Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will I make dd look like an idiot if I raise issues about this?

61 replies

Jerseytired · 08/03/2023 11:02

DD is in sixth form. She has autism, OCD and emetophobia.
She is extremely sensitive to textures and smells. Her OCD became very bad in lockdown, counting, checking, massive contamination fears, washing her hands until raw etc,

She has been at college for three years, she has even made bacteria but because it was done clinically she was fine.

Last week a tutor was putting fake bacteria on the students, some asked not to for skin reasons and DD told them she had OCD. The teacher laughed at her and sprayed it getting some on dd and her coat. DD came home and absolutely lost it.

Next week they are doing a practical that involves bacteria, fake sick etc. DD remembers it last year when the other class did it and she could not even walk passed the room without feeling ill.
DD has again told her tutor she has OCD and asked for help but she has just told her she HAS to do it or she will fail her and dd is freaking out.

aibu to at least speak to the tutor and ask for reasonable adjustments

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tothelefttotheleft · 08/03/2023 17:29

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 08/03/2023 14:17

My DD had to leave 6th form. I remember being in a zoom meeting telling the Head of 6th form and the SENCO about her diagnosis and they nudged each other and laughed - they were passing notes to each other and sniggering too. I had a representative from a local charity on the call to support me, they knew they were untouchable - there's no come back on schools that behave like this. My DD's psychiatrist then wrote to the Head teacher and the letter was never even acknowledged. I asked the Head Teacher's PA if the letter had actually reached him and she said it had but that he wouldn't be replying. Yet they publicised that all their staff had mental health training from Mind (i.e., they sat through a presentation and marked it down in their CPD diaries and then ignored it ...) They received accolades for it in their OFSTED report too.

I get so angry when you see posters on here talking about how teachers are beyond reproach etc., you've only got to have a few like the one OP is describing and it can devastate a child or young person. Anyway, sorry, I've gone off on a tangent!

This was exactly my experience and it made me realise there is a veneer of what should happen and then the actual experience. This doesn't just apply to schools but also children's mental health services etc.

Newstartonwards · 08/03/2023 17:26

I expect it was uv paint or something rather than bacteria.

this would be judged as assault. It is also abusive and threatening behaviour from the staff member. I would go bonkers totally bonkers at the head of the college

totally unacceptable

IDontWantToBeAPie · 08/03/2023 17:20

I have a blood phobia and was always allowed to miss lessons which involved it or anything about it . So yes call them

Pointerdogsrule · 08/03/2023 14:19

Hold on, someone who teaches at 6th form and is deemed to be safe with vulnerable teenagers behaves like fucking that?

I'd be going fucking nuclear if this was my DD .

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 08/03/2023 14:17

My DD had to leave 6th form. I remember being in a zoom meeting telling the Head of 6th form and the SENCO about her diagnosis and they nudged each other and laughed - they were passing notes to each other and sniggering too. I had a representative from a local charity on the call to support me, they knew they were untouchable - there's no come back on schools that behave like this. My DD's psychiatrist then wrote to the Head teacher and the letter was never even acknowledged. I asked the Head Teacher's PA if the letter had actually reached him and she said it had but that he wouldn't be replying. Yet they publicised that all their staff had mental health training from Mind (i.e., they sat through a presentation and marked it down in their CPD diaries and then ignored it ...) They received accolades for it in their OFSTED report too.

I get so angry when you see posters on here talking about how teachers are beyond reproach etc., you've only got to have a few like the one OP is describing and it can devastate a child or young person. Anyway, sorry, I've gone off on a tangent!

Brightblueskysunshine · 08/03/2023 14:10

Definitely raise it with the college. I think you need to have a meeting with the teacher concerned as well and remind him of confidentiality before describing dds condition.

