Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent spending so much on presents?

59 replies

LovingLife0 · 07/03/2023 10:31

Every month, I’m spending so much of my disposable income on other people. For example this month I have/will have paid for presents for:
2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
My brother’s birthday £20
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10
A friend who’s had a baby £20
Mothers Day £20
A friend’s birthday £15
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.

I know I could spend less but I find it hard finding something nice for less than the above. I also really love these people! But it is so much money and selfishly I’d love to buy some new clothes instead of getting bits at charity shops!

AIBU to resent spending this much? How other people manage this sort of spending?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NellietheElephantpackedhertrunks · 07/03/2023 20:33

takealettermsjones · 07/03/2023 11:49

You sound kind and generous but if you can't afford it, just don't.

2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
My brother’s birthday £20
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10
A friend who’s had a baby £20
Mothers Day £20
A friend’s birthday £15
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.

I'd do:

2 x son's friends: notebook and stickers or busy book, reading book etc - £6 each.
Donations at work: just don't.
Brother's birthday: depends how close you are, but either keep this or reduce a little by planning in advance - alcohol on offer maybe, or a jumper in sales etc. £15.
Friend's daughter's birthday: don't. Or if necessary, same as son's friends above (£6).
Friend who had a baby: a babygro and a scratch card. £5.
Mother's Day: bunch of flowers and a home made cake. £8.
Friend's birthday: again depends how close you are. Potentially keep this. £15.
Total: £55 - £61.

This is good. I would add, buy cards at The Card Factory (5 for £1) and bulk buy kids’ toys at The Entertainer or on Amazon (can be v cheap).

UWhatNow · 07/03/2023 20:19

takealettermsjones · 07/03/2023 11:49

You sound kind and generous but if you can't afford it, just don't.

2 friends of my sons (they’re going to their parties) £10 each
2 donations to people going on maternity leave at work £5 each
My brother’s birthday £20
My friend’s daughter’s birthday £10
A friend who’s had a baby £20
Mothers Day £20
A friend’s birthday £15
This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.

I'd do:

2 x son's friends: notebook and stickers or busy book, reading book etc - £6 each.
Donations at work: just don't.
Brother's birthday: depends how close you are, but either keep this or reduce a little by planning in advance - alcohol on offer maybe, or a jumper in sales etc. £15.
Friend's daughter's birthday: don't. Or if necessary, same as son's friends above (£6).
Friend who had a baby: a babygro and a scratch card. £5.
Mother's Day: bunch of flowers and a home made cake. £8.
Friend's birthday: again depends how close you are. Potentially keep this. £15.
Total: £55 - £61.

This is great advice.

I’m a generous gift giver and it does add up. These ideas are still nice (not random charity shop stuff) but perfectly do-able without the cost or cringe.

LazJaz · 07/03/2023 20:13

This is what TK Maxx mega clearance is for
should have name changed as would hate for people to know my (totally open) secret 😂

in the 90s, my mum had a rule about children’s gifts - now more then £5.
i think I get better things on this same exact budget (not inflation adjusted) because I only shop for gifts at TK MAXX clearance.

Thing about gifts is if you resent, don’t give. A gift given through obligation and with resentment is not a real gift in my opinion. It is a grudge waiting to happen.

Overthebloodymoon · 07/03/2023 20:07

@Hollyhocksandlarkspur - as a PP said, I wouldn’t use anything that was homemade, particularly not baking kits or toiletries that someone else had made. It’s a nice thought but most of that stuff ends up in the bin!

BasiliskStare · 07/03/2023 20:07

@LovingLife0 My DB & SIL used to buy birthday presents so we felt obliged to buy back. Birthdays we have come to a just cards agreement and also a kindly thought but not expensive Christmas present.

A good friend & I decided between us - no more presents & that suits us both fine

I don't care about Mother's Day presents and neither does my mother - a nice card and a phone call fine.

For young children I would go cheaper - I used to recycle shamelessly duplicate presents etc which had been bought for DS . Also I remember him getting a few plastic soldiers which a mother had wrapped up ( probably from Asda in those days and she had split up the pack ) and he loved that. ( but he was very young then so children's presents do depend on age )

Does anyone one remember the person who said would a box of Malteser's do ( School party not relatives ) and the resounding answer seemed to be yes.

I would not feel pressurised for work collections - stick something very modest in to join in but make sure they are doing it properly & it is anonymous so no-one knows what you have given but you can sign the card - do not feel you have to spend more than you are comfortable with for a work college.

Present giving is lovely & I like giving presents but not at the cost of your welfare

Lcb123 · 07/03/2023 19:58

Agree with adults not to exchange presents - I guarantee they’ll be pleased. And honestly would it be missed if you didn’t take a present to a kids party? Or do £5 book token.

minipie · 07/03/2023 19:54

Out of your list I would only do the first two and the friend who’s has a baby (although probably only if first baby).

As for the others

We haven’t done adult presents in my family for years
I don’t buy for friends except “big “ birthdays, and even then only if I am celebrating the birthday with them
I don’t buy for friends’ children, except godchildren.

This isn’t for money reasons. I’m just really not a huge fan of presents, I think the times they are truly something the person wanted are rare. (Backed up by all this talk of present drawers and buying bargains). More often the item goes in a drawer or is regifted. Waste of time money and resources. I’d much rather someone went out for a coffee with me than bought me a present.

LovingLife0 · 07/03/2023 19:43

Struddlefor1 · 07/03/2023 19:00

I totally agree. I set out my budget for the year in January and there are multiple “only once a year” occasions every month. There are very few weeks when there isn’t some sort of occasion.

I’ve cut down spending on each person, and moved to cards only with people that were willing, but it still feels relentless.

I didn’t mind so much in previous years, but money is tight now and buying little gifts for people uses up nearly all of my non-essentials money, so there’s not much left for anything else that I want to do.

Yep, I put aside £100 a month for presents and am never left with any. I agree that I could cut down buying for certain people but they would continue buying for each other for sure - I don’t want to be the only friend in the friendship group not buying a present! Family, maybe I could cut down, but we already don’t buy for each other at Christmas and they’d also continue buying for each other.

As PP said, it isn’t a one off this month. For example last month I had a 30th and a wedding plus my son’s birthday. It’s always a few birthdays but then different ‘one offs’. I guess the only solution is buying cheaper stuff or not buying at all, neither of which really work for me. So I’ll just have to suck it up!

OP posts:
Struddlefor1 · 07/03/2023 19:00

I totally agree. I set out my budget for the year in January and there are multiple “only once a year” occasions every month. There are very few weeks when there isn’t some sort of occasion.

I’ve cut down spending on each person, and moved to cards only with people that were willing, but it still feels relentless.

I didn’t mind so much in previous years, but money is tight now and buying little gifts for people uses up nearly all of my non-essentials money, so there’s not much left for anything else that I want to do.

RobinRobinMouse · 07/03/2023 18:46

£10 seems quite generous for children's parties, I'd usually spend about £5. Can you reduce all gifts by a little bit so that the overall burden is lower?

Plaidparty · 07/03/2023 18:42

Around here the going rate for kids birthdays is £10-£15. A £1 book (which the kid has probably got) would look incredibly tight. As a parent I’d prefer just a card tbh.

Also, sorry to be that person but I would absolutely hate a homemade gift from someone other than my child. I’d bin homemade foot soak or beeswax. Unless you are making loads most of the time the ingredients cost more than a £10 and I’m
sure most people would prefer the £10.

Hollyhocksandlarkspur · 07/03/2023 18:35

Agree with PP get into homemade gifts: if gardener take cuttings eg fruit bushes, perennials when divide in spring, grow seeds, store seed in envelopes in autumn. I often give bunch of flowers from garden. Lots of bought bouquets make great use of foliage from trees, shrubs and just a few flowery stems. Wrap in recycled paper/newspaper. Or make home made brownies, muffins, biscuits, cheese scones, make jars of homemade mix ready to add liquids and bake, package with reused ribbon and label. Make own homemade bathsalts, foot soak, bath oil, room freshener, lip balm, beeswax wraps. Or give lovely photo that has meaning. Homemade art if good at painting. Or treat voucher if you can afford time, eg babysit, skill offer, lift after holiday from airport/station, help with decorating etc. Have reduced our gift budget to about a quarter.

thesnailandthewhale · 07/03/2023 18:33

When ds was little I used to let him open all his Xmas presents and a few weeks later there was always a game/book/toy that hadn't been opened that would then be stashed away in my gift cupboard. He'd had the excitement of opening the parcel but it obviously wasn't going to get use from him so would be rehired ready to be given at a school mates party.

I also pay my council tax over ten months rather than twelve, so feb/March that money would be squirrelled away for Christmas presents.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 07/03/2023 18:31

Friends kids agree with your friends that you won't buy for each others kids. I did this with all my friends and the relief all round was palpable.

General kids party gift have a £5 limit.

Have a gift and bday card box, I bulk buy bday cards from Card warehouse who often do 10 cards for £1.

Places like The Works for cheap books and games.

I gift on books or toys that duplicates or dd doesn't like.

MrsPetty · 07/03/2023 18:26

I buy things all year round when they’re on sale and stick them in my gift cupboard. Generic things … I start buying the presents for DDs friends’ in the January sales.

2023istheyearigetmyacttogether · 07/03/2023 18:22

I've massively cut back as I was finding I was spending loads each month, generally buying generic presents and then received a load of generic stuff come my own birthday. I did mention this to friends and family in advance so that they didn't feel hard done by and it was a bit odd on my own birthday as, other than my parents & DH, I had no presents but I'd also bought myself my favourite chocolates, a new book and the candle that I really like so I had a lovely day and I things I genuinely liked rather than quite liked or actually disliked

Samkey · 07/03/2023 18:21

I put money into a sinking fund for Birthdays, Christmas, Mother's/Father's Day which means it is spread out across the year.

Caspianberg · 07/03/2023 18:17

Well yes, time, that’s what Mother’s Day is supposed to be, not a £20 gift and no time.

Doesnt have to be expensive, I mean surely op is eating dinner/ lunch anyway, so it’s cost of a few more ingredients not an entire meal as her family will be eating anyway. I know if I make a roast for us 3, making it for 4 isn’t another £20.

SomersetONeil · 07/03/2023 18:14

GoodChat · 07/03/2023 18:12

Mother’s Day - bunch of daffodils and make cake or lunch for here

By the time she's bought ingredients for cake or lunch she'll almost be at the £20 mark anyway

Exactly! Plus the time it takes.

GoodChat · 07/03/2023 18:12

Mother’s Day - bunch of daffodils and make cake or lunch for here

By the time she's bought ingredients for cake or lunch she'll almost be at the £20 mark anyway

tunamayo81 · 07/03/2023 18:10

I spend more than that on gifts/birthdays. I’d give £30-£40 for a birthday. I don’t resent it but then i’m a generous person. Are you being unreasonable? depends how much you earn!

Caspianberg · 07/03/2023 17:02

I just don’t buy half of those

Adults don’t need gifts for birthdays, mothers don’t need donations to have a baby.

children’s friends for party x2 - buy a book/ Lego when on offer/ chocolate A- £5-10 each ( there’s often lego 2 for £15 on offer)

Mother’s Day - bunch of daffodils and make cake or lunch for here

Dont buy anything else - so down to £20-30 instead

cocksstrideintheevening · 07/03/2023 16:45

Also don't do adult presents unless it's a significant birthday. My friends and I stopped when we realised it was pointless giving each other a gift card to just give them a gift card when it was their birthday.

Christmas we do secret Santa amongst the adults that are there on the day, £50 limit so you can get something decent.

My kids are older now so less parties and for their good mates it's £20 in body shop or a primark voucher.

FourFour · 07/03/2023 13:05

I don't buy for a single adult except my mum and dh. Surely adult gifts are unnecessary? For kids, there's always deals/sales absolutely everywhere. 10 books for £10 is a good one.

2bazookas · 07/03/2023 13:03

*This comes to £115 and is a normal type of month.
I know I could spend less but I find it hard finding something nice for less than the above. I also really love these people!"

You invest £115 in buying their love.

IF they really love you, they'd be just as happy with a card.

Swipe left for the next trending thread