Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you intelligent? How do you gauge intelligence?

130 replies

Terrifiedofwastingmylife · 07/03/2023 16:12

Sure, there are different kinds of intelligence so there will be many answers to this question. But I am interested in how people define intelligence? Are you comfortable in your intelligence?

I do not feel intelligent, according to any definition of it. My brain seems to have really slowed over the last decade, I find it very difficult to learn new systems (I get almost mentally paralysed from fear and stress) and struggle to retain information. I sometimes worry if I'm in the early stages of vascular dementia, which would obviously be different from not having any raw intelligence to begin with. But perhaps I've always been like this, I've just not realised before, and it's nothing to do with dementia.

Anyway, whatever the cause I mostly feel the opposite of intelligent - I can't even work out in my fuzzy brain what it even means anymore.

OP posts:
Echobelly · 07/03/2023 22:17

I don't think you'll ever meet an intelligent person who is not curious about the world around them. Lack of interest in things beyond their immediate sphere seems to be something that indicates someone not being very intelligent in general.

Also, people who are intelligent know they don't know everything. You see that stupidity with people like Donald Trump. He just assumes the world works how he thinks it works, that he can comment wisely on anything because he's so clever and cleverness is answering everything, even with total bullshit off the top of your head. Actually intelligent people are capable of saying 'That's not my area' or 'I'll have to ask X about that' or 'I'll have to look that up'.

I've got a 1st class degree in an 'intellectual' subject from a top 10 UK uni, and I know quite a lot of random shit about history, music and literature. I can't 'do anything' that smart like speak another language fluently or do complex maths though.

piedbeauty · 07/03/2023 21:55

I'm intelligent. In a few subject areas, I have vg knowledge. I know I know nothing about some areas, though, eg chemistry.

I am good at arguing, at discussing, at seeing all POVs in an argument, and I'm good at looking at new information and revising my own opinion.

leccybill · 07/03/2023 21:54

I'm only of average intelligence really. I struggled with university and find new things hard. I'm a teacher. I kinda get by by being very hardworking but it's draining.
What takes other teachers no time at all takes me ages.

JaninaDuszejko · 07/03/2023 21:48

Firstly, and most importantly, high EQ is not always a good thing, sociopaths have high EQ, as do a lot of senior executives (lots of whom are also sociopaths). If you understand other people's emotions you can manipulate them. High EQ does not mean nice.

Secondly, 'common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen' as Einstein said. One of which is that anyone intelligent 'lacks common sense'.

Anyway, I have all the traditional prestigious academic qualifications. I also have the knowledge and experience to make connections between disparate concepts. I know I'm more intelligent than most people but work and socialise in a bubble where everyone is smart (in my STEM job 90% of us have PhDs) so don't think about it day to day and then every so often will be having a conversation with someone and realise they aren't understanding something I think is straightforward. Conversely of course there are some people you speak to who don't have loads of academic qualifications but are clearly very smart (good trades people often are, although that may be because the type of problem solving intelligence required to be a scientist and to be an plumber or electrician are related so we recognise it in each other).

@ThreeLocusts makes an interesting point about excess weight being given to certain aspects of intelligence but whole I agree I do think that varies a bit from job to job. Nobody would recruit BoJo as a surgeon, aircraft engineer or clinical trials coordinator, his lack of attention to detail is well known but wasn't an issue as PM because he had civil servants for that, he could do the bit he was good at with their support. Obviously there were other failings that lead to his downfall.

topofbighill · 07/03/2023 21:37

I believe intelligence is a mixture of common sense, good general knowledge, being able to make fast judgements and being practical.

Phonemonkey2023 · 07/03/2023 21:37

Oh going back re the slow processing, I’ve definitely got that too, once I grasp something I understand it completely but it takes me a while to get there, I’m always amazed when people speed read things and understand them and I’m still on page 1. I think I’m neurodivergent also.

Persephoned · 07/03/2023 21:36

Snoopystick · 07/03/2023 16:54

Difficult my DS has what I think would be called high social intelligence - he’s got the gift of the gab and talk to anyone about anything. He’s just been to Cambridge Uni on a school trip and it’s made him not want to apply. He tried to speak to various people and none of them could even look him in the eye, bearing in mind they will all have been incredibly academic and intelligent.

I guess this is an example of where it is good not to judge.

TheHateIsNotGood · 07/03/2023 21:33

Intelligence is abundant - the intelligence used in some manual work is quite astounding; the use of brain, hands and natural knowledge far surpasses most conventional assessments of intelligence.

That's why people with degrees in polenta and quinoa living in Islington pay good money to learn things like hedgelaying and making pots and call it an holiday.

Phonemonkey2023 · 07/03/2023 21:32

Haven’t read the whole thread OP but my brain sounds like yours - would have said I was above average intelligence at school but not since, I have an under-active thyroid though which could be partly to blame.

CantStopWontStop0 · 07/03/2023 21:30

Intelligence is a spectrum without one singular definition.

My manager is incredibly articulate, knowledgeable and critical thinker. He can't even do the most basic DIY painting a room.

We're gifted in different ways.

Amy8 · 07/03/2023 21:28

Yes - academically something I've always been told and known due to ridiculous levels of testing in my life

However , emotional intelligence something I think I've only really been able to fine tune at the age I am now, sadly I had to undergo much pain to get to that

BlimeyO · 07/03/2023 21:27

BlimeyO · 07/03/2023 21:26

Was thinking the same thing, when I read the post…

Gah, that was meant to be in response to a previous poster’s reference to the perimenopause.

BlimeyO · 07/03/2023 21:26

Was thinking the same thing, when I read the post…

Moonicorn · 07/03/2023 21:25

I don’t know if I am and I wouldn’t want to guess.

To me intelligence is objectivity. The stupidest people I know are the most confident, it never occurs to them they’re wrong about anything, meaning their thinking skills are massively impaired.

The most intelligent ones know what they don’t know, can remove their emotions/wants from a situation and are good at seeing things from various points of view. They don’t use meaningless circular phrases or try to make out most things are black and white.

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 07/03/2023 21:21

Educational psychologist assessed twice as a kid/teen. IQ measured at 148, so yes on paper and in discussions I’m intelligent. Dropped out of uni, the course wasn’t teaching me what I wanted (should have done business studies) but pretty successful now. Rubbish at making friends though.

WandaWonder · 07/03/2023 21:21

I do pretty good on iq tests I dont think it proves anything other than being good at iq tests though

I guess intelligence is using all parts of your brain effectively

Fairislefandango · 07/03/2023 21:16

So in the education system then, is slow processing a polite word for well, being a bit lacking in intelligence?

Not always. There are students who take longer but gain a good, deep understanding with time. Or students who benefit from different ways of learning. However, as a general rule I'd say fast processing is indicative of higher intelligence. I think a lot of what constitutes what we generally recognise as high intelligence is a combination of fast processing, good memory, plus being very articulate (though the latter not always true, especially of people in non-wordy spheres).

Like I say, grammar is the real litmus test in my subject. Even in the grammar school where I teach, there are students who really, really struggle with it even after years of studying the language. Others just instantly get it. They are all bright, but the ones who just get the grammar tend to be the brightest.

Terrifiedofwastingmylife · 07/03/2023 21:06

I've googled that Visual Basic suggestion, and proving my point I can't understand it...is it a programming/ coding thing?

Sadly, it's not that the spreadsheet task I'm doing is complicated, it's not. I haven't even got to a point where using formulae would be a useful thing to help with what I'm doing... I'm just compiling a list of particular medical specialists and key data points relating to them. I

t's a very simple task, I'm just painfully slow and in high anxiety I'll put the wrong academic bio beside the wrong person, and be muddled when I ring them and they will be furious and I'll fuck things up.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 07/03/2023 20:57

@Terrifiedofwastingmylife

i know this isn’t the point of your thread, but there is a way to automate or semi-automate almost every spreadsheet task and most of them don’t require resorting to Visual Basic. you would be amazed at the functions that people don’t know about. I have seen really smart phds wasting hours and hours doing things manually that I come though and show them how to automate in seconds. It’s just a matter of experience. I even have had people show me new tricks that I don’t know about which is hard because I’m 30 years in at this point.

if you want to share what you are trying to do, we may be able to help.

Ydgkordh · 07/03/2023 20:43

You write well OP and come across as intelligent in your posts

Snoopystick · 07/03/2023 20:42

ThreeLocusts · 07/03/2023 20:35

Nah they aren't. Former CB lecturer speaking. The Oxbridge admissions system puts in a floor; you don't get the dimmest students. You maybe get 20 per cent really smart ones rather than 5 per cent at other unis, but the bulk are what I'd call good average, and often get in b/o expensive education.

I became more aware than ever in CB that 'intelligence' is a composite and that certain elements of it are given way too much weight: what I think of as conversational intelligence (what B Johnson has) and intellectual confidence.

Meanwhile attention to consequences, circumspection, which is a very valuable aspect of smarts, is barely noticed - if it were, the Borises of this world wouldn't be allowed to run wild.

Note that this is partly a cultural thing (I'm not British) - elsewhere, there are different imbalances.

That’s interesting especially about Boris. Food for thought thank you.

Barbecuebeans · 07/03/2023 20:36

Terrifiedofwastingmylife · 07/03/2023 19:23

I'm bright, but not intelligent.

But what does that mean? I honestly don't understand.

My thread is making me feel even less intelligent Grin

I'm the opposite. I can make quite difficult connections with complex issues at times. However I can fail to understand the most basic set of instructions, like travel directions, for instance, or flat pack instructions.

I make mistakes on things like spreadsheets, but can also find creative solutions to challenging problems.

Surely we all have strengths and weaknesses OP. It sounds like you'll be increasingly more valuable the higher up you get in your organisation. I would have thought creativity is a rarer quality than accuracy in basic tasks and therefore valuable.

It also sounds like you're incredibly hard on yourself and maybe you've been criticised for making mistakes in the past, hence the paralysis when you're being observed.

Would you benefit from some executive coaching to learn how to harness your strengths and mitigate your weaknesses?

ThreeLocusts · 07/03/2023 20:35

Snoopystick · 07/03/2023 16:54

Difficult my DS has what I think would be called high social intelligence - he’s got the gift of the gab and talk to anyone about anything. He’s just been to Cambridge Uni on a school trip and it’s made him not want to apply. He tried to speak to various people and none of them could even look him in the eye, bearing in mind they will all have been incredibly academic and intelligent.

Nah they aren't. Former CB lecturer speaking. The Oxbridge admissions system puts in a floor; you don't get the dimmest students. You maybe get 20 per cent really smart ones rather than 5 per cent at other unis, but the bulk are what I'd call good average, and often get in b/o expensive education.

I became more aware than ever in CB that 'intelligence' is a composite and that certain elements of it are given way too much weight: what I think of as conversational intelligence (what B Johnson has) and intellectual confidence.

Meanwhile attention to consequences, circumspection, which is a very valuable aspect of smarts, is barely noticed - if it were, the Borises of this world wouldn't be allowed to run wild.

Note that this is partly a cultural thing (I'm not British) - elsewhere, there are different imbalances.

Gherkingreen · 07/03/2023 20:34

My job requires me to work quickly and creatively, grasp ideas and develop them.
I work to my strengths tho, and so I feel 'intelligent' most days as I'm on my comfort zone.
However, put me in a room with engineers, or mathematicians and I'd be totally out of my depth.
I'm really good at Only Connect but rubbish at University Challenge 😁.

Terrifiedofwastingmylife · 07/03/2023 20:33

Also, as a teacher, I see both fast and slow processing, very noticeably, all the time in my students. Teaching grammar really shows up the relative mental agility and acuity of my students!

So in the education system then, is slow processing a polite word for well, being a bit lacking in intelligence?

Years ago I was assessed as dyspraxic at uni, slow processing being one thing mentioned. Diagnosed with adhd later on but feel this is not accurate for me, it just all feels like an excuse for being hopeless (in relation to me having it).

But if slow processing is just sugar coating a lack of intelligence, maybe that's what my uni assessment person was trying to tell me, but softening the blow with dyspraxia.

I'm shit at spatial awareness, sports etc so just really have nothing going for me!

The world is so competitive, just to be average you have to be so competent in at least several areas.

OP posts: