Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my SD1 is an entitled brat?

289 replies

UlrikaUmbridge · 07/03/2023 23:37

Firstly I will say- I do adore, very much consider her a part of my family but I’m sick of her behaviour.

I have two stepchildren- aged 21 and 15 and 3 of my own who are all primary school age.

I work from home, and SD2 is also home schooled.

I met their dad 10 years ago now- he had been living in the UAE with his ex wife (and the girls mum), nasty divorce and he got full custody after a very long court battle. We have always got on well, with difficulty at the start as the girls were not used to having a loving maternal figure in their lives.

SD1 has been a handful since 16- when she argues with her Dad, she calls her mum and flys over there, will refuse to speak to us until 2/3 weeks later she’s crying down the phone wanting to come home. And, of course, we welcome her back with open arms.

She moved out last year as she had a good job (mobile hairdresser). Her dad offered to build her a salon in the basement of our new house and also a sort of mini studio flat for her to live in.

The agreement was while she was building up a client base, we wouldn’t charge her rent for 6 months but there would be ground rules- if you out past 10 don’t come home as it will wake the other children, boyfriend allowed to stay at weekends but not every night and in exchange she would babysit once a week so me and DH could have a night out.

Obviously she is on our electricity and gas. I have a rule that the heating goes on at 5-8pm, no earlier or later. She insists on putting it on at 9am ”because it’s bad for business otherwise”

Its 8 months later- she hasn’t paid a penny in rent (keeping in mind we only ask for £100pw to cover the cost of electricity/gas, water, insurance, her rent and food). When we bring it up with her- she threatens to go back to her mums, so DH gives in. Coupled with the fact she regularly comes in past 10, loudly banging doors which wakes the children up and most nights sneaks her boyfriend in- we aren’t a fucking BNB

She is costing us a fortune and is making a decent amount of money- has booked 3 holidays this year, swanky new car and parcels of clothes and makeup turn up at least 3 times a week.

DH is being a spineless twat- I understand he wants her here, and I genuinely do too, but we can’t fund her forever surely?

OP posts:
AIBUNoNo · 08/03/2023 10:07

sillysmiles · 08/03/2023 10:00

we aren’t a fucking BNB

But it is her home, and like anyone else, should be able to come and go when she pleases in her own home.

If she wants to be totally selfish and 'come and go' means waking up everyone else, she should get her own home.

Why is that not on your list of solutions?

I get sick and tired of entitled posters spouting 'It's her home'. Yes, in theory it is but it's also the OPs home, her dads' home and the other children's homes.

If she was sharing a house with people her own age they'd tell her what to do- be more considerate or pack your bags and go! There are house rules in shared houses.

Wheresthebeach · 08/03/2023 10:05

The issue is that she runs away to her mother when it suits her, and then runs back again. Lots of emotional blackmail going on here which needs to stop.

As a unit, you've done a lot for her, and she's not paying rent which isn't right. The curfew is silly and that needs to change as it's treating her like a teenager, not a grown up. She needs to be quiet when she comes in.

You do need to sit down with your DH and sort out what happens when she doesn't keep to her side of the bargain. She's learnt how to get everything she wants, and that needs to stop for her sake as well as everyone else's.

AIBUNoNo · 08/03/2023 10:04

Okay this is what I'd do.

I'd make her move out into a rented flat or a house and with her BF if that's what they want.

I might allow her to use the basement of your home as work premises but at a cost, paid by DD every month, no quibbling.

She is old enough to support herself and learn some financial responsibility.

At her age, my two were out of uni, working in stressful jobs and sharing houses.
They had to manage their own finances.

I don't think it's fair or reasonable that she is basically living with her BF in your home when they are staying up late, cooking food late and waking you up.
This is what a teen might do until the leave home. She's not a teen.

StrawberryAnnie · 08/03/2023 10:02

It’s also not very wise to take out a contract on a ‘swanky new car’ when her business is run from her parents basement and she has minimal overheads.

sillysmiles · 08/03/2023 10:00

we aren’t a fucking BNB

But it is her home, and like anyone else, should be able to come and go when she pleases in her own home.

StrawberryAnnie · 08/03/2023 09:58

ootb · 08/03/2023 09:39

@StrawberryAnnie It actually sounds like she is living beyond her means and could be getting into debt. The lifestyle she leads with holidays, cars, packages etc. is extravagant for a young person who has just started a business.

I don't think this sounds that extravagant, actually! She's definitely not slumming it, but she's not exactly splashing out the cash either. It just sounds like she's spending a bit unwisely, like any young person who's just started earning.

A holiday with Easyjet/Ryanair/even BA can be £100+ or even under that, if booked in advance. Not exactly something you go into debt for. I went on quite a few holidays with my friends/boyfriend when I first started work.

She has 1 car, which is quite normal for a young person. We don't know if it's a Toyota or a Porsche. In some areas of the UK, you need a car to get around anyway.

Online shopping can probably be cut down on. That said, online shopping is usually a lot cheaper than shopping in person. Plus, many young people (myself included) order a boatload to try on at home and then return at least half of it.

She should pay rent or move out, I agree. I think rent is another matter that's separate from her social life / lifestyle – most young people spend a bit frivolously the first year they start working.

I hear what you are saying. I also spent money on myself when that age. I didn’t always make the best decisions, but knew how to budget.

I was always able to cover my outgoings. Rent, bills, food etc.

3 packages of make up and clothes a week is particularly excessive.

Credit can be so easily available for young people, and it can begin to snowball.

Young women in particular are constantly bombarded online with marketing from the beauty industry and social influencers.

Kittlbua · 08/03/2023 09:58

YABU
Your rules are ridiculous.
You can't make a 21 year old stick to a 10 pm curfew.
I don't agree with you about the heating either - clients won't want to be sitting in a cold salon and she'll lose business.
You should be charging her rent though and perhaps more towards the gas and electricity if she is using more. But she is paying ca. 400 a month already. Also, she shouldn't be eating your food and making a mess in your kitchen. Does she not have cooking facilities in the studio? She shouldn't be waking the entire household up when she comes either.
DH needs to talk to her and establish some ground rules such as not making a noise or a mess in the kitchen, a larger contribution to bills and/or rent but at the same time removing the curfew nonsense and the heating times need to be changed to accommodate the business.

WilsonMilson · 08/03/2023 09:57

The 10pm rule is insane, she’s 21. At 21, a night out STARTS at 10pm!!

The mistake here was the home salon. She will take the piss because she can, the boundaries are too easy to flout. It’s not teaching her responsibility because she knows she can get away with doing what she wants. It’s going to continue to cause issues, so I think it was a bad idea and she should have rented a chair somewhere else or got her own salon when she could afford to and actually learned how to operate a business.

I think for her own sake she’d be better to move out. I doubt you’d feel quite the same way if this was your actual daughter though.

Thekirit · 08/03/2023 09:56

As an aside
@UlrikaUmbridge does the basement have a window.

Supersands · 08/03/2023 09:54

She would be better working elsewhere. She is young she is craving her independence. She is right the salon needs to be heated in the morning. The 10pm curfew is ridiculous no wonder she is rebelling. You need to treat her like the adult she is.

Nooyoiknooyoik · 08/03/2023 09:53

Scienceadvisory · 08/03/2023 00:02

I would be walking out of a hairdressers if it was really cold. Which in this case it likely would be seeing as its a basement and the heating doesn't go on until 5pm. Sabotaging her business won't help you.

It's also ridiculous to give a 21 year old a curfew, especially a 10pm one.

Unfortunately your husband has spoilt her and given into her tantrums. She should be paying rent so I would focus on that issue first.

She’s paying £400 per month.

No wonder she swings from one difficult home to the other.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/03/2023 09:53

You’re on a hiding to nothing if DH won’t insist on her paying the rent you all agreed she would. He’s not doing her any favours by pandering, whatever the reasons he’s doing it.

Is he going to support all 4 other DC the same way?

Velvian · 08/03/2023 09:52

@Twinedpeaks if she was living with her her mum and dad her life would be very different. The whole divorce and moving countries, moving in with a new family must have been extremely challenging.

You can't separate the behaviour from the circumstances of her upbringing.

bizclasswindows · 08/03/2023 09:50

DailyMaui · 08/03/2023 09:34

I have a couple of questions:

Was the divorce in the UAE? Did he get full custody because that's where the divorce was? Did the mum really not want to look after her kids? Just wondering as it's sadly all too common for women to lose custody of their children in the Middle East. There can be a long, bitter fight but if the man has decided he'll have the kids then khallas, no custody for the mum and massive trauma all round. My friend lost her son AND the husband accused her of a "crime*" so she would also get deported. Then he carried on with his busy job and the kid ended up being looked after up by the maid (he was a British national, just used the rules to benefit himself and ruin my friend's life for having the temerity to want a divorce). That kind of messy divorce can lead to all sorts of trauma for the children. If she's running back to her mum there's obviously some sort of relationship there.

The studio - it sounds more like a bedroom with a workstation attached... Does it have its own separate entrance, en suite facilities, kitchen area, salon area? Because if it was actually a studio flat with a salon attached she'd be able to come and go as she pleases without using your kitchen and TV late at night.


*the crime was working without his permission, despite the fact she'd been working as a teacher throughout her whole marriage... I get the screaming rage just thinking about it and the years of absolute misery that man has caused her.

I did secretly wonder about the UAE/male custody aspect, because in the UK at least, full custody for a man is very unusual. UK courts favour mothers.

I know OP says the bio mother is not a loving maternal figure (and OP apparently is), but that's just the story she's been told.

I think the "stepdaughter" aspect is relevant, because it does explain why the daughter could be acting out due to how she feels she fits in with this dynamic – eg could she be slamming the door to show she doesn't care about waking up OP's biological kids? She's a bit too old to be acting up, for sure, but she's being kept in an infantilised role due to very strict rules.

ItsaMetalBand · 08/03/2023 09:48

Salons need to be warm. YOU might not think the heating is needed, but if she's got women with wet hair sitting waiting to be cut, or older ladies who feel the cold very easily or people like me who have raynauds and once we get cold take hours to warm up.

I wouldn't pay heating for my business either if the landlord refused to let me put it on until an hour before I close the premises.

The arrangement isn't working. Neither of you are happy so it's best that she moves premises and rents a place with her boyfriend, and maybe in the process gain a bit of maturity and understanding about the cost of living.

Twinedpeaks · 08/03/2023 09:47

Ah OP, try reposting this with her as your DD, not SD, and you'll get much more helpful responses.

ootb · 08/03/2023 09:39

@StrawberryAnnie It actually sounds like she is living beyond her means and could be getting into debt. The lifestyle she leads with holidays, cars, packages etc. is extravagant for a young person who has just started a business.

I don't think this sounds that extravagant, actually! She's definitely not slumming it, but she's not exactly splashing out the cash either. It just sounds like she's spending a bit unwisely, like any young person who's just started earning.

A holiday with Easyjet/Ryanair/even BA can be £100+ or even under that, if booked in advance. Not exactly something you go into debt for. I went on quite a few holidays with my friends/boyfriend when I first started work.

She has 1 car, which is quite normal for a young person. We don't know if it's a Toyota or a Porsche. In some areas of the UK, you need a car to get around anyway.

Online shopping can probably be cut down on. That said, online shopping is usually a lot cheaper than shopping in person. Plus, many young people (myself included) order a boatload to try on at home and then return at least half of it.

She should pay rent or move out, I agree. I think rent is another matter that's separate from her social life / lifestyle – most young people spend a bit frivolously the first year they start working.

Neverhot · 08/03/2023 09:39

You are being really unreasonable regarding the heating and curfew. Yes she needs to pay, but for £400 a month you need to compromise more.

Poscapen · 08/03/2023 09:38

"And to say she ‘only’ contributes £450 a month and you expect her to pay for her own food, additional running costs and invite clients into a cold basement."

She doesn't contribute. She's supposed to pay £100 per week and doesn't!

£100 per week for premises for a hairdressing salon is an absolute bargain, let alone the fact that this includes all her heating costs and food and board.

DailyMaui · 08/03/2023 09:34

I have a couple of questions:

Was the divorce in the UAE? Did he get full custody because that's where the divorce was? Did the mum really not want to look after her kids? Just wondering as it's sadly all too common for women to lose custody of their children in the Middle East. There can be a long, bitter fight but if the man has decided he'll have the kids then khallas, no custody for the mum and massive trauma all round. My friend lost her son AND the husband accused her of a "crime*" so she would also get deported. Then he carried on with his busy job and the kid ended up being looked after up by the maid (he was a British national, just used the rules to benefit himself and ruin my friend's life for having the temerity to want a divorce). That kind of messy divorce can lead to all sorts of trauma for the children. If she's running back to her mum there's obviously some sort of relationship there.

The studio - it sounds more like a bedroom with a workstation attached... Does it have its own separate entrance, en suite facilities, kitchen area, salon area? Because if it was actually a studio flat with a salon attached she'd be able to come and go as she pleases without using your kitchen and TV late at night.


*the crime was working without his permission, despite the fact she'd been working as a teacher throughout her whole marriage... I get the screaming rage just thinking about it and the years of absolute misery that man has caused her.

slowquickstep · 08/03/2023 09:34

She is 21, tell your DH to sort it out or move out with her.

Lockheart · 08/03/2023 09:32

Not quite sure why everyone is wanging on about OP forcing people to sit in a cold salon. If the salon needs to be warm, SD needs to pay for the additional heating. Which she is presently not doing. It's SDs fault the salon might be cold, no-one else's.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 08/03/2023 09:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Newmum0322 · 08/03/2023 09:22

“DH is being a spineless twat”!

You’re unreasonable for this alone, and incredible rude!

Your SD is 21 and you’re acting as if you’re role in her life as parents is done. No free food, shelter or warmth! And to say she ‘only’ contributes £450 a month and you expect her to pay for her own food, additional running costs and invite clients into a cold basement.

When you’re own children grow up and ask for the basics like food and shelter aged 21 it’ll be you that becomes the spineless twat and you’ll maybe understand where her Dad is coming from.

StrawberryAnnie · 08/03/2023 09:09

A 10pm curfew and no use of the heating during the day when running a business is far too restrictive for any adult.

One of the main issues you have with her is about her financial contribution.

The arrangement you have at the moment is too informal and not making her take responsibility. Has the £100 per week been broken down and what it covers explained? .

It actually sounds like she is living beyond her means and could be getting into debt. The lifestyle she leads with holidays, cars, packages etc. is extravagant for a young person who has just started a business.

What you and her father probably need to do is have a structured conversation with her about finances for the salon in addition her contribution to the house, and put it in a spreadsheet.

Rent- Could you agree a fair amount for room and heating only, rather than bed and board? ( Say £75 per week) Then her buy her own groceries or contribute an amount to weekly shop separately ( say £25 per week) ?

After that you can move on to the business. It could be worth separately charging for the use of the salon space, so she knows if her business is actually turning a profit. ( keep it by for her so that she has some start up money for her own premises) You could also calculate electricity usage during the day and add it to this.

She might even then decide it’s no longer worth hairdressing in the basement, and move her business elsewhere.