Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think restaurants shouldn't be allowed to add service charges?

188 replies

Precipice · 07/03/2023 22:12

Prices are listed on the menu. Maybe the menu has a tiny tiny print somewhere about service charges being added (or maybe it even doesn't!). When it comes to the bill, there it is.

You're already paying for the service in the cost, just as you're paying for someone to prepare whatever you're ordering if it's being prepared, and for the fact that you're there in a restaurant at all.

AIBU to think that if restaurants want to charge you 10 percent more for everything, they should raise their actual prices by 10 percent openly?

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 11/03/2023 03:16

"1x table of 10 will use more time and resources than 5x tables of two"

I'm not sure that's always the case. In actual fact serving 5 tables of 2, seating them, acknowledging them, offering menus, exposing meals if the day, clearing away extra cutlery, drinks and water, serving starters then mains, checking food is ok. Presenting bill. Doing machine transaction. Later cleaning and re-laying 5 separate tables.

5 times. Across 5 different tables. How is that less work than serving 1 table of 10?

Oblomov23 · 11/03/2023 03:09

Hmm. I feel torn on this. Saddens me when people don't tip, not even a couple of pounds for good service. I did waitressing all my life and even though I nearly always gave good service, when I was busy people would wait for their change. The bill was £4.80, Give me a £5 and wait for the 20p change.

But automatic 10%, especially on big parties is sometimes unfair. Big parties can be hard work, but not always, not necessarily any more than any other table.

I later felt this was a bit unfair on me recently. I organised my party in a restaurant, 12. £600 so 10% service was £60 which seemed like quite a lot, and it was automatically included. I would have left a tip but I wanted to choose how much. I organised pre booking of all starters, mains, cocktails and drinks. Service was fine. But having been a waitress and a pub owner, this table was no more work than anyone else. Plus I'd made it so much easier by going to the trouble of pre booking everything. I just felt afterwards that the fact it was so much more than what the service is for us as a family of 4 when we eat there occasionally, £10 or £60, seems a bit harsh.

Maverickess · 11/03/2023 02:58

Precipice · 10/03/2023 23:09

And we don't charge for larger tables, not does the poster I was replying to, I was proposing a solution to the issue that 1x table of 10 will use more time and resources than 5x tables of two, a fairer and more customer friendly solution than adding an automatic and not pointed out service charge to all tables.

Your place doesn't, but my point was that imposing a service charge for larger tables on this basis is already an existing practice, though one in some places now replaced by a blanket service charge for all tables. What I'm saying is that your proposed idea has been implemented in the past in other restaurants and continues to be implemented in other restaurants.

To be honest, if you object to the tone of my reply, I'm inclined to assume that the customers you characterise as 'aggressive' may just be acting normally. Customers ask for the bill just based on menu prices because they have prior experience of receiving bills with added charges. That's not an attack on you or on your restaurant. It's just defensive. I don't do this, but I understand that they want to avoid the song and dance of asking for a bill, seeing that the price is wrong, having to raise this with you at that point and get a corrected bill. If the restaurant industry as a whole stopped service charges, you wouldn't get customers actively assuming your restaurant is going to try to rip them off by adding extra charges. It's also odd that you feel defensive over customers trying to make sure there are no added charges, but don't seem to understand that customers may feel defensive over being overcharged.

You can be inclined to think what you want of course about what I term as 'aggressive' - but what I was referring to was the customers who ask for the bill and add comments like "And I won't be paying a service charge/and you can remove the service charge before it comes because I'm not paying it!" Or similar, like they seem to think they've got me somehow and when I reply that we don't add a service charge, they don't seem happy as you would think, they go on to lecture me about how the hospitality industry need to change this and how wrong it is (there is the occasional 'oh good') - based on precisely nothing because we don't add a service charge, and I'm not in charge of the hospitality industry, so basically because I'm serving them that night, I am somehow responsible for the way other establishments are run and the fact that other places charge a service charge.

There's no need when you can just ask at any point if a service charge will be added, and ask for it not to. I'm not responsible for the way other businesses are run, what they've charged you and how they treated you, only what happens (to a certain degree) where I work, so no, I don't understand the defensiveness from people who behave like that.
In the same way that I don't approach and treat every customer thinking they're going to make a malicious complaint to get free stuff, or start grabbing at my junior staff, or abuse any one of the team because we've had it happen many times before, until they prove otherwise.

At least find out first if you're going to actually get charged the service charge before you start getting all defensive and snippy with someone who's not going to in the first place. I don't say anything and nod along and smile, but I am allowed to be pissed off about being told off on behalf of the hospitality businesses that do add a service charge. Like I said, I wish it wasn't allowed to happen because it would save scenes like that.

Your tone came across the same way as above, ready to jump down my throat over the slightest little thing - even when I'm in agreement with you over the service charges, and about the adding on for larger tables, as you are so at pains to tell me, some places do add it on for larger tables - because as pp pointed out, they use more resources - is it not preferable to all prices increasing to cover these incidental costs that a) the service charge is added to tables above a certain amount of covers and not all tables by default as this appears to be a big issue with it, and b) the customer is informed of the service charge ahead of time when they book/arrive so they are aware - so they can make an informed choice, which many have said here is the thing they object to.
Many have said that they would prefer to be aware of the total price at ordering, what I said (and yes, I know that some places do this before you tell me again) achieves that because under 10 people you pay the price on the menu and leave a tip if you want and over 10 people you pay the price on the menu plus 10%(or whatever) because the larger tables take more resources.

I'm literally saying what others are saying they would prefer - yet for some reason you're feeling the need to be patronising about it and that's a common thing towards hospitality staff - as much as people try to deny they do it.

Florenz · 11/03/2023 01:37

Service charges that are not explicitly stated on the menu should be illegal and the customer should be legally entitled to not pay anything should an unannounced service charge be levied on them when it comes to paying the bill.

I'm undecided on tipping culture. While in the US I got to know some women who came to New York to work because they could easily earn $2000 a week in tips. If you did away with tipping and paid the NMW or even a bit more, they'd earning less than a third of that.

WandaWonder · 11/03/2023 01:08

Wouldn't it be simpler to just increase their menu price by 10% overall or whatever percent

anunlikelyseahorse · 11/03/2023 00:59

I have no issue with eateries charging a service charge, providing it's stated clearly on the menus that a service charge or gratuity of xx% will be added to your bill. This enables me to do a quick math calculation and weather or not I want to dine at the establishment. I would be extremely pissed off that it was added unexpectedly and I would automatically request its removal.

I'm really surprised by the attitude to tips on here though, as mumsnet always seems predominantly left of centre, and yet tipping absolutely smacks of "the rich man in his castle, the poor man at his gate, he made them high and lowly, and ordered their estate". I hated being tipped, I'm not a serf, and I took pride in my job., oh and just because you're leaving me a tip doesn't give you a free pass to grope me (older men seemed to think a 'pat' on my backside was perfectly acceptable, because I'd get a tip). Yes waiting at table is physically hard, yes obnoxious twats abound, but that's true in all customer facing professions, as it is with teaching or clinical work, yes the pay is shit, but so it is if you're a health care assistant, or teaching assistant, or nursery worker, shop assistant or shelf stacker etc.
for the most part I enjoyed my work, but I loathed the tipping culture, and feeling I owed a debt if I was given a particularly generous tip.

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 23:24

It's highly unlikely that restaurants would stop charging service charges without some kind of government legislation, and that's not likely to happen any time soon.....VAT is applicable so why would they!

Precipice · 10/03/2023 23:09

And we don't charge for larger tables, not does the poster I was replying to, I was proposing a solution to the issue that 1x table of 10 will use more time and resources than 5x tables of two, a fairer and more customer friendly solution than adding an automatic and not pointed out service charge to all tables.

Your place doesn't, but my point was that imposing a service charge for larger tables on this basis is already an existing practice, though one in some places now replaced by a blanket service charge for all tables. What I'm saying is that your proposed idea has been implemented in the past in other restaurants and continues to be implemented in other restaurants.

To be honest, if you object to the tone of my reply, I'm inclined to assume that the customers you characterise as 'aggressive' may just be acting normally. Customers ask for the bill just based on menu prices because they have prior experience of receiving bills with added charges. That's not an attack on you or on your restaurant. It's just defensive. I don't do this, but I understand that they want to avoid the song and dance of asking for a bill, seeing that the price is wrong, having to raise this with you at that point and get a corrected bill. If the restaurant industry as a whole stopped service charges, you wouldn't get customers actively assuming your restaurant is going to try to rip them off by adding extra charges. It's also odd that you feel defensive over customers trying to make sure there are no added charges, but don't seem to understand that customers may feel defensive over being overcharged.

OP posts:
Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 22:48

Like I say there is no obligation to pay a service charge. The main reason we don't add it is because on the whole most of our customers leave in excess of 15% as a tip for our staff.
Outside of London (not sure about other cities) I don't think it's regularly added - certainly not in the local independents that we go to

PriamFarrl · 10/03/2023 22:37

Adding a service charge for larger tables has been the case for a long time now. It’s only started creeping in for all tables in the last 10 years or so. And it’s not a ‘London thing’ I had it a while ago in a Suffolk village pub.

PriamFarrl · 10/03/2023 22:31

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 21:38

OP Do you think Thames Water don't charge me for tap water? Or the veg supplier for the lemon? Or the electric company for the electric to power the ice machine...
I don't know much about Eastern Europe but certainly Italy, Spain, France, Austria have cover charges

Yes, and I bet they charge you for the water you use to wash up and the water customers use to flush the toilet. But, like the cost of turning the lights and heating on, you factor that into the running costs.

Maverickess · 10/03/2023 22:17

Precipice · 10/03/2023 21:57

Service charges for larger tables exist! I've mostly seen it from 6+. In some places it's gone because it's been extended to all the tables, even for 1.

Some aggressively so because they demand it be taken off before they've even seen the bill. To be honest, I think this is the best solution from the customer's side (though not the best solution overall) and will become more common with service charges becoming more common. It shouldn't be in an aggressive manner, but it seems to make sense to go 'hi, can we get the bill please, and please don't add an automatic service charge' than to get the bill with the service charge and have to get the waiter back to bring another, correct bill instead. It's a case of trying to get the correct bill the first time, without imposed extra charges.

If it's important to you to that level, why wouldn't you ask about it at time of booking/arriving/getting menu's or ordering? Instead of waiting until you're ready for the bill and then stating you want something taken off that isn't even being put on?
Because more than once I've had "Well, most places add it and I don't agree with it, it shouldn't be happening" leaving me standing there like a twat feeling told off for something that's not even happening in that moment, when I reply that we don't add a service charge.
I would have very little control over the place I work adding one should they choose, but I have even less over what other establishments do!

And we don't charge for larger tables, not does the poster I was replying to, I was proposing a solution to the issue that 1x table of 10 will use more time and resources than 5x tables of two, a fairer and more customer friendly solution than adding an automatic and not pointed out service charge to all tables.

And the tone of your reply is exactly what I meant when I said upthread that sometimes, I feel like we're treated like the enemy, rather than someone who does the job because we enjoy it and we like facilitating people enjoying themselves.

Precipice · 10/03/2023 21:57

Service charges for larger tables exist! I've mostly seen it from 6+. In some places it's gone because it's been extended to all the tables, even for 1.

Some aggressively so because they demand it be taken off before they've even seen the bill. To be honest, I think this is the best solution from the customer's side (though not the best solution overall) and will become more common with service charges becoming more common. It shouldn't be in an aggressive manner, but it seems to make sense to go 'hi, can we get the bill please, and please don't add an automatic service charge' than to get the bill with the service charge and have to get the waiter back to bring another, correct bill instead. It's a case of trying to get the correct bill the first time, without imposed extra charges.

OP posts:
Maverickess · 10/03/2023 21:51

@SFHJ

Similar story here with prices rising and the effect it's having, those of us in management are working harder than ever trying to cover all angles and save some money to keep cash flowing while customers demand higher service in return for higher prices - completely disregarding the fact that everything has risen in price and we're charging more because the raw costs have increased.
I think hospitality is in for a tough few years to be honest, especially off the back of COVID and mandatory closures. People have less money to spend, so they're going to be more choosy about where they spend it.
And bigger tables are more demanding, they use more resources, totally agree, possibly an answer is to introduce a service charge for tables of 10 or above, explaining that they use more resources than smaller tables, at time of booking/arriving?

My employers have said they don't want to add an automatic service charge to bills, but, we too have noticed that a lot of people assume that it has been added too. Some aggressively so because they demand it be taken off before they've even seen the bill. And some seem disappointed that it's robbed them of the chance to feel aggrieved and give you a lecture about how wrong it is even when you don't do it.

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

The customer who genuinely thanks me, leaves a good review and treats me like a person will be the ones I welcome back and find a table for at short notice when we're full, or who I go and talk with the chef about accomodating something we don't normally do, who I'll dig out some of our decorations for when it's a special occasion and ask kitchen to do something special with their desert - they're the ones I'll go over and above for, regardless of whether they tip or not.
The ones who try and humiliate me, tell their kids they'll end up like me if they don't try hard at school, accuse me personally of ruining their night/week/life because they don't like the table they were allocated and no others are available or because we ran out of something on a busy day, but leave a large tip are the ones who I won't go over and above for.

Or the ones who look at the bill and ask me if I've heard of the cost of living crisis and how can I justify such prices, nah, hospitality is well known for being paid such massive salaries that I haven't noticed prices rising left right and centre you utter knob.🙄.

I like my job for the most part but service charges are causing an issue between staff and customers that doesn't need to be there.

Precipice · 10/03/2023 21:47

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 21:38

OP Do you think Thames Water don't charge me for tap water? Or the veg supplier for the lemon? Or the electric company for the electric to power the ice machine...
I don't know much about Eastern Europe but certainly Italy, Spain, France, Austria have cover charges

Of course they charge you for water, but Parliament has legislated to impose a duty for certain premises/businesses to provide tap water. Not liking a law doesn't give an entitlement to ignore the law.

There's no duty to provide ice or lemons. That's a decision made by the business. I've sometimes received them when I asked for 'just plain tap water, without anything in it'.

The point is that some countries in Europe doing something doesn't mean Europe as a whole does something. They speak Romanian in Romania but it would be ridiculous to claim universally that 'they speak Romanian on the continent'. Or, to take another example of customers losing money for no reasonable justification, the fact that in Poland when you pay in cash and they don't have exact change to give you, they'll ask to 'owe you' that (or tell you outright!) (you will not see that penny again, unless maybe it's a small shop and you are a regular and at one point it's in your favour and balances out). It would be silly to claim on this basis that 'on the continent, they don't always give you your change'.

OP posts:
Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 21:38

OP Do you think Thames Water don't charge me for tap water? Or the veg supplier for the lemon? Or the electric company for the electric to power the ice machine...
I don't know much about Eastern Europe but certainly Italy, Spain, France, Austria have cover charges

GoAgainstNicki · 10/03/2023 21:38

meemawsmoonpie · 07/03/2023 23:41

I'm a server. I get paid minimum wage.
I earn every damn tip I make. I run back and forth to tables with drinks, starters, more drinks, mains, desserts and many many free glasses of water. Im scrupulously thorough with orders for people with allergies. I sweep up after peoples children, I make a fuss of people on their birthdays, I make a fuss of their children when they're making it hard for parents to enjoy their food, I make the effort to chat to my customers and have a bit of banter with them, I listen to their problems sometimes. I get verbally abused and sometimes LIED about to my manager because people want something for nothing. I run around like a blue arsed fly after huge parties of people who all want to order and pay separately to avoid service charges. It takes me twenty minutes or more to finalise a bill for these kind of tables. If you don't agree with tipping that's your prerogative but I have regular customers who throw money at me because I take pride in my job and I care about their experience.

It’s one thing for customers to tip you because they feel obliged or because you gave good service.

It’s a whole thing entirely to just add service change onto a bill and expect people to pay it on top of the prices for their food. Not sure where the confusion is?

Precipice · 10/03/2023 21:34

A service charge is added and is normally to cover incidental non money making things like tap water/lemon

Places that have a license to sell alcohol are required by law to provide free tap water. It's customary for places that don't sell alcohol to provide tap water for free as well. If the service charge is being added to cover something that should be being provided for free by law, that's another problem in and of itself.

As for 'the continent', many countries, many customs. Not a thing in Poland, for example, and I haven't seen it in Lithuania either.

OP posts:
PriamFarrl · 10/03/2023 21:25

Runnerduck34 · 10/03/2023 21:20

I don't like service charges automatically added. We have 4 DC so feel it's unfair if a service charge is added as we are a family of 6.
It costs enough to eat out as it is! We leave a tip but usually less than 10%.
It does feel stingy to ask it to be removed.
Given how few people carry cash nowadays I do think there should be an option for a tip when you pay by card but tips should be discretionary imo.

There very often is an option on the card machine.

Runnerduck34 · 10/03/2023 21:20

I don't like service charges automatically added. We have 4 DC so feel it's unfair if a service charge is added as we are a family of 6.
It costs enough to eat out as it is! We leave a tip but usually less than 10%.
It does feel stingy to ask it to be removed.
Given how few people carry cash nowadays I do think there should be an option for a tip when you pay by card but tips should be discretionary imo.

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 21:07

That said obviously if you don't want to pay a service charge you don't have to - so you're right in that it's also discretionary

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 21:06

No - a tip is not added to a bill.
A service charge is added and is normally to cover incidental non money making things like tap water/lemon or splitting a bill 6 ways which takes up a waiters time plus reams of till paper.
On the continent it's called a 'coperta' or cover charge - it's to cover those things
For the record we don't charge a service charge and tips are discretionary and paid in full to all our staff including the kitchen. We also pay well above NMW to make sure we keep good staff (although sadly the best are often only with us while at Uni)

BluebellBlueballs · 10/03/2023 20:56

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 20:54

@BluebellBlueballs a service charge is completely different to a tip.
And no, it's not factored in to the cost of running a restaurant.
If you've ever looked at a restaurants P&L you will see how tiny the margins are on everything.

How is a service charge different to a tip?

They are both discretionary for good service!

You need to factor your costs into your meal prices, not a discretionary annoying charge!

Thunderpunt · 10/03/2023 20:54

@BluebellBlueballs a service charge is completely different to a tip.
And no, it's not factored in to the cost of running a restaurant.
If you've ever looked at a restaurants P&L you will see how tiny the margins are on everything.

SFHJ · 10/03/2023 20:45

IfIGoThereWillBeTrouble · 07/03/2023 23:24

I’d be interested to hear from waiters/servers in the UK what their contractual hourly rate is and what their average hourly rate is including tips. Just cos I’m nosey really!

I manage a restaurant and I am on £10/hour, other staff are on minimum wage. It will be going up to £11 when the minimum wage goes up to £10.50. We would love nothing more than to be able to pay staff more.

we are getting destroyed by costs, business rates going up £14k in one year, wage increases, gas and electric, quadrupled compared to last year.
the owner doesn’t take a wage out any more.
the brewery have upped prices of everything. Cellar gas has gone through the roof, the VAT bill is killing us.
rent bill gone up, insurances are going up….
Food prices are through the roof. Vegetable oil has gone up £17 a drum since this time last year. We go through 5 a week sometimes more. We are just scraping by week by week at the moment.

Where I work tips go to staff who have worked that day, we pool them. Housekeeper, pot wash, chefs, everyone who has worked that day gets a cut.
it usually adds £1-£2 per hour extra.
big tables are a lot more difficult and demanding than lots of smaller tables hence I know why usually bigger tables get service charge out on.
we don’t put a service charge on. But it is being debated as often now people assume the price has the service charge included and we’ve noticed a drop.
our reviews always mention the quality of service and friendliness of staff.
we are debating how to move forward with this, however I don’t want my staff getting complacent and not giving the service required as service charge included.

Swipe left for the next trending thread