Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest putting trousers on to go out in the snow

347 replies

Shebelievedshecouldbutshecba · 08/03/2023 19:49

DS was being taken to football today. Was in football kit ready to go. DH asked him to put trousers on before getting in the car, given it was snowing. DS refused point blank. DH said he wasn’t taking him unless he put the trousers on. I agreed. DS refused, so DH wouldn’t take him and we now have had a 2h tantrum (with screaming) about what awful parents we are.

WWBU? I don’t think we were. Would have taken him less than a minute to put the trousers on, the consequence of not doing so was clearly laid out, and then we followed through with the consequence.

And any guesses how old DS is?

OP posts:
MysteryBelle · 09/03/2023 18:18

Why did he have to change? He was going to be riding in the car, right, not walking in the snow.

My son went through a phase where he wanted to only wear shorts no matter what the weather. He also went through another phase where he had to wear a jacket all the time no matter the weather. No amount of reasoning with him helped. He finally grew out of the phases. Turns out a teacher in prek admonished him once for not wearing a jacket on a cool morning and that’s where the jacket thing came from. Your son has a reason for wanting to go to practice with his kit already on. Find that out, and you’ll be closer to resolving the issue.

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 09/03/2023 18:17

My son is 15 in April. He plays football as well. He point blank refuses to wear trousers in colder weather as it’s too much grief to get on and off with his boots on.

you and your husband were simply too harsh.

should have just brought the trousers along incase he got cold enough to decide to wear them.

artsperson · 09/03/2023 18:13

Shebelievedshecouldbutshecba · 08/03/2023 19:49

DS was being taken to football today. Was in football kit ready to go. DH asked him to put trousers on before getting in the car, given it was snowing. DS refused point blank. DH said he wasn’t taking him unless he put the trousers on. I agreed. DS refused, so DH wouldn’t take him and we now have had a 2h tantrum (with screaming) about what awful parents we are.

WWBU? I don’t think we were. Would have taken him less than a minute to put the trousers on, the consequence of not doing so was clearly laid out, and then we followed through with the consequence.

And any guesses how old DS is?

He's a babish 6 year old?

Dis626 · 09/03/2023 18:11

My DS is 10 and wears shorts all year round to school and football. Most of the boys in his class do. They are fine! I think YWBU.

Hazey19 · 09/03/2023 18:06

My son wears shorts all year round. Try as I might to get him trousers he won’t have it!

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 09/03/2023 18:05

7?

MMUmum · 09/03/2023 18:02

From being about 3 years old I told my DD you make your choice and suffer the consequences, as long as it wasn't a serious matter. I once asked her to put her coat on as we were going out, she refused and said she chose to be cold, off we go coat in my hand, she steps outside and said I think I choose to put my coat on, because it was freezing. He's old enough to make his choices and suffer the consequences, pick your battles.

Angebot · 09/03/2023 17:55

Was it worth the 2 hour fallout?
Pick your arguments I sat

cracklefick · 09/03/2023 17:48

Pick your battles. Mine is only 5 and if it was going to cause that much of a fuss then I would have left him to it. He'll get cold legs and learn for next time. I definitely would be letting a 12 year old make their own choice on that one.

Take a pair of trousers with you and say 'I told you so' when he sheepishly asks for them.

Highover · 09/03/2023 17:44

Orangetapemeasure · 08/03/2023 20:47

The phrase ‘pick your battles’ springs to mind.
my mum always says ‘will it matter in 2 hours, 2 days, 2months, 2 years’. Very little actually matters.

I like this - going to remember for future reference

Climbles · 09/03/2023 17:37

spelunky · 09/03/2023 15:37

Bringing up kids well is exhausting. Doesn't mean you don't bother.

I was talking about teachers. They have 30 kids to deal with. Where did I say I don’t bother to bring up my own children? I actually said I discuss with them the merits of healthy food, bed time, screen time almost constantly and of course discuss real body autonomy and boundaries too.

spelunky · 09/03/2023 15:37

Climbles · 08/03/2023 22:48

I would find it exhausting to constantly be debating with and strongly encouraging kids who think they know better. But it’s not an exact situation I’ve been in and hopefully teachers have a lot of patience.

Bringing up kids well is exhausting. Doesn't mean you don't bother.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 09/03/2023 14:49

I see Nimbostratus has arrived to tell us all the child will potentially DIE of hypothermia.

@Shebelievedshecouldbutshecba This is the sort of thing my stubborn-as-a-mule husband would do. I would then wade in a say if he wants to get cold, he gets cold. At 12 he's big enough and ugly enough to take responsibility.

Quartz2208 · 09/03/2023 13:42

The fact is though at 12 they should be perfectly capable of making autonomous choices. Clothes is something as well that is v personal depending on individual body temperatures. My two run v differently abd will often wear different levels of clothing. As do me abd DH he often is in multi layers and thermals and I will be in one jumper.

Climbles · 09/03/2023 12:43

Puppers · 09/03/2023 11:30

Well, no. You are drawing comparisons that aren't relevant which demonstrates that you either don't understand or are being deliberately obtuse. I suspect that others, like me, aren't bothered in the least whether or not you agree with us, but are perhaps a little frustrated that you are repeatedly attempting to misrepresent our viewpoint. So I shall leave you to it 👍

They do not seem comparable to you but they do to me. It has helped me to understand some others view points by explaining why they would act one way in this situation but not in others.

PearlClutzsche · 09/03/2023 11:49

Elsanore · 09/03/2023 08:13

He might be one of life's Shorts Men. I've noticed them around throughout life. Men who wear shorts all the time no matter what. PE teachers. Walkers in the countryside. Boys at primary or secondary school. Sporty 6th formers/ uni students. Some men are just Shorts Men. Let him get on with it I say, while providing other leg wear options.

Oh yes, shorts man! I know a few!

Only recently a school gate mum acquaintance was talking to me about her husband, who is often in school picking up, but I couldn’t think who she was referring to. She said “dark hair… shorts!” And from the “shorts” I knew who she meant!

PearlClutzsche · 09/03/2023 11:44

A child that age has to learn to be able to make their own judgements. If he refuses to wear trousers after being strongly advised to and having it pointed out that he may be cold, then he may get cold. His choice. He’d likely wear them next time.
I’d have let him get on with it and taken some trousers along just in case.

It seems you and your DH were more bothered about having your authority undermined than anything else. It’s great that he goes out to do a sport. Don’t discourage it.

Puppers · 09/03/2023 11:30

Climbles · 09/03/2023 10:47

I understand, I just don’t agree. There are other people contributing to the thread that agree with me. I sense people are becoming frustrated that I won’t concede to their view which is ironic considering the subject of the thread.

Well, no. You are drawing comparisons that aren't relevant which demonstrates that you either don't understand or are being deliberately obtuse. I suspect that others, like me, aren't bothered in the least whether or not you agree with us, but are perhaps a little frustrated that you are repeatedly attempting to misrepresent our viewpoint. So I shall leave you to it 👍

Climbles · 09/03/2023 10:47

Puppers · 09/03/2023 10:22

For whatever reason you just aren't understanding what people are saying.

No it isn't comparable to a bedtime for a child. Obviously when they are young that's completely in the control of the parents, whether the child likes it or not. As they get older it's natural that they will start to have more control over when they sleep. Obviously if they are unable to make sensible decisions and this affects their health (which long term lack of sleep does), their education or affects other people in the house due to mood, noise etc then parents step in and lay down rules. The rules, even if the child doesn't like them, should be reasonable and understood by the child. I.e. bedtime is going to be 9pm. I know you'd like to stay up until 10pm but when you make that choice, you are moody and unable to focus at school. End of discussion.

The issue with OP's scenario is that the decision of the parents to override the child's autonomy is based on nothing other than a desire to "win" and exert control. The child knows whether he needs trousers or not, he is capable of making decisions about how to dress himself for his own comfort and the consequences do not affect anyone else.

I understand, I just don’t agree. There are other people contributing to the thread that agree with me. I sense people are becoming frustrated that I won’t concede to their view which is ironic considering the subject of the thread.

Dalekjastninerels · 09/03/2023 10:26

I have not read the whole thread as I work full time and my free time is a precious gift.

I would just let him wear what he likes; he is not a 2 year old. If he is cold then that is his problem.

TheFifthTellytubby · 09/03/2023 10:22

One thing I learned while mine were growing up (and it was definitely a learning curve) was the importance of choosing your battles. Unless your DS has some medical condition that requires him to keep warm - in which case, he probably wouldn't be playing football in the snow anyway - why were you so insistent that he should wear trousers just to go to and from the car? He's the one who would end up with cold legs, but he's never going to admit that now, is he? The only real conseqences of not wearing trousers would be momentarily cold legs - it was you that escalated those consequences into missing the football session. My response would have been to take the trousers in the car and let him know they were there if he wanted them, possibly with a discussion on the way about warming muscles up properly before exercise to avoid injury.

Puppers · 09/03/2023 10:22

Climbles · 09/03/2023 09:12

Would the posters here claiming the OP is unreasonable also never tell their children to go to bed? The same thing applies surely. He knows if he is tired, the consequences are to him alone. I don’t understand why telling him he should wear appropriate clothing for the weather, then following through when he flatly refuses is so terrible. Sometimes 12 year olds don’t know what’s in their best interests. I find the posters claiming she will have affected him for life and he will be vulnerable to abuse frankly ridiculous.

For whatever reason you just aren't understanding what people are saying.

No it isn't comparable to a bedtime for a child. Obviously when they are young that's completely in the control of the parents, whether the child likes it or not. As they get older it's natural that they will start to have more control over when they sleep. Obviously if they are unable to make sensible decisions and this affects their health (which long term lack of sleep does), their education or affects other people in the house due to mood, noise etc then parents step in and lay down rules. The rules, even if the child doesn't like them, should be reasonable and understood by the child. I.e. bedtime is going to be 9pm. I know you'd like to stay up until 10pm but when you make that choice, you are moody and unable to focus at school. End of discussion.

The issue with OP's scenario is that the decision of the parents to override the child's autonomy is based on nothing other than a desire to "win" and exert control. The child knows whether he needs trousers or not, he is capable of making decisions about how to dress himself for his own comfort and the consequences do not affect anyone else.

redskylight · 09/03/2023 10:13

Climbles · 09/03/2023 09:12

Would the posters here claiming the OP is unreasonable also never tell their children to go to bed? The same thing applies surely. He knows if he is tired, the consequences are to him alone. I don’t understand why telling him he should wear appropriate clothing for the weather, then following through when he flatly refuses is so terrible. Sometimes 12 year olds don’t know what’s in their best interests. I find the posters claiming she will have affected him for life and he will be vulnerable to abuse frankly ridiculous.

Of course you tell a young child to go to bed.

By the time a child gets old enough to understand how much sleep they need and that lack of sleep/not being rested affects how they feel the next day, they should be setting their own bedtime. If they persistently go to bed too late and are unproductive and grouchy the next day, then the parent can step back in and "suggest" that they need to go to bed earlier.

The problem with this example is not the OP suggesting that her DS should wear trousers. It's the fact that she's ignored his response. If this was the latest in a line of scenarios where the DS refused to wear warm clothing and came home crying with the pain of the cold, then she would be at liberty to point out that that's why she's asking and that the fact he though he'd be fine was demonstrably incorrect.

My parents made me go to bed at 7.30pm until I was 15 (when I was allowed to stay up until 8). They insisted I needed the sleep. I really didn't. They didn't know better than I did - they just thought they did.

Rubyupbeat · 09/03/2023 10:06

I don't understand why you just didn't let him learn for himself, rather than engage in a big screaming fallout. Being cold doesn't make you ill, just very uncomfortable.
My son used to refuse to wear a coat and it was a stressful battle each time, until I decided to let him decide for himself, after 2 times without, he decided wearing a coat wasn't a bad idea.

FatGirlSwim · 09/03/2023 09:36

Energydrink · 08/03/2023 23:46

YANBU
I feel like people are confusing permissive parenting and natural consequences. Natural consequences does not mean be a hands off parent and allow them to make whatever choice they want.

If given a reasonable request they decided not to oblige , the natural consequence in this instance is no lift. Why would you send your child into a condition they would feel uncomfortable in just to teach them the lesson.

presumably they wouldn’t be wearing the shorts until just before they start running round. At which point they would of course warm up, until that point - trousers!

that being said, if they were older than 13… I would leave them to it

No lift isn’t a natural consequence. That’s an artificial consequence imposed by parents. Natural consequences means letting children learn from the consequences of their actions. Being cold would be the natural consequence of his choice.