Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Putting dog to sleep - advice please

33 replies

TheWendInTheWillows · 07/03/2023 10:36

We have two old dogs, they’re brothers, I’ll call them Bill and Ben. Bill is in poor health and we’re having to think about putting him to sleep. We’ve found a vet who will come to the house, which is a huge relief - he hates going to the surgery and gets so stressed and I’d hate that to be the last feeling he has.

But we’re really stuck about what to do with Ben. I don’t think he needs to be in the room while Bill is being put to sleep but do we let him see Bill’s body afterwards, so that he knows, however much dogs can know, that Bill is no longer there. Or do we remove Bill’s body without Ben seeing him and just carry on without Bill there.

I know I’m anthropomorphising and I’m trying to stay away from human concepts like closure and grief but the dogs are littermates so have never known any life without each other and I’d just like to handle this is best I can so any advice would be much appreciated
Many thanks

so, my AIBU:

yabu: do not show Ben Bill’s body
yanbu: let Ben spend a little time with Bill afterward

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MuchuseasaChocolateTeapot · 07/03/2023 22:19

Absolutely have them there, or at least let your other dog visit when he has died. We did with our two, but the younger has been very clingy since. Sending love and kind wishes. It isn’t easy but it’s the price you pay for loving x

GreenVeined · 07/03/2023 22:10

My other dog was in the room, I think it was the right decision.

The other dog sat next to my husband whilst I was on the floor next to dying dog, stoking him. When the dog had gone the other dog came over. I think he knew his best mate was dying and it was time to say goodbye.

It was obviously a sad time but very peaceful and I’m glad we were all there to say our goodbyes and show our love in those final moments.

XenoBitch · 07/03/2023 22:02

I recall seeing a program about a zoo/safari park, and one of the resident wolves was PTS. The staff took his body for all the other wolves to sniff and accept.

Years ago, my grandad had one of his dogs PTS, and the his other dogs saw it all happen and got very distressed. It seems they knew something bad was going on. His last dog acted the same when my grandad had a catastrophic stroke in front of him too.

I hope Bill has a safe journey Flowers

TheWendInTheWillows · 07/03/2023 21:40

Gosh, so many moving stories here, thank you all so much for sharing your experiences. So much sadness but so much love from our wonderful girls and boys. Dogs, cats, rabbits, horses - they’re all much loved family
Thanks to your advice we’ve agreed to let Ben see Bill when it’s all over, thank you all again

OP posts:
Iloveeverton1878 · 07/03/2023 18:32

I’m so sorry.

My dog was pts 2 years ago. My younger dog is nervous and used to howl if he went anywhere without her. He was pts in the vets and we brought her in to see his body. She knew and was very quiet for weeks but no howling and looking for him.

She slept in my bed and we took her on holiday and eventually got her a little brother.

JustFrustrated · 07/03/2023 18:08

Not the same I know, but when I had to have my rabbit PTS we were advised to let the remaining rabbits smell her and see her to prevent their stress and trauma.
The eldest still sits on the spot we buried her, when we give the eldest treats it's where she runs to with them.

Cherrysoup · 07/03/2023 17:45

My dog’s brother did not care, he was more excited to see new people in the house.

I’m sorry you’re going through this, it’s the worst part of having animals, bloody heartbreaking.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 07/03/2023 17:42

My old terrier had several fits in the fortnight before he died. My husband's husky adored him and was very distressed by the fits, refusing to come into the room and being unwilling to pass him. He also avoided licking the terrier's bowl like he used to do.

Then one morning the fits got worse and we realised it was time for him to go. We made the decision to take him to the vet. The husky came into the room, sniffed him and let out the most horrendous cry, halfway between a howl and a scream. His tail went between his legs and he ran out of the room and stood shaking as we got ready to leave - grabbing a blanket to wrap the terrier and putting our shoes on. By the time we reached the vet five minutes away he was dead - most likely had died in my arms before we left the house.

It was so clear that the husky knew that his best mate was dying. He was reluctant to enter the living room for a week or so even though we did all we could to comfort him and encourage him to join us.

KarmaStar · 07/03/2023 17:14

💐🌈my heart goes to you.
It's very difficult isn't it? I would let them say goodbye then take Ben out of the room.
Animals are far more spiritual than us,they both know Bill is very ill and his time to return to spirit is coming.Animals don't fear it as we do.
Ben will grieve like you will.we got our dog a teddy dog with a heartbeat inside that was quite loud on Amazon and she cuddled up to him for weeks,I think(hope))it helped her in some way.
you may or may not believe,but Bill will be ok where he is going,better than ok.🐾🐾

DilemmaDelilah · 07/03/2023 17:11

We were in your position with our elderly cats last week. They were from the same litter, about 17 years old. One had kidney failure and was just wasting away and we had to make the heartbreaking decision to have her put down. Like you, we had the vet come to our house, but we shut the other one out while the vet was here and the vet took the body away. We don't have a garden to bury her in. We didn't show her body to our remaining cat and perhaps we should have done. She hasn't been looking for her sister but she has been very clingy and has been crying loudly at night. To be honest we haven't had an unbroken night's sleep since her sister was put down. We thought maybe she was cold, so I have bought her a heated pad to sleep on - it is due to arrive today. I hope that it helps to settle her. Our cats were never allowed upstairs but we have relaxed that now as she just cries all night if we leave her downstairs.
I am so sorry you are having to go through this - my only consolation is that we wouldn't be so upset if we hadn't had so many good years with her.

WoodTrees · 07/03/2023 17:00

I follow Iain Dale on Twitter. It was from there that I read that it's recommended for the other dog to see their deceased friend. It gives them closure, they know they're not coming back, and don't keep looking for them. I didn't know this when I had my previous dogs, but I will definitely do this with my current rescue dogs; they are very bonded, and I know that one dog in particular will sit by the front door forever if he doesn't know the other isn't coming back. I don't think I will have both dogs in the room when one is PTS, purely in case they associate the vet with their loss. I'm very sorry for your coming loss.

loadofcrap10 · 07/03/2023 16:57

I had my 14yr old golden retriever put to sleep at home. I was sat on the floor in front of the settee with her laid on my knee, my other GR was on the settee watching with his head on my shoulder 😪.
When she had gone he jumped down, licked her for a little while then just laid on the rug looking at us both till the vet took her away.
I wouldn't have not wanted him there.

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/03/2023 16:57

No advice as I haven't had the same experience - but I have had beloved dogs pts and I send my love to you.

Dogs are here to teach us about unconditional love and they're so good at it, aren't they?

eightyearslater · 07/03/2023 16:50

One dog we had PTS at home, the other dog didn't see the body but refused to enter that room for the rest of the time we lived there. It was like he could smell the death that happened in there and just refused to go in.

LoveLabradors · 07/03/2023 16:49

I showed our then young lab girl the body of our beloved lab boy who’d been put to sleep (he had lymphoma). We were advised to when we came back from the vets. She totally adored him and they were inseparable. She started with a strange foaming vomit after she saw him. The next morning I found her sitting on his grave in the garden (he was buried 5ft down). She really grieved for him for months. I always wonder if we did the right thing but I suspect it’s the same with humans and loss and grief - everyone reacts differently.
Shes now a very old lady and we have a younger lab who adores her - I don’t know what we will do when the time comes.
Thinking of you with Bill and Ben - there is no wrong decision because it will be made with love. You’ve given him a lifetime of love.

FearTheWankingDead · 07/03/2023 16:46

MuttsNutts · 07/03/2023 14:49

🥺

This is what happened with my parents dogs.
We treated the grieving dog really well, she had extra snuggles and treats we all had a few tears together
Sending hugs 💐

BourbonBon · 07/03/2023 16:38

Let him see the body or he’ll be forever waiting for him to come back.

Dogs are not stupid, they know when a pack member is dead in front of them.

blobby10 · 07/03/2023 16:23

When I had my second old girl PTS, I asked the vet to come to my parents house - both dogs had spent lots of time there and could be buried in the orchard. My parents dog stayed with me whilst my girl was PTS and was so wonderful - just the pressure of her head on my lap whilst her nose rested on her doggie pal as i held my girl for the last time was so comforting. I would let your other dog be there and don't shut him out.

BMW6 · 07/03/2023 16:15

I had a relatives 2 dogs with me when he went on a holiday. One of the dogs was elderly and had been pretty poorly for a while and it was obvious one night (very early hours of a Sunday) that it was dying.

The other dog stayed in the room while I comforted and nursed the dying one but didn't take much close notice and didn't pine at all afterwards.

It died naturally and peacefully around 5am.

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/03/2023 15:46

Whenever we've had one go at home, we've let the other dogs see.

They do understand what 'dead' is, and I think for them thats generally going to be less stressful than their friend just... vanishing.

We tend to have the other dogs out of the room and occupied doing something nice, the vet does their thing and then they go and sit in their car (if they're taking the body with them)... and we let the other dogs in for a sniff and a few moments to understand whats happened.

Be aware... many dogs will sniff and walk away, seemingly indifferent.

Some may paw at or shove at or even bite...

Some may be frightened.

As long as you're prepared for potentially weird/unusual behaviour and ready to comfort them or distract as necessary, this is all normal and fine.

Then take them out again and let the vet/vet nurse take the body away.

We've never done the transportation to a pet crem ourselves and I wouldn't keep a body here for more than a few minutes afterwards just because I am not comfy with that, but it is also an option of course - better if you have another room where your passed pet can rest, away from the other dogs until you do whatever you're doing.

I've always sorted out a plan in advance and let the vets know in advance (or had a friend let them know if I can't manage that) so that on the day, no decisions need making, just focus on the dogs themselves and make it as easy as possible for everyone.

MuttsNutts · 07/03/2023 14:49

2bazookas · 07/03/2023 14:19

I sent our younger dog out for a long walk with son, while they were out, vet came to the house, put down old dog, and we buried her. Good and deep under a big rock, way beyond reach of badgers and foxes; turf back on top. All done and dusted while YD was miles away.

On his return , YD immediately ran straight to the spot and lay there howling. Inconsolable., For the next several weeks he spent hours every day lying by the grave, mourning her.

🥺

2bazookas · 07/03/2023 14:19

I sent our younger dog out for a long walk with son, while they were out, vet came to the house, put down old dog, and we buried her. Good and deep under a big rock, way beyond reach of badgers and foxes; turf back on top. All done and dusted while YD was miles away.

On his return , YD immediately ran straight to the spot and lay there howling. Inconsolable., For the next several weeks he spent hours every day lying by the grave, mourning her.

MatildaTheCat · 07/03/2023 13:42

I’m so sorry for your situation. We lost out beautiful boy a little while ago. Just for what it’s worth, I’d always planned to have the vet come to our house but in the end he declined very rapidly and I couldn’t get anyone out. We had to take him into the surgery and it was ok- they sedated him before trying to cannulae him and he gobbled up a LOT of treats before falling asleep. He still died in my arms very peacefully despite not being at home.(I just thought I’d add this in case you do end up going in).

When our cat died at home we did try to show her body to the dog but he refused to look. It was quite strange. However in your situation I’d definitely try.

Wishing you all well, it’s such a painful experience.

TheWendInTheWillows · 07/03/2023 13:33

Thank you so much everyone for your advice and kind words. I’ll keep and refer back to it. The boys are twelve year old terriers so potentially a few more years in Ben. I’m worried about him pining so will take extra care and he won’t be left alone at all.
thanks again x

OP posts:
Esssa · 07/03/2023 10:50

I had one horse pts in the field with my other. She just knew. Never came over to see. Just stayed out of the way. I do think it helped her cope after. Not quite the same as dogs but still animals who had lived together a long time. I'd do the same for my 2 dogs when necessary. One thing I will say is my remaining horse aged dramatically in the following months so watch out for that with your dog, especially as they are the same age.