Lately I have seen so many people joking about OCD and other mh conditions which are actually very serious in nature but not everyone understands this unfortunately.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 08/03/2023 14:10

Also @Jerseytired OCD Action have excellent zoom/skype parents meetings where you can get advice and support, also something called "Navigating Services" which you can sit in on, this explains how to get correct treatment for OCD, which is usually only available at specialist centres - I mentioned CAMHS earlier, is she under them or has she transferred to Adult mental health team yet?

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 08/03/2023 14:05

Servalan · 08/03/2023 12:35

Might be worth forwarding a copy of the NICE guidelines and OCD description from an organisation like OCD UK or OCD action

My DD19 is housebound as she has several types of OCD assessed as being on the severe scale (this is an assessment your DD should have, can be done by some CAMHS psychiatrists but not all have enough experience). One of the types she has is contamination OCD, I think its important to use the right words and as a fellow sufferer @Servalan is making some good suggestions - definitely get onto the OCD Action and OCD UK websites, lots of information on there about contamination OCD and their helplines/email helplines are excellent (particularly OCD UK). Get some evidence and make a complaint.

Jammydodger1981 · 08/03/2023 13:56

DrBlackbird · 08/03/2023 13:30

You might want to remind the college of this tragic case.

A young woman, a physics undergraduate who suffered from severe social anxiety, took her life the day before she was due to give a “terrifying” oral exam in front of teachers and fellow students. She had asked for another assessment method and was told ‘no’. The parents sued for not taking reasonable care of their daughter’s wellbeing, health and safety and the University was found to have failed to make reasonable adjustments and breached their duty of care.

www.theguardian.com/education/2022/may/20/bristol-university-found-guilty-of-failings-over-death-of-student-natasha-Abrahart

Thanks @DrBlackbird I was coming on to talk about this case. I work in HE and our Student Welfare team has (quite rightly) beaten this into everyone repeatedly following this case.

This would be good to use if you get pushback OP

LuluLehman · 08/03/2023 13:38

I am very sorry that your DD had to experience this. No student should be subjected to that kind of treatment. It isn't up to the tutor to decide what your DD is able to tolerate or not.

The tutor has an obligation to make reasonable adjustments for your DD. I would raise the issue first with tutor, and if I got no luck I would take it higher. This isn't just a matter for your child but for other students with similar issues.

I would say that the tutor's reaction is a disciplinary matter, but that is for their department to deal with. You need to go through the process and, if you get no joy, make a formal complaint. Remember to bring any medical evidence with you.

I hope your DD has a good outcome from this.

Justmeandthedog1 · 08/03/2023 13:35

Jerseytired · 08/03/2023 11:42

It IS a social care course so I am fully aware of the issue around this however she has been doing the same subject since year 9, so for six years in some form (it was the only course she could get on at college) and this is the first time this has come up and she finishes in June, hence asking for advice here first!

She will not be going on to do health care when she finishes.
She could just fail and stop next week to be honest and it would not make a difference but seems a waste so close to finishing if something can be done to help her.

No, she shouldn’t give up —- she deserves her diploma or certificate.
The teacher is totally in the wrong. What else was he or she going to laugh at, a blind student, a deaf student? Totally unacceptable, I feel angry on your daughter’s behalf.
Please contact the college, in writing as pp suggested. Point out their obligations and that you do not expect to see these broken in any way.

Choconut · 08/03/2023 13:34

It's not a teachers place to decide whether a student saying they have OCD is 'for real' or not. Her choice to say no should have been respected. What are we teaching students if we tell them that no means no - but then show then that this doesn't apply if someone thinks you might be joking.

Hopefully the teacher will be horrified when they realise that this is a genuine diagnosis that they have trampled all over and apologise to dd. I think all her teachers need to be made aware of her diagnosis and look at what they can put in place to enable her to do what she needs to.

DrBlackbird · 08/03/2023 13:30

You might want to remind the college of this tragic case.

A young woman, a physics undergraduate who suffered from severe social anxiety, took her life the day before she was due to give a “terrifying” oral exam in front of teachers and fellow students. She had asked for another assessment method and was told ‘no’. The parents sued for not taking reasonable care of their daughter’s wellbeing, health and safety and the University was found to have failed to make reasonable adjustments and breached their duty of care.

www.theguardian.com/education/2022/may/20/bristol-university-found-guilty-of-failings-over-death-of-student-natasha-Abrahart

lieselotte · 08/03/2023 13:07

If a practical is required, I assume there would be a way for her to take part without actually getting stuff on herself, whether fake or real.

If for example she needed to show she knows how to deal with a contaminated substance, she could do it with an empty container, or they could just wet something with water, or wet her hands with water or some other substance she is ok with like whatever soap or shower gel she usually uses. I am not remotely involved in this area and have already thought of several possible solutions so why on earth can't the teacher?

I see someone has also suggested using a tin of beans as fake vomit. Exactly that - something that she won't mind getting on her, but she can show the relevant skills.

And laughing/goading is despicable.

Cherrysoup · 08/03/2023 12:59

I always, always ask students if they're happy to have something done, SEND or not. The teacher is disgraceful and needs to be told so.

whatchaos · 08/03/2023 12:59

YADNBU, you're advocating for her and being a great mum. I hope she is given all the support and the tutor is rightly reprimanded for being such a dickhead.

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 08/03/2023 12:58

You've had lots of really good advice here so I won't add anything to the main, but i have an idea about the experiment with the "fake vomit"...
if it's something for example to demonstrate correct handling of spillages, would it help if your daughter could use, say, a tin of vegetable soup or baked beans, that she opens and sets up herself so she knows exactly what it is she is handling? Just an idea if it might help. Smile

Jamieleecurtain · 08/03/2023 12:56

Does the teacher definitely understand that DD has diagnosed OCD? And isn’t just jumping on the ‘im a bit OCD’ wagon?

As her mother I would have no problem coming down hard on the school for dismissing mental health concerns

TeenDivided · 08/03/2023 12:52

Absolutely contact them.
I know just where you are coming from as my 18yo DD has (doctor recognised) germ anxiety and worries massively about germ transfer.
Yes fully able NT teens should be able to advocate for themselves but ND teens with anxiety or other issues often can't, all their energy goes into getting through the day.

lifeturnsonadime · 08/03/2023 12:50

The amount of folks - including well educated folks - that think OCD means having a preference for sparkly taps and CDs in alphabetical order is very high.

This.

You can be disorganised but have OCD.

Pythonesque · 08/03/2023 12:46

From what you say that she has managed some practical exercises previously, I'm wondering if the reasonable adjustments that she would need might be achieved by use of waterproof gown, gloves (or double gloves?) and goggles / visor? As well as sensible lab behaviour rather than trying to "make it fun" ...

Good luck.

Regulus · 08/03/2023 12:39

Three years at college so over 18? If so I wouldn't email/contact them directly but I would support her to take it further and to access support from the SENCO.

Servalan · 08/03/2023 12:35

Might be worth forwarding a copy of the NICE guidelines and OCD description from an organisation like OCD UK or OCD action

Iyjd · 08/03/2023 12:34

In my safeguarding training at school we are reminded not to touch students, I always find it ridiculous we need to be told because I believed nobody would be stupid enough to not know that. It turns out your DDs teacher is the reason. I would make sure the complaint goes above her, your daughter refused consent to a physical act and it was ignored. The teacher will more than likely listen to your email in this case but then possibly not give it a second thought in future, it coming from their line manager will mean they have to listen and the college are aware of the gaps in the training.

Copy in the sendco in regards to next weeks lesson. I don’t have autism or ocd, but I couldn’t be around fake sick either and I would insist that is respected as I am not a robot.

Jerseytired · 08/03/2023 12:33

Thank you all.

I fully expected to be told I was being unreasonable.

I have now emailed the tutor and cc'd in the lead senco.

College must hate me but at least they only have her a few more weeks...

OP posts: