Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your experience of EMDR

65 replies

PumpkinSpicedLatte · 08/03/2023 20:51

This isn’t an AIBU but I’m hoping for some success stories/advice.

I’ve been advised to try EMDR therapy for PTSD surrounding my daughters birth 2.5 years ago.
I suffered post natal mental illnesses but went into recovery after a lot of intervention. The one and only thing I haven’t made a recovery in is my PTSD.
i have read a lot about what EMDR involves but I’d love to hear of any experiences, and I know MN is a very honest platform.
Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SirWalterElliot · 09/03/2023 17:12

I found it incredibly helpful. I can now think of the traumatic experience like any other memory, rather than something completely overwhelming that I'm reliving. Mine was face to face.

Surplus2requirements · 09/03/2023 17:06

Powtayto · 09/03/2023 16:20

Can someone please explain step by step what a session involves. Do you talk about the traumatic event whilst doing the eye movement? Is this for a few minutes?

I don't know how much it varies but for me it was a bunch of talking sessions first, I don't remember how many, 5 or 6 to kind of explore around the memories. What I was thinking, doing, smelling, feeling everything.

The actual EMDR sessions were more like a guided meditation where I was lead through the memories while being prompted to experience it as fully as possible while following his finger.

Not sure about the time, maybe 15mins max, probably more like 10. Lots of breathing exercises after, making sure I was OK.

The first session I remember thinking part way through that I wanted to stop, that I was going to be a complete mess and unable to get home but to be fair, apart from being very tired I was surprisingly together if somewhat numb and feeling empty.

It wasn't an instant cure but I did have a lessening of symptoms over a period of about a week and was offered more talk or more emdr each week.

I've been twice about 18 months apart and would have probably continued longer each time if funds had allowed.

Powtayto · 09/03/2023 16:20

Can someone please explain step by step what a session involves. Do you talk about the traumatic event whilst doing the eye movement? Is this for a few minutes?

Beaglesonlyplease · 09/03/2023 13:11

I’ve had it. EMDR that is for ptsd. The therapist used the eye movement (finger following) in person.
The first few sessions left me feeling hollow and exhausted and nauseous (DH picked me up after each session and had a fizzy drink and chocolate which was actually a good idea of his.
I have PTSD (or had?) for over 3 years after SA (by a doctor) and found it impossible to live any kind of normal life. Constant nightmares, sweaty, heart-pounding, feeling (and being) sick if I had to go near the hospital he works at (with a disabled DD that was often), developed social anxiety and couldn’t go out after mask wearing stopped because I’d be shaking in my legs etc.
Flashbacks that twice nearly caused me to have a car accident.

EMDR literally saved my life. I’m also on Sertraline and have regular counselling.

I think trauma of any kind that’s experienced as trauma could potentially be helped greatly with EMDR - though I had about 12 sessions I had to come back after a year as the nightmares started up again (I’m going through a legal issue over this).

What made it worse was being called a liar or mad or “overreacting “ by so many people.
it seemed like everyone saw me as a crazy liar.

I’m also someone who had child SA, other violence on my life and lost my first DD at full term. None of those things affected me (possibly made me more susceptible to ptsd) so the trauma based CBT I did with the EMDR therapist helped me sort through what was affecting me.

I had a strong ability and tendency to dissociate which the therapist had to really work on to get me to focus on the memories .

there is very little talking in EMDR when you start the treatment part in my experience

maybekauri · 09/03/2023 12:28

Can I ask if anyone has experience of EMDR for someone on the autistic spectrum? I am thinking about whether it could be helpful for 18 year old DD who has trauma over school experiences.

Also how typical is sadcatsface’s experience? They related ‘sitting with a flashback for a solid hour, being made to describe it whilst being prevented from dissociating by the therapist’. I don’t think DD could manage that because of her tolerance of distress.

Also, how much talking by the participant does there need to be. DD has selective mutism.

Rummikub · 09/03/2023 11:59

I think I had a few examples of feeling abandoned. So they were grouped but I worked on the strongest memory.

It was weird as some stuff I’d not thought about but perhaps it was having an impact because as soon as I started focussing on it I was in floods of tears and right back there.

Powtayto · 09/03/2023 11:13

Rummikub · 09/03/2023 11:03

I had some of these. And the therapist asks you to think of the situation. Or as pp said group them together.

So when you say group them together do you mean memories or feelings? So in my example would that mean - thinking about being left out or do you think about the feelings of being left out? Or both? Sorry if I'm not making sense.!

Rummikub · 09/03/2023 11:03

Powtayto · 09/03/2023 07:11

Can I ask what if you have not had a 'major' trauma but just a generally crap childhood. Being left out, ignored, ridiculed, being told to shut up and go away, feeling lonely. I ended up just blending into the background and not speaking. I think I may have has selective mutism for a bit too. I think I may have cptsd. Would it work for someone like me?

I had some of these. And the therapist asks you to think of the situation. Or as pp said group them together.

Hopingforno2in2023 · 09/03/2023 09:10

I am currently having it for CPTSD due to childhood abuse. I have been having it for almost 6 months now as there are so many traumatic memories that need reprocessing. My therapist did warn me at the start that I would need a longer course of treatment due to the sheer amount of trauma. It is having a brilliant effect. Was very hard the first few sessions but so much easier now. Would definitely recommend.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/03/2023 08:15

You can have it and be on anti depressants without coming off them. I was.

It can be used for other reasons as well as ptsd.

