Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think restaurants shouldn't be allowed to add service charges?

188 replies

Precipice · 07/03/2023 22:12

Prices are listed on the menu. Maybe the menu has a tiny tiny print somewhere about service charges being added (or maybe it even doesn't!). When it comes to the bill, there it is.

You're already paying for the service in the cost, just as you're paying for someone to prepare whatever you're ordering if it's being prepared, and for the fact that you're there in a restaurant at all.

AIBU to think that if restaurants want to charge you 10 percent more for everything, they should raise their actual prices by 10 percent openly?

OP posts:
bellotorino · 10/03/2023 15:20

Maybe restaurants should just add 20% to everything on the menu then to cover the staff costs.

The only problem with that is that if the service is terrible you can't take it off.

Personally I just mentally add 20% to the prices when I look at the menu. It's not hard really. It's not a surprise is it.

tootiredtobother · 10/03/2023 15:16

my new hairdressers has done this, get handed the card reader with screen showing 5, 10, 20 £ tip ! or you have to say No no tip there is no button for just paying the actual price, I often go home wet as im a fussy blowdryer, so until ive done that i dont know if its a good haircut

Precipice · 10/03/2023 14:24

@BitOutOfPractice But it's not at all an age-old practice. Restaurants adding service charges to your bill is pretty new. From my experiences, I'd say something that sprung up in the last decade and really kicked off in the last 3-5 years. During this time I've seen restaurants that did not previously do this switch to doing so and now it's a thing that's not uncommon.

The idea of tipping is old. Service charges are new. They're related practices, but not the same thing, since a tip is voluntary and a decision of the customer.

OP posts:
PriamFarrl · 10/03/2023 13:02

I used to work in an opticians.

I would spend ages with one customer giving them personal service and advice, answering questions, putting through the order, sending it off to be made in the on site lab. Then helping to collect them, fitting them etc.
I would get sworn at, abused, shouted at.

All for NMW.

If someone would like to explain how that is significantly different to waiting tables then I’d love to hear it.

PriamFarrl · 10/03/2023 12:51

BitOutOfPractice · 10/03/2023 07:39

@Precipice i have never said it’s a fair system. Or a good system. For the staff or the customer. But it’s the system that’s there, that’s been there since god was a lad and you deciding you don’t like it and refusing to tip only punishes one person, the waiting staff. Not the boss, not the company, not the system, just the waiting staff.

@justgettingthroughtheday i don’t work in hospitality. But I have. And so have my kids. I hate this race to the bottom mentality. The ‘I work hard for not much so nobody else should want to get paid more’ attitude. It’s not a competition.

Its not tipping that’s the issue, it’s the charge that is added without consultation.

MotherofBingo · 10/03/2023 09:35

I'm a waitress, and as much as I agree that service charge shouldn't be mandatory - I can't survive on my wage alone. There are less customers/or customers spending less now which means my hours have been cut and I'm on NMW which isn't enough to live on. I really do rely on my tips to get by. It shouldn't be that way, and it's not the customers fault and obviously there are other jobs which also pay NMW and those workers can't get tips. But that's why I left one of those other jobs because I couldn't manage on that pay. We are so understaffed and we do work hard - that's not saying other people don't - but the quality of service will suffer because there just aren't enough of us to provide the level of service the customer deserves.

We do also receive a lot of abuse, sneering and general disrespect by many customers. I think every one of my colleagues have had times where we've cried in the kitchen due to the nastiness of some people. Again, I recognise that other jobs also deal with nasty customers and don't get tips but that doesn't make it OK for us either. The problem is it's a cycle - people don't want bad service (understandably), but when the staff are overworked and underpaid (like many other jobs), the service declines and customers give more abuse/don't tip so servers leave or become demotivated and the service gets even worse.

Maverickess · 10/03/2023 09:03

donttellmehesalive · 10/03/2023 03:09

However, I fear it is here to stay as more and more restaurants will adopt it to attract staff. Places not doing so will increasingly find it difficult to recruit. We seem to be following the US with this despite the fact that they have no NMW, maternity pay, ssp, protected annual holiday entitlement etc which I think helps to justify it over there.

I don't think it's this practice specifically that would need to be adopted to try and ease the issues around staffing in hospitality, just generally better pay and conditions - employers who adopt this are going about that the easiest and cheapest way for them and maybe some feel it's better to have an optional charge than one that is static, the alternative is increasing prices by that amount anyway - which will still be resented.
Increasing pay and conditions won't go down well when prices increase and companies start defending their staff and people are refused service completely if they are awful to the staff because the company need to hold on to them and don't want them driven away by people who treat them badly.

People are already having a hard time understanding that prices have increased for hospitality services from their suppliers like gas & electricity, buying food in and other consumables and therefore the prices have gone up for the same service, or that service levels have dropped to accommodate increased prices and places are closing on some days or there's less staff or choice available to try and cut costs.

Unfortunately, although it would seem that it's a job that is really important to do well, judging by the way people react when it's not, there's a culture that it's a shitty job that isn't deserving of decent pay or respect and then there's surprise when no one wants to do it and there's a shortage 🤷🏼‍♀️

LolaSmiles · 10/03/2023 08:54

Happy for them to be paid more. Add it to the prices on the menu like every other industry manages to do so I can make an informed decision about whether I can afford to eat there.
Agree with this.

Objecting to a service charge being added on, that you have to request to be removed, isn't a rush to the bottom. It's pointing out that businesses should be transparent about their pricing and not rely on customer's not noticing or feeling awkward to get more money out of them.

donttellmehesalive · 10/03/2023 08:47

BitOutOfPractice · 10/03/2023 07:39

@Precipice i have never said it’s a fair system. Or a good system. For the staff or the customer. But it’s the system that’s there, that’s been there since god was a lad and you deciding you don’t like it and refusing to tip only punishes one person, the waiting staff. Not the boss, not the company, not the system, just the waiting staff.

@justgettingthroughtheday i don’t work in hospitality. But I have. And so have my kids. I hate this race to the bottom mentality. The ‘I work hard for not much so nobody else should want to get paid more’ attitude. It’s not a competition.

Happy for them to be paid more. Add it to the prices on the menu like every other industry manages to do so I can make an informed decision about whether I can afford to eat there.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 10/03/2023 08:23

I refuse to pay a service charge added automatically to a bill but am happy to pay a tip, amount of my choosing in cash separately if the meal and service are good.
I remember at a restaurant in America once, there was a service charge added to the bill automatically and the server asked what amount of tip I would like to leave on top! They were annoyed when I said I wouldn't be paying both.

HubertTheGoat · 10/03/2023 08:04

For all those saying, 'try working in hospitality' isn't the problem that many people have worked in hospitality at some point in their life? I, along with many of my friends, waitresses at school and university. I've also worked in retail and don't agree hospitality is intrinsically harder, not to the point you can earn such a significant extra amount hourly from tips. I think tipping 10% is fine for excellent service but more than that isn't necessary.

BitOutOfPractice · 10/03/2023 07:39

@Precipice i have never said it’s a fair system. Or a good system. For the staff or the customer. But it’s the system that’s there, that’s been there since god was a lad and you deciding you don’t like it and refusing to tip only punishes one person, the waiting staff. Not the boss, not the company, not the system, just the waiting staff.

@justgettingthroughtheday i don’t work in hospitality. But I have. And so have my kids. I hate this race to the bottom mentality. The ‘I work hard for not much so nobody else should want to get paid more’ attitude. It’s not a competition.

1099 · 10/03/2023 07:24

I used to work in hospitality long before service charge was added to bills.
These days when I eat out I always ask the staff at some point during the meal whether they get the service charge or the business keeps it. If it's the business I have it removed and tip in cash if the staff get it then it depends on the service, I don't tip because it's expected, I tip relative to the service I receive.

LlynTegid · 10/03/2023 07:08

There needs to be a modern consumer act to end many of the rip-off and hidden charges there are. This is one but by no means the worst.

donttellmehesalive · 10/03/2023 03:09

However, I fear it is here to stay as more and more restaurants will adopt it to attract staff. Places not doing so will increasingly find it difficult to recruit. We seem to be following the US with this despite the fact that they have no NMW, maternity pay, ssp, protected annual holiday entitlement etc which I think helps to justify it over there.

donttellmehesalive · 10/03/2023 03:05

'If you can't afford to tip, you can't afford to eat out.'

I wonder whether restaurants would rather we ate out and paid for our meal but didn't pay the service charge, or decided not to eat out at all.

Just adjust your published prices, pay your staff fairly and stop being the only industry who feel that you do such a uniquely difficult and special job that you deserve an entirely different pricing structure to anyone else.

I hope that hospitality staff who agree with this are happy to pay a surprise extra 10% to their builder, plumber, electrician etc when the bill arrives. An extra 10% when nan's care home bill comes in. An extra 10% for their flights when they arrive at the airport. Every other industry manages to price service into the published price.

Mumskisail · 10/03/2023 02:42

Shouldn't be added, it should be discretionary but it's common practice in London. I have discreetly asked that it be removed if service was poor.

maddy68 · 10/03/2023 01:01

I always without fail knock it off and then tip as I see fit. Often it's more but sometimes much less it's optional

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 10/03/2023 00:58

Agree with you OP. Super annoying, just build it into the price or tell me upfront. I think it's a bit dishonest

Maverickess · 10/03/2023 00:41

I'm in hospitality and I believe that tips should not be expected, but are a nice bonus when you receive them and I don't like the practice of adding a service charge automatically, I would be put off working somewhere that did that, where I work now doesn't and won't because they believe the same.

I give good service, to the best of my ability and the circumstances at the time, to every guest, not the one spending the most or who I think might tip - I'm there to serve everyone, regardless and if they decide to tip then I'm grateful but if they don't then there's no issues.

There's also something a bit grubby about this attitude of getting nmw means no one will give good service and service is better when the staff have to rely on tips "They don't pander enough if you pay them a decent wage you know!" It's insulting and derogatory, like someone who works in a restaurant couldn't possibly have pride in their job.
Although some countries do have the staff relying on tips to make up their wages, it's interesting that waiting on or bar work is more highly regarded in general and respected rather than looked down on and seen as carrying a plate or tray of drinks to a table.

To do the job well is far more than that, ever been somewhere that's a bit busy but not majorly so and everything is going tits up? People waiting ages for stuff? Food wrong/cold? That's because it's not being run properly and I can promise you, it's harder than it looks and far more than carrying a plate to a table, and it requires input deeper than carrying stuff to tables from all staff for it to work well and smoothly, and even more to pull it back when something starts to go wrong.
We are so demeaning towards service staff in this country, but by God the whining and carrying on when it doesn't go right would indicate that actually, it's important to get it right.

I agree that many other jobs that pay poorly don't get tipped, I've worked in care where you're not allowed to receive tips or gifts (except small tokens sometimes) and the work can be far harder. And they work 24/7 and 365, so with care excepted I would say a difference between other low paid jobs and hospitality is that hospitality works harder at the times when others are traditionally relaxing or there's a limited service available from many places - evenings and weekends, bank holidays, Sundays, Christmas, Easter etc. So that's a difference between some of the jobs listed that don't get tips and hospitality.

And you're playing with fire as an employer if you aren't declaring tips and the staff aren't paying tax on them - businesses can and do get caught and into trouble for it.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 10/03/2023 00:19

YANBU I always ask them to take it off.

Precipice · 10/03/2023 00:17

Or not even 'should have to pay'. That they should only be billed for what charges were listed, not inflated charges.

I don't see a difference between the restaurant charging me

BILL
dish: 15.00
service fee: 1.50

and
BILL
dish: 16.50

in a scenario where the menu said that the dish was 15.00. Neither should be happening.

OP posts:
justgettingthroughtheday · 10/03/2023 00:15

@BitOutOfPractice I challenge you to come and work my job for a week. You will then be very happy to go back to you easy hospitality role and perhaps feel a little less entitled yourself!

Precipice · 10/03/2023 00:08

@BitOutOfPractice "by entitled customers like you"

How charming! Please do explain what about thinking they should only have to pay the charges listed upfront before ordering makes a customer entitled. While you're at it, please also add why a waiter bringing over a more expensive bottle of wine or dish deserves more than a waiter bringing over a cheaper bottle of wine or dish (percentage rate additional charge).

Given that an added service charge of 10 percent in effect raises all prices by 10 percent, explain why the system of an added service charge is superior and justified over a system of raising all prices outright and having the customers pay according to the price list.

OP posts:
viques · 10/03/2023 00:07

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 09/03/2023 23:51

I have never seen a restaurant menu that doesn’t state the cost of drinks!

I've seen quite a few with 'minimalist' menus that don't mention the drinks. At any rate, if they have a standard bar, they likely have far more options than they could include in the menu. But even if they didn't, most people find that they need a drink with their meal - and then, even if they can see the prices, they find that anything they choose is high-priced.

People needing/wanting to direct their budget at the meal itself used to ask for water - which was fine until the expensive ruse of bottled mineral water came in, which a lot would bring by default if you asked for water - hence the law about free tap water. Even now, you still have to remember to specify tap water, to avoid the possibility of being charged for bottled stuff.

As well as this, it's very common practice for waiting staff to bring the menus and then ask "Can I get you drinks whilst you're deciding?" - before anybody has had any time to look at the drinks prices.

Then you either ask for the drinks menu if the prices aren’t shown or say you need another few minutes to decide, or ask them to bring some tap water to start.