Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School and data protection

34 replies

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 13:59

Hello all,

I don't know if I'm being massively oversensitive and looking for reasons to get angry at DD's school or not.

Quick background: DD (YR6) was bullied a few months ago - the school dealt with this well, put appropriate sanctions in place, have followed up with additional measures for the bully and checking in on DD. I'm not sure how much of this they would have done without me driving it but to be fair to them, they have responded to my concerns whenever raised.

However, one of the teachers has a DC in DD's year (not same class) and has clearly accessed notes from conversations I've had with the school about the bullying and reflected them back in WhatsApp chats with me. We are not particularly close and neither are our kids. I know she may need to access data like that as part of her role but to use the detail of sensitive conversations out of context has really pissed me off.

Today, the school has sent out an email to approx 50 parents from different year groups with everyone on cc rather than bcc.

Both of these incidents have given me the rage and I do not know if it is reasonable to complain? I think I am just really angry about the clear use of private info about DD but this, compounded with the email fuck up is making me question their data protection / privacy policies.

I work in a field where either of the above incidents would be a sackable offence - or at least one that would lead to huge disciplinary interventions - so again, this could be colouring my reaction.

Would love some calm perspectives on this - should I complain about both / either incident? Or just go and have some tea and calm down!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ginandcolic · 09/03/2023 10:22

Thanks all for your thoughts, much appreciated.

The email issue has now been sorted - it was someone helping out to support admin colleagues with their workload so more a case of trying to do a favour but getting it horribly wrong.

The teacher / parent WhatsApp issue is still vexing me. I think I might just bring it up with the person in question next time I see her (which will be this week) as your comments have made me wary of assuming too much about her intention.

I don't want to wade in with an official complaint if the intention was good but I also do want to raise it as it's left me feeling uncomfortable

Thanks again for your perspectives - really helpful xx

OP posts:
Lonelyplanet · 08/03/2023 17:22

I'm assuming parents rather than the school have organised the WhatsApp group.

It is difficult to balance being a teacher and parent at the same school. However, if you are not friends socially, I think her contacting you directly about a personal school issue on social media is over stepping boundaries.

I'm surprised a teacher would want to be in a whole year group WhatsApp group at a place she works. Especially if there are more than one class in the year group. Our staff would avoid anything like this, as there are usually a few of parents who can be very unpleasant. Most teachers would not want a large group of parents to have their personal number; they could then be contacted 24/7.

PuttingDownRoots · 08/03/2023 16:43

We lived in a small community for a few years, and teachers and parents were friends outside of school... but there was a very clear boundary and rule... School was School, Home was Home (although we had the extra complication of DD2s teacher being DD1s best friend mother!). All school based communication went through official channels, all Home communication was on personal channels. It was basic Safeguarding.

Email mistake has been covered.

babybythesea · 08/03/2023 16:30

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 15:40

Very helpful to have insight into what it's like to be a teacher at your own DC's school, thank you.

Yes it could well have been something like you've suggested. It just seemed to be random but maybe she was trying to double check her child wasn't involved.

I don't have a problem with her having my number as we're all on the group WhatsApp, it's just using it in what came across as a weird way but maybe she was just checking up on DC, albeit clumsily. Thank you!

I don’t know of course. I’m just trying to think of possible reasons. I still don’t think it’s a good idea. If I was genuinely worried I’d probably try and speak to you in person rather than bring it up where everyone else can read it. And she may have another reason entirely. But no, WhatsApp groups are not the place. Especially if there’s a risk of something being out there that shouldn’t be. Just because every staff member at s school knows something, doesn’t stop it being confidential. That sort of thing is on a need to know basis. Staff members do need to know. Parents don’t.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 15:40

babybythesea · 08/03/2023 15:27

Speaking as someone who has a child at they same school I work in, I suppose it could be that she’s checking - if my child was involved I’d want to know because I’d read the riot act to her. And maybe she is worried that your child hasn’t mentioned hers because she’s a staff child? I know the kids at our school sometimes say “You won’t do anything because it’s your daughter.” (They’re right - in general we have a policy of not being involved in incidents involving your own child, so if they come to me, if there is another adult around I say “I can’t at the moment- can you go and tell Mrs X please?” It’s not because I don’t discipline my own child, it’s to ensure fairness so I don’t either let her off or (more likely) come down on her much harder than I would on another child).

I’m wondering if she’s trying to make absolutely sure that your daughter hasn’t kept quiet for fear of the teacher retaliating or something.

It doesn’t make it right but I know when something happens at school I am so tempted to go over and say “Is my child involved? What’s she done?” I also have many parents numbers etc. I just never put anything about the school on any social media. I want their numbers because if my child is at their house, I need to be able to get in touch with them. But it can be a very fine line to tread sometimes.

Very helpful to have insight into what it's like to be a teacher at your own DC's school, thank you.

Yes it could well have been something like you've suggested. It just seemed to be random but maybe she was trying to double check her child wasn't involved.

I don't have a problem with her having my number as we're all on the group WhatsApp, it's just using it in what came across as a weird way but maybe she was just checking up on DC, albeit clumsily. Thank you!

OP posts:
babybythesea · 08/03/2023 15:27

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 15:16

Thank you, really helpful. I also was just a bit confused, her DC was not involved in the bullying at all so I couldn't work out why she even got in touch. There didn't seem to be an agenda or even a point to the communication

Speaking as someone who has a child at they same school I work in, I suppose it could be that she’s checking - if my child was involved I’d want to know because I’d read the riot act to her. And maybe she is worried that your child hasn’t mentioned hers because she’s a staff child? I know the kids at our school sometimes say “You won’t do anything because it’s your daughter.” (They’re right - in general we have a policy of not being involved in incidents involving your own child, so if they come to me, if there is another adult around I say “I can’t at the moment- can you go and tell Mrs X please?” It’s not because I don’t discipline my own child, it’s to ensure fairness so I don’t either let her off or (more likely) come down on her much harder than I would on another child).

I’m wondering if she’s trying to make absolutely sure that your daughter hasn’t kept quiet for fear of the teacher retaliating or something.

It doesn’t make it right but I know when something happens at school I am so tempted to go over and say “Is my child involved? What’s she done?” I also have many parents numbers etc. I just never put anything about the school on any social media. I want their numbers because if my child is at their house, I need to be able to get in touch with them. But it can be a very fine line to tread sometimes.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 15:16

babybythesea · 08/03/2023 15:04

But yes, she shouldn’t have said anything on WhatsApp. That’s not good.

Thank you, really helpful. I also was just a bit confused, her DC was not involved in the bullying at all so I couldn't work out why she even got in touch. There didn't seem to be an agenda or even a point to the communication

OP posts:
Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 15:15

babybythesea · 08/03/2023 15:03

Just to say that this would be totally normal in my school too. Everybody is made aware of any ongoing issues between children. Especially lunch staff and TAs who are more likely to be supervising break times. It’s so if a child comes to you and says “Fred just called me an idiot/bumped into me” or whatever you can respond appropriately. If you think it’s a one off you might respond with ‘we don’t do that, do we Fred? Can you say sorry?’ or whatever the process is in your school. Which leads to “Harry’s bully pushed him again and he told the staff and they just asked Fred to say sorry, nothing else happened and I’m sick of it.” because you are unaware it’s part of a pattern.

On the other hand, knowing there is an issue puts you on alert. You watch to see where Fred is going, and whether he seems to be making his way deliberately towards Harry, and if so you can drift that way yourself and head things off before they happen. And if something does happen, you can deal with it properly in the context of an ongoing issue.

This makes a lot of sense, thank you!

OP posts:
babybythesea · 08/03/2023 15:04

But yes, she shouldn’t have said anything on WhatsApp. That’s not good.

babybythesea · 08/03/2023 15:03

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:04

Thanks @BibbleandSqwauk ! That's very helpful and interesting that the bullying would be widely known about to help watch out for DD, makes me less rageful

Just to say that this would be totally normal in my school too. Everybody is made aware of any ongoing issues between children. Especially lunch staff and TAs who are more likely to be supervising break times. It’s so if a child comes to you and says “Fred just called me an idiot/bumped into me” or whatever you can respond appropriately. If you think it’s a one off you might respond with ‘we don’t do that, do we Fred? Can you say sorry?’ or whatever the process is in your school. Which leads to “Harry’s bully pushed him again and he told the staff and they just asked Fred to say sorry, nothing else happened and I’m sick of it.” because you are unaware it’s part of a pattern.

On the other hand, knowing there is an issue puts you on alert. You watch to see where Fred is going, and whether he seems to be making his way deliberately towards Harry, and if so you can drift that way yourself and head things off before they happen. And if something does happen, you can deal with it properly in the context of an ongoing issue.

Allmarbleslost · 08/03/2023 14:53

The WhatsApp is unprofessional and the teacher concerned should be spoken to. I would report that to the headteacher. The cc thing will be reported to the ico by the school - it will be classed as a minor breach though and there won't be any consequences for the poor overworked admin person who made a genuine mistake.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:48

Nowthenhere · 08/03/2023 14:45

Huge safeguarding issues here. A teacher reached out to you directly. So she's used a number that was meant for group discusion/updates with parents as an opportunity to discuss teacher-pupil knowledge. It gives the opportunity for someone with a level of power to access and share. It's less than appropriate and unless she's stating how she's going to reduce your daughters risks directly, it's not even a slight reason for this.

Did you consent to share information about your child's bullying on a different platform?
Did you consent to detailed discussions of the bullying being open to all teachers and all teaching staff?

I would report the teacher. I would report them for both reasons.

The cc part: I would just reply to all "thanks to the teaching staff x, I now have your email address and you have mine. "

Really good points. No, I did not consent to any of it.

OP posts:
Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:47

MoneyInTheBananaStand · 08/03/2023 14:38

Ok so the context makes it sound even worse!

She's just fishing for info isn't she? Totally inappropriate and the head should be informed.

Yes it did feel like fishing and very self-motivated like "I know this about your child and now tell my what your child said about my child." Very odd

OP posts:
Nowthenhere · 08/03/2023 14:45

Huge safeguarding issues here. A teacher reached out to you directly. So she's used a number that was meant for group discusion/updates with parents as an opportunity to discuss teacher-pupil knowledge. It gives the opportunity for someone with a level of power to access and share. It's less than appropriate and unless she's stating how she's going to reduce your daughters risks directly, it's not even a slight reason for this.

Did you consent to share information about your child's bullying on a different platform?
Did you consent to detailed discussions of the bullying being open to all teachers and all teaching staff?

I would report the teacher. I would report them for both reasons.

The cc part: I would just reply to all "thanks to the teaching staff x, I now have your email address and you have mine. "

MoneyInTheBananaStand · 08/03/2023 14:38

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:08

No it was raised along the lines of, "I heard xyz happened" and then asked if her DC was involved so referencing it did feel very inappropriate (even if her seeing the info was not).

Yes good shout re the GDPR lead, thanks

Ok so the context makes it sound even worse!

She's just fishing for info isn't she? Totally inappropriate and the head should be informed.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:24

CatOnTheChair · 08/03/2023 14:22

The teacher was unprofessional in sharing something she'd learnt in a professional capacity (and I think she should have known for work purposes) with you. I don't think school have done anything wrong here the individual is at fault.

The bcc/Cc bit is worse, and needs mentioning.

Thanks, yes that's a helpful distinction in terms of separating the teacher vs the school.

OP posts:
CatOnTheChair · 08/03/2023 14:22

The teacher was unprofessional in sharing something she'd learnt in a professional capacity (and I think she should have known for work purposes) with you. I don't think school have done anything wrong here the individual is at fault.

The bcc/Cc bit is worse, and needs mentioning.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:22

Lonelyplanet · 08/03/2023 14:14

The cc email thing is not good, but probably a mistake that needs mentioning.

Why do you have a personal WhatsApp number for a teacher who is not your friend? This seems very odd and you should stop using it. Make sure all communication goes through tye school email system, it will cover you both as there will be a record. All relevant staff should have been informed about the bullying to keep tabs on it.

It's because her DC is in my DD's year so we're all on the year group WhatsApp and she reached out to me directly

OP posts:
SnowLemons · 08/03/2023 14:15

MrsCat1 · 08/03/2023 14:13

The cc message was probably sent out by an admin person earning just above minimum wage. I'm sure they will be mortified when it is pointed out. It's an easy mistake to make. I wouldn't get in a rage about it.

It's basic Email admin.

Lonelyplanet · 08/03/2023 14:14

The cc email thing is not good, but probably a mistake that needs mentioning.

Why do you have a personal WhatsApp number for a teacher who is not your friend? This seems very odd and you should stop using it. Make sure all communication goes through tye school email system, it will cover you both as there will be a record. All relevant staff should have been informed about the bullying to keep tabs on it.

MrsCat1 · 08/03/2023 14:13

The cc message was probably sent out by an admin person earning just above minimum wage. I'm sure they will be mortified when it is pointed out. It's an easy mistake to make. I wouldn't get in a rage about it.

SnowLemons · 08/03/2023 14:11

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:10

Same here - I'd be out on my ear faster than I could spell GDPR but I always wonder if that means I'm expecting too much for organisations that do not have that kind of pressure. But I guess data is data regardless?

I know what you mean. But yes data is data and its serious. Even if they don't sack the sender immediately it needs addressing.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:10

SnowLemons · 08/03/2023 14:10

You also don't know that for sure though. Not meaning to scare you but you don't know who has your info. They might have a crush on you and turn stalkerish or sell on your details to hackers.

Fair point re the hackers, hadn't thought of that

OP posts:
SnowLemons · 08/03/2023 14:10

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:09

Same in DD's school. I'm far too boring to be endangered by the sharing of any personal info but there are others who are not.

You also don't know that for sure though. Not meaning to scare you but you don't know who has your info. They might have a crush on you and turn stalkerish or sell on your details to hackers.

Ginandcolic · 08/03/2023 14:10

SnowLemons · 08/03/2023 14:09

I might be bias as I work in a job where that would mean I'd be in trouble. If on probation I'd be let go. It's that serious.

Same here - I'd be out on my ear faster than I could spell GDPR but I always wonder if that means I'm expecting too much for organisations that do not have that kind of pressure. But I guess data is data regardless?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread