Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

2 Free GCSE choices only

93 replies

Bunce1 · 07/03/2023 13:26

School is in special measures and failing in every aspect. We have got a MAT in now and things are looking up.

However the school has now set the GCSES as follows
COMPULSORY
Eng language
Eng Literature
Maths
Science (double or triple. But no extra time on timetable for triple)

MUST BE ONE FROM
Geog
MFL
History

FREE CHOICE OF 2 from
all the usuals like art, PE studies, food DT, drama, music and so on. And then also Psychology, some BTECs, business and a media GCSE

So that’s 8, and not the more common 9 so lots of parents asked and they said oh yeah the extra GCSE is COMPULSORY and it’s RE.

AIBU to think that there should be 3 free choices. Totally free and not RE. I am a RE specialist and did it at Uni so I see the value in the subject but I think more broadly the push back from the parents and kids will be huge and really the children should have more choice at this age not leSs!

AIBU- RE is fine.
YANBU- 3 totally free choices is better.

OP posts:
geminiflanagan · 07/03/2023 15:16

Sounds like mine from 20 years ago too, except a language was compulsory as well. I had 2 free choices, did history and Latin and ended up doing 10 in total with triple science.

I don't think what you have posted is unusual?

Dodgeitornot · 07/03/2023 15:13

This is normal. Almost all schools work like this.

MissyB1 · 07/03/2023 14:50

Crikey ds has just submitted his options, he was allowed to choose 4! The only mandatory ones are
Maths
English Language and Literature
Science - their choice of double or triple.

No other stipulations. No compulsory language, and despite being a Catholic school no compulsory RE GCSE - although they will all continue to have RE lessons.

He has chosen
Geography
business
Drama
Sports Science

SimplySipping · 07/03/2023 14:43

Leftbutcameback · 07/03/2023 14:31

Also a bit strange about the triple or double science - are they teaching them all together and just having different exams?

How is that strange? We have separate sets and the triple sets go at a quicker pace, with more homework.

There are other ways to do it but most schools round us do it this way.

Silvergreenblue · 07/03/2023 14:39

I thought children could be removed from RE lessons so how can it be compulsory?

Tapenade · 07/03/2023 14:35

I had one free choice when I was at school so things have improved slightly!

It is annoying when it stops people doing subjects they’re more suited to. I was never going to pass any of the technology subjects offered, but would have done well with a second MFL.

Leftbutcameback · 07/03/2023 14:31

Also a bit strange about the triple or double science - are they teaching them all together and just having different exams?

Leftbutcameback · 07/03/2023 14:30

So they can only take one language if I’ve understood? That’s a shame for those who love languages as I think most who do a ML degree will have done two languages to A Level

tweedlee · 07/03/2023 14:27

YANBU but it was the same for my DS now Y11
usual English, maths, science, then
had to do Spanish or French
also Geography or History
RE compulsory
then 2 free choices

BrieAndChilli · 07/03/2023 14:22

we are in wales and its

COMPULSORY
English Language (and then if in the top sets you can do English Lit also)
Maths
Maths Numeracy
Science (double or triple)
Welsh
Skills Challenge

OPTIONAL
choose 3 from the other subjects - humanities, languages, and others like art/drama/IT/music etc.

Gagagardener · 07/03/2023 14:12

Presumably there wd also be staffing and timetabling implications of having 3 rather than 2 free choices?

Cosyblankets · 07/03/2023 14:10

I wouldn't mind if the kids got a certificate for ebacc but it's just another measure for the school

Tiredalwaystired · 07/03/2023 14:07

LittleOwl153 · 07/03/2023 13:52

Its interesting they are throwing out their Ebacc numbers with that set up as unless history/geoegraphy/MFL are options to choose in addition to their 1 choice initally none of the kids will hit ebbac - which government expects 90% of kids to do... so that won't do their ofsted chances much good?!

Ebacc requires English, maths, science, history or geography AND mfl I believe. Which can't be achieved on that set up.

2 x English
Maths
2 or 3 x science
History or Geography
MFL
And two choices is fairly usual.

Doesn’t have to be a MFL. Latin counts for Ebacc too at my daughters school.

BellaJuno · 07/03/2023 14:07

Bunce1 · 07/03/2023 13:51

Really interesting responses and you have made me calm down a bit so thank you!

I am hearted to hear that many schools do the same- I think it’s just a big change for us as a school community but of course that needed to happen. School was a violent shit show so I am very relieved at the MAT coming in.

I thought- why not have a free choice or if it was a rounding up of subjects why not PE? Anyway I’m sure all will be come clear at the parents meeting next week.

For PE GCSE, you have to undertake 3 different sports to a pretty good standard to get a decent practical grade, the rest is very science based. This won’t suit a lot of kids, especially those who don’t play sport outside of the school.

IVFbeenverylucky · 07/03/2023 14:06

I'm confused. Can you only do one out of MFL, history and geography? So you can't do history and a language, or two languages for example? This is very weird and restrictive and totally unfair on kids with certain interests and aptitudes...

randomsabreuse · 07/03/2023 14:02

Splinters in bum here from wriggling on the fence. I don't like that mfl is with history/geography, I hope doing both is possible. RE fits better as "compulsory" humanity option meaning children can then have 3 choices including History/Geography/ MFL.

That said 2 "creative/practical " subjects is likely enough because they tend to have a BIG workload regardless of ability.

I would have hated this system, as I struggled to get down to the 11 subjects I did (2 Languages, Latin, Music, Geography on top of the compulsory subjects) and would have resented RE for making me drop something I really wanted to do. Although I did music as an extra (lunchtime) and only had 2 free choices (Had to choose geography or history and choose 1 MFL). It was set up so you could choose 2 MFL and Geography and history if that's what suited though. RE was available as a short course (extra) or main in block subject (not compulsory) as we had daily assembly.

It also depends how likely you are to get what you choose - my school had blocks you could pick from to preempt timetabling issues so it was more likely than not that you'd get your choices if the teachers approved.

AvoidingHousework · 07/03/2023 14:01

Seems completely normal and any school doing EBacc normally wants a MFL as well as History or Geography. Ours does so only one free choice. Also, no extra time for triple science is also the norm.

RE (or RP) seems a sensible core subject choice to me. Learning the similarities and differences between religions as well as ethics can't be a bad thing.

WhiteFire · 07/03/2023 13:54

Similar for my DC. History or Geography then two others. DD did French which was compulsory. DS isn't doing French and is doing computing instead. (Dependent on pathways)

Bunce1 · 07/03/2023 13:52

And no we are not a religious school or ever have been historically.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 07/03/2023 13:52

Its interesting they are throwing out their Ebacc numbers with that set up as unless history/geoegraphy/MFL are options to choose in addition to their 1 choice initally none of the kids will hit ebbac - which government expects 90% of kids to do... so that won't do their ofsted chances much good?!

Ebacc requires English, maths, science, history or geography AND mfl I believe. Which can't be achieved on that set up.

2 x English
Maths
2 or 3 x science
History or Geography
MFL
And two choices is fairly usual.

Tombero · 07/03/2023 13:52

I’m surprised they’re not having to pick a language and a humanities subject. The RE seems a bit odd too.

Bunce1 · 07/03/2023 13:51

Really interesting responses and you have made me calm down a bit so thank you!

I am hearted to hear that many schools do the same- I think it’s just a big change for us as a school community but of course that needed to happen. School was a violent shit show so I am very relieved at the MAT coming in.

I thought- why not have a free choice or if it was a rounding up of subjects why not PE? Anyway I’m sure all will be come clear at the parents meeting next week.

OP posts:
mn29 · 07/03/2023 13:50

My children's school is the same - compulsory RE GCSE. It really annoys me that it's compulsory - I'm guessing it's because they are required to have at least some hours on the timetable so think they may as well make it more worth their while. But to me it means kids are missing out on another subject they'd prefer. For triple science there is an extra lesson once a week after school at ours.

titchy · 07/03/2023 13:46

RE is often compulsory as schools have to have some sort of RE and PSHE and what is taught has quite a big overlap with the RE syllabus. For bright kids it's also pretty easy, for less academic there is a half GCSE option.

Two free choices is also quite normal. There's always a big song and dance about options, but in reality once the core subjects have been chosen there is very little choice - you actually have three if you include the choice between H/G/MFL...

LaRitournelle · 07/03/2023 13:45

GiltEdges · 07/03/2023 13:36

Sounds exactly the same as the choices I had at GCSE, almost 20 years ago. Not sure why it's a big issue 🤷‍♀️

Yes same as me 10 years ago...

We did English x2, Maths, Science x2, RE and an MFL, then had to choose history or geography plus two options from Triple science, PE, one of the techs or Art.

Swipe left for the next trending thread