Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For using a foodbank when my family are relatively well off ?

638 replies

Notaskingmuch · 08/03/2023 05:18

But won’t help me ?

I was told yesterday by someone I know that ‘you know foodbanks are for people with no other choice and no support at all not ones who could get help from family’

The thing is my family WONT help me.

I can’t explain to people my family dynamics, how dm is narcissistic and I’m the scapegoat. How she’s happy to have both my dsis round for regular get together a where they have nice meals or go out to restaurants but I’m not invited , that they get invited round for afternoon tea but I don’t ….etc etc

Once recently when I was desperate I asked could I borrow a few staple food items and got told ‘I don’t have much here sorry’ on another occasion I asked could I borrow £20 to do a basic shop and was told ‘sorry no-you need to support yourself’ (from someone who owns their home outright , has a DP who still works and earns well and who regularly treats her other 2 daughters)

So we use a food bank, well 2 actually as one is church run and unlimited and the other is via a voucher and limited.

i can’t bring myself to have to explain as I’m exhausted and wish she had kept her comment to herself. I can see it looks like somethings off as she knows my family but I just don’t want to be judged she clearly thinks I’m a CF though .

OP posts:
Okunevo · 08/03/2023 19:01

OldFan · 08/03/2023 18:42

However what if like this poster just mentioned the food bank decides they don’t qualify or there is no food left what’s the plan then?

Our local food bank started only letting people have a few weeks and then have to have a week off claiming it, so people don't become dependent on it.
But I suppose people would just go to another one for that week then, if they were determined or desparate.

Donations are likely to drop off and demand increase with the cost of living crisis and especially the cost of food. I currently donate but am on a low income myself and it will have to stop in a few months as my family are likely to need help.

OldFan · 08/03/2023 18:42

However what if like this poster just mentioned the food bank decides they don’t qualify or there is no food left what’s the plan then?

Our local food bank started only letting people have a few weeks and then have to have a week off claiming it, so people don't become dependent on it.
But I suppose people would just go to another one for that week then, if they were determined or desparate.

WiIson · 08/03/2023 18:28

I totally believe that people should try and maximise their work hours in order to maximise their earnings if they are struggling.

I think the key here though is the op has been unwell, she has a time frame for working more hours, but at the present time she needs a bit of help. This is exactly the scenario where people should be able to use the support available to them, to enable them to get back on their feet again.

thedogsmum · 08/03/2023 18:18

Your friend was very unkind and judgemental - as pps have said you should just tell her that your family refuse to help so until you can increase your work hours in Sept, you unfortunately need the extra help.

Lots of people here being very unkind and judgemental too, you getting support that you need, and it is shameful that the social welfare is so inadequate that you need to use food banks, no shame at all in you needing to use them.

longtompot · 08/03/2023 18:18

I feel I am missing something with some of the posts on here.

Op and her dh are both working 7 days a week between them.

Her dh Sat 8-6, Sun 9-4, Mon 8-6 & Tues 8-6 when she is parenting their children and probably also trying to recover from her accident.

Op works Wed, Thur & Fri 9.30-4pm when her dh is parenting their children.
When op gets home from work it sounds like she has dinner and then goes to bed early, as she is still recovering from her accident.

How would her dh be able to go out to work more hours? It's not like her 'helpful' family would offer childcare (hence the reason for their post in the first place), and her dhs parents live abroad.

@Notaskingmuch I don't think you are being unreasonable to use a food bank when you are struggling. That is what they are there for, people in need. As for your friend, why doesn't she help you if she feels so strongly about you using them?

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 08/03/2023 17:54

@Pink39tree I agree that an extra 52 pounds a week could make a huge difference but the OP did say that on the days she works ( wed-friday) she needs to rest after work to be able to work at all , because of her health it is doubtful that she could care for kids from 4-7.30 she said she went to bed after work, she is obviously slowly improving and hopes to be either well enough to up her hours or well enough to do more childcare
for me I think the best Option is for DH to try and work during the day on either wednesday or friday so the kids can be in school or childcare it would depend on him earning enough to pay for that childcare as it may not gain much if child care is £4 an hour per child and he works 30 minutes away from 9-6 ( an hours lunch he will need childcare form 8.30 to 6.30 ie 10 hours at £4 for 2 children total £80, 8 hours at minimum wage roughly £80 - taxes so actually probably a loss as there will be a cost in getting to work and no extra money maybe the eldest child will get free hours but often these are set hours and don't include lunch the free hours for us were 9-12 and 1-4 for those getting 30 hours, or 9-12 if you got 15 free hours, they charged £5 for 12-1 and from 3-5 another £10 then they shut and you couldn't drop off before 8.55 so sometimes childcare isn't the easy answer
it is ridiculous that someone works 8 hours and after childcare costs they are actually in negative money or maybe thye have worked 8 hours and are about £10 better off an extra 8 hours only benefits if childcare and commuting costs are tiny
the other ideas are the DH trying to find something he can do during the day when OP works maybe from home that he can fit around nursery runs for free hours, but this kind of work is tricky to find

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:47

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 08/03/2023 17:44

I can't work out if some of the posters on here at thick, heartless or both.

I'm going for both.

ancientgran · 08/03/2023 17:47

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:39

Where have you pulled that from? I’ve skimmed through her posts again and that’s not mentioned it only that he needs to be there to so she can go to bed early?

Shes clearly well enough to work 3 days a week and looks after her kids for the rest of the time so I’m sure she’s well enough to cope with 4 more hours of looking after her children to let her partner work those hours.

Again, you’re all ignoring what would happened if the food bank help stops and there was no food to feed the children. What would your advice be then? This is the risk that’s being taken with relying on food banks for another 7/8 months- could stop at any moment.

Oh well if you're sure about what she can do you can sort it out easily can't you.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:46

Jesus fucking Christ. Honestly oh she can cope. no! The whole point of this thread is that she can't, they're doing what they need to do to cope, and they've hit hard times.

This situation will not be solved with cries of "work more you lazy shits" which clearly is all a lot of mners can offer.

At least offer some fucking empathy.

ancientgran · 08/03/2023 17:45

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:34

£52 a week for people who can’t feed their children will be life changing and will enable them to be less reliant on food bank help that can stop at any moment.

The childcare isn’t relevant in this because the father could work at a time it doesn’t impact childcare as the mother would be there.

So it would still be beneficial to work more hours

Local nursery where I am is £70 a day so they'd be £18 worse off.

His part time availability, well Saturday, Monday and Tuesday he is working from 8 till 6, presumably he has do boring stuff like wash/dress/grab something to eat and travel time to work and back and needs a meal so he could possibly start another job at 8, can't do many hours as he has to be up at maybe 6 am the next morning, oh forgive me he can have a lie in till 7 on Sunday. Can't really work on days OP is working as he is looking after the kids when she's at work and when she has to rest when she gets home.

He might get a bar shift on the Saturday but they'd probably want him to work till 1 or 2 am if pubs and clubs round here are anything to go by which won't work with his job the next day, Monday and Tuesday harder to get a shift (GS currently trying.)

I'm sure you can come up with a better schedule.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:45

.... you've literally just said it.

And clearly she can't just fucking manage, otherwise she already would be. Are you a bit dense?

I'm not ignoring it. It's unlikely. I don't have any suggestions, theyre in a bad situation ffs. I'm not going to make suggestions that aren't doable for them and berate them for it, or suggest they can clearly cope, when it's been advised they can't, actually.

Your suggestions are useless because they're not workable.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 08/03/2023 17:44

I can't work out if some of the posters on here at thick, heartless or both.

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:39

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:32

You're still ignoring the fact op is unwell and needs her husband to look after the children when she finishes work.

Where have you pulled that from? I’ve skimmed through her posts again and that’s not mentioned it only that he needs to be there to so she can go to bed early?

Shes clearly well enough to work 3 days a week and looks after her kids for the rest of the time so I’m sure she’s well enough to cope with 4 more hours of looking after her children to let her partner work those hours.

Again, you’re all ignoring what would happened if the food bank help stops and there was no food to feed the children. What would your advice be then? This is the risk that’s being taken with relying on food banks for another 7/8 months- could stop at any moment.

MyGreenBedspread · 08/03/2023 17:36

@Pink39tree but the op is ill and needs her husband there in the evening to look after the children. So he can’t just work in the evening.

ancientgran · 08/03/2023 17:35

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:31

Exactly the point I’m trying to get at. Seems like we are the only ones trying to offer practical solutions for OP and partner to try and be self reliant when everyone is saying “just use the food bank for however long you need”.

However what if like this poster just mentioned the food bank decides they don’t qualify or there is no food left what’s the plan then?

There are other hours in the week that won’t impact the partner from working and NOTHING will have to be paid in childcare as the mother will already be there.

Not wanting to do that because they think it’s unfair or life is hard and they shouldn’t have to work extra hours is totally their choice. Just what’s the plan if the food bank stops?

That's fine if they are both 100% fit and well but they aren't, the OP is doing her best but she needs support. Hours he works, hours she works, travel to and from work, caring for kids, eating, sleeping. There are only so many hours.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:35

Still. Ignoring. The. Facts

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:34

whatkatydid2013 · 08/03/2023 17:24

Except it’s wrong. Current minimum is £9.50/hour. Tax + NI is 32%

Monthly increase to work one extra day = £224 or £52/ week.

Full day of childcare is easily going to cost that £52.

When minimum wage increases it will be more like £57/week, which again will mainly be eaten up by childcare cost. There will be parts of the country it would cost more for childcare than the extra earning. It may be some of it is covered by UC but the more you earn the less you are entitled to.

£52 a week for people who can’t feed their children will be life changing and will enable them to be less reliant on food bank help that can stop at any moment.

The childcare isn’t relevant in this because the father could work at a time it doesn’t impact childcare as the mother would be there.

So it would still be beneficial to work more hours

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:33

And nobody has said they don't want to do it because it's unfair or life is hard. That's your shitty, judgy opinion.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:32

You're still ignoring the fact op is unwell and needs her husband to look after the children when she finishes work.

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:31

Snoken · 08/03/2023 17:25

I don’t think anyone has said that they shouldn’t use food banks in the short term, the problem is that they are relying on them to be able to feed their kids for the next 6 months or so rather than trying to maximise their earnings. What would they do if they turned up one week and the food bank said: sorry, we’re all out this week? The following week, same thing.

More and more people are using food banks, less and less are able to donate. They can’t just not feed their kids, but there isn’t unlimited stock there either and to qualify will get harder. There is a risk that OP’s family suddenly won’t qualify anymore because there are others in an even worse position. It has already been established that there is no family help to get so they are completely reliant on nothing changing.

Exactly the point I’m trying to get at. Seems like we are the only ones trying to offer practical solutions for OP and partner to try and be self reliant when everyone is saying “just use the food bank for however long you need”.

However what if like this poster just mentioned the food bank decides they don’t qualify or there is no food left what’s the plan then?

There are other hours in the week that won’t impact the partner from working and NOTHING will have to be paid in childcare as the mother will already be there.

Not wanting to do that because they think it’s unfair or life is hard and they shouldn’t have to work extra hours is totally their choice. Just what’s the plan if the food bank stops?

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:30

Maximize their earnings is such a shitty nothing phrase isn't it.

Snoken · 08/03/2023 17:25

TessoftheDubonnet · 08/03/2023 17:13

Agreed. This is one of the nastiest threads I've read on here in a long while.

@Notaskingmuch - I hope you are not taking all the vile comments to heart.

Luckily, 93% agree that you are not unreasonable to use the food banks. I expect most of them cannot be bothered to argue with those individuals who clearly have had a compassion bypass.

I don’t think anyone has said that they shouldn’t use food banks in the short term, the problem is that they are relying on them to be able to feed their kids for the next 6 months or so rather than trying to maximise their earnings. What would they do if they turned up one week and the food bank said: sorry, we’re all out this week? The following week, same thing.

More and more people are using food banks, less and less are able to donate. They can’t just not feed their kids, but there isn’t unlimited stock there either and to qualify will get harder. There is a risk that OP’s family suddenly won’t qualify anymore because there are others in an even worse position. It has already been established that there is no family help to get so they are completely reliant on nothing changing.

WiIson · 08/03/2023 17:24

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 17:21

How do you jump from one extreme to another. Nobody has said that. We just think that an adult responsible for children should at least be working full time hours to pay to put food on his children’s table.

Whose going to look after the kids? Between them they work more than full time.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 17:24

BadNomad · 08/03/2023 17:23

The OP isn't allowed a break either. She's supposed to finish work then solo parent in the evenings while her partner goes out to work some more.

Precisely

whatkatydid2013 · 08/03/2023 17:24

Pink39tree · 08/03/2023 16:29

Hit the nail on the head here, everyone saying OPs husband works full time when he actually doesn’t when you take into consideration unpaid breaks. Even if it’s a additional few hours a week to get him up to full time hours that could be the difference between paying something towards a food shop and relying on a food bank for the extra bits!
childcare wouldn’t be a issue as OP is already home for those days

Except it’s wrong. Current minimum is £9.50/hour. Tax + NI is 32%

Monthly increase to work one extra day = £224 or £52/ week.

Full day of childcare is easily going to cost that £52.

When minimum wage increases it will be more like £57/week, which again will mainly be eaten up by childcare cost. There will be parts of the country it would cost more for childcare than the extra earning. It may be some of it is covered by UC but the more you earn the less you are entitled to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread