Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are people so bothered by what my son wears?

419 replies

WindowGazers · 07/03/2023 08:59

My son is 4yo and I let him choose his clothes in the morning. Most days consists of some brightly coloured trousers, probably a mis matching top, and he loves to put tutus over everything. He always looks great and is so confident in whatever outfit he wears.

I'm very introverted personality wise but also choose to wear very extroverted clothing. I don't care what people think about what I wear, but people have started saying in front of me and me son 'aren't you worried that he looks like a girl' or saying directly to him 'interesting choice of clothing you've got there'.

It drives me slightly mad as they're just clothes and he's happy. A dad on the nursery run asked me if I was raising him trans (he was literally wearing black trousers, a hulk top and a red tutu over the top) in front of him!

Am I supposed to just dress him in blue and black or AIBU in thinking that I should be encouraging to wear what he's comfortable in? Also funny how his friends love his clothes (and him!) and it's just the adults who seem to find them out of the ordinary.

I was raised by very extroverted parents who let me wear the most bizarre outfits, but I loved it and I've now turned into an adult who adores alternative fashion. I'm so glad they supported me rather than trying to push me into a box. Opinions?

OP posts:
XelaM · 07/03/2023 16:20

If a simple choice of clothing by a young child will "make them a target" for bullying by other kids, then maybe the parents of those kids should parent them properly and teach them not to pick on others for what they wear.

Good luck with that

takealettermsjones · 07/03/2023 16:19

XelaM · 07/03/2023 15:59

Maybe their parents should dress them properly and not make them a target. No stranger has ever commented on what my daughter wore when she was a baby/toddler but then I did curtail her self-expression by making her wear weather- and occasion-appropriate clothes. She's a teen now and doesn't seem traumatised by not wearing a bikini in winter to nursery 🤷‍♀️

Nobody has said it's fine to dress kids in weather-inappropriate clothes but ok

If a simple choice of clothing by a young child will "make them a target" for bullying by other kids, then maybe the parents of those kids should parent them properly and teach them not to pick on others for what they wear.

Guis23 · 07/03/2023 16:19

I wouldn't send your son to school in a tutu once he starts. It would be unkind. He might be picked on. Other children can be harsh.

copperplated · 07/03/2023 16:13

@XelaM
Imagine curtailing your child in that way!😆 I suppose you had the audacity to say no to her too on occasion!
I hope she doesn't feel too bereft of a personality seeing as you prevented her from expressing herself at every opportunity.
You could have raised an icon, an influencer so influential the world has never before seen the like! What a missed opportunity, I would be throughly ashamed of myself if I were you😂

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 16:12

XelaM · 07/03/2023 15:59

Maybe their parents should dress them properly and not make them a target. No stranger has ever commented on what my daughter wore when she was a baby/toddler but then I did curtail her self-expression by making her wear weather- and occasion-appropriate clothes. She's a teen now and doesn't seem traumatised by not wearing a bikini in winter to nursery 🤷‍♀️

She was dressed entirely appropriately. In a dress, cardi and shoes.

some idiot took it upon themselves to assume she was a boy because she had short hair, and give us a lecture about wearing their sister’s clothes.

entirely weather and occasion appropriate 🙄

I did not “make her a target”. Societal norms did that.

Bookworm20 · 07/03/2023 16:09

My son is 4yo and I let him choose his clothes in the morning. Most days consists of some brightly coloured trousers, probably a mis matching top, and he loves to put tutus over everything. He always looks great and is so confident in whatever outfit he wears.
Most 4 year olds don't give a toss what they are wearing and would pick anything. You seem to have alot of focus on him 'choosing' his clothes, as though its something thats made a big deal of. And that his 'choice' of clothing is whats making him confident. I very much doubt clothes are the reason for a 4 year olds confidence. Plus everything he has to 'choose' from are things you have purchased for him.

I'm very introverted personality wise but also choose to wear very extroverted clothing. I don't care what people think about what I wear, but people have started saying in front of me and me son 'aren't you worried that he looks like a girl' or saying directly to him 'interesting choice of clothing you've got there'.
Not sure what extroverted clothing is. Is it stuff that makes people look at you for one reason or another? Its good you don't care what people think, best way to be. But I'm not sure why you are confused that people look and possibly comment when you dress yourself and your son in clothes that make some kind of 'look at me' statement. Its one thing dressing yourself in clothes that shout attention, but I can't understand why you are surprised when people give attention to your son when you dress him in, sorry buy him clothes to dress himself in clothes for exactly that reason.

It drives me slightly mad as they're just clothes and he's happy. A dad on the nursery run asked me if I was raising him trans (he was literally wearing black trousers, a hulk top and a red tutu over the top) in front of him!
If it drives you mad, why do it? It you are not bothered what people think, why does it drive you mad?

Am I supposed to just dress him in blue and black or AIBU in thinking that I should be encouraging to wear what he's comfortable in?
You don't dress him though apparently. And you can buy whatever clothes you want for your child. Is he genuinely comfortable in a tutu though? Or does he wear it because you encourage him to?

Also funny how his friends love his clothes (and him!) and it's just the adults who seem to find them out of the ordinary.
They are 4. Are they really chatting about each others wardrobe on a daily basis? Or is it because they don't seem to notice when clothes are mismatched or he is wearing a tutu? Again they are 4. I imagine most have dressing up clothes, so are totally familiar with that, and not many 4 year olds are clued into what actually matches.

I was raised by very extroverted parents who let me wear the most bizarre outfits, but I loved it and I've now turned into an adult who adores alternative fashion. I'm so glad they supported me rather than trying to push me into a box.
Again, the extrovert personality seems to equal - not the norm in clothing? So your parents supported your fashion sense of anything goes, and now you are doing the same for your son. How much of that was influenced by your parents on you? People wearing 'normal' clothes (eg not dressing up stuff or stuff that matches) are not people pushed into a box. Its what they choose to wear, it just isn't 'look at me' clothing on an everyday basis.

Opinions?
If he genuinely loves the tutu, so what? What do you care and why are you so baffled people comment on it? If you think the few comments you have received are negatively affecting your son, stop dressing him like an 'extrovert'. I'd of thought your sons confidence is more important than making a fashion statement, even if you don't want him to just 'conform'. It is possible to say no to a child and make decisions for them.

daisypond · 07/03/2023 16:08

Eyerollcentral · 07/03/2023 15:37

Clothing that doesn’t match. There is nothing about dressing your child in a nice way that says they are a doll to be dressed up, but as I say I wouldn’t send a child of mine out messy or looking like I just put the first thing I found on them because I wouldn’t go out like that myself.

What do you mean by “match”? Plain navy top with plain navy bottoms? Stripey navy top with stripey navy bottoms? Navy top with stripey bottoms? Orange top with navy bottoms? No patterns at all?

WindowGazers · 07/03/2023 16:04

AIBUNo · 07/03/2023 15:09

I'm very introverted personality wise but also choose to wear very extroverted clothing. I don't care what people think about what I wear,

I think @WindowGazers that you care very much what you wear and how other people react.

I'm not sure what extroverted clothing is ( not all extroverts wear clothes that scream LOOK AT ME!' although you seem to think they do.)
I think you need to educate yourself on what introverts and extroverts are, but that's another issue.

I suspect you choose clothing that attracts attention as it deflects from who you really are underneath (ie insecure.) It's easy for on lookers to focus on your loud clothing, rather than the shy person underneath it.

It's a bit like war paint. It's there as a barrier for you to hide behind.

You bought your son a tutu. You are clearly passing on your own issues to him - ie 'being noticed' - as you surely know that little boys don't wear tutus unless it's a dressing up session OR their parents have offered them one as an option.

In all seriousness, I think you ought to consider therapy for your own issues. Or at least understand why you like to attract attention by wearing clothes that people stare at.

Your child doesn't have the emotional intelligence to make those judgements yet.

Absolutely love an armchair psychologist who doesn't have a fecking clue what they're on about. Thanks for your diagnosis.

OP posts:
copperplated · 07/03/2023 16:03

social norms change, but until new ones are established, pushing boundaries will always encourage comments and discussion. Some people pretend not to know this.
Why?

XelaM · 07/03/2023 15:59

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 15:52

The adults can decide it’s irrelevant, but children have heard it.

hear it once too often and they absorb the messages.

i don’t give a fuck what people think, but children do pick up on people being nasty about them.

Maybe their parents should dress them properly and not make them a target. No stranger has ever commented on what my daughter wore when she was a baby/toddler but then I did curtail her self-expression by making her wear weather- and occasion-appropriate clothes. She's a teen now and doesn't seem traumatised by not wearing a bikini in winter to nursery 🤷‍♀️

takealettermsjones · 07/03/2023 15:58

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 15:55

Not seen an adult woman go to work with a red tutu over her clothes either tbf.

so neither men nor women go to work in tutu’s, yet somehow it’s less acceptable for boys to wear them.

This.

Didn't think I'd be reading arguments on MN for people to stay in their gender-stereotyped box, but here we are.

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 15:55

AIBUNo · 07/03/2023 15:50

That's a very silly comparison because women do own cars.
No one thinks it's odd for a woman to buy a car or be interested in them.

But I can't think of the last time I saw an adult man going to work in a red tutu over this suit.

Not seen an adult woman go to work with a red tutu over her clothes either tbf.

so neither men nor women go to work in tutu’s, yet somehow it’s less acceptable for boys to wear them.

80s · 07/03/2023 15:53

I can't remember the last time I saw an adult woman going to work in a knee-length skirt and knee-high white socks.

XelaM · 07/03/2023 15:53

AIBUNo · 07/03/2023 15:50

That's a very silly comparison because women do own cars.
No one thinks it's odd for a woman to buy a car or be interested in them.

But I can't think of the last time I saw an adult man going to work in a red tutu over this suit.

I agree @AIBUNo .

It's the parents' "self-expression" 🙄

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 15:52

Hearmeout · 07/03/2023 15:48

And she's awful for saying that but again - just walk away?

yes she's rude, so you treat her as you should and walk away. her reasons and motivations for what she said are not your responsibility and further more, you can't stop how she spoke, but you can decide it's irrelevant to you.

The adults can decide it’s irrelevant, but children have heard it.

hear it once too often and they absorb the messages.

i don’t give a fuck what people think, but children do pick up on people being nasty about them.

AIBUNo · 07/03/2023 15:50

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 15:39

You bought your son a tutu. You are clearly passing on your own issues to him - ie 'being noticed' - as you surely know that little boys don't wear tutus unless it's a dressing up session OR their parents have offered them one as an option

I bought my dd a toy garage and set of cars. Do people surely know that little girls don’t play with cars unless their parents have offered them as an option?

young children can’t got to the shop and buy there own stuff. So everything a child has has been offered to them by a parent. You could say the same about girls and tutu’s, they will only wear them if a parent has bought one.

why shouldn’t parents buy things that offer their dc a wide range of activities, regardless of whether that thing is percieved to be “for girls” or “for boys”?

why should kids be restricted to activities associated with their gender? What exactly is wrong with a boy having a tutu or a girl having a toy tool set?

That's a very silly comparison because women do own cars.
No one thinks it's odd for a woman to buy a car or be interested in them.

But I can't think of the last time I saw an adult man going to work in a red tutu over this suit.

Hearmeout · 07/03/2023 15:48

Weallhaveavoice · 07/03/2023 15:41

An elderly lady in a coffee shop stopped me as we left with our three boys and said
” how sad, can’t you make girls “.
( my MIL said the same. )

People feel entitled to be rude these days.

And she's awful for saying that but again - just walk away?

yes she's rude, so you treat her as you should and walk away. her reasons and motivations for what she said are not your responsibility and further more, you can't stop how she spoke, but you can decide it's irrelevant to you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/03/2023 15:48

My Ds used to wear stuff like this when he was 3/4 years old. Tutu or dress over jeans and top etc. Was never a problem. Some people used to say “oh I love your outfit” or something but as a kid he’d take it at face value.

He’s 9 now and doesn’t dress like this anymore, not that I’d mind if he did. Interestingly though he does always like things with an outfit - like rock music for example - and cares a lot about his clothes, but his style has changed.

Both of my brothers are like this about hobbies with an outfit too! I think there’s something in the idea that stereotypical men’s clothing is very dull but that’s not women’s fault 😂

Eyerollcentral · 07/03/2023 15:47

Weallhaveavoice · 07/03/2023 15:45

🙄
Did I say it was innovative?

Fair enough. What do you think about second hand clothes will cause a backlash then? Most people I know have put their children in seconds hand clothes.

Weallhaveavoice · 07/03/2023 15:45

Eyerollcentral · 07/03/2023 15:43

Backlash for buying second hand??? What a bizarre viewpoint. For those of us not from a well off back ground probably 80% of my clothing was second hand, families shared clothes between and indeed neighbours also passed on old clothes between them. Guess what? If items were part of a set - a tracksuit or a skirt and jacket - they were passed on as a set, which my friends and family still do now. How out of touch to think this is innovative.

🙄
Did I say it was innovative?

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 07/03/2023 15:44

My ds when younger, liked to wear a lot of pink, occasionally other bright colours. He also liked wearing my dresses.
Now he's 17 and has gone beige on me. He buys his clothes from the female section. I'm glad that he doesn't wear black, but considering I like colours I'm disappointed in him😁

Lastnamedidntstick · 07/03/2023 15:44

Hearmeout · 07/03/2023 15:37

You've been stopped in the street and asked "what on earth is mummy doing putting you in your sisters dresses..." are you in a BBC2 sit com from the 80's ? who talks like that?

Again, even if that's true, so what?

Say it's none of your business and walk away?

Where's the fire??

Because my child, as a toddler, is already getting messages that some things are “for boys” and others are “for girls”.

i don’t agree, and have raised them to think what they like is what they like, and the reason they like dolls and cars is not driven by their genitals.

i don’t need strangers in the street telling my child they can’t do x or y because they’re a girl. Or in the example I gave, that they must fit a certain criteria re. Appearance. In that case, because she had short hair a stranger thought it was ok to stop and lecture her about wearing a dress.

takealettermsjones · 07/03/2023 15:43

Weallhaveavoice · 07/03/2023 15:38

Gosh, someone has admitted buying second hand , I was keeping that one quiet.
When a PP mentioned clothes come in matching sets I thought not in my world.

Prepare for some backlash there @daisypond

I was thinking that too! I get bundles of everything, luck of the draw 😂

Or, when the kids were younger, there might have been a matching set for five minutes in the morning, until one of the items got puked on (or worse) and had to be thrown in the wash.

In that situation I would hazard a guess that most people just change the bit that needs changing and get on with their day, rather than return to the armoire to find a whole new co-ordinated outfit, but maybe that's just how it works in my circles.

Eyerollcentral · 07/03/2023 15:43

Weallhaveavoice · 07/03/2023 15:38

Gosh, someone has admitted buying second hand , I was keeping that one quiet.
When a PP mentioned clothes come in matching sets I thought not in my world.

Prepare for some backlash there @daisypond

Backlash for buying second hand??? What a bizarre viewpoint. For those of us not from a well off back ground probably 80% of my clothing was second hand, families shared clothes between and indeed neighbours also passed on old clothes between them. Guess what? If items were part of a set - a tracksuit or a skirt and jacket - they were passed on as a set, which my friends and family still do now. How out of touch to think this is innovative.

80s · 07/03/2023 15:42

Don't we all buy clothes for our children that reflect our own tastes and preferences? Should we buy a wider range of clothes, including things we don't like, to ensure that they are not affected by our choices?