Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you throw your things on the floor, I’m putting them in the bin!

29 replies

Springhurryupnow · 08/03/2023 19:04

Dh shouted this at Dd, 4 earlier, he said he spoke firmly, but he didn’t, she ran off and cried. She’d cut some heart things out and threw them around like confetti (annoying, yes, that bad though?)
I said it was harsh and he said she needs to learn to tidy up and he’s not tidying all her stuff up.
I said there are ways of doing it and shouting at a 4 year old to tidy up won’t work. I said I do it with her like a game or help her a bit as she’s only young, tbf when in the right mood, she does a great job of tidying up
I just find him so harsh in things. She’s really difficult to get ready for school at the moment (has been ill and doesn’t want to go in, but Is ok when there)
He’s usually gone off to work and I get her ready and take her, then go to work. He was off this week and witnessed how she was and just went nuts, shouting that she needed to get ready and shouting he was sick of it and slamming doors.

Who is being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
BatwomansRevenge · 08/03/2023 19:30

You don't have to make it into a game. Nor do you have to shout.

You tell the child that if they make a mess, they'll have to tidy it up.

You ask them nicely to tidy and offer to help if needed, as not all 4 year olds could do this by themselves. You repeat the request if needed, calmly, once or twice.

If they refuse, you explain calmly that if you have to do it yourself, you will put them in the bin so they don't make the mess again.

This is how children learn that they can't leave mess all over the house, without also expecting adults to make every single little thing into fun entertainment for them.

He needs to be more patient (and stop slamming doors) but it's perfectly acceptable for four year olds to learn that their actions have consequences.

NumberTheory · 08/03/2023 19:18

Shouting at a 4 year old is almost always unreasonable. But I also see why some adults find it unreasonable to have to turn everything into a game to get young children to do what they need to.

Sounds like you could do with a bit of help with parenting as a couple, coming up with a consistent way to parent that will work and you are both happy with.

But if he’s slamming doors in annoyance I would be concerned that he wasn’t really prepared to do that and is just expecting everything to fall into position to fit how he wants his life to be.

pigsDOfly · 08/03/2023 19:12

Who is being unreasonable here?

Do you really need to ask?

He's shouting at a 4 year old child and slamming doors because he doesn't get thing done the way he wants?

He threatens to put the hearts she cut out into the bin because they were on the floor?

He sounds like a bully.

If he wants his little girl to grow up crushed and fearful of his reactions to anything she doe that doesn't live up to his exacting standards he's going the right way about it.

His behaviour is horrible.

earsup · 08/03/2023 19:11

I used to stick a post it note to items chucked on floor, and wrote on it, " item will be binned, if not removed, picked up or put away in 3 days "....i did it....it worked !

Swipe left for the next trending thread