Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think restaurants shouldn't be allowed to add service charges?

188 replies

Precipice · 07/03/2023 22:12

Prices are listed on the menu. Maybe the menu has a tiny tiny print somewhere about service charges being added (or maybe it even doesn't!). When it comes to the bill, there it is.

You're already paying for the service in the cost, just as you're paying for someone to prepare whatever you're ordering if it's being prepared, and for the fact that you're there in a restaurant at all.

AIBU to think that if restaurants want to charge you 10 percent more for everything, they should raise their actual prices by 10 percent openly?

OP posts:
FlyingCapybara40 · 10/03/2023 00:04

I definitely would prefer to tip for exceptional service than either feel compelled to pay a service charge or opt out. I don't like being put in the position of opting out or not.

I do like to tip when service has been exceptional . It shows appreciation when someone has served above and beyond.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:51

I have never seen a restaurant menu that doesn’t state the cost of drinks!

I've seen quite a few with 'minimalist' menus that don't mention the drinks. At any rate, if they have a standard bar, they likely have far more options than they could include in the menu. But even if they didn't, most people find that they need a drink with their meal - and then, even if they can see the prices, they find that anything they choose is high-priced.

People needing/wanting to direct their budget at the meal itself used to ask for water - which was fine until the expensive ruse of bottled mineral water came in, which a lot would bring by default if you asked for water - hence the law about free tap water. Even now, you still have to remember to specify tap water, to avoid the possibility of being charged for bottled stuff.

As well as this, it's very common practice for waiting staff to bring the menus and then ask "Can I get you drinks whilst you're deciding?" - before anybody has had any time to look at the drinks prices.

Blinky21 · 09/03/2023 23:49

I prefer when it's already added on, if you don't want to pay it, remove it, no big deal

justgettingthroughtheday · 09/03/2023 23:46

BitOutOfPractice · 09/03/2023 23:01

I think if you can’t afford the tip @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll, yiu can’t afford to eat out. That’s the cold hard economics of it from the waiting staff’s perspective 🤷‍♀️

Why should they get a tip for just doing the job they are paid to do? 🤷🏻‍♀️ I work every bit as hard for roughly the same wage and I don't get a tip! What's so special about waiting staff?

PriamFarrl · 09/03/2023 23:41

It’s not the concept of tipping that I object to, it’s the way the service charge is added on automatically. Sometimes I’ve not noticed because I don’t scrutinise the bill so I leave a tip as well.

As for the ‘it has to be that way to make hospitality work’, how does it work in a small cafe where they don’t get tips on the scale of a restaurant. If it works there then why not in a restaurant?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:40

Getting paid minimum wage to sit behind a counter at Boots, scanning items is a completely different job to the one you mentioned above. Most people wouldn't work front of house if they didn't receive tips, they'd rather get a minimum wage job elsewhere where it's less stress and work.

I realise that it isn't a race to the bottom and that NMW is too low for anybody to really live on; but I think it's sad that you feel the need to justify your own (rightful) deserving of more money by putting down other low-paid people's jobs.

Have you never read any of the many threads on MN where people who work in retail recount horrifying treatment - negging, abuse and aggressive threats among others - that they experience day in, day out?

I'm also curious as to why you choose what you perceive to be an easy job by way of comparison with what you have to do, and not, say, the likes of carers, who have to give intimate care to patients and deal with unpleasant bodily waste - many of whom also suffer from dementia which can make them abusive, violent and often downright dangerous? Is it a regular occurrence in your restaurant that customers scream in your face and try to smear poo over you? Carers not only don't get tips or service charges on top of their low wages, they often don't even get reimbursed for their considerable travel costs to get between jobs in their working day.

viques · 09/03/2023 23:31

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 22:08

Wasn't the whole idea of legally requiring restaurants to offer free tap water to help people better understand what the cost of their meal will be and not be taken by surprise by the (sometimes very high) cost of drinks? Especially as, for people who are not on their uppers but are on a budget (as sneered at above), the benefit and enjoyment of a meal professionally prepared and cooked for you is much more significant than the same bottle or can you could buy at a supermarket just opened and poured into a glass.

Other than wine, many restaurants don't put the prices of drinks on the menu, so that leaves the very obvious temptation for them to exploit this by charging well over the odds. Most people like/need a drink to have with their meal, so making sure that there is a simple free option puts the ball back in the court of the restaurant to price their meals transparently and realistically.

I get that there's the (tiny) cost of the water, the freezer for the ice, a bit of lemon and somebody to fill, bring and wash the jug and glasses, but it only has to be available to people already buying a meal; they can't just walk in only for as jug of free water and not pay the restaurant anything at all.

I have never seen a restaurant menu that doesn’t state the cost of drinks!

PriamFarrl · 09/03/2023 23:31

nanny2012nanny · 09/03/2023 22:38

If you worked in hospitality you wouldn’t be annoyed
look up tronc

No.

BitOutOfPractice · 09/03/2023 23:30

@DevantMaJardin your medal is in the post. Along with your “never did me any harm” certificate. I hope you enjoy getting to the bottom first.

Arapawa · 09/03/2023 23:28

OnaBegonia · 09/03/2023 23:24

I always tip, but recently on a visit to Cafe Andaluz; which is casual tapas I noticed they now add 10% service, I did ask for it to be removed as service was very slow and I'm not being forced to tip.

why would you "always tip" ? With crap service, crap food, dirty place - you always tip??

DevantMaJardin · 09/03/2023 23:25

meemawsmoonpie · 07/03/2023 23:41

I'm a server. I get paid minimum wage.
I earn every damn tip I make. I run back and forth to tables with drinks, starters, more drinks, mains, desserts and many many free glasses of water. Im scrupulously thorough with orders for people with allergies. I sweep up after peoples children, I make a fuss of people on their birthdays, I make a fuss of their children when they're making it hard for parents to enjoy their food, I make the effort to chat to my customers and have a bit of banter with them, I listen to their problems sometimes. I get verbally abused and sometimes LIED about to my manager because people want something for nothing. I run around like a blue arsed fly after huge parties of people who all want to order and pay separately to avoid service charges. It takes me twenty minutes or more to finalise a bill for these kind of tables. If you don't agree with tipping that's your prerogative but I have regular customers who throw money at me because I take pride in my job and I care about their experience.

This reads like entitled bollocks. I did all that and more when I worked in McDonalds where we were famously not allowed tips. I did that and more when I worked in food at Alton Towers where we were not allowed tips. And I did that working silver service where I did get a tip (and the managers counted themselves in when they divvied up the tips). Never, ever did I feel like I was entitled to those tips, that's such a childish world view, they're a bonus not a right.
If you are in the UK you are paid at least a minimum wage which covers everything you do in your job, just like everyone in a non-tipping job. If you don't like the list of duties that you are paid minimum wage for, there are plenty of non-tipping jobs out there where that minimum wage will be the entirety of your earnings.

OnaBegonia · 09/03/2023 23:24

I always tip, but recently on a visit to Cafe Andaluz; which is casual tapas I noticed they now add 10% service, I did ask for it to be removed as service was very slow and I'm not being forced to tip.

BitOutOfPractice · 09/03/2023 23:21

@Precipice none of those businesses you quote have an even vaguely similar business models. Because very few businesses treat their staff as badly as hospitality businesses do while simultaneously expecting stellar levels of customer service.

have you tried it yourself? Because it’s a spectacularly hard way to earn a pittance while being treated like serfs by entitled customers like you

inky1991 · 09/03/2023 23:21

meemawsmoonpie · 07/03/2023 23:41

I'm a server. I get paid minimum wage.
I earn every damn tip I make. I run back and forth to tables with drinks, starters, more drinks, mains, desserts and many many free glasses of water. Im scrupulously thorough with orders for people with allergies. I sweep up after peoples children, I make a fuss of people on their birthdays, I make a fuss of their children when they're making it hard for parents to enjoy their food, I make the effort to chat to my customers and have a bit of banter with them, I listen to their problems sometimes. I get verbally abused and sometimes LIED about to my manager because people want something for nothing. I run around like a blue arsed fly after huge parties of people who all want to order and pay separately to avoid service charges. It takes me twenty minutes or more to finalise a bill for these kind of tables. If you don't agree with tipping that's your prerogative but I have regular customers who throw money at me because I take pride in my job and I care about their experience.

This. Exactly this. Most of these comments are clearly from people who haven't ever worked in hospitality. The whole mentality of "well I don't get tipped in my job" makes me squirm

Getting paid minimum wage to sit behind a counter at Boots, scanning items is a completely different job to the one you mentioned above. Most people wouldn't work front of house if they didn't receive tips, they'd rather get a minimum wage job elsewhere where it's less stress and work.

Like someone said above, no-one is getting rich on your 10%. If you can't afford to add a couple of extra quid on to a bill (when service is good) when you eat out, then you can't afford to eat out!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:20

Can the restaurants who are the beneficiaries of this not afford their rent and their ingredients and their gas and heating, or do you think they all pay 10% over what they are charged happily?

It's a very valid question!

She earns decent tips, most in one night 485 dollars she brings home more than me

This is what I simply don't understand, whenever the question of tips and added service charges comes up:

  1. Serving staff depend on their tips because they're so low paid and would really struggle to make ends meet without them, so you're a shameful, nasty big tight-fisted meanie if you don't tip.
  2. Serving staff don't want to give up the system of tipping and other additional charges sprung on the customer in favour of an agreed fair set wage, as they can make a fortune from all the extras, far in excess of their actual wages.

Which is true? It cannot be both.

cherish123 · 09/03/2023 23:18

A lot of London-based restaurants add a 10-12% service charge which is optional. I think they often rely on people being too embarrassed to ask for it to be taken off. It is quite cheeky.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:14

I think if you can’t afford the tip yiu can’t afford to eat out. That’s the cold hard economics of it from the waiting staff’s perspective

I realise that this is how the system is set up. I just think it's a very dishonest system and wish that the hospitality industry would be run on more reputable principles.

And I don't blame the individual staff at all for finding themselves in the position of having to rely on optional goodwill for part of their earnings rather than an actual salary - I realise that any change would have to come from the top.

The cold hard economics of it from many customers' perspective is that it is deceitful and manipulative for a business to state a price and then expect people to pay 10, 15, 20% more unless there was something wrong.

Do you personally think that everybody in all jobs earning below a certain level should expect to ask for (or just add on) tips and extra charges? Maybe the government could considerably reduce the NMW, if low-paid people across the board genuinely prefer to receive a lower guaranteed basic wage and then hope that they can get more by asking their customers, clients or employers for extra to bump it back up?

Kay286 · 09/03/2023 23:09

FlyingCapybara40 · 09/03/2023 22:11

It's sad that restaurants don't pay a decent wage to their staff. They should then the servers wouldn't have to rely on whether someone pays a tip or service charge

She earns decent tips, most in one night 485 dollars she brings home more than me 🤣

Precipice · 09/03/2023 23:08

BitOutOfPractice · 09/03/2023 23:01

I think if you can’t afford the tip @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll, yiu can’t afford to eat out. That’s the cold hard economics of it from the waiting staff’s perspective 🤷‍♀️

This strange line is constantly trotted out, despite the fact that it's an insane take. Can you 'not afford' the dentist because you don't add 10% to her listed charges? Can you 'not afford' your shopping if you object to being charged a different price than that listed on the shelf/affixed to the item? Can the restaurants who are the beneficiaries of this not afford their rent and their ingredients and their gas and heating, or do you think they all pay 10% over what they are charged happily?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:04

I can’t think of any other business where one price is advertised and then a higher one charged, unless the customer actively disputes this and asks to pay what was originally stated. I think it is a very poor practice, and would like to see it abolished.

Yes, very well summarised. Not quite as straightforward as 'well, simply don't pay it, it's not compulsory', as some people like to make out, is it?

BitOutOfPractice · 09/03/2023 23:01

I think if you can’t afford the tip @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll, yiu can’t afford to eat out. That’s the cold hard economics of it from the waiting staff’s perspective 🤷‍♀️

Arapawa · 09/03/2023 23:01

Service charge in the UK is always optional.

I hate it. Find it patronising and just wish the restaurant would charge honestly.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:00

Don’t pay it then it’s not compulsory

We realise that, but it's also clear as day that it rounds off what should have been a pleasurable evening out with family/friends with awkwardness and social embarrassment if you ask for it to be removed - that's exactly what it's designed to do, so that many people will just pay it, even if they object.

LumpyandBumps · 09/03/2023 22:59

I fully accept that it may not be logical but I have always tipped waiting staff, hairdressers, taxi drivers and large item delivery drivers.

Whilst I am happy to tip a waiter who has enhanced my dining experience I don’t want the restaurant to add a 10 or 15% surcharge to be split between other staff. The chef may be great, the kitchen porter and cleaners may be the best, but they don’t directly affect me, or not as directly as the waiter.

I also don’t normally tip a set percentage as it’s no harder to bring a glass of wine to the table than a coke, or a plate with steak than a plate with pizza.

If the restaurant management wants additional money to go to all staff then it should be included in the basic meal cost, and customers can choose to dine there or not. I don’t want to sit there with a mental calculator working out what 110 or 115% of each item will cost, and nor do I want to look like a cheap skate when asking for the charge to be removed.

I can cook at home, I occasionally go to a restaurant for an enjoyable experience, and I don’t want that marred by feeling awkward about challenging a surcharge which should be, but almost never is, shown as prominently as the price of the dishes.

I can’t think of any other business where one price is advertised and then a higher one charged, unless the customer actively disputes this and asks to pay what was originally stated. I think it is a very poor practice, and would like to see it abolished.

BitOutOfPractice · 09/03/2023 22:59

Yes yes @donttellmehesalive they should be happy and grateful to be working hard for the bare minimum and be damn cheerful about it eh? 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread