Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For using a foodbank when my family are relatively well off ?

638 replies

Notaskingmuch · 08/03/2023 05:18

But won’t help me ?

I was told yesterday by someone I know that ‘you know foodbanks are for people with no other choice and no support at all not ones who could get help from family’

The thing is my family WONT help me.

I can’t explain to people my family dynamics, how dm is narcissistic and I’m the scapegoat. How she’s happy to have both my dsis round for regular get together a where they have nice meals or go out to restaurants but I’m not invited , that they get invited round for afternoon tea but I don’t ….etc etc

Once recently when I was desperate I asked could I borrow a few staple food items and got told ‘I don’t have much here sorry’ on another occasion I asked could I borrow £20 to do a basic shop and was told ‘sorry no-you need to support yourself’ (from someone who owns their home outright , has a DP who still works and earns well and who regularly treats her other 2 daughters)

So we use a food bank, well 2 actually as one is church run and unlimited and the other is via a voucher and limited.

i can’t bring myself to have to explain as I’m exhausted and wish she had kept her comment to herself. I can see it looks like somethings off as she knows my family but I just don’t want to be judged she clearly thinks I’m a CF though .

OP posts:
mrstreacle · 08/03/2023 11:06

fashionqueen1183 · 08/03/2023 09:18

I don’t see a problem with two people working part time. If it means no childcare bills it makes sense. There’s no point in them both working full time and one persons wage entirely going out on childcare. It’s also not that easy to find jobs which work around school hours and a second one on top. It’s not any different to having one person work full time and the second parent stay at home. Kids are only little once and benefit from seeing their parents at some point in the day! We all need quality of life too.

Thank you. At last someone who can use common sense and add up

Boymamabee · 08/03/2023 10:58

Sorry things are so tough for you OP 💐

I know my mum’s help has prevented us from using food banks a few times. They reckon most of us are two payslips away from food banks.

People don’t realise until they’re in that situation.

MegaManic · 08/03/2023 10:55

YANBU at all, what a horrible thing to say to you. I hope things improve for you and your family very soon.

ancientgran · 08/03/2023 10:51

Doesthepopeshitinthewoods · 08/03/2023 09:27

Soul destroying to read, isn’t it?

I find it really upsetting, people are so smug. I had a tough time in the 70s and my mum's help was a Godsend, I can't imagine what it must be like to be doing your best and people put the boot in.

ilovesooty · 08/03/2023 10:41

Doesthepopeshitinthewoods · 08/03/2023 09:14

I think I’m going to have to stop looking at this thread. So many posters are such cruel twats: demanding her medical history, accusing them of being lazy, of lying about her family’s situation, suggesting it’s really drug and alcohol addictions behind why her family won’t help, suggesting she’s misusing the Foodbank.

The scorn towards the OP is odious. And posters would do well to remember that ’there but for the grace of god, go I’, and all that. Anyone can fall on hard times.

I agree. Some of the posters who've seen fit to be so callous and judgemental are all over posts about benefit claimants, refugees, asylum seekers and anyone else who's deemed "lesser". They're not entitled to the OP's medical details either.

Onefootinthegroove · 08/03/2023 10:36

OheeOheeOh · 08/03/2023 10:35

I mean use the food bank if you need it, but couldn't one of you (the higher earner) go ft and just one of you pt? I don't understand why childcare requires 2 people to be pt? You have to juggle, my parents worked opposite shifts to make it work, we couldn't have survived on pt wages or afforded childcare. I think you need to try and work a solution out yourselves rather than getting annoyed otherwise people won't give you money or help. We all make plans before we have children, what was the plan for childcare before having your children?

Try actually reading the thread 🙄

Guis23 · 08/03/2023 10:36

Why do people not help financially or practically when they clearly could ?
Who knows unless they tell you but ....

Sometimes it might be because if they are very old they never had any help during very hard times. No welfare state to speak of and certainly not like today, no food banks, and have a hardened attitude. With the welfare state and food banks they cannot see why someone cannot get help.

If older they are very anxious about their future care costs which are thousands of pounds a week if self funding. And they don't want to be in a social services home. So spend very little and save all.

Sometimes family can get used to turning to the bank of mum and dad as it is known. Frequently. Sometimes people are rigid in what work they will take/can do. And decide they will not or cannot do too wide a range of jobs. So remain out of work. They focus on what they cannot do not what they can do.

Parents of frequent askers may feel they have failed. The child now adult is not financially independent. Will this be a regular request ?
They may have other children who they haven't given a bean to. And feel guilty because of this.

The manner of asking might not be quite right. If someone just asks it might not be what helps. If you said asked for advice or if someone could help work out a budget to see how better things could be done ( you might be missing something obvious) or say I have planned what I need to do to work things through it looks more positive as though you are wanting to make and taking steps to manage.

It is awful to be in dire straits. Whether you work or not. But there is a lot of help out there. From working out budget and frugal meal plans to housing costs, reducing council, help with energy costs etc. The help you can ask for isn't always money.

OheeOheeOh · 08/03/2023 10:35

I mean use the food bank if you need it, but couldn't one of you (the higher earner) go ft and just one of you pt? I don't understand why childcare requires 2 people to be pt? You have to juggle, my parents worked opposite shifts to make it work, we couldn't have survived on pt wages or afforded childcare. I think you need to try and work a solution out yourselves rather than getting annoyed otherwise people won't give you money or help. We all make plans before we have children, what was the plan for childcare before having your children?

whatkatydid2013 · 08/03/2023 10:28

RichardHeed · 08/03/2023 08:35

You want Op to divulge her medical information to you? What the actual fuck man, listen to yourself. Who do you think you are?

Also if you had even glanced at OPs post you could have worked out all of the answers to your snippy little questions yourself.

OP is physically exhausted from working so her husband can't work evenings because she us unable to look after the children so he does. I'm going to guess he also wants a bit of sleep because he's looking after the kids the following day too... unless you think he should be sleep deprived and in charge of minors or when he is at work? How responsible. Not to mention his health could (will) take a nose dive after so long working all hours under the sun. They can't afford that now can they?

You would be heartbroken your children didn't work full time? Says a lot about you tbh.

Her husbands parents are not financially well off, but help when they visit the UK, I'm not really sure why you're struggling to glean this information. It's all in the OPs posts.

Most professionals work at least 40, often 50
Most professionals aren't also caring for a partner recovering from an accident and children I'd wager like. I don't know a single 'professional' who regularly work 50 hours, working time regs state you shouldn't work over 48hrs a week. Yes you CAN opt out of that, but lets not pretend that is the norm.

The fucking contempt oozing out of you for people who are struggling is absolutely vile. OP is exactly the type of family who benefits and catchment nets should be there to help. They aren't slobbing around watching TV and fucking off work all day then rocking up to a food bank. They are working the maximum hours that the can for their situation right now, OP has said when she is well and one of the kids is in school they will increase hours. Nothing about them screams waster but you've seen the words food bank and benefits and started frothing at the mouth.

On the working hours lots of professionals do work 50 hours a week but (& it’s a huge but) they generally have a fair bit of flexibility about when they do those hours and can fit them around other things. Also most families with 2 professional workers will have enough income to fund help (childcare, cleaners, gardeners, using meal boxes/takeaways etc etc). It’s not comparable.

My OH and I both typically do 45-50 hours a week full time equivalent (he actually does 35-40 but he only works 4 days at the moment) but I can work 7-4 in the office with a lunch break and then I’ll usually do some work after 8 a couple of evenings and pick up some email at the weekend. It’s not uncommon for me to walk along to school pick up on a work call or to be answering queries while my kids are at their swimming lesson or while I’m making the tea. It’s really really not the same as having to physically be at work for 50 hours

whumpthereitis · 08/03/2023 10:16

family that could help are irrelevant if they won’t.

the other comments though sound like she’s fed up of being asked for things. She’s said no on two occasions, but how many times has she said yes? It seems like you’re comfortable asking her for things, and have the expectation that she should provide them.

JustDanceAddict · 08/03/2023 10:15

AmIThatMam · 08/03/2023 05:26

You are an adult and therefore responsible for your own life/children, so it’s irrelevant what your parents earn. Your mum is an a-hole and that’s not your fault. No one should need to use a food bank, I’m sorry you find yourself in that situation. I wish we had a better support system, better wages, better government.

It’s not irrelevant if your parents can afford and are willing to be generous. I would never see my adult DC struggle and would always help if they needed it - we can afford it. Obviously there’s a line between bankrolling them and helping out in dire need - no excuse not to help your DC if they’re going through tough times.
The OP’s family sound awful, but that’s not the norm. It’s different if the DC don’t want help but it’s not the case here.

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/03/2023 10:14

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 10:11

This thread just shows what people really think and it's absolutely disgusting.

It certainly is.

The Victorian attitude towards people who are struggling (most often through no fault of their own) is horrific. Particularly as the family members who will suffer most aren't the "feckless" parents who shouldn't have had children if they couldn't guarantee at least 20 years of full employment and excellent health, but those children themselves.

Some people on here should be ashamed of themselves.

IncompleteSenten · 08/03/2023 10:12

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 10:11

This thread just shows what people really think and it's absolutely disgusting.

Couldn't agree more.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 10:11

This thread just shows what people really think and it's absolutely disgusting.

ItsaMetalBand · 08/03/2023 10:11

The fact that you use food banks despite your mother's wealth speaks volumes about HER. Not you.

I've thankfully never needed to go to a food bank, but during the recession we really struggled and couldn't pay all our bills despite the two of us on full time (and good) wages. All it would have taken is a bout of ill health or reduced hours at work during those years to really fuck us over. By the grace of god and all that.

Anyway, a decade on, and we are in a different position - redundancy and ill health happened to DH but thankfully in the intervening years my career progressed nicely, plus he also inherited a house so we are managing despite one wage coming in and it's temporary. It's tight, but nowhere near as tight and stressful as it used to be for us. When we did (and when we will again) have money, we gave loads to charity because we came so close at the time to needing it.

Your life will not always be this hard and you won't always be this broke. And when you are back on your feet, and you both are in a position to help others, I've no doubt that you will pay it forward and donate to the food bank that helped you during this time.

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/03/2023 10:10

Snoken · 08/03/2023 06:43

I agree you both have to work more. Not many families can survive on two part time wages. You have chosen to have multiple children without having the means to feed them. It’s really irresponsible to assume you can then work part time and rely on food banks to make up the shortfall. Whilst you figure this out use the food banks to make sure your kids don’t go hungry, but you need to figure out a way to support yourselves.

You have chosen to have multiple children without having the means to feed them. It’s really irresponsible to assume you can then work part time and rely on food banks to make up the shortfall.

I very rarely say this @Snoken , but "F" off.

We can none of us see the future. Any one us can be financially comfortable one day and one the edge of poverty the next - an accident, a death, a pandemic, a Brexit that pushes prices up to unheard of levels while wages remain low - who knows what's around the corner.?

Very few people have children thinking "Oh, we'll have the kids and the food bank can feed them." We have them thinking we will be able to support them - it's not irresponsible of OP at all.

Castergirl · 08/03/2023 10:10

shattered25 · 08/03/2023 09:01

Bloody hell some of the posts on here.... didn't realise that if you have health issues and can't work you still must work and it's all your fault and how dare you not predict the future and have children when you were going to get ill and a cost of living crisis happened?? Don't you know it's Britain we don't spend time with our children growing up and must work morning noon and night to prove we are decent moral human beings 😂😂 then obvs spend the wages on childcare but that's acceptable... weird parents wanting to raise their own children!

Exactly. As well as the 'well I did so you can too' posts. The lack of kindness and empathy is so depressing. OP I'm sorry. I hope things look up for you soon.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 10:08

KitsyWitsy · 08/03/2023 08:33

The DP’s parents could still help from abroad. Ever heard of bank transfers?

OP, I think you need help with budgeting and one of you needs to do more hours.

They aren't well off. Ever heard of reading properly?

Onefootinthegroove · 08/03/2023 10:05

@WilsonMilson . 4 years ago I lived in the uk. 2 grown up DC, I worked ft , DH was semi retired so worked pt. On our income we could comfortably run a 3 bed semi detached, have a car each, gym memberships, ddog , social life ect.
We decided to retire abroad- and are happy with that decision every day as on the income we had then we would be struggling to survive now. Wages are not keeping pace with the cost of living. People are falling through the cracks.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 08/03/2023 10:04

And yet again a thread about the cost of living crisis and it's very real effects swarming with incredulous posters who have no idea what it's like to be struggling. So again the deserving/ undeserving poor rhetoric.
They both work. He works condensed hours . She works according to her consultants advice . Her family could help, but dont. And yet somehow some posters are twisting this as them being feckless and scroungers. Un fucking believable.

I agree. They are just sticking the boot in out of sheer nastiness.

Ignore them OP.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 08/03/2023 10:04

Plirtle · 08/03/2023 07:27

I must say both working part time seems like a luxury- aren't there childcare vouchers?

What a naive comment.

A) no, childcare vouchers aren't a thing anymore unless you were using the system years ago.

B) UC is up to 75% but the thresholds are tiny and ime very few people get the 75%

C) you can get tax free childcare but it doesn't really make a dent.

Emotionalsupportviper · 08/03/2023 10:01

neighboursmustliveon · 08/03/2023 05:25

Clearly you don't have family help if the help is refused. Personally I would keep it to myself but if it does come up just say you don't have any help and try and leave it at that.

If the person keeps on you could say something like 'That's for pointing out how horrible it is to have family that could help me but won't, that makes me feel great about myself!'

You shouldn't have to though.

This - but I agree that it is none of her damn business.

Families like this are the equivalent of a hidden disability. I would never challenge someones right to use a disabled facility just because the "look" healthy, because I have no idea whether they have Crohn's Disease, difficulties with their joints which mean that they need the extra space to manoeuvre themselves etc - even claustrophobia, for heaven's sake! How would I know.

And because I don't know, I don't comment.

Tell them. "You don't know my circumstances. Please mind your own business."

monsterradeliciosa · 08/03/2023 10:00

Well if they won't help you then your family being well off is about as much use to you as it is to me.

If you worried about every single comment you would be.... well, you'd be doing this.

I've used foodbanks too but never told one person in real life about it, hence no comments, not that I would have cared.

Ellie56 · 08/03/2023 09:58

Your partner doesn't work part time! He works long hours over 4 days but it still equates to full time work.

Squamata · 08/03/2023 09:52

OP your life sounds hard, I hope soon you can recover and find a way to earn more.

Emotionally though, you need to take care of yourself a bit more. You're obviously really hurting about how your mum behaves and differences in how she treats your sister. You need to find a way to not be on the back foot with that and feel more empowered in the relationship (maybe by accepting it and not waiting for her to turn around and give more to you, because she's probably not going to).

I personally wouldn't ask to borrow from a friend unless it was both desperate and a short term issue and I knew I could pay back within a month or so. Because if a friend helps you out once when you're desperate, chances are you'll ask again and before you know where you are, they're doling out regular amounts with no hope of getting it back and it's not unreasonable that a friend would not want to do that.

Don't have any shame in using a foodbank. Prices have outstripped wage increases, that's not your fault. Your family finances are no one else's business.