Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent spending so much on presents?

59 replies

LovingLife0 · 07/03/2023 10:31

Every month, I’m spending so much of my disposable income on other people. For example this month I have/will have paid for presents for:
2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
My brother’s birthday £20
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10
A friend who’s had a baby £20
Mothers Day £20
A friend’s birthday £15
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.

I know I could spend less but I find it hard finding something nice for less than the above. I also really love these people! But it is so much money and selfishly I’d love to buy some new clothes instead of getting bits at charity shops!

AIBU to resent spending this much? How other people manage this sort of spending?

OP posts:
Parky04 · 07/03/2023 13:02

All family and friends have agreed to stop buying presents for each other. It's such a relief!

Margo34 · 07/03/2023 12:59

If you resent doing it, then.....don't do it 🤷

Ditch present buying for brothers birthday (assuming he's an adult) and the friends birthday, ditch the donations at work (would they even know if it's in a kitty anyway?), halve the amount on the kid's friends birthdays, get a bunch of supermarket flowers or box of chocs for mother's day, up to £8 or less!

2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each £5 each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
My brother’s birthday £20
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10 £5
A friend who’s had a baby £20
Mothers Day £20 £8 flowers/chocs
A friend’s birthday £15
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month. £43 total
^^
Alternatively - switch to get gifts from charity shops and new clothes for yourself.

Overthebloodymoon · 07/03/2023 12:40

Agree with you OP. You could maybe save a little but not too much more than you already are from what I can see. Where we are, people put £15-20 in a card. A £5 voucher would look incredibly tight. Ditto a £2 bunch of daffs. My DM isn’t precious but she’d be right to be insulted by a tiny bunch of flowers that cost half the price of a cup of coffee!
I also have a present cupboard and buy in bulk, offers, 342, Card Factory cards etc. but costs have grown massively over the last few years. You used to be able to get a decent present for £5 in the sales. Now it’s more like £10.

dottiedodah · 07/03/2023 12:22

We dont buy presents for Adults .Your DB for example probably would be relieved at not having to get a present! Apart from the cost ,its a pain to know what to get everyone . Likewise your chum who has had a baby .Some Daffs or tulips ,a card and something small like an outfit from SB or Asda .A fiver each to colleagues seems a lot .A couple of quid each.Mothers Day is only once a year but I would hate my Adult DC to spend what they cant afford .Im sure your Mum would feel the same .Some nice flowers or Chocs is what most mums like.Probably £5 /£10 .

WonderingWanda · 07/03/2023 12:15

You can easily spend less

friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each £5 Waterstones voucher each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each £2.50 each
My brother’s birthday £20 £10 wine, beer or costa voucher plus card
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10 £5 waterstones voucher
A friend who’s had a baby £20 £10 flowers or a box of nic biscuits plus a card
Mothers Day £20 £10 flowers and card or chocs and card
A friend’s birthday £15 £10 flowers, wine or chocs plus card
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.

This would be £60 leaving you £60 to buy something new. I know it's nice to gift things and be thoughtful but it really is the thought that counts not the expense. Also if you really want to get kids a gift get online and look at The Works.

RuthW · 07/03/2023 12:14

2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each
Have a stock of cheap pressies or £5 in a card

2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
Cut down to £2/3

My brother’s birthday £20
£10 voucher or stop exchanging

My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10
As kid's friends

A friend who’s had a baby £20
You can get lovely ores for £10

Mothers Day £20
A bunch of daffs £2

A friend’s birthday £15
As brother

Mary46 · 07/03/2023 12:07

Yes op. Endless. I have 6 nieces nephews. Then godkids. Then big ones 18 21 etc. No end to it. Godkids x2 more. Its not a thing end it as sister bought for ours over the years.. thats without friends but we just do cards now. Sick it at times...

FallonofDynasty · 07/03/2023 12:04

You could reduce the donation to the work colleagues for a start.
Have a word with your friend re getting her dd a birthday present, could you agree to stop this?

Colourinsidethelines · 07/03/2023 11:58

We were like this and it was getting unmanageable! I’ve stopped buying for my siblings, just their kids. For children’s parties we do £5 in a card. My kids are in reception and y2 so I think that’s fine. I buy cards in Card Factory on the 10 for £1. If you have a large family of group of friends I can easily see how it comes to that much. I have a large family so we mostly only but children now, no adults.

stayathomer · 07/03/2023 11:58

We had a tough few years a few years ago and pretty much cut out presents for friends or friends’ children by coming to agreements etc and my god it was miserable. Then one year my friend’s mum had died and her birthday was coming up and I asked a group could we chip in for a few bits for her so sent her a balloon, a gift set, a book and some chocolates. Chocolates were pound shop, gift set on offer, book too-the most expensive thing was the balloon. The gushing out of her afterwards, honestly! She was saying it was the first real birthday she’d had in so long, how lovely and exciting it was etc. I think sometimes yes we need to cut back, but this is just a reminder that it’s the thought that counts. Some great ideas above for cutting down

takealettermsjones · 07/03/2023 11:49

You sound kind and generous but if you can't afford it, just don't.

2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
My brother’s birthday £20
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10
A friend who’s had a baby £20
Mothers Day £20
A friend’s birthday £15
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.

I'd do:

2 x son's friends: notebook and stickers or busy book, reading book etc - £6 each.
Donations at work: just don't.
Brother's birthday: depends how close you are, but either keep this or reduce a little by planning in advance - alcohol on offer maybe, or a jumper in sales etc. £15.
Friend's daughter's birthday: don't. Or if necessary, same as son's friends above (£6).
Friend who had a baby: a babygro and a scratch card. £5.
Mother's Day: bunch of flowers and a home made cake. £8.
Friend's birthday: again depends how close you are. Potentially keep this. £15.
Total: £55 - £61.

SkyandSurf · 07/03/2023 11:36

Another vote for the present cupboard.

I buy generic presents when they are on sale. I also buy boxes of cards when they are on sale. I reuse wrapping and bags and it all gets stored there.

Saves a lot of time and money.

But if even that is too costly, I suggest getting into making presents. Someone gave me a brownie in a jar mixture recently and I thought it was really cool. They bought a bunch of jars in a charity shop and then pre-measured all the ingredients bar eggs and milk into the jar. Inexpensive but exciting to receive.

BritInAus · 07/03/2023 11:29

I don't exchange any birthday presents with adults except my partner, parents and brother. They aren't extravagant presents either. Work donations can be kept small. Kids parties seem to be all the time, but I try to get stuff on special offer to spend a bit less on most, and then spend a little more for 2/3 of DC's best friends. I don't buy any presents for friend's kids - except a baby shower/newborn gift, and a small gift for a 1st birthday, if I'm invited to a party. The only kids I buy gifts for every birthday and xmas are my 3 nieces/nephews. Even then, they're not extravagant.

DuvetDownn · 07/03/2023 11:27

Could you put for example £40 per month away for this type of thing and use some of the tips already posted above?

thecatsthecats · 07/03/2023 11:16

If these people loved you, then they wouldn't get sniffy about not doing gifts.

I also hate receiving "gifty" things over small, practical items that will bring me joy over time - a fiver spent on craft materials would make me much happier than a £20 necklace that I felt I had to reciprocate in kind.

HairyToity · 07/03/2023 11:15

I have a presents drawer, for re-gifting or bargains that I've picked up. Sometimes even bought new unopened toys for a quid in charity shops.

Also have a card drawer with a cheap card stash.

Kittlbua · 07/03/2023 11:11

Reduce the amount you spend on each present.
Agree with other adults not to exchange presents any more.
You can't afford to be spending that much if it means that you can't afford new clothes for yourself.

Mialouu · 07/03/2023 11:07

There's a good £70 there that sounds like not regular.....mothers day, brothers birthday, new babies....are you sure every month is like that for gifts? If it is, then I'd be temped to agree with friends that you don't do gifts for each other anymore, only the kids for example.

spelunky · 07/03/2023 11:05

You don't have to buy presents for your friends/ friends' children/ friends having babies. None of that should be expected (if it is, maybe it needs a conversation with your friends).

Keep the kids party gifts, mothers day, family gifts and colleague contributions.

You would have spend £70 this month instead of £115 if you did this.

Ponoka7 · 07/03/2023 11:03

We stopped adult presents years ago. I don't need anything so instead of my adult DD's buying me things for Mother's Day etc, we try a new restaurant or have a day out that we all want to do. Or we meet up and whoever's occasion it is doesn't have to cook or contribute. Children's presents are £10 in a card. If it's a soft play party etc, it pays for itself in that sense.

deplorabelle · 07/03/2023 10:58

Definitely reduce gift giving where you can. I have absolutely no disposable income at the moment and it actually gets me down receiving gifts because so few of them are things I want to buy myself.

I had a birthday recently and received lovely kind gifts from friends and family which I really appreciated but I did also look at them thinking "I've got to buy you something in a couple of months" and also "MIL you have yet again spent god knows how much on hand wash only clothing I will never wear while I am crying that I can't spend a tenner on supplies for my hobby which I love"

We agreed on no Christmas presents among our friendship group this year and it was much better

WandaWonder · 07/03/2023 10:58

PeekAtYou · 07/03/2023 10:50

It's also ok to decline a party invite - as the saying goes it's an invitation and not a summons. Most kids will have say a handful of children that they are close to so want to go their party but some parties are whole class so missing it doesn't matter so much.

I agree with you! Op stop buying so many presents

Far out have you read mn lately if you declined it would be the Spanish inquisition

LovingLife0 · 07/03/2023 10:56

Some great ideas - I might speak to my siblings and see if they want to move to just cards. Also I’ll try bulk buying kids presents - I need to be more organised!

Some months there is slightly less to buy but I save the remainder from £100 and put towards the kids/Christmas. But honestly, most months are like this one way or another. This is what I resent - there always seems to be something I didn’t expect!

But thanks for the advice - all really helpful

OP posts:
CharlotteDoyle · 07/03/2023 10:54

That does seem like quite a lot of gift giving this month, but Mother's Day is only once a year and surely you don't have a siblings' birthdays and colleagues going on mat leave every month.

If your child is going to another kid's birthday party then yes you need to buy a small gift but the rest is optional really

PeekAtYou · 07/03/2023 10:51

Have you considered £5 in a card for the school friends? They can buy what they want.

Swipe left for the next trending thread