Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not count calories in my dinner?!

119 replies

BiscuitBandit32 · 07/03/2023 15:05

OK I've got an idea.

I am around 3 stone overweight and SO CONFUSED about how to get the weight off. I'd settle for 1 of those stones off tbh. I've battled with several methods over the years but never found anything I can stick to. I tried calorie counting (again) recently but found it really impractical with a family. Yes, I know loads of mums do it and succeed but I'm just being honest, I struggle. And I don't think it's a coincidence that the people you see on insta pushing calorie counting are mostly either teenage girls or childless men. It's all well and good calorie counting if you are cooking for 1 and have no stress in your life.

So I had an idea...is this totally stupid??

Basically I thought I could count calories BEFORE my dinner only...so breakfast lunch and any snacks. I'd try and keep those below 800. Then I'd just eat my dinner as normal. I'd try to be mindful of portion size, increase my veg, try and make sure its a healthy nutritious meal but I would not count the calories in it. As long as I don't go mad or load up on pasta and butter, any meal would be well below 1000 calories.

The reason I'm thinking of this is because I really struggle with calorie counting dinner. I find it super stressful. Dinner time is chaos in our house and when I'm trying to plan, weigh, measure, track and log my calories it just feels like a HUGE chore, I get fed up and quit.
But I know I need to be in a caloric deficit to lose weight. And I can probably cope with tracking my own bfast and lunch and snacks as its not a complicated family meal.

My idea was that if my pre dinner food comes to 800, my dinner won't be more than about 800 (probably an over estimate really) so I would probably end up with less than 1800 total calories per day (wich is what most calorie calculators give me as a target.

Thoughts? Anyone else tried this way of doing things? I'm thinking it might take the pressure off whilst still reducing my intake.

OP posts:
PonyPals · 08/03/2023 07:37

Find this podcast
It is honestly life changing

To not count calories in my dinner?!
DanceMonster · 08/03/2023 07:03

I lost 2 stone on 1700 calories a day (I’m very active) so the actual number of calories is individual to everyone. I’d give it a try OP. If you don’t lose any, you still have scope to make changes.

Slimjimtobe · 08/03/2023 06:55

I have recently lost 2 stone and I would say 800 calories before dinner is too much

I would have two boiled eggs in the morning and then a chicken fillet with salad and small dinner (eg omelette or stir fry)

cryinginhmart · 08/03/2023 06:52

I will preface this by saying I didn’t lose weight in a healthy way, wasn’t overweight to start with, and am not recommending it.

I lost about 20lbs without really counting calories. I would for packaged things but I would generally ballpark figure it. I would eat very little in the day and then a more regular dinner. It’s definitely possible. However, 1600 calories is quite a lot to lose weight on but if that’s what your calculations show then go with that I guess.

Vallmo47 · 08/03/2023 06:48

I know some people swear by calorie counting but I can say, hand on heart, I’ve never done it. For me it would likely become obsessive and it would suck all the fun out of life. Deep down I know what foods and drinks to avoid/limit and I think most people do. I’ve lost over 4 stone by walking and doing lane swimming 5 times a week. Better diet and exercise works. Good luck Op.

MaireadMcSweeney · 08/03/2023 06:42

Berklilly · 08/03/2023 04:05

I have used cc for several years very successfully, combined with high level of exercise (weight lifting).

I don't think it's a terrible idea, and if you think it might work for you, you should definitely give it a go - it wouldn't have worked for me though.

Agree with posters that said you don't need to count everything to the gram all the time. It's accepted that there is a margin of error, but it goes both ways so it balances out and what matters is the trend.

Unfortunately, I also agree with posters that said you calorie goals seems a bit off. I am the same height as you, and was similar weight, and 1700 was my maintenance goal (incl exercise like running 10ks on weekends and hiking). So 1600 sounds a bit high, particularly if you are doing approximations. Recommendation from my PT was to ignore the "activity" bit in the calculator, base your cc on you height/weight only, and consider any activity as a bonus that helps you achieve your goal faster/better.

Her calculations are fine. I was a similar starting weight and my calorie expenditure is still between 2300 and 2500 a day - more when I go to the gym. I lose weight eating 17-1800 a day at around 1lb a week.

MaireadMcSweeney · 08/03/2023 06:41

I lost weight doing more or less what you are suggesting but I didn't count any calories. I burn between 2300-2500 a day so worked out if I kept under 1700 I would lose weight. I had the same breakfast every day and kept lunch and dinner to meals that I KNEW were lowish calorie (having done enough calorie counting to know!) and lost weight with zero snacks and limiting alcohol. It was very simple.

Sunriseinwonderland · 08/03/2023 06:39

If you have a family to cook for you would be much better off doing slimming world. Maybe online if you don't want to go to clubs. I certainly don't. It does work. There is no point calorie counting for half the day.
Like another poster said I never eat breakfast. It just .ages me more hungry. I have a banana mid morning to keep going.

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 08/03/2023 06:33

I use Nutracheck app. It’s so easy because every food is in there. I have a family to cook for too

lost 13lbs since January

Berklilly · 08/03/2023 04:05

I have used cc for several years very successfully, combined with high level of exercise (weight lifting).

I don't think it's a terrible idea, and if you think it might work for you, you should definitely give it a go - it wouldn't have worked for me though.

Agree with posters that said you don't need to count everything to the gram all the time. It's accepted that there is a margin of error, but it goes both ways so it balances out and what matters is the trend.

Unfortunately, I also agree with posters that said you calorie goals seems a bit off. I am the same height as you, and was similar weight, and 1700 was my maintenance goal (incl exercise like running 10ks on weekends and hiking). So 1600 sounds a bit high, particularly if you are doing approximations. Recommendation from my PT was to ignore the "activity" bit in the calculator, base your cc on you height/weight only, and consider any activity as a bonus that helps you achieve your goal faster/better.

EmbarrassedAboutIntake · 08/03/2023 03:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JudgeRudy · 08/03/2023 00:52

I agree with some posters that 1600 a day might not mean much (if any) in terms of weight loss. I do understand the social pressure of family meals but you could be setting yourself up to fail.
A lot of people think if they drastically lower their intake they will lose weight. If you're eating a lot this might not be the case. Reducing your calorie intake might actually mean you're not putting on weight so quickly but your still eating above what you need.
I think it's worth getting some sort of professionall input initially so you have a good 'sense' of calorie load.
Of course your way could work if you keep under your 'maintenance' calories. You could even try some distraction techniques so put the plates out for all but start loading the dishwasher, get everyone a drink etc....then sit down and mindfully eat your small portion of whatvyou fancy.
Another option might be intermittent fasting. I think it's important you get a few psychological wins under your belt so do a bit of prep first to give you the best chance. The NHS have several programs to in F2F and online plus WW, SW, and apps.
God luck

EyesOnThePies · 08/03/2023 00:08

I lost nearly 3 stone (18Kg) without calorie counting.

Adjusted my diet to healthier eating, smaller portions, no snacking and 4 nights alcohol free.

Breakfast: a couple of spoons of granola, blueberries, banana or apple, a spoon of Greek yogurt.

Lunch: soup or something proteiny with no more than one slice of toast. Loads of salad.

Snack: 30g of cheese and 2 oatcakes, or a cup of cocoa and one plain biscuit.

1 fruit item

Dinner: normal family dinner but a small portion of carbs.

Siameasy · 07/03/2023 23:27

I would also recommend dropping a meal. I’m 47 5’4” and have maintained at sub 10 stone for 4 years now. I’ve not eaten breakfast for years and actually can’t stomach it any more. I do use the gym but I don’t go crazy. I just try to eat my meals between 12 and 7.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 07/03/2023 23:21

Might work. A portion plate for dinner could help too.

Ploddlewoddle · 07/03/2023 20:24

With your stats, the maintenances is 2015. On circa 1400 you’d lose approx 2lbs a week. I’d say count and do Michael Mosley fast 800 with an additional mea or snack or double one. I doubt you’ll lose otherwise

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 07/03/2023 20:16

LondonJax · 07/03/2023 17:59

Thank you @HowcanIgetoutofthisalive . The important thing for me is that I'm not obsessed. I don't think about food anymore. And I don't feel like I'm missing out. I bought a small 'Freddo' bar the other day and shared it with DH because I really fancied some milk chocolate. But I added it to my carb count and adjusted my other foods for the day to allow it.

I don't do chocolate often because of the pre diabetes rather than the carbs (keeping up with sugar isn't a good idea with pre diabetes). But sometimes you have to eat something to stop the craving. I just have a small piece now and I'm happy. Whereas on other diets I've resisted, resisted then eaten a whole bar of chocolate in a moment of weakness. Then felt bad about myself and that's not a good way to live for me.

Yeah it's just re-learning and forming new habits isn't it. Just difficult to get going!

maddening · 07/03/2023 20:09

You could work out 14 family meals that you know the calories for and work them on rotation- think once only that way and you will know the portion size also which will make it easier to avoid eating bigger portions without realising

RandomMess · 07/03/2023 19:06

I would recommend dropping breakfast altogether then a healthy lunch.

It lets your body fast and it gives you a larger dinner calorie allowance

Personally I only get hungry once I start eating and it's Kellogg's that made up the whole myth about breakfast being an important meal.

whosaidtha · 07/03/2023 19:05

I suppose it depends on how much you usually eat before tea? If you usually eat 1200 calories by tea then reducing your daily calories by 400 is probably going to lead to weight loss. But if you usually skip breakfast and have a soup for lunch then you won't be reducing you calories enough to lose.

Favouritefruits · 07/03/2023 19:02

I’ve been going to ‘Fitfans’ for a while now and it’s so different to other slimming programs p, it’s aimed at people just like you, busy mums. I’ve been today and the lady who runs it is so practical, she said even if you only manage to calorie count three days it’s better than none, so yes I think if your plan suits you then you should give it a try as it’s better than nothing!

Newusername3kidss · 07/03/2023 18:58

I’m so sorry but no this wouldn’t work. Everyone underestimates the amount of calories if they just guess, there was a recent recipe for a veggie lasagna in a magazine which looked so nutritious but was 900 calories a portion and I could easily eat two portions! maybe get the pinch of nom books for recipe ideas for the whole family as tend to be lower calories due to food swaps

reddwarfgeek · 07/03/2023 18:55

It would be quite hard to loose weight this way, unless you are very disciplined.
I lost a lot of weight using my fitness pal to calorie count every day for about 6 months. Unfortunately after holidays and Christmas I gave it up and put almost all the weight back on. I still try to myfitnesspal but if I start days and don't stick to it in the evening (like you suggest) I find I eat more as I'm 'unaccountable' for the calories 😅
Just a thought.

whosaidtha · 07/03/2023 18:50

So I was told (by team rh) that this is inaccurate and the only way to do it is to weigh every individual ingredient by the gram, weigh your pot, cook it, then weigh the full dish, minus the weight of the pot, then weigh your serving. Which when you have 3 screaming kids and the dinners burning and the baby has pood and the toddler is trying to murder the cat starts to feel like a huge massive faff on.
Do you just estimate a portion then? Like input your recipe and divide by how many people?

That's barmy. If you are weighing the ingredients for your recipe then your weighing is done. If you're making it without weighing then I would weigh the calorific things but estimate the others. Eg one onion on mfp is probably not that accurate but will only be a few calories different. But potatoes vary a lot more and one medium potato could be a lot more than you think.
I usually just estimate if it's a tray bake/lasagne. I would weigh pasta for example.
Tonight we had loaded fries. I weighed out my potatoes and partitioned them off so I knew which were mine. Two rashers of bacon easy. I weighed my cheese but guessed everyone else's and I just guessed with the onion because it's so low cal it won't make much difference.

MrsRandom123 · 07/03/2023 18:45

I’m also about 1600-1700 calories maintenance i don’t count anymore and eat what i want as i know most things now (lost 6 stone 10 years ago & have kept it off) but if jeans start to get a bit tight say after christmas or summer holidays i’ll drop back down for a bit to loose a few lbs. I think 800 the rest of the day and a dinnee under 1000 not tracking will be too many calories and you won’t lose weight. I had to drop to 1200 to lose weight.