask her directly. That's what I took from the posts.

I'd be upset about that as well, it's not very amicable, and op thought they had an amicable relationship, as stated.

But its clear he wants to go through the formal channels, as I woud. As most women do. Whats the problem with that and why would you be upset about it?

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 09/03/2023 11:32

Dinosaureally · 09/03/2023 00:13

Trouble is he did provide. I cannot do the same. I didn’t touch a penny of the money as ai said after expenses 80% was in savings for her as it’s not my right to take from my daughter but I feel very let down now & he’s got a new girlfriend so he won’t talk to me about it

His gf is irrelevant, he paid towards your daughter, now you need to do the same because CMS will make you.

Porkandbeans1 · 09/03/2023 11:23

I think that going through child maintenance is the fair thing to do. They will work out what you should pay as a percentage of your earnings. It sounds like your ex has contributed significantly although I am a little confused by your posts.

Marchforward · 09/03/2023 11:13

Be honest with yourself. Lots of your comments aren’t making logical sense and you mention the new girl friend a few times. Are you annoyed about the new girl? That question is for you, you don’t need to reply to it.

Your ex has applies for maintenance as his is right to support the cost of raising his daughter. You could have done this too. It’s not clear if he has paid the amount CMS would have suggested (including school fees) or not but if he wasn’t that was down to you to sort in the past.

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 11:10

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/03/2023 11:06

It’s up to him to make a counter claim which he’ll be able to evidence.

Labouring the point a bit, as it was just advice for op really, but if he doesn't put in a counter claim (as he earns too much) then op is claiming it for a child who doesn't live with her. It's easy to overlook that kind of thing for ages and forget to cancel the claim.

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/03/2023 11:06

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 11:05

well it is up to the op to cancel her cb claim! It's her claim in her name Which is why I mentioned it. If he is a high earner he won't be asking for it to be transferred, will he?!
I don't know whether it needs to be cancelled but it's something to look into. She doesn't want to be accused of claiming it when she wasn't entitled later down the line.
Same applies to other benefits of course but cb is something forgotten about sometimes

It’s up to him to make a counter claim which he’ll be able to evidence.

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/03/2023 11:05

He clearly doesn’t think it’s amicable. And if she’d voluntarily offered to pay the full amount he’d probably have accepted. Only they know what’s really going on.

But OP seems confused on the details and resentful of having to pay despite receiving plenty of money when she was the RP. So her ex is doing the right thing by making it official and taking the feelings out of it.

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 11:05

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/03/2023 10:59

If a woman posted that her ex was offering her “what he could afford” and it was less than she thought she’d get via the CMS and he was being a bit chippy about it, she’d be advised to stop engaging with him and just open a claim. I know that because it’s happened plenty of times. She’d be told not to accept him pitiful offer, the money is to contribute to the costs of the shared child, and to get every penny due.

Whether the paying parent is male or female is irrelevant. The only reason people seem to think it is is that men are blamed for being the non resident parent and leaving the hard work to mums, and blamed for being the resident parent and taking the kids off mum to feather their own nests with maintenance. 50/50 is apparently even worse because the child has no one stable home and men only request it to avoid paying maintenance.

In this case, it’s not up to OP how much maintenance she wants to pay or what happens to the child benefit. She won’t have the child living with her so doesn’t get the child benefit. Her ex potentially earning over the threshold isn’t relevant.

well it is up to the op to cancel her cb claim! It's her claim in her name Which is why I mentioned it. If he is a high earner he won't be asking for it to be transferred, will he?!
I don't know whether it needs to be cancelled but it's something to look into. She doesn't want to be accused of claiming it when she wasn't entitled later down the line.
Same applies to other benefits of course but cb is something forgotten about sometimes

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 11:02

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 10:53

Thats not what I took from the OP, it seemed to me he was saying 'no I dont want to take your calculation of maintenance' and wants to go through formal channels. Which he is entitled to do.

I didnt get from it he was saying he didnt want maintenance. In any case he is entitled to change his mind if he did originally say that.

The op says in the first post and several other posts that he could have just asked and she is specifically upset that he chose to put in a formal request rather than just ask her directly. That's what I took from the posts.

I'd be upset about that as well, it's not very amicable, and op thought they had an amicable relationship, as stated.

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 11:01

Absolutely, the way this man is being portrayed on here for 'going behind her back' is unbelievable

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/03/2023 10:59

If a woman posted that her ex was offering her “what he could afford” and it was less than she thought she’d get via the CMS and he was being a bit chippy about it, she’d be advised to stop engaging with him and just open a claim. I know that because it’s happened plenty of times. She’d be told not to accept him pitiful offer, the money is to contribute to the costs of the shared child, and to get every penny due.

Whether the paying parent is male or female is irrelevant. The only reason people seem to think it is is that men are blamed for being the non resident parent and leaving the hard work to mums, and blamed for being the resident parent and taking the kids off mum to feather their own nests with maintenance. 50/50 is apparently even worse because the child has no one stable home and men only request it to avoid paying maintenance.

In this case, it’s not up to OP how much maintenance she wants to pay or what happens to the child benefit. She won’t have the child living with her so doesn’t get the child benefit. Her ex potentially earning over the threshold isn’t relevant.

mrsm43s · 09/03/2023 10:53

CMS is the BARE MINIMUM that you should be paying, especially if you are on a low wage. It's unlikely to cover a fair share of her costs.

If you offered less than the CMS rate, then you are a CF, and he is absolutely right to have gone to the CMS to enforce a fair payment.

Sorry, can't make head nor tail of him paying less than needed, but also you managed to save 80% of it! Makes no sense at all. In fact, reading between the lines, it sounds as though his higher wage significantly subsidised your household, and now you're upset that you're being expected to pay your own way, including a fair contribution towards your daughter's costs.

On the face of it, it seems like he's being entirely reasonable, and you entirely unreasonable. I don't understand why you would have a problem with him contacting CMS, unless you were planning to shirk your responsibility to pay reasonably towards your daughters costs? If you were planning on doing the decent thing and paying anyway, it makes no difference, does it?

bellac11 · 09/03/2023 10:53

ArcticSkewer · 09/03/2023 10:40

You don't think it weird to say'no I don't want maintenance ' then instead put in a claim for maintenance (when the next step anyway is to then approach the parent to agree maintenance informally?)

Why wouldn't you just say 'yes I would like maintenance. Let's use the cms calculator or agree an amount between us'?

Do words not have meaning? no is yes?

Thats not what I took from the OP, it seemed to me he was saying 'no I dont want to take your calculation of maintenance' and wants to go through formal channels. Which he is entitled to do.

I didnt get from it he was saying he didnt want maintenance. In any case he is entitled to change his mind if he did originally say that.

JJ8765 · 09/03/2023 10:51

Off topic but will she be likely to go to uni. If so she will get a lower maintenance loan living with a high earner so check he intends to make up the shortfall. Moneysavingexpert has a calculator. If she needed a higher loan it would be better for her to live with you I think they need to have been at the address for 2 years. You can’t just swap addresses at the time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread