Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think restaurants shouldn't be allowed to add service charges?

188 replies

Precipice · 07/03/2023 22:12

Prices are listed on the menu. Maybe the menu has a tiny tiny print somewhere about service charges being added (or maybe it even doesn't!). When it comes to the bill, there it is.

You're already paying for the service in the cost, just as you're paying for someone to prepare whatever you're ordering if it's being prepared, and for the fact that you're there in a restaurant at all.

AIBU to think that if restaurants want to charge you 10 percent more for everything, they should raise their actual prices by 10 percent openly?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 22:57

I just looked up tronc and one of the first hits said:

"The word ‘tronc’ is believed to be from the French words ‘tronc des pauvres’ meaning poor box. Having developed from the old boxes left in churches to collect money for the poor, a tronc is now a term for a special pay arrangement used to distribute tips, gratuities and service charges, as well as a sophisticated way of saving National Insurance Contributions (NICs) in the hotel and hospitality industry."

If you're happy with relying on a system originally developed to support those who depended on charity to survive for part of your earnings, rather than being allowed the dignity and pride of receiving a fair agreed wage in return for your work, like the vast majority of people, then fair enough.

Also, when it says 'saving' NICs, does it actually mean cleverly avoiding making your fair contribution to society?

nanny2012nanny · 09/03/2023 22:56

Don’t pay it then it’s not compulsory

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 22:51

If you worked in hospitality you wouldn’t be annoyed

But I don't work in hospitality - I'm coming from the perspective of a customer.

It really doesn't bother me how the staff end up being paid a fair wage from the proceeds of the business, just as long as it doesn't depend on me being socially manipulated into overpaying on an artificially-low stated price, rather than an actual proper inclusive price, as determined by the person who is supposed to be running the business.

Daisyinthegrass · 09/03/2023 22:41

I generally disagree with the idea of tipping, waiters and waitresses are paid a minimum wage which is no different than people such as carers who are not tipped. One poster said they spend their shift running back and to fetching drinks, ensuring people's allergy requirements are met - surely this is literally their job and again no different to carers who are not tipped. And if that poster is spending their time entertaining another table's toddler so the parents can eat their meal, why should I have a service charge added as my table has clearly not been looked after by that waiter/waitresses during that time?

Adding service charges is not right. If people want to tip they can but I agree with previous posters who say that the restaurants are just relying on people being too uncomfortable asking for it to be removed. Who gets the service charge anyway? If it just goes to the waiter/waitress that is really unfair - the chef is the one who has had the most difficult job and therefore the one who deserves the credit. Restaurants should just charge customers what they expect customers to pay and then pay their staff what they think they should earn.

nanny2012nanny · 09/03/2023 22:38

If you worked in hospitality you wouldn’t be annoyed
look up tronc

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 22:34

It's not just a case of increasing food prices by 10% as 100% of the service goes into wages there are no costs, you'd need to increase food prices by much more than that to make the same amount of profit to meet the staff salaries.

So how do supermarkets manage to give a simple price for what they are selling and neither expect nor actually accept tips? They need thousands of staff to make their business work, but they factor this into the prices they charge the consumers - there's no extra tip for the delivery drivers, shelf stackers, checkout assistants, HR and payroll managers etc. Whether they pay a fair wage is debatable, but if not, it is their sums that are wrong and not the principle.

What's the point of running a business if you expect your customers to run part of it for you, instead of just being allowed to be end consumers paying a stated price?

How can somebody be capable of factoring in all of their other costs such as building purchase/rental/lease, business rates, taxes, accountants, utilities, kitchen staff wages, their own profits/livelihood, appliances, furniture, crockery, cost of buying in the ingredients, provision of toilets, cleaners etc.... but they somehow still need help to be able to work out that one element of how they can include their staff costs in the overall budget? Either they're not very competent businesspeople or otherwise their intent is to deceive and confuse for their own benefit.

I'm absolutely not asking for lower wages for serving staff - I just want them to be able to rely on actual guaranteed wages, ultimately funded by non-schemed customers who are given an honest all-inclusive price to pay.

GeorgeA12 · 09/03/2023 22:27

that reminds me - i went to a restaurant and at the end the waiter stood there and asked if i wanted to donate to the restaurants charity as well. After paying for the meal i thought it was a bit unfair to do this as you feel obliged so i felt i had to pay but spoiled the meal somewhat.

ayegazumba · 09/03/2023 22:21

Any decent restaurant will have a tronc scheme. Google it if you want to know what that is. My dh runs a London restaurant. His total salary is £45k + 10% bonus for meeting targets. £25k of that comes from the restaurant, £20k of his salary Is tronc. We literally could not live without the service charge. It's easy to default to 'restaurants just keep the tips and don't give to staff' but in all the restaurants he's worked in I've never heard of that. They operate a fair scheme through a tronc master. It's not just a case of increasing food prices by 10% as 100% of the service goes into wages there are no costs, you'd need to increase food prices by much more than that to make the same amount of profit to meet the staff salaries. As you can see nearly 50% of my DH wage is service.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 22:21

Any kind of expectation of tipping or additional service charge for restaurant staff, so that they take home more in line with what they hope to (or what is promised/suggested by the employer), is just condescending towards and exploiting people in low-paying jobs.

Show me a lawyer, accountant, tradesman - anybody in a 'white-collar' role and/or who runs their own business - who will only bill you for 90% of what they want/expect to receive for their work and then rely on your good nature to optionally bump it up to their required amount, as long as they've smiled enough at you or been sufficiently entertaining.

It's a very simple concept, regardless of the type of business transaction: the customer is effectively asking "How much do I need to pay you to secure your delivery of the agreed goods and/or services?" and then the vendor/provider states the full inclusive price that they require in return.

It works perfectly well in Tesco, where the price of an item shown on the shelf is the exact amount I need to pay them to become the new owner of the item - and they don't seem to be too hard-up as a company as a result of this transparent pricing policy. Of course, they have a whole load of costs to them in supplying it, but as it is their business and not mine, it is up to them to allow for all of these and bake it in to the single price that they ask me to pay for each item, if I want it.

Vannyvikki66 · 09/03/2023 22:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

RainbowBrightside · 09/03/2023 22:19

I always ask for it to be removed yet feel annoyed that I’m being put in that position of having to ask. It’s not the right of the restaurant to demand I pay extra and that’s the exact reason I don’t leave a tip if the service charge is automatically added. The only time the team are in with a chance of a tip is if the service is fab and if they don’t put that stupid charge on. Otherwise it’s a big 👎 👎 from me.

DCxx · 09/03/2023 22:13

I’ve noticed this happening much more often where I stay. I wondered if it was because more people are paying by card now and often don’t have cash to leave a tip so possibly don’t leave one. I don’t think it should be added as automatic though, I think there should just be an add on option on the card machine

FlyingCapybara40 · 09/03/2023 22:11

Kay286 · 09/03/2023 22:03

My daughter earns 15 an hour plus tips.
I’m from the U.K. but live in canada and when I first moved over I hated the tipping culture… however I’ve not come to agree with it the severs are motivated to provide excellent service and that is what you get … not a plate dropped on your table from a miserable face to not be seen again!

It's sad that restaurants don't pay a decent wage to their staff. They should then the servers wouldn't have to rely on whether someone pays a tip or service charge

Dintananadinta · 09/03/2023 22:09

When you ask to remove the service charge they get annoyed with you and ask you why you want to remove the service charge. Most of the owners keep the money for themselves as well.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 22:08

Wasn't the whole idea of legally requiring restaurants to offer free tap water to help people better understand what the cost of their meal will be and not be taken by surprise by the (sometimes very high) cost of drinks? Especially as, for people who are not on their uppers but are on a budget (as sneered at above), the benefit and enjoyment of a meal professionally prepared and cooked for you is much more significant than the same bottle or can you could buy at a supermarket just opened and poured into a glass.

Other than wine, many restaurants don't put the prices of drinks on the menu, so that leaves the very obvious temptation for them to exploit this by charging well over the odds. Most people like/need a drink to have with their meal, so making sure that there is a simple free option puts the ball back in the court of the restaurant to price their meals transparently and realistically.

I get that there's the (tiny) cost of the water, the freezer for the ice, a bit of lemon and somebody to fill, bring and wash the jug and glasses, but it only has to be available to people already buying a meal; they can't just walk in only for as jug of free water and not pay the restaurant anything at all.

Kay286 · 09/03/2023 22:03

FlyingCapybara40 · 09/03/2023 21:56

Servers aren't paid well in Canada though. I'm not sure it's the same in the UK or not ?

My daughter earns 15 an hour plus tips.
I’m from the U.K. but live in canada and when I first moved over I hated the tipping culture… however I’ve not come to agree with it the severs are motivated to provide excellent service and that is what you get … not a plate dropped on your table from a miserable face to not be seen again!

FlyingCapybara40 · 09/03/2023 21:58

Luckydip1 · 09/03/2023 21:51

The problem with the service charge added on is that it doesn't encourage better service because it's expected. If you had to really earn your tip, the service would be much better.

I agree and I also think it's the restaurants responsibility to pay their serving staff a decent wage.

FlyingCapybara40 · 09/03/2023 21:56

Kay286 · 07/03/2023 22:14

I live in canada and you get added tax 13%, plus min expectation of 20% tip so I’m used to it and don’t mind it, so I agree with tipping - servers are generally not paid well so I wouldn’t begrudge 10%

Servers aren't paid well in Canada though. I'm not sure it's the same in the UK or not ?

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 09/03/2023 21:54

If you choose to tip and want the server to get the tip pay in cash. Because paying by card doesn't mean they have to get the tip. Legally the restaurant can keep any tips paid by card.

Luckydip1 · 09/03/2023 21:51

The problem with the service charge added on is that it doesn't encourage better service because it's expected. If you had to really earn your tip, the service would be much better.

EmbraceTheGrace · 09/03/2023 21:48

Thunderpunt · 09/03/2023 21:27

How about all those jugs of tap water you love to order with ice and lemon, or don't want a tea or coffee? Just a hot water with a slice of lemon that you don't get charged for (but i still pay for the person to serve it to you, plus the washing up of the glass, plus the actual water, ice and lemon)
We don't as a rule add service charge to any tables but if any of the above happens and the customers are rude with it.....you'll get a service charge from me!

You can say the same for any business, a customer browsing in a shop who doesn't buy anything, you still have the same staffing level, heating etc.A builder/plumber/electrician has travelling time, admin, sourcing, then working out estimates that may not be taken up ? They pay rent & tax as well
What do you think everybody else does , yet you think it's reasonableto add a service charge for doing their job? I will happily give a tip but a service charge added = grabby
How about a shoe shop ? Should they apply a service charge?

Smoky1107 · 09/03/2023 21:40

My teenager doubles her wage in Saturday job from service charge. I pay it every time now

Starlightstarbright1 · 09/03/2023 21:35

DoorstoManual · 07/03/2023 23:17

If you can’t afford to eat out then dont’, nobody is getting rich on your 10%

Well maybe they can afford a meal out but additional 10% might be more than budget.

Maybe service doesn't warrant a 10% topic

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 21:34

You always get people in threads about tipping/service charges calling others 'tight' for not wanting to overpay the stated price.

The only 'justification' that people seem to have for why you should tip is 'well, because you just should' - no critical thought seems to go into it.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 21:32

YANBU and customers shouldn't have to ask for the charge to be removed from the bill (they bank on the fact most will be too embarrassed to), it shouldn't be there in the first place. Tipping is discretionary, not compulsory.

This.

If you can’t afford to eat out then dont’, nobody is getting rich on your 10%

That makes no sense at all. If you have enough available money to pay the stated price of goods and/or services, that obviously means that you can afford it.

If the 10% is of such little consequence, maybe they should add it to the stated cost to the customer, so they're actually being honest about their pricing and how much they expect people to pay in exchange for what they are selling.

I bet you'd be the first to complain if the council sent out their demand for the year and then added 'only' 10% on to your direct debit, to pay for all their admin costs in collecting it, unless you specifically asked them to remove it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread