Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For using a foodbank when my family are relatively well off ?

638 replies

Notaskingmuch · 08/03/2023 05:18

But won’t help me ?

I was told yesterday by someone I know that ‘you know foodbanks are for people with no other choice and no support at all not ones who could get help from family’

The thing is my family WONT help me.

I can’t explain to people my family dynamics, how dm is narcissistic and I’m the scapegoat. How she’s happy to have both my dsis round for regular get together a where they have nice meals or go out to restaurants but I’m not invited , that they get invited round for afternoon tea but I don’t ….etc etc

Once recently when I was desperate I asked could I borrow a few staple food items and got told ‘I don’t have much here sorry’ on another occasion I asked could I borrow £20 to do a basic shop and was told ‘sorry no-you need to support yourself’ (from someone who owns their home outright , has a DP who still works and earns well and who regularly treats her other 2 daughters)

So we use a food bank, well 2 actually as one is church run and unlimited and the other is via a voucher and limited.

i can’t bring myself to have to explain as I’m exhausted and wish she had kept her comment to herself. I can see it looks like somethings off as she knows my family but I just don’t want to be judged she clearly thinks I’m a CF though .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whatkatydid2013 · 10/03/2023 10:32

Snoken · 09/03/2023 15:04

I have never said she needs to work more. I have said her husband should work at least 40 hours a week. Why do you think he shouldn't? Why do you think that their current situation is safe and secure? They have nobody who can help them if they stand there without food. They have no safety net and they have two small children. That is quite a stressful and scary situation to be in when they don't have to.

I think if the OP has access to free childcare hours then having OH work while their child uses them could be a solution but. . .

Schools that provide the hours usually will only offer either am/pm for 3 hours each day in termtime, which is relatively minimal help

Many private nurseries/childminders will charge additional fees to use the hours &/or will only offer them in same way schools do so you can’t just use them to have 1 or 2 full days year round.

If both parents are at work for a couple of days together they’ll need childcare for one of their children through the school holidays even if the youngest can use free hours through the year. I well recall the logistical pain in the neck of coordinating one at nursery and one at various holiday clubs running on stupid hours. It was very doable for us as our employers are flexible. It really wouldn’t be for someone with an inflexible employer and it often seems like the lower paid the role the less flexible it is.

I assume intention is that come September when both kids are at school and OP has had time to recover then there will be opportunities to pick up extra shifts in termtime &/or for OH to work an evening but for now they are doing as much as they can while OP is unwell.

I don’t think it’s a horrible idea to look at additional hours but the OPs responses seem to already indicate this isn’t feasible so why is it impossible to accept that and that they are stuck as they are till September. Why can’t you accept that is true? Also don’t you think in those circumstances it’s pretty awful her family won’t support her? I’d help either of my girls even if they were being a bit useless as mine and my partners parents would help us. Goodness I’d help a friend or a parent at school or a neighbour in those circumstances never mind my own child

GnomeDePlume · 10/03/2023 08:22

A few posters on this thread have been displaying a very Victorian attitude of deserving/undeserving poor. The OP & her DH have been categorised as 'undeserving' because the DH isnt working every possible hour.

I cant imagine the OP is using foodbanks as a lifestyle choice. This is a stop gap until she can start working more hours in September.

It may come as a shock to some but not everywhere is like everywhere else:

  • Not all employers will give extra hours to employees just for the asking. Retailers like PT workers because it is easier to sort cover if one person is off.
  • Not all people have cars to use for delivery/Uber gig jobs (one PP suggested this)
  • Not all places have good public transport to make commuting between extra jobs possible
  • Not all places have loads of easily picked up jobs available

I get the feeling that some posters wont be satisfied until the OP has posted up her bank statements and a minute by minute schedule of the family day so that they can pore over them and pick at any 'faults'.

getalifesonny · 09/03/2023 22:56

@Springchicken75 when you give to charity you do keep on banging about it. Lots of us do and we do realise that these are real people out there who are needing help more than ever and we are fortunate to be able to help. Be grateful instead of being so spiteful and if you are going to judge whoever uses the food bank then don't donate. I am sure someone else will fill the gap. OP and her family are genuinely struggling who need help. People need food. No one I have seen uses the food bank just for the fun of it. It's already soul crushing to be going through such poverty that you have to use food banks and then there are people like you who beat the already dead man.

OP you do you. You know your situation best. Bad times can come on anyone and I pray that no one of us has to experience it and pray for you that your situation gets better soon. You don't have to justify yourself to anyone. And stay away from these judgey friends. No one needs to know your financial situation unless you know you can rely on them not being judgemental.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/03/2023 22:03

There are other times in the week he could work.

Such as?

He already works 4 fairly long days and the other 3 looks after the children while OP is at work. She then needs him around to help her on those evenings.

Did I miss the memo that there are now 8 days in a week?

WiIson · 09/03/2023 16:14

The ops plan is to try and get more work hours in September.
She has a plan. She has a timescale. More than reasonable.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 09/03/2023 16:07

But you're ignoring the fact that her husband is pretty much a carer while she recovers. He clearly needs to be around at certain times, otherwise they'd have already thought of the extra hours/different job solution.

The OP is following her consultants advice in the hope of making a full recovery and being able to work full time again. The future for her family will be a lot more manageable if she is allowed to recover.

Sometimes circumstances mean you can't access the 'easy' solutions, and it's really frustrating when people keep shoving those solutions in your face as if you were incapable of thinking of them for yourself.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 09/03/2023 16:02

Snoken · 09/03/2023 15:46

As far as I can see the OP has not confirmed that. She has said that she needs him home in the evening after she finishes work but that's it, unless I have missed something. There are other times in the week he could work. They may be able to get free childcare too since the child is 3+ so they could both work at the same time.

I am just making suggestions, but everyone is acting like I'm forcing the OP and her DH to work 24/7 just for the hell of it. Wouldn't you rather make an extra £50 a week than not knowing if you can feed your children?

Her comment about her needing him literally does confirm that. And yes, they could get free hours but they're short and they're term time. Presumably they've probably already thought of this...

Yes, I would, if I could, I think it's fairly obvious that's the situation here as well! I don't think its a conscious choice to be using a food bank.

Snoken · 09/03/2023 15:46

Birdsbirdsbirds · 09/03/2023 15:36

But none of the suggestions are workable! They're literally useless. It's been explained why he can't work more, several times.

As far as I can see the OP has not confirmed that. She has said that she needs him home in the evening after she finishes work but that's it, unless I have missed something. There are other times in the week he could work. They may be able to get free childcare too since the child is 3+ so they could both work at the same time.

I am just making suggestions, but everyone is acting like I'm forcing the OP and her DH to work 24/7 just for the hell of it. Wouldn't you rather make an extra £50 a week than not knowing if you can feed your children?

Snoken · 09/03/2023 15:41

WiIson · 09/03/2023 15:26

And you really care about the op don't you. I can see that. You really care and you really want to help her. Even though you haven't noticed her barriers to your plan for her. But it's all coming from a good place regardless.

🤨

Why are you so mean and angry? What do you think they should do then? Just carry on and hope for the best? You haven't answered any of my questions. You just came on to tell me how horrible I am but without actually contributing anything. I have noticed OP's barriers, she is recovering from an accident so she can't do more hours and she needs her husband around in the evenings after she finishes work, but there are other hours of the day when he can work more. OP hasn't said if that works for them or not, so I have no idea I am just suggesting things they can do to get out of the situation they are in.

It is great that there are food banks and it's great that people can use them in the short term but it can't be relied upon, especially when having kids and no safety net.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 09/03/2023 15:36

Snoken · 09/03/2023 15:04

I have never said she needs to work more. I have said her husband should work at least 40 hours a week. Why do you think he shouldn't? Why do you think that their current situation is safe and secure? They have nobody who can help them if they stand there without food. They have no safety net and they have two small children. That is quite a stressful and scary situation to be in when they don't have to.

But none of the suggestions are workable! They're literally useless. It's been explained why he can't work more, several times.

Onefootinthegroove · 09/03/2023 15:33

@Pink39tree you sound like my old line manager , the one who refused to let me have my crutches within reach because she had " seen onefoot walking around Tesco with her crutches in the trolley" - no amount of reasoning would make her see that I was leaning on the trolley and didnt posess a 3rd arm and hand hand to hold 2 crutches and the trolley at the same time .
Some people just have no empathy, imagination or common sense.

WiIson · 09/03/2023 15:26

And you really care about the op don't you. I can see that. You really care and you really want to help her. Even though you haven't noticed her barriers to your plan for her. But it's all coming from a good place regardless.

🤨

Snoken · 09/03/2023 15:04

WiIson · 09/03/2023 15:00

Yes, aren't we so horrible for trying to find ways for the OP to feed her children without relying on charitable donations which can end at any point?

Disingenuous.

I don't think for one moment, those berating the op, and telling her that she should work harder despite being unwell are doing this to be helpful or altruistic towards her. It's the usual MN angry attack and pile on, even if someone is vulnerable and unwell, there is no care or consideration for that.

I have never said she needs to work more. I have said her husband should work at least 40 hours a week. Why do you think he shouldn't? Why do you think that their current situation is safe and secure? They have nobody who can help them if they stand there without food. They have no safety net and they have two small children. That is quite a stressful and scary situation to be in when they don't have to.

ilovesooty · 09/03/2023 15:03

Agreed @Wilson. Indeed MNHQ saw fit to act on the reports they must have received about some of the posts.

WiIson · 09/03/2023 15:00

Yes, aren't we so horrible for trying to find ways for the OP to feed her children without relying on charitable donations which can end at any point?

Disingenuous.

I don't think for one moment, those berating the op, and telling her that she should work harder despite being unwell are doing this to be helpful or altruistic towards her. It's the usual MN angry attack and pile on, even if someone is vulnerable and unwell, there is no care or consideration for that.

Snoken · 09/03/2023 14:55

ilovesooty · 09/03/2023 14:20

The most unpleasant posters on this thread are probably incapable of that kind of self reflection. Imagine actually knowing them in real life.

Yes, aren't we so horrible for trying to find ways for the OP to feed her children without relying on charitable donations which can end at any point? It would be so much better if we all just said stay as you are, hopefully people needing food banks will decline now with the cost of living crisis, and other people will have lots more disposable income to use for donations with the rise of inflation. So much better if you look at the bigger picture, right?

ilovesooty · 09/03/2023 14:20

FrangipaniBlue · 09/03/2023 11:52

This thread is truly awful and some posters need to take a long hard look at themselves.

Appalling behaviour.

The most unpleasant posters on this thread are probably incapable of that kind of self reflection. Imagine actually knowing them in real life.

Birdsbirdsbirds · 09/03/2023 13:18

Pink39tree · 09/03/2023 10:47

Im beginning to think you’re the OPs husband in disguise because why are you so passionate on him not working more hours to support his own family? No grown father should be working less than full time when they can’t even put food on their children’s table.

So bored of this discussion about him “nearly working full time” OP herself said he works part time, the hours she’s given taken away breaks confirms he doesn’t work full time and therefore he should be working more hours to help his family.

If they want to stop relying on food banks that can stop the help at any time then the only way to get more money to pay for food is to work more hours.

Oh sorry, stating what "full time" is, you can Google it if you want, equates to being the ops husband?

Bore. Off.

He does work full time. Learn to count.

FrangipaniBlue · 09/03/2023 11:52

This thread is truly awful and some posters need to take a long hard look at themselves.

Appalling behaviour.

MyGreenBedspread · 09/03/2023 11:23

Pink39tree · 09/03/2023 11:13

OP has never confirmed what her husbands contracted paid hours are she’s just given us his working hours which everyone has interpreted as his contract which clearly wouldn’t be the case as it’s not taking into consideration unpaid breaks.

OP herself has confirmed her husband works part time hours, as such I will continue to believe he doesn’t work full time because that’s what she said.

The hours she said added up to 37 hours… so over 35 which is the limit of full time (I had always thought it was 37.5 but I just looked it up). If he is contacted to the hours stated then he is employed full time (albeit condensed into 4 day). He may have unpaid breaks in there but that doesn’t alter the status of his employment.

Pink39tree · 09/03/2023 11:13

MyGreenBedspread · 09/03/2023 11:07

@Pink39tree but millions of people are working ‘full time jobs’ who don’t get paid breaks and lunch. In many jobs if you apply for a full time position with the hours given as 37.5 a week it is taken for granted that your breaks etc aren’t paid… does everyone think hang on, I have 45 minutes of lunch and breaks unpaid in there so it isn’t really full time and then look for an extra job for 45 minutes a day?!

OP has never confirmed what her husbands contracted paid hours are she’s just given us his working hours which everyone has interpreted as his contract which clearly wouldn’t be the case as it’s not taking into consideration unpaid breaks.

OP herself has confirmed her husband works part time hours, as such I will continue to believe he doesn’t work full time because that’s what she said.

MyGreenBedspread · 09/03/2023 11:07

@Pink39tree but millions of people are working ‘full time jobs’ who don’t get paid breaks and lunch. In many jobs if you apply for a full time position with the hours given as 37.5 a week it is taken for granted that your breaks etc aren’t paid… does everyone think hang on, I have 45 minutes of lunch and breaks unpaid in there so it isn’t really full time and then look for an extra job for 45 minutes a day?!

Pink39tree · 09/03/2023 10:49

Snoken · 09/03/2023 10:42

What is your solution then? Just hope for the best and that the food bank will continue to feed them for the next 6 or so months? I wouldn't want to gamble like that with my childrens health and wellbeing. It is already established that it is getting harder to get food from food banks and you can't count on it as a long term solution which 6 months+ is.

The solution apparently is just to continue relying on help that can stop at any time and not actually taking accountability of one’s own situation and trying to help themselves. Then have the nerve to suggest their parents should help when they aren’t helping themselves.

I’m sorry but it’s so frustrating, working full time hours should be the bare minimum you do for your kids to ensure they are fed. Nobody is saying what’s the plan if the food bank stops which very well can at any moment?

Pink39tree · 09/03/2023 10:47

Birdsbirdsbirds · 09/03/2023 10:30

Anything over 35 hours is classed as ft, not over 40.

Im beginning to think you’re the OPs husband in disguise because why are you so passionate on him not working more hours to support his own family? No grown father should be working less than full time when they can’t even put food on their children’s table.

So bored of this discussion about him “nearly working full time” OP herself said he works part time, the hours she’s given taken away breaks confirms he doesn’t work full time and therefore he should be working more hours to help his family.

If they want to stop relying on food banks that can stop the help at any time then the only way to get more money to pay for food is to work more hours.

Snoken · 09/03/2023 10:42

Birdsbirdsbirds · 09/03/2023 10:31

It's not 80%.

I don't want them to do anything, I've simply explained why some people's "solutions" won't work for this particular couple.

What is your solution then? Just hope for the best and that the food bank will continue to feed them for the next 6 or so months? I wouldn't want to gamble like that with my childrens health and wellbeing. It is already established that it is getting harder to get food from food banks and you can't count on it as a long term solution which 6 months+ is.