Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this your child? Staying home on Friday?

183 replies

NetballMumGrrr · 07/03/2023 19:47

Article about how more children are staying home on a Friday as their parents are at home?

Link to BBC News

I’m assuming it’s vulnerable children. Not sure why people are not valuing education more or AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fridaytwattery · 09/03/2023 18:41

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:40

@carriedout - it would cost the same as today. 5 days teaching. But the Friday, anyone who chooses to not send wouldn’t get told off for it. So you could
opt to send your child 3 Fridays a month for sports and arts, and 1 Friday do your own thing. Would be better as people choosing to go to other places ie museum, swim lido Friday, would make it less crowded on the weekends also.

I think you're thinking all parents are like you. Some parents would keep their kids home as carers, some would just let them roam free, others would just give them unfettered access to devices. We are battling this as it is for some children on a daily basis. Not all parents would do what you are hoping they will do to support their children's academic education.

Also with the PE curriculum we plan, teach and assess. The Govt want us to do this in a particular way, hence the various schemes of work we then subscribe to and pay for. Will parents do that? Or are you asking the Govt to not include PE on the national curriculum anymore?

fridaytwattery · 09/03/2023 18:32

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 07:13

@Sherrystrull - intervention? Not all child gets that though surely? so most miss just reading which they can easily do anywhere else. Most could easily visit grandparents and read to granny 30 mins and not get behind

Reading is not just reading a book (which we encourage children to do at home). The reading lessons we do cover retrieval, inference, prediction for example, and that has to be taught. Many parents at my school would not know how to teach this as a skill, which is developed over the primary years.

TomeTome · 09/03/2023 07:47

PaigeMatthews · 09/03/2023 05:54

Holidays in peak school holiday times are more expensive for everyone, not just parents.
Nobody needs to go on holiday.
setting a week’s worth of work for one member of the class is a big task that does have time allocated for.
Text books cost money schools do not have. And as teachers do not teach from a text book, the work wouldn't be what the other students completed by being in the lesson.
Massive changes were made to the curriculum since 30 years ago. Gove in particular went content crazy. It is significantly bigger than when you were last in a school.

Holidays in peak school holiday times are more expensive for everyone, not just parents. yes they are but parents are usually paying for multiple people to go on holiday not themselves so the difference is more marked.
Nobody needs to go on holiday.
Rather depends on their life situation and how much they prioritise wellbeing or family.
setting a week’s worth of work for one member of the class is a big task that does have time allocated for.
yes but teachers actually plan their lessons and are perfectly capable of describing what the content is and what works was done. They certainly HAVE textbooks or worksheets already or at the bare minimum can point to the skills taught that have been missed.

Massive changes were made to the curriculum since 30 years ago. Gove in particular went content crazy. It is significantly bigger than when you were last in a school. I’m not sure this is accurate but I don’t think it’s a widely held view. Certainly most of the first year in university now is spent doing what would have been considered Alevel maths for many stem subjects. But if more IS being taught at what stage and in which subjects.

Badbudgeter · 09/03/2023 07:44

I never went anywhere as a child (poor and couldn’t of afforded it even if we were skipping school). I travelled loads as an young adult, when you are happy with cheap and cheerful accommodation and it’s easy to pick up odd jobs abroad.

Holidays and travel are a nice to have imo not essential and you can see the world when you’re old enough to appreciate it.

Heartsandbirds · 09/03/2023 07:38

DS has ASD. We occasionally give him ‘mental health days’ to recharge (about one a term) and these would always be on a Friday for the benefit of the long weekend. The school know and are fine about it.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 09/03/2023 07:32

PaigeMatthews · 09/03/2023 05:54

Holidays in peak school holiday times are more expensive for everyone, not just parents.
Nobody needs to go on holiday.
setting a week’s worth of work for one member of the class is a big task that does have time allocated for.
Text books cost money schools do not have. And as teachers do not teach from a text book, the work wouldn't be what the other students completed by being in the lesson.
Massive changes were made to the curriculum since 30 years ago. Gove in particular went content crazy. It is significantly bigger than when you were last in a school.

"nobody needs to go on holiday" tends to boil down to "poor kids can miss out on going on holiday"

Rich kids can pay the fines, middle-ing kids can go in summer. Poor kids get priced out.

Actually I think holidays and travel are important.

IHateLegDay · 09/03/2023 07:16

I had parents evening on Tuesday and the teacher said that they have children who are always off on a Friday as the parents have caravans and like to go away for a long weekend. (During a conversation about attendance)

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 07:14

@carriedout - that’s my point. I wouldn’t mind paying for others to still go to school Fridays for activities even if I didn’t send mine. As it would benefit them. Hence saying it wouldn’t be a waste of tax payers money.

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 07:13

@Sherrystrull - intervention? Not all child gets that though surely? so most miss just reading which they can easily do anywhere else. Most could easily visit grandparents and read to granny 30 mins and not get behind

carriedout · 09/03/2023 07:12

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 07:04

@carriedout - I wouldn’t mind tbh. I would happily have a 4 day week so wouldn’t care if nothing on Fridays. But I understand some need it for various reasons and some children wouldn’t spend Fridays swimming at lake or out on bikes just at home so it’s fine they get it there.
I don’t use the nhs either, but still pay for it for others

You still benefit from the NHS. You live in a country where people are able to access healthcare meaning the workforce is healthier meaning our GDP is higher meaning you have the opportunity to be richer.

Those who pay for private education still benefit from an educated population.

Education of offenders benefits me despite me (hopefully) never having cause to even visit a prison.

Social improvements benefit all in society. Reducing education will not benefit society.

Sherrystrull · 09/03/2023 07:08

FrenchFancie · 09/03/2023 06:55

Children missing random days really does have an effect on education - if child A missed the day you teach something new in maths, comes back one day later when the rest of the class has moved on to the next thing, applying that knowledge learnt yesterday, child A is adrift and not easily able to catch up. Yes the TA might be able to sit with them and go through it, but you might not have a TA, and the maths curriculum is so full there’s very little time to go back over things.

multiply that by two or three kids in a class of 30 who persistently miss odd days here and there and it’s madness, there’s kids missing bits of knowledge all over the place and no way to catch them up….

This is absolutely true. It's manageable when you miss the occasional child to illness but for a two week holiday or every Friday they will really suffer. There's no spare staff to leap into action for children who have missed bits. We're already stretched to the maximum.

Sherrystrull · 09/03/2023 07:06

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:24

Do schools actually do much ‘education’ in the afternoons anyway? Most people’s we know is lunch and then it is art or sports, which presumably you can just do at home.
I would rather they did 4 day week compulsory, then offered Friday ‘sport or activity days’ for anyone who wanted to go in, but it’s optional.

All of our group reading and intervention takes place in the afternoon.

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 07:04

@carriedout - I wouldn’t mind tbh. I would happily have a 4 day week so wouldn’t care if nothing on Fridays. But I understand some need it for various reasons and some children wouldn’t spend Fridays swimming at lake or out on bikes just at home so it’s fine they get it there.
I don’t use the nhs either, but still pay for it for others

carriedout · 09/03/2023 07:01

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:40

@carriedout - it would cost the same as today. 5 days teaching. But the Friday, anyone who chooses to not send wouldn’t get told off for it. So you could
opt to send your child 3 Fridays a month for sports and arts, and 1 Friday do your own thing. Would be better as people choosing to go to other places ie museum, swim lido Friday, would make it less crowded on the weekends also.

It may cost the same, but it is not an appropriate use of taxpayers' money. It would just be a hugely expensive optional social club, it makes no sense at all.

It would cost the same for lower return for the nation, how can that be justified?

FrenchFancie · 09/03/2023 06:55

Children missing random days really does have an effect on education - if child A missed the day you teach something new in maths, comes back one day later when the rest of the class has moved on to the next thing, applying that knowledge learnt yesterday, child A is adrift and not easily able to catch up. Yes the TA might be able to sit with them and go through it, but you might not have a TA, and the maths curriculum is so full there’s very little time to go back over things.

multiply that by two or three kids in a class of 30 who persistently miss odd days here and there and it’s madness, there’s kids missing bits of knowledge all over the place and no way to catch them up….

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:40

@carriedout - it would cost the same as today. 5 days teaching. But the Friday, anyone who chooses to not send wouldn’t get told off for it. So you could
opt to send your child 3 Fridays a month for sports and arts, and 1 Friday do your own thing. Would be better as people choosing to go to other places ie museum, swim lido Friday, would make it less crowded on the weekends also.

carriedout · 09/03/2023 06:28

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:24

Do schools actually do much ‘education’ in the afternoons anyway? Most people’s we know is lunch and then it is art or sports, which presumably you can just do at home.
I would rather they did 4 day week compulsory, then offered Friday ‘sport or activity days’ for anyone who wanted to go in, but it’s optional.

That would be unfair. You can't provide an optional club for some at taxpayers' expense!

Also not sure which schools just do 'art or sport' in the afternoons, all my kids did a full curriculum.

carriedout · 09/03/2023 06:26

TomeTome · 09/03/2023 00:33

As teacher's we're constantly told that we have loads of holiday (13 weeks) so it's not like there isn't time to cherish with family members and build memories and do the other side of education that isn't academic. you’re forgetting parents don’t get 13 weeks off, and that they can afford holidays at peak season, or that thats when they need to go. Why on Earth don’t you just give the child catch-up work if they miss a week? Surely if this IS an ongoing problem you could have text books available? How much bigger is the curriculum really than 30 years ago because people aren’t hitting university with a better understanding of maths etc, rather the opposite?

I disagree with this idea kids were better qualified. Far more left school functionally illiterate historically and many subjects cover way more now, if you get a top grade now in Maths GCSE you have covered a lot.

Kids are far better taught now, teachers can't just teach to the middle.

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:24

Do schools actually do much ‘education’ in the afternoons anyway? Most people’s we know is lunch and then it is art or sports, which presumably you can just do at home.
I would rather they did 4 day week compulsory, then offered Friday ‘sport or activity days’ for anyone who wanted to go in, but it’s optional.

BobSacamono · 09/03/2023 06:20

This is bonkers. But could also be considered another justification for a four day week.

Caspianberg · 09/03/2023 06:17

I think it’s fine tbh. Dh and I only work Mon-thurs so we have Fridays off. Ds isn’t school age yet but if we wanted to go somewhere it would make sense to go Fri-Sunday.

As it is, we live in and country where school is only 8am-11.45am, so everyone does go away Friday lunchtime straight after. If they can all finish every day by lunchtime their whole school life and still manage to be qualified by the end of school, I’m not sure tbh why the uk school day is so long. Seems like a lot of wasted time happening, and no time to actually enjoy life day to day.

PaigeMatthews · 09/03/2023 05:54

TomeTome · 09/03/2023 00:33

As teacher's we're constantly told that we have loads of holiday (13 weeks) so it's not like there isn't time to cherish with family members and build memories and do the other side of education that isn't academic. you’re forgetting parents don’t get 13 weeks off, and that they can afford holidays at peak season, or that thats when they need to go. Why on Earth don’t you just give the child catch-up work if they miss a week? Surely if this IS an ongoing problem you could have text books available? How much bigger is the curriculum really than 30 years ago because people aren’t hitting university with a better understanding of maths etc, rather the opposite?

Holidays in peak school holiday times are more expensive for everyone, not just parents.
Nobody needs to go on holiday.
setting a week’s worth of work for one member of the class is a big task that does have time allocated for.
Text books cost money schools do not have. And as teachers do not teach from a text book, the work wouldn't be what the other students completed by being in the lesson.
Massive changes were made to the curriculum since 30 years ago. Gove in particular went content crazy. It is significantly bigger than when you were last in a school.

Sleepless1096 · 09/03/2023 04:13

@fridaytwattery . But that's not the case with the strikes. Some children are missing out on education, others are not. In year groups in the same school, some classes will be in learning and some classes at home because their teacher is on strike. And teachers aren't meant to catch the children up on what they miss... as someone said above, the whole purpose of the strikes is to disrupt children's education. So they're meant to fall behind. I get that, it's the only way teachers will get their message across.

But as a parent, I'm not going to let my child's education be disrupted. So I'll do what any responsible parent would do and cover the material missed with my DC myself. That means reading up on what the class should be covering and working out where the gaps in my child's knowledge are. I take primary responsibility for my child's education and knowing what they should be learning (admittedly easier at primary than secondary level).

However, if I can do this for strikes, then I can also do this to cover other days off for my child. I did it when my child was off with chicken pox... when they were feeling better, we covered the material that their class was covering in school in a couple of hours. So the argument that days off are necessarily going to impact children's education depends mostly on how engaged the parents are.

TomeTome · 09/03/2023 00:33

As teacher's we're constantly told that we have loads of holiday (13 weeks) so it's not like there isn't time to cherish with family members and build memories and do the other side of education that isn't academic. you’re forgetting parents don’t get 13 weeks off, and that they can afford holidays at peak season, or that thats when they need to go. Why on Earth don’t you just give the child catch-up work if they miss a week? Surely if this IS an ongoing problem you could have text books available? How much bigger is the curriculum really than 30 years ago because people aren’t hitting university with a better understanding of maths etc, rather the opposite?

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/03/2023 23:30

As for strikes, then no teaching is taking place, your child is not missing out in the same way, with gaps in their education, whilst their peers do not.

They may not be missing any teaching but they are missing routine, structure and predictability that supports building good habits around work and focus. They are missing the reinforcement of the process of daily study. It does impact children, their capacity for learning and motivation to learn when schools are so disrupted.

It’s very hard to persuade a child that they need to go to school daily when they’ve hardly had a full week at school since August, which is the case for mine between holidays, inset days and strike days. strike days seem to be set awkwardly too - mine were back 1 day after the Christmas break and were off for a strike day, the inconsistency is very tricky to manage. And in Scotland the strikes are wholly about salary, I know that’s not the case elsewhere but it is here. So their education is being disrupted because the best paid teachers in the uk want more money.

I can teach my kids fractions, I also pay a private tutor to try and fill the gaps left by Covid, so it’s not like I lack commitment to their education. I’m just not buying the whole “one day missed compromises your child’s life chances” thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread