Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect 2 nights to equal 2 days of childcare? (separation)

59 replies

Bobsmyaunty · 07/03/2023 20:44

SO close to agreeing the consent order with my STBXH ... but then I started talking about childcare cover the holidays he was aghast that two nights a week equalled two days and therefore he needed to find two days of childcare over the holidays.

Now he's thrown the whole thing out saying it needs to be revisited and it's impossible, and that he thought I would be organising all childcare 'otherwise what is he paying maintenance for.'

AIBU in expecting 2 nights to equal 2 days and therefore 2 days of childcare???

Background: We have a 65/35 childcare split, he is full time and pays CMS as per Gov calculator. I am part time (3 days a week, split over 4 so I can pick up children etc). I do need the days that he has the children so that I can do some long days at work, and pick up any of the extra work bits that I haven't got done (I'm a contractor so I need to be efficient and I don't get paid for holiday / sick days). He had previously agreed to pay some spousal maintenance (he's a very high earner and I am not) and decided he wanted to do this as a clean break. Bu then just about to sign when holiday childcare popped up. I said that's fine, you organise your days because you can afford the expensive clubs, and I'll organise mine as I'll probably need to find some cheaper work arounds. AND THEN HE BLEW UP.

Literally said that was impossible, not what he expected to do. I've said I'll help him find clubs, and find the ones their friends go to, but for him - for some reason that I can't fathom - it's a complete dealbreaker.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
emptythelitterbox · 09/03/2023 08:57

If he wants private school, he can pay for it that is if he can afford it.

Sometimes it takes a smack to their ego.

He probably has a certain image he likes to portray.
Take advantage of that.

He won't want to be seen as too broke and cheap to pay as it makes him look bad, not for any other reason.

Likewise, he won't tell you he doesn't want the extra days even though he really doesn't want them, as it makes him look bad.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 09/03/2023 03:15

Can you use this as an opportunity to arrange holiday clubs that you would like them to go to but can’t afford, yes it’s a annoying you have extra work to do but can be used to your advantage.

JudgeRudy · 08/03/2023 23:15

YANBU to believe 2 nights it's actually 2 full days....like when you go on holiday for 14 nights, you're there in the day too.
I don't think he's unreasonable to be 'shocked' if it's something he's never taken responsibility for. What was your previous arrangement when you were together? He's been sideblinded. He doesn't sound like a deadbeat dad etc. Tbh if he's paying you spousal support I don't think it's unreasonable for you to go someway towards organising things. As others have said it might be simpler if you have a week each end of term.
I bet he'll be happy to 'pay' for convenience so suggest a week-long club for him with price, Who knows, he might be willing to pay for another week if he knows the kids will benefit.

Goawayangryman · 08/03/2023 23:01

clearly I am not a lawyer! Listen to actual lawyers : www.hcsolicitors.co.uk/news/who-pays-private-school-fees-after-divorce-or-separation

But from an educational point of view, you as a parent have equal rights, with him, to choose where your children attend school.

Goawayangryman · 08/03/2023 22:53

I really don't think you should capitulate on this, and I think you absolutely have the measure of him. He is throwing his weight around. It is very common particularly when you've had the gall to disengage from a man with entrenched ideas about gender roles and responsibilities.

There is absolutely no way on earth I would agree to private secondary school. No way. He will be forever scrutinising your outgoings and I have a feeling this will be lauded over you by him. You can explain why if you want in simple factual non emotional terms, or you could just say "no".

I'd be telling him firmly that you do not agree to private secondary schooling because you cannot afford it and he will not commit to paying for it entirely by himself until they leave school. What happens if he loses or gives up his job? Then the guilt will pile on you to cough up the fees.

If he creates, you will need a specific issue order from the court and I'd imagine they are extremely unlikely to agree with the mad suggestion that he (or whoever) periodically scrutinises your finances to see if you should start contributing. Why would a court make you effectively sign a blank cheque? I am not a lawyer though.

OhamIreally · 08/03/2023 21:45

That really annoyed me so I can imagine how much it infuriates you OP. The fact he says it's impossible!

He is absolutely pushing back on that mental load. Doesn't want it, won't do it. No wonder there's a fucking pay gap.

Bobsmyaunty · 08/03/2023 10:19

Yes BreadwinnieBaker, exactly this. Thank you.

OP posts:
BreadwinneBaker · 08/03/2023 09:40

you might also want to think about feeding and clothing as part of that discussion, OP... not only do men like him not think about the admin "wife work" of life, he'll not think about other stuff/play similar games.

i have a family member whose ex uses it as a form of control and i was surprised, but appparently games are not that uncommon.

thankfully, my family member agreed days and times as part of the custody arrangements... so the ex mucks around withthe kids clothing and food as part of his power playing.

i.e. some days at the agreed drop off (at say 5pm) they'll have been fed a huge roast dinner at 3pm (so, not quite lunch, but not quite dinner) leading to them being hungry just before bed. other times, other weeks, they're dropped off having NOT EATEN in 8 hours since a bowl of sugary cereal at 8am! then some weeks he brings back all the kids clothes all dirty, having done no laundry. expecting the ex wife to do it when they're at hers.. but also when they're at his... other weeks they come back with empty bags and no clothes, so all the clothes she buys keep disappearing.

what i'm trying to tell you here is:

get agreed dates/times for custody written in stone in legal terms.

but don't be surprised if someone as entitled as him, who thinks basic childcare is beneath him and his stressful job.. starts playing other games.

if you give into him and agree arranging childcare on HIS days is your job... you're going to end up with a fuck tonne of extra wife work because his entitlement will be reinforced. for YEARS ahead.

gettingolderbutcooler · 08/03/2023 09:17

Living in a ground floor flat in London.
The person that then bought the upstairs flat was someone I had known years before.

emptythelitterbox · 08/03/2023 09:03

He's the typical male who thinks you're still default skivvy and he's too lazy and important to do it himself.

He doesn't get his way he has a tanty and threatens to withhold something. He thinks hes buying your labor with his money. Not a nice man or father.

beingsunny · 08/03/2023 09:00

CM and spousal maintenance are seperate things.

Spousal is for you, not the children. Anyone suggesting you forgo this in lieu of paying childcare on his days is unreasonable.

Agree you need to clarify handover times, removes the grey areas of sick days or inset days.

He is responsible for covering childcare on his days, whichever they are, and I completely understand what you mean when you said you will arrange it. It's talking to the friends parents to coordinate them attending things together rather than them going to a club alone.

He has reduced CM because he is expected to cover all associated costs of raising the children on the days they are with him.

If his job is stressful, that's on him, the upside of that stressful job is he can throw money at the problem and hire a nanny, or childminder for school runs and put them in good clubs in the holidays.

This is not for you to fix for him.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/03/2023 08:55

Just be careful with it - for a while my friend refused to organised his childcare for him (and rightly so) but then he just started not turning up to collect the children which had an even bigger impact on her work.

Finding the right hill to die on can sometimes be tricky.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 08/03/2023 08:54

Friend of mine has it written into their order that she organises and pays for all childcare, but he gets no overnight reductions on his maintenance. He effectively swapped the discount for leaving her the responsibility.

QueenCremant · 08/03/2023 08:53

Make it clear now that you are not going to take on all the mental load/admin of parenting.
I have an ex like yours that seems to think that because he pays maintenance that he can opt out of doing anything but having them on his set days. I’ve really had to push back to get him to do parents eve, organise outfits for dress up days on his days etc.

If you arrange childcare for him you are effectively still doing all his wife work. And you will resent it in the years to come when he’s able to swan off on holidays etc and you can only have a long weekend away. 5 years on, I’m still trying to make our parenting more equal…

Theelephantinthecastle · 08/03/2023 08:47

I agree - he either needs to accept everything that goes along with having them in the holidays or say he doesn't want them that many days and pay up for you to have them instead

Bobsmyaunty · 08/03/2023 08:44

Sorry I meant by 'not argue' that I don't need him to understand my point of view and all the arguing that would ensue if I attempted that, but I just need him to agree to sort childcare stuff for his days and sign the order and then we can MOVE ON.

Honestly, our divorce is taking AGES. It's been two entire years since we agreed to separate.

OP posts:
Bobsmyaunty · 08/03/2023 08:42

Exactly.

I feel very strongly that he can rage against this if he wishes, but legally (surely?) two nights equals two days and all the care that comes with that.

Also: he's not even mustering the balls to just say to me, 'can I drop the number of days I have the kids.'

OP posts:
Theelephantinthecastle · 08/03/2023 08:39

But if you don't argue with him and just agree to it, this sets the tone for the next ten years you're co-parenting together. You'll basically have set and agreed a price to continue being his wife for life admin purposes.

Bobsmyaunty · 08/03/2023 08:31

Yes this is exactly what I thought ... it's some kind of male privilege at play.

And generally he's a decent person and he looks after the kids well. To me, this feels like bullying: 'do what I want or I will throw out the consent order and leave you worse off.'

But he REALLY doesn't see that. I don't want to argue with him. I just need him to agree the consent order and sort his days.

We've been separated a year, and we've sold the family home and split the asset pot (60/40 - he has a higher paid job and also an inheritance). All that has settled.

The only other item on the agenda (which I haven't mentioned because I felt it was a distraction) was private school. They are both in private junior school and if they continue into secondary really he will have to pay. I am perfectly happy for them to attend the local secondary (it's really nice, lots of their friends go there), so it would be more his driver if they went to private and also he would pay ... although he has asked for a financial review every year to see if I am in a position to contribute. This also felt like control so I said, no, lets do it at trigger points i.e. new job or marriage etc. However, I am reluctant to go down the private route at all because I feel like if I make myself better off by say £5k, he'll scoop that up for private school. I also like our state secondary.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 08/03/2023 07:44

She's a contractor - not an employee.

If you're self-employed, a contractor or a freelancer, you don't get paid if you don't work.

Theelephantinthecastle · 08/03/2023 07:44

It's not even that hard to sort - get dates, pick club, do online booking - I sort our summer holiday childcare in under an hour. It's a point of principle for him that he's too important to do it.

Bumblefuzz · 08/03/2023 07:42

Bobsmyaunty · 07/03/2023 21:04

If I really challenge myself on it, I think I'm also looking for a separation of responsibilities. His first idea was to take the holidays, deduct our leave from it, and then share out the days and I organise childcare.

But I don't get paid for leave so I need to have control over when I take (i.e. save up a surplus). I also don't want him telling me what to do!

Why are you not paid for annual leave?

BreadwinneBaker · 08/03/2023 07:39

I agree btw with a previous poster, it sounds like he's a high earner and feels organising childcare is beyond him. That's what he bought his ex wife to do! Arse.

BreadwinneBaker · 08/03/2023 07:38

Sooo he thinks spousal maintenance is to keep you as his housekeeper and do the family organisation? He's having a laugh. You've seen right through his entitled arse.

One of the best upsides of your splitting up (for you op) is you're no longer responsible for facilitating his life. It's not your job or role at all.

Beyond the children and the legal agreement around custody, it's his problem to sort his life. Perhaps arranging childcare for himself for once rather than taking you for a mug might make him appreciate how you facilitated his life in earlier times.

Btw I would step clear from organising it or doing the mental load here... Just say no. It's not normal or healthy for the dynamic for kids to see one parent still enmeshed in that dynamic.

ArcticSkewer · 08/03/2023 07:38

Does the spousal pay enough to make it worthwhile for you?
I think he sees it as buying a housekeeper.
Can you go for a greater overall share in the split instead?

Swipe left for the next trending thread