Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed about being asked for money?

166 replies

Xzxzxzxz · 08/03/2023 21:15

I know a man through volunteering at an organisation we're both interested in. I would say we are friendly acquaintances. Tonight he messaged asking if I could lend him money because he can't afford to put his gas on till Monday. I asked how much and he said £25.

I have sent it because I felt guilty if he was freezing and I could help, but AIBU to feel annoyed that he asked and put me in an awkward position? I don't want it to become a regular occurrence and it has made me feel uncomfortable. AIBU to be a bit annoyed by the request, or should I just accept he had no option but to ask because of his circumstances?

OP posts:
Xzxzxzxz · 08/03/2023 22:48

TheHouseNextDoor · 08/03/2023 22:47

The trouble with lending money to someone struggling with money, is that they will struggle to pay it back. You can almost put them into a spiral of debt.

I'll no longer lend a friend money. She doesn't have the means to pay it back. If I have the money I'll just give it to her.

I did actually think this - am I just making it worse for him next week.

OP posts:
TheHouseNextDoor · 08/03/2023 22:47

The trouble with lending money to someone struggling with money, is that they will struggle to pay it back. You can almost put them into a spiral of debt.

I'll no longer lend a friend money. She doesn't have the means to pay it back. If I have the money I'll just give it to her.

Forensix · 08/03/2023 22:45

Hopefully some of you never experience the day that you're totally fucked and need to ask for a helping hand.

BensonStabler · 08/03/2023 22:43

he may need that amount for the prepay meter if he has used up emergency credit on it, so you need to pay more when it finally cuts off to then get it back on, as you pay what you owe first before you can then put on enough funds to last those days-week ahead.

Also this and next month many are still receiving the government help for heating costs during cold months and prepayment is usually a voucher (I think) however, there’s many people I know who have been desperately waiting on it arriving but they have delays. So he should be getting a little help for now, but a chance that still has not arrived.

I wasn’t aware of the loan type situation a pp said, for those struggling and on prepayment to get a code for a top up and repay in instalments. Maybe he wasn’t either. Definitely point that out if he comes to you again.

I think you have been very kind and generous given you’re not exact friends, I understand why it’s made you uncomfortable, I would never dream of asking someone in that situation. I do know however what it’s like to be absolutely desperate, no one to get help from, and I’m disabled so the cold causes me increased pain. I do hope it’s genuine and he pays you back asap. However it’s completely healthy to put firm boundaries saying no going forward. Don’t let anyone take advantage of that kind heart.

MrsMiddleMother · 08/03/2023 22:43

I voted yabu because if it's the first time he asked he must be desperate and it's literally snowing. If he asks again and you don't feel comfortable, say no but I think you did the right thing this time

discobrain · 08/03/2023 22:39

Compassion is alive and well on Mumsnet I see 🙄

Agapornis · 08/03/2023 22:38

Please flag this up with the volunteering organisation. Your volunteer manager should want to know this under duty of care. (Care for you as well as him.) The manager should have a chat with him and be able to put him in contact with organisations that can help him.
Hopefully you signed a volunteer agreement at the start - it should mention some behavioural standards. Asking fellow volunteers for money probably won't be mentioned in it explicitly, but it will be frowned upon.

Also, if the volunteer organisation doesn't take this seriously, please find somewhere else to volunteer.

Jenasaurus · 08/03/2023 22:37

I had a situation like this, I worked with someone who was aware I had just inherited some money and this person asked me for money for lunch, which I gave and then another time, and occasionally paid it back. They then said they wanted to start a business and asked me for 10k, I am sure this wont happen to you, but in the end I found myself avoiding this person as they always had a sob story to tell, I am sure your friend is genuine in their need but these things can escalate (and no I didn't give my colleague 10k, I wouldnt have done anyway but especially as they still owed me a fair bit of money for lunches etc.

ObviouslyIchangedmyname · 08/03/2023 22:36

JudgeRudy · 08/03/2023 22:26

I suggest you re-read. Nowhere have I said you don't know what 'emergency' is or that you don't know what you're talking about. No idea what the 'holier than thou but means'. Yes I said I probably would lend the money but I'd ask nosey Qs so not quite holier or even holy.
I've also said is £25 THAT high? It's more than I use but a lot less than others (especially if the £25 equates to £15 of fuel). Note how I used a question here. A 'know it all' would have said £25 isn't that high. ....or maybe "the amount is excessively high"!

If you don't understand what that means....lucky you.

Nowhere have I said you don't know what 'emergency' is or that you don't know what you're talking about.

You implied it pretty clearly.

For starters, if he only needed to use £15 in gas but is in emergency credit now then why can’t he top up £15 and go back into emergency credit until Monday? Clearly he needs to use £25 of gas if he needs £25. £25 in gas in four days is incredibly high for the vast majority of people. Hence why I asked why it was such a high amount.

Garrie · 08/03/2023 22:36

I doubt you'll see that again.

Zipps · 08/03/2023 22:34

You will never get the money back, you barely even know him. Next time (and any subsequent times ) say "No I don't have any spare money"

I would only ever lend to my immediate family and then I wouldn't want it back. No one else gets my money whatever the reason. People just take the piss if you let them.

Xzxzxzxz · 08/03/2023 22:34

Peony26 · 08/03/2023 22:30

Yeah but if he’s in a position of ask or freeze, how can you be annoyed at him?

If you found out his poor family were freezing. Would you not feel that you wished they asked for help? Would you not want to help if you can?

He lives alone.

No, honestly I wouldn't rather he asked me. If he was a friend, yes, I'd want to know. If he was a friend I'd invite him to stay at my house if he was cold. But he isn't a friend.

OP posts:
Xzxzxzxz · 08/03/2023 22:31

EddyF · 08/03/2023 22:27

People have such bad spirits. You haven’t even given him a chance to return the money and you are being weird about it. It’s 25 pounds; a pittance/takeaway money. Can’t you just accept you did a good deed and leave it?

I'm largely not bothered about whether he returns it. It's that he asked at all that's annoyed me.

OP posts:
Peony26 · 08/03/2023 22:30

Yeah but if he’s in a position of ask or freeze, how can you be annoyed at him?

If you found out his poor family were freezing. Would you not feel that you wished they asked for help? Would you not want to help if you can?

EddyF · 08/03/2023 22:27

People have such bad spirits. You haven’t even given him a chance to return the money and you are being weird about it. It’s 25 pounds; a pittance/takeaway money. Can’t you just accept you did a good deed and leave it?

Peony26 · 08/03/2023 22:26

I think just give him the benefit of the doubt this once, it’s gone really cold and many are really struggling. Tbh if I believed if it was for gas I would of just given it him if I could afford it this once, but I wouldn’t keep doing it, if he started taking the mick then I would say I haven’t got it sorry I’m short myself so he wouldn’t ask again

JudgeRudy · 08/03/2023 22:26

ObviouslyIchangedmyname · 08/03/2023 22:05

Yes the whole world is ignorant except for you. We get the message that you’re a holier than thou know it all 🙄 My PAYG meter was removed in January, so I know exactly what I’m talking about thanks.

I suggest you re-read. Nowhere have I said you don't know what 'emergency' is or that you don't know what you're talking about. No idea what the 'holier than thou but means'. Yes I said I probably would lend the money but I'd ask nosey Qs so not quite holier or even holy.
I've also said is £25 THAT high? It's more than I use but a lot less than others (especially if the £25 equates to £15 of fuel). Note how I used a question here. A 'know it all' would have said £25 isn't that high. ....or maybe "the amount is excessively high"!

Cornishclio · 08/03/2023 22:22

He turned his problem into your problem and made you feel guilty enough to give him money. No I would not have helped him. He was not a friend and he does not even sound like a nice person. He may not have had any money or he might be sitting on a fortune and this sounds like a nice scam to get a bit of cash out of someone. That might be cynical but I volunteer on the MSE website and there are stories galore on there about "friends" borrowing money and never paying it back. This guy wasn't even a friend. Just say no next time unless you are happy to lose the money and it does not sound like you are.

Quitelikeit · 08/03/2023 22:22

Choose you hard

A: saying no and being worried about him being cold

B: giving money and feeling emotionally pressured

How about you feel good that you did some good for someone in the world today? That’s how I would look at it

However in your circs I would not have given £25 maybe 10 or £15 tops

Zapzep · 08/03/2023 22:19

If you do work at voluntary organisations then you are going to meet people with unfortunate circumstances. I was nice of you to lend the money, put don’t feel obliged too.

BasiliskStare · 08/03/2023 22:18

I can actually understand being annoyed at being asked - lending it in case the chap was genuinely in need - but still being annoyed for being asked. When all is said and done @Xzxzxzxz has done a kind thing & if the money is wasted or he should be looking elsewhere well so be it if OP can afford it.

So I think a kind gesture but I don't think OP is wrong for being annoyed. I wouldn't be doing again though.

Rainbowshine · 08/03/2023 22:16

His problems are not your responsibility to solve. You need to get your head around that. I don’t understand why you feel that you have to rescue people who have such a tenuous connection to you. I think you need to think about that. That will help you to say no without all the angst.

Lockheart · 08/03/2023 22:15

It was a kind gesture as a one off.

But what will you do if he doesn't repay you and he keeps asking?

You need to direct him to charities and local services who can provide proper long term help.

Riverlee · 08/03/2023 22:15

@Xzxzxzxz

i understand where you are coming from. Basically, he made his problem your responsibility, and if you refused to help, you become the baddy (which you’re not).

Are there any warm hubs you can direct him to also.

MrsMoastyToasty · 08/03/2023 22:14

If he asks again say something along the lines of you getting in trouble with the organisation that you volunteer for but offer to signpost him to other charities who may be able to help.