Rollingupahill · 09/03/2023 08:09

I had loads of different types of traumas - health problems, parenting, traumatic deaths of loved ones. It worked for me.

wolfwalk · 09/03/2023 07:34

My experience of it was very strange. I had to stop before the end of treatment as my physical reaction to it was so strong (headaches, nausea, shakes/twitches etc). I'd be full-body shaking for hours after a session.

UseOfWeapons · 09/03/2023 07:14

Currently undergoing it now, for C-PTSD. Via WebEx. Early days, so can’t really comment, but sometime feel traumatised afterwards, and sometimes utterly numb for a few days. We’re using the tapping method, rather than eye movements.

Powtayto · 09/03/2023 07:11

Can I ask what if you have not had a 'major' trauma but just a generally crap childhood. Being left out, ignored, ridiculed, being told to shut up and go away, feeling lonely. I ended up just blending into the background and not speaking. I think I may have has selective mutism for a bit too. I think I may have cptsd. Would it work for someone like me?

JamBiscuitBun · 09/03/2023 06:55

I've had a lot of EMDR from a top practitioner. It's useful for small focused traumas but not enough for those with C-ptsd. You often come out feeling quite 'free' for 3 or 4 days but then it wears off. I imagine it's very helpful in less complicated histories.

wibblewobbleball · 09/03/2023 06:33

Highly recommend it. Worker brilliantly for me, twice.

malificent7 · 09/03/2023 05:41

Life changing...i stopped being angry with my abusive ex and went on to meet my wonderful fiance!

lborgia · 09/03/2023 04:28

How would you know that it was medicine that stopped it working properly?

3 family members including me, used it for 4 very different reasons, all using 3 different types of prescription/ssris/tricycles etc, and all had huge successes with it, including:

PTSD
CFS- related mental health issues
Chronic pain
Night terrors

Thethuthinang · 09/03/2023 03:23

I think it saved my life. Some years ago my depression became resistant to medication even at very high doses. I was intensely suicidal and on the verge of being institutionalized. I had a small child at home and did not want to be shut up and given stronger medication which might not work anyway and would have terrible side effects. I decided to try EMDR. Two or three sessions did more for me than years of conventional therapy. After about six months the EMDR therapist cautioned me that it might not work completely as I was still on some medication. With some difficulty I was able to taper off that completely and after another few months of EMDR my depression and anxiety went completely ok not remission. I still had a lot of memory loss, a side effect of the medication. Neurofeedback helped with that.

newtb · 09/03/2023 00:29

It works by the eye movements causing the same type of reprocessing that occurs in rem sleep ie when you dream.
It was discovered by Francine Shapiro while walking her dogs, by a river from memory.

I've had it, too. I can only describe it like a kid's transfer floating on water that gradually breaks into tiny pieces and then just disappears into dust.

For anyone looking, there's a Europe wide directory of practitioners.

Escapetofrance · 09/03/2023 00:07

I had it a few years ago and it did nothing. Im trying again now and I’m hoping it will work this time. I’m still optimistic.

Sadcatface · 09/03/2023 00:03

I had this over zoom last year, about 12 weeks for abuse that spanned roughly 20 years from age 5. Obviously it wasn’t going to fix everything, however the specific flashbacks that we covered each week no longer occur. I would regularly zone out of my body and go back to a particular time, that doesn’t happen to me anymore. I don’t think the lights, eye movements or tapping are the part that works but more to do with sitting with a flashback for a solid hour, being made to describe it whilst being prevented from dissociating by the therapist. Therapists differ, so I won’t speak for all, although my therapists approach seemed very similar to brainwashing techniques I’ve read about used by Moonies or Scientologists. But it did the job it set out to do, no more no less.

It is incredibly exhausting, and I did feel extremely unwell mentally throughout the 12 weeks, but a year on I do not experience these flashbacks. I was previously put on CBT as a teenager, which was awful. The EMDR process doesn’t blame you for your feelings and experiences, nor does it make you feel like your symptoms are caused by a personal defect or lack of willpower. (At least it shouldn’t!)

I would recommend planning comfortable things to do after a session, try and not have something intense or stressful to undertake afterwards if possible. A nice tasty snack and a hot drink helped me wind down afterwards. Wish you all the best with it 💐

Cantthinkofausername2022 · 08/03/2023 23:58

I found it very distressing. I became flooded with the same emotions and physical response at the time of the trauma to the point I thought I might even vomit
The therapist was able to calm me after about 10 mins but I felt physically shook the rest of that day
I do now feel a sense of detachment and have healed from the traumatic event but unsure if it was down to the EMDR or if I just processed it myself?

giggly · 08/03/2023 23:55

Enthrallingstoryofstillness · 08/03/2023 23:41

Is it good if you have say a bad relationship with someone but not any particular episodes you could refer to? Like a general anxiety around that person?

That would depend on your anxiety response. So if some one makes you feel slightly anxious because they are unpleasant I’d say that was a normal anxiety response and not a significant response. Anxiety is a normal emotion that we all experience but only becomes problematic when our perception of being able to cope tips is off balance and affects our ability to perform normal daily activities.

Surplus2requirements · 08/03/2023 23:54

Enthrallingstoryofstillness · 08/03/2023 23:41

Is it good if you have say a bad relationship with someone but not any particular episodes you could refer to? Like a general anxiety around that person?

The way it has been explained to me is EMDR focuses on specific traumatic events.
During trauma the brain doesn't file memories like it normally does so it's like the memories are floating around and can surface at any point unbidden, uncontrolled and unfiltered.

The therapy takes you back to those moments as fully as possible and 'resets' the brain so it can file it properly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread