Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my SD1 is an entitled brat?

289 replies

UlrikaUmbridge · 07/03/2023 23:37

Firstly I will say- I do adore, very much consider her a part of my family but I’m sick of her behaviour.

I have two stepchildren- aged 21 and 15 and 3 of my own who are all primary school age.

I work from home, and SD2 is also home schooled.

I met their dad 10 years ago now- he had been living in the UAE with his ex wife (and the girls mum), nasty divorce and he got full custody after a very long court battle. We have always got on well, with difficulty at the start as the girls were not used to having a loving maternal figure in their lives.

SD1 has been a handful since 16- when she argues with her Dad, she calls her mum and flys over there, will refuse to speak to us until 2/3 weeks later she’s crying down the phone wanting to come home. And, of course, we welcome her back with open arms.

She moved out last year as she had a good job (mobile hairdresser). Her dad offered to build her a salon in the basement of our new house and also a sort of mini studio flat for her to live in.

The agreement was while she was building up a client base, we wouldn’t charge her rent for 6 months but there would be ground rules- if you out past 10 don’t come home as it will wake the other children, boyfriend allowed to stay at weekends but not every night and in exchange she would babysit once a week so me and DH could have a night out.

Obviously she is on our electricity and gas. I have a rule that the heating goes on at 5-8pm, no earlier or later. She insists on putting it on at 9am ”because it’s bad for business otherwise”

Its 8 months later- she hasn’t paid a penny in rent (keeping in mind we only ask for £100pw to cover the cost of electricity/gas, water, insurance, her rent and food). When we bring it up with her- she threatens to go back to her mums, so DH gives in. Coupled with the fact she regularly comes in past 10, loudly banging doors which wakes the children up and most nights sneaks her boyfriend in- we aren’t a fucking BNB

She is costing us a fortune and is making a decent amount of money- has booked 3 holidays this year, swanky new car and parcels of clothes and makeup turn up at least 3 times a week.

DH is being a spineless twat- I understand he wants her here, and I genuinely do too, but we can’t fund her forever surely?

OP posts:
Sassyfox · 08/03/2023 09:07

I agree with @Velvian there is obviously a lot of things going on and she’s obviously got some trauma from childhood.

Her dad still needs to have set boundaries in place though because a child like this can easily go off the rails.
Maybe some therapy sessions would help her deal with these issues better.

Sassyfox · 08/03/2023 09:04

Your issue isn't your SD, but your DH!

I agree!

Your DH sounds like a kind man and a good dad but he is making his children spoilt and that will do them no favours.
Daddy is not always going to be there to bail her out.

I think the 10pm rule is ridiculous and she needs to be treated like an adult.
I think she’s probably acting like a teenager because she’s being treated like one.

However, there was a plan in place for her to start paying after 6 months and she needs to follow through with it.

Who builds an entire business in their basement!
I think that’s mad and she doesn’t even realise how fortunate she is.
You’ve both been more than fair.

If it was me I’d be putting my foot down and telling her that she needs to start paying.
I think it would be good if she goes running back to her mum because then she might realise how good she has got it.

Unfortunately, though this isn’t your issue to deal with, its DH’s and if DH isn’t going to give her any consequences then nothing is going to change.

Velvian · 08/03/2023 08:58

YABU about the heating. Her clients are sitting still in a chair, it needs to be really warm. I WFH anf have the thermostat at 18/19 and that is with 2 jumpers, fingerless gloves and a scarf. When you get your hair cut, you can't be wearing all that.

Does the basement area have a separate entrance and kitchen? YANBU about coming in, making noise and eating the DC's packed lunches. She needs to be more considerate.

It does sound like she has had a shit childhood and adolescence. I suspect there is a lot of resentment there and a wish to punish her dad, you and the younger DC who are having a better childhood than she had. She may feel that her dad has a debt to repay to her.

Talking all that through and acknowledging how difficult things have been for her might go a long way.

Poscapen · 08/03/2023 08:50

To summarise -
She's supposed to be paying a tiny rent for her business premises, studio and food. She doesn't.
She wants the heating on for longer - but doesn't actually pay anything for it.
When she's been out at night she comes back making enough noise to wake the household, she does it deliberately knowing she'll wake up young kids and doesn't care in the slightest. If she didn't do that you wouldn't have asked her to be in by 10 or stay away.
She and her boyfriend help themselves to the family food, even to the point where you don't have what you need in the morning.
She'd like to move her boyfriend in so he can freeload off you and her dad as well.

I don't know why you're getting a hard time here Op, she's treating you and the rest of the family like shit. I don't know what you can do with her dad being so useless about it. But obviously she needs to be charged more rent, reflecting the fact that she is living and running a business in the house - then the heating costs won't be an issue. If she doesn't pay ideally she would need to be given her marching orders with no messing.

The amount she pays needs to be enough to cover the food they eat. Or she needs a fridge freezer and cupboard in her accommodation somewhere and told to get her own.
But this is MN Op, so you're the big bad stepmother. The fact that you're dealing with a nasty, entitled and spoilt adult is neither here nor there. No respect, no consideration and unprincipled enough to have no problem with keeping all her income to herself while fleecing the rest of the family. What a gem.

Tryingtorelocate · 08/03/2023 08:50

You sound very uptight. And this thread is very very outing

ootb · 08/03/2023 08:47

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 08/03/2023 08:25

She's 21, not 14. At her age, most young people have been to university and have spent a lot of time crashing at goodness knows where and making crap choices. It's part of growing up between 18 and 21. A 21 yr old with a job ought to be living elsewhere, where she can come and go as she pleases without bothering anyone else. The husband is at fault here for not helping her to become properly independent.

No, it would be dangerous for any young adult woman to be told they have to find a random person's house to sleep in after 10pm.

At uni for example, halls or flats don't have doors that lock you out after 10pm or even midnight or 1am. If they did, consequences would be bad as for example you might feel obliged to stay with a man you weren't comfortable with just to have a warm place to sleep that night.

Dustybarn · 08/03/2023 08:47

It sounds like she was enjoying her independence and then her dad bribed her to come back home. She is resentful so she is pushing it as far as she can as she doesn’t really care if she gets chucked out. If I was 21 and lived at home with 4 siblings I’d be out the door at the first opportunity. Instead she’s working from the family basement and not having any interaction with her peers so missing out on friendships and fun. However well intended the home salon idea was, it’s not working. Have a sit down meeting with her and ask her what she really wants. If it is the home salon, then she must immediately pay rent for this month, plus an amount towards heating (she really cannot run a business without heating). If not, she should be encouraged to find a chair in a salon starting April and also to move out. Her father’s own dependence on her and lack of boundary setting is stopping her from growing up. He needs to lead the meeting and treat her like an adult and she in turn needs to behave like one.

JackHackettsMac · 08/03/2023 08:44

I think you’re daft to build her a salon in the basement and then say she can’t have the heating on. You won’t get clients returning to a cold salon. The 10pm curfew is also ridiculous.

She’s an adult and needs to be making her own way in life and your DH needs to back off and give her more freedom. Surely she’d be better off renting a chair in a salon and moving out to her own place, with her boyfriend if she wants to?

bigbluebus · 08/03/2023 08:34

Get a standing order set up for the rent. Do a paper version - get your DH to stand over her whilst she signs it then he posts it to her bank. If she cancels it or it's recalled due to lack of funds then she needs to be told she's out.

TommytheSquirrell · 08/03/2023 08:32

TommytheSquirrell · 08/03/2023 07:14

Some of your rules don’t work. No heating before 9am running a business doesn’t work. Not coming home past 10pm does not work as a young adult (lived at home and regularly came home at 3/4am at that age but I was quiet). She obviously should be paying rent. I can also understand not having the boyfriend home every night.

You need to sit down and have a conversation with her about paying rent, make it clear you expect her too and sneaking the boyfriend in.

I’d loosen up on the heating (maybe up her rent to £150/£175) and the coming home at 10pm (make her realise she must be quiet) and let her run to her mum for a few weeks if she want to.

She runs her business from your home she’ll obviously be back.

Sorry missed that her rent was weekly! That’s over the top, £200 per month max. You seem very strict.

KatherineJaneway · 08/03/2023 08:28

Your issue isn't your SD, but your DH!

Relaxingtime · 08/03/2023 08:27

Time to get together and sort the lack of payong up or let her go on her way.
Ligten up on your rules the girls is now a 21 yr old woman.
With a business, good on her.

booboo24 · 08/03/2023 08:26

A bit of both. I have a 21 year old still at home (final year of uni) who has a boyfriend of 5 years. She works part time so pays for things on an ad hoc basis. I agree your sd should be paying rent now she's working full time, but I don't think her behaviour is that abnormal for her age, dad needs to speak to her and set this up properly, I doubt she'll run back to mum over this as what would would happen with her client base then - she's manipulating you both with this I think!

10pm rule is ridiculous! The poor girl it's her home, surely you can't expect her in at that time every night, on a weekend the night is just beginning at that point! What's she supposed to say to friends? That she can only come out if she can stay at theirs after? I bet her friend's parents think that's lovely of you.....

Same with the boyfriend, why inly at weekends? She's not a school girl.

Also the heating, it's freezing first thing still, I can't imagine many people would want to sit still for an hour or so in a chilly room, whilst paying for the privilege. She's right, the clients won't be happy about that.

Would any of your rules relax if she was paying rent?

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 08/03/2023 08:25

YukoandHiro · 08/03/2023 08:15

The 10pm rule is really dangerous OP! I definitely wouldn't institute that. Who knows where she could end up crashing just because she doesn't feel like she's able to come home. That could easily push her into some very bad choices.

She's 21, not 14. At her age, most young people have been to university and have spent a lot of time crashing at goodness knows where and making crap choices. It's part of growing up between 18 and 21. A 21 yr old with a job ought to be living elsewhere, where she can come and go as she pleases without bothering anyone else. The husband is at fault here for not helping her to become properly independent.

Ponoka7 · 08/03/2023 08:24

This sounds very controlling and suffocating for both SDs. Is your DH from a middle eastern heritage? Are you in the UK? As said the setting up of the salon and its running costs were tax deductible. Has she been helped to sort out her NI contributions? As said, she needs her independence and should be encouraged to start up elsewhere and live her own life.

BellePeppa · 08/03/2023 08:24

MrsDoylesDoily · 08/03/2023 00:02

I'm having trouble marrying up the 'loving maternal figure' with the same woman who wants those completely unreasonable rules in place.

Yes especially the ‘if you’re not back by 10 don’t come back that night’ is she supposed to sleep on a park bench if she’s nowhere else to go. Who the heck says that, certainly not a loving maternal figure.

Baconking · 08/03/2023 08:23

Novatherova · 08/03/2023 00:11

If my mum told me to be home by 10pm or stay elsewhere at the age of 21 I'd laugh my head off.

That is absolutely ridiculous. Who on earth does that? And the heating rule....your poor children. It's minus 14 outside.

And by the sounds of it, if you can afford to build a studio and business premises in the basement, then you can afford to put your heating on.

Loving mother figure also would not be jealous of her 21 year old going on holiday and buying clothes.

Bring up the rent situation but everything else is laughable and quite frankly very weird.

10 pm curfew for 21 year old get a grip.

I don't agree with the OP having the heating off but most places in the UK are not currently minus 14 or ever get anywhere near that low.

It's currently zero degrees where I am. I've never experienced minus 14

YukoandHiro · 08/03/2023 08:15

The 10pm rule is really dangerous OP! I definitely wouldn't institute that. Who knows where she could end up crashing just because she doesn't feel like she's able to come home. That could easily push her into some very bad choices.

ootb · 08/03/2023 08:13

Also, sometimes adult children live with their parents to save money, but things like the 10pm rule are quite extreme. That seems more like "temporary measures" from a parent who desperately wants their adult child to haul arse out of the family home ASAP.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 08/03/2023 08:13

cloudsandream · 08/03/2023 05:59

Typical MN always rushing to the defence of stepchildren despite their behaviour Confused. Being at that age, with an income, and paying fuck all towards rent is taking the piss. Had this been OPs bio child the responses would be entirely different, but stepparents are always shit on, god forbid they have rules and standards. Slamming doors, eating all the food, and complaining about heating whilst not providing a penny is quite frankly, absurd.

I couldn't agree more. And it somehow all seems to have landed on the OP, whereas her husband is the one who ought to be putting a stop to all of this entitled nonsense, rather than facilitating it.

I have a 21 yo and there is no way I'd either encourage or tolerate them taking the piss like this, especially not if I had younger children who were being affected by it.

Thoughtful2355 · 08/03/2023 08:12

PLUS what it sounds like is DH had been living with them in another country, Took full custody and dragged them to another country with him leaving theyre mother behind then got with another woman who had 3 of her own kids!! no doubt making these 2 girls jealous that those kids have a mother and step father so 2 parents living in the same house not charging them rent. I would be mad too, I would probably act out a little at that as well because they are still young and experiencing hormones and sad feelings.

ootb · 08/03/2023 08:12

Boomboom22 · 08/03/2023 07:50

So her dad is a nasty piece of work who removed her from her mum, no doubt dripping poison. And you clearly intensly dislike her and want her business to fail. She's 21 not 15, her bf can be round whenever. 10pm is ridiculous. She needs to move away from you and her dad.

I don't think it may be that cut and dry, but I feel very sad for the child in this situation. (Referencing before she turned 21)

Yes it's true, sometimes children of divorced parents weaponise "I'm going to the other parent's house". (At the same time, without getting too blamey, they can only use it as a threat if the parents have a black-and-white POV – why is your DH so scared of her visiting her mother at this big age of 21 now?)

At the same time, that also doesn't mean they don't truly miss the other parent. She lost her own mother in a nasty court battle, and during puberty was forced to relocate with her father to a new country with a new woman.

(It's also unclear if you met her father before or after the divorce, but either way having a new mother is hard for any child.)

At 16, that was when your own biological children came into the picture too, and she may have been made even more aware of her stepchild status.

Her mother lives on the other side of the world, so it's not like they get to see each other on weekend visits. It's quite natural for children (especially when emotionally distressed) to want to go to Mum!

Yet for that natural urge, a teenage girl is called "a handful", it's implied that she's manipulative and disruptive, it's implied that OP and her DH are doing her a big favour by letting her come back (sorry, but as your DH fought a nasty battle for full custody, it's his duty to take her back in).

I know it must have been really hard for you and your DH, and you sound like you're trying your best... But I don't know if keeping her by your side now and fighting over draconian top-down rules is the best way to fix DH and her family dynamics.

Zodfa · 08/03/2023 08:10

You clearly hate her mother, who she seems to at least like. It's possible she may have picked up on this at some point in the last ten years and decided you aren't worthy of her respect.

Thoughtful2355 · 08/03/2023 08:09

heating thing wrong if shes doing a business in the basement, Itll need to be warm for people to want to go. 10pm is stupid! thats a curfew for 14 year olds. I also cant understand why kids would br woken up by someone coming in hopefully quietly after 10 pm.

£100 pw is also Alot so id expect more flexibility with other rules, where i live a house share is between £90-£120 a week all bills included and has no curfews or rules like that so i think YABU although charging £100 a week is fine if she is earning it and being allowed to enjoy the home.

gonnabeok · 08/03/2023 08:05

You are being unreasonable
What adult at that age wants to be in by 10pm????
It's her home - she should be able to invite who she likes.
Who wants to sit in a salon with no heating???? Ridiculous , it's her business - I'm sure you wouldn't want to have your hair done in a freezing cold salon either.
You don't have a step daughter problem you have a husband problem - he needs to have an adult conversation with her regarding paying her way when it comes to her financial responsibilities.
Good luck, until your husband problem improves things won't change. ..