Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why nobody wants to be a nurse.

130 replies

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 08:49

I just wanted to raise awareness of why we are struggling to train nurses. I'm a third year student and just completed a 8 week placement where I had to drive 1.5 hours each way driving on top of 12.5 hour shifts. I have a disability which long driving has a detrimental impact on my health. I also have caring responsibilities and limited financial support so we effectively pay to train. You also have to do assignments and exams on top.

I got a choice of defer the placement so lose hours (not get my pin on time) or get on with it. I enquired about funding for a hotel which was ignored. Non drivers are regularly being sent 2 hours each way on top of 12.5 hour placements which makes them drop out. When I enquired with this to the university they said nursing requires resilience. Many nursing roles allow you to go part time and I have found a job very close to my house which wouldn't require the insane commuting times. Just after I finished a 8 week placement , I received a snotty email on Sunday night saying an admin mistake made by my assessor could result in me having to redo all the competencies, I have already achieved so years of hard work. At the moment I wanted to scream and say fuck it.

The whole system needs reworking , nurse training is a punitive unrewarding experience and I can understand why so many don't want to go through it. I am already doubting whether I want to do it because I feel beaten down by the training already.

OP posts:
Hobbitlover · 08/03/2023 21:57

12.5 hr shifts on placement, 3 or 4 in a row, plus travel & sitting exams while on placement, no support from uni were all part my leaving. I feel your pain😥

Throwncrumbs · 08/03/2023 21:47

mumda · 07/03/2023 22:33

Loving the adverts for spire healthcare.

Not much better than working for the NHS!

Carlycat · 08/03/2023 16:58

Throwncrumbs · 07/03/2023 10:37

40 years of nursing, the long shifts, the lack of sleep between shifts, the never ending professional development once qualified…etc etc has I think contributed to my poor health now. All the years of missing out of things with my kids, the Christmas’s I’ve worked, the school plays I’ve missed, the times I’ve been to tired to enjoy family time… never ending… I think ‘was it worth it’ ..there were good times and good friends made but nursing is something I wouldn’t recommended to anyone I know now. Sad really

This x 100
Plus
Chronic back issues ( no manual handling back then )
Burn out resulting in a MH break down
Endless hoops to jump through
Ever increasing roles and a tick box culture
I'd actively discourage anyone from taking on this thankless job
I couldn't retire quick enough

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 08/03/2023 13:18

It’s not different for AHPs now, exactly the same challenges just shorter shifts.

Any HCP on here, you can make a difference by offering placements. This is literally the key which will enable students to progress through and complete their courses and therefore become part of your team so you have more staff available.

inloveandmarried · 08/03/2023 06:03

Gosh this is awful. I had no idea.
I trained as AHP in the early 90's. In theory we were sent anywhere in the country for our practical hours, in blocks of a term or half term at a time. But, we were always provided with accommodation or helped to find affordable accommodation and only ever did a 7.5 hour day.
Even a 90 minute commute had accommodation although I chose to drive on that occasion.

We had 5 placements. My closest placement was 20 mins drive, the next was 50 min dive, then 2 hours, the one before last was a 90 minute drive and my final one was 30 minutes. We were contributing for the full 7.5 hours but it wasn't ever frantically busy.

There's no way I'd be able to do the hours and travelling required for nursing. How strange it's so different for AHP training often on the same ward at the same time and same level of qualifications.

Starflecked · 08/03/2023 05:31

It’s then really falling when a student says they don’t want a placement which has been really difficult to get. Whilst it’s not the student’s responsibility to know how difficult it’s been, when students present entitled behaviour in their approach of saying ‘I don’t want that one’, it does make us roll our eyes, if it’s not for genuine reasons.

OPs is a genuine reason. Challenging it might be but it's evidently a reason many leave training, I doubt driving 2 hours home after a night shift they think ah its okay the system is fucked I am so grateful.

endofthelinefinally · 08/03/2023 04:42

The worst manager I had literally used her affair with a senior person to get her promotion. She was quite brazen about stealing other people's work - business cases, research proposals and passing them off as her own.
She moved to another trust and was sacked for incompetence within a few months. It is far too common in the NHS IME.

HollaHolla · 07/03/2023 23:29

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 07/03/2023 22:43

I’m glad someone has pointed this out.

There are huge shortages of placement offers across the board and increasing numbers of students to try and fill the current shortfall. This means that you’re often trying to fit 100 students into 80 placements.

Students will (quite rightly) not know the circumstances of colleagues so complaining that someone has a placement close to your home when you don’t know their situation can be counterproductive, but equally human beings can make mistakes. The people arranging placements don’t know every student off the top of their head so sometimes might miss things like this when they’re arranging hundreds of placements maybe drop the administrators or other student an email to say you’ve noticed this thing, is a swap realistic from their perspective and if they say no, accept it.

Finally a note about humility. Again, whilst mistakes are made and it’s helpful to highlight these, students are there to learn and sometimes the people with 10, 20, 30 or more years experience of doing the job that you’re training to do will know more than you. Asking why decisions are made from a place of curiosity rather than criticism is a helpful skill.

(I’d also be wary of any job offering £39k to a newly qualified HCP)

Thanks - yes, good point about ALWAYS being short of placement offers. I’ve actually spent the best part of 5 hours today, trying to get an additional 40 offers for our final year Nursing and Paramedic students. There’s a fair amount of calling in favours to do this, for example. It’s then really falling when a student says they don’t want a placement which has been really difficult to get.
Whilst it’s not the student’s responsibility to know how difficult it’s been, when students present entitled behaviour in their approach of saying ‘I don’t want that one’, it does make us roll our eyes, if it’s not for genuine reasons.

I didn’t like to say that about £39k for a newly qualified NMAHP, but as you have, I’d agree. I’d worry that the expectation on a newly qualified professional could be unreasonable for that money. Obviously, you know the details, OP, but I’d be looking for a role with support of experienced colleagues; and somewhere you will be given the space to seek when needed.

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 07/03/2023 22:43

HollaHolla · 07/03/2023 22:26

Ok. So I’m qualified as an AHP, but work on managing placements for nurses & AHPs in a university.
I’m really sorry you’re finding it tough, but I can give you some explanation around why some decisions might be made (or how they are at my institution.)

Placement locations might not always feel sensible to students. However, we have a requirement to ensure that all students have a wide range of placements - that’s sites and specialities. So, just because there was a placement 20 mins from your house, it doesn’t mean that it was the right one for you at that point of your course. So, in my experience, we ensure students have community, city,,and small local ‘cottage’ hospital experience. They also need acute, A&E, neuro, MH, paeds, maternity, Rehab, etc. It’s a common complaint from students that they have to travel, but it’s not done to be deliberately difficult. The terms of the bursary/reclaim of expenses are such that you can be funded to travel up to 2 hours per way for placement. We try not to do that, especially if you have adjustments, or caring responsibilities, but if you live rurally, for example, it’s hard not to have some placements like that.

Re: your HCA experience not being counted; this is correct. (At least in Scotland, where I am.) Thats because you’re not operating as a nurse/nursing student, and aren’t being asked to undertake the correct competences for assessment. As HCA work isn’t supervised by qualified practice assessors, we cannot say that there’s a consistent approach taken, sadly. You need 2400 hours of the correct type of assessed placement to be allowed to be placed on the register.

Regarding the cock up with your placement not being assessed correctly - that sounds far from correct. A student shouldn’t be asked to redo a placement for those reasons. I’d suggest you involve your students union, to support you in appealing that decision.

I wish you every luck with your future career. Nursing can be the best job in the world - so I’m told!!

I’m glad someone has pointed this out.

There are huge shortages of placement offers across the board and increasing numbers of students to try and fill the current shortfall. This means that you’re often trying to fit 100 students into 80 placements.

Students will (quite rightly) not know the circumstances of colleagues so complaining that someone has a placement close to your home when you don’t know their situation can be counterproductive, but equally human beings can make mistakes. The people arranging placements don’t know every student off the top of their head so sometimes might miss things like this when they’re arranging hundreds of placements maybe drop the administrators or other student an email to say you’ve noticed this thing, is a swap realistic from their perspective and if they say no, accept it.

Finally a note about humility. Again, whilst mistakes are made and it’s helpful to highlight these, students are there to learn and sometimes the people with 10, 20, 30 or more years experience of doing the job that you’re training to do will know more than you. Asking why decisions are made from a place of curiosity rather than criticism is a helpful skill.

(I’d also be wary of any job offering £39k to a newly qualified HCP)

mumda · 07/03/2023 22:33

Loving the adverts for spire healthcare.

HollaHolla · 07/03/2023 22:26

Ok. So I’m qualified as an AHP, but work on managing placements for nurses & AHPs in a university.
I’m really sorry you’re finding it tough, but I can give you some explanation around why some decisions might be made (or how they are at my institution.)

Placement locations might not always feel sensible to students. However, we have a requirement to ensure that all students have a wide range of placements - that’s sites and specialities. So, just because there was a placement 20 mins from your house, it doesn’t mean that it was the right one for you at that point of your course. So, in my experience, we ensure students have community, city,,and small local ‘cottage’ hospital experience. They also need acute, A&E, neuro, MH, paeds, maternity, Rehab, etc. It’s a common complaint from students that they have to travel, but it’s not done to be deliberately difficult. The terms of the bursary/reclaim of expenses are such that you can be funded to travel up to 2 hours per way for placement. We try not to do that, especially if you have adjustments, or caring responsibilities, but if you live rurally, for example, it’s hard not to have some placements like that.

Re: your HCA experience not being counted; this is correct. (At least in Scotland, where I am.) Thats because you’re not operating as a nurse/nursing student, and aren’t being asked to undertake the correct competences for assessment. As HCA work isn’t supervised by qualified practice assessors, we cannot say that there’s a consistent approach taken, sadly. You need 2400 hours of the correct type of assessed placement to be allowed to be placed on the register.

Regarding the cock up with your placement not being assessed correctly - that sounds far from correct. A student shouldn’t be asked to redo a placement for those reasons. I’d suggest you involve your students union, to support you in appealing that decision.

I wish you every luck with your future career. Nursing can be the best job in the world - so I’m told!!

tunamayo81 · 07/03/2023 22:16

Sillykillbill · 07/03/2023 18:48

Absolutely.
Funnily enough I find that some nurses who climb the ladder quickly are not necessarily the best nurses, not even particularly good at management, just extremely loud, confident and opinionated, keen to look good and charm the right people.
I was a band 6 for 5 years in crit care. Good at my job according to my managers, approachable and respected for my knowledge but too bloody nice for my own good, I really couldn't stand the back biting and bitchiness, the cliques, the arse licking and above all, the bone laziness of some staff.

This!!!!!! I’m so sick of seeing mouthy inexperienced staff getting promoted because they managed to charm and manipulate the right people!

Booooot · 07/03/2023 22:09

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 19:53

Awww lovely , my advice is lean on your cohort for support I wouldn't have got this far without my lovely student friends. I will probably be friends with them for life. I pick up bankshifts at MH hospital I do twilight's 19:15 - 0:00 when it's theory time. I get enhancements on the weekends and I still get time to spend with family. It's really helped lighten some of the load financially when every £1 counts.

Ive applied to join the bank but need to have completed 12 weeks if placement first so not long. Just about to finish 7 weeks, so 4 weeks into my next placement I’ll be able to join!

Needsomeadvice33 · 07/03/2023 22:07

@NotAnotherBathBomb I don't care what the nhs can sustain, I'm not a martyr, my health and happiness are all that i consider, perhaps thats why im in the position that I am. My point is not that nurses need to work hard but they need to move away from being a staff nurse in adult general wards if they want any kind of quality of life, unfortunately thats just the way it is as the conditions are just so bad now. I'm qualified in 2 niche areas in post grad studies (currently only work in 1). You need unique skills in unsaturated areas therefore you can command higher salaries. Thats a fact in pretty much every industry, nothing wrong with pointing it out.

AliceS1994 · 07/03/2023 21:54

I'm a nurse, and I really do feel for you. I remember it well it was misery. Since then things haven't got much better, truth be told. I wish I had done something else, I love my job but the conditions are intolerable.

BadNomad · 07/03/2023 21:21

It doesn't get any better, unfortunately. Not if you work for the NHS.

If I had my time again, I would train as a podiatrist instead of a nurse. I might have had my own practice by now, and spend my days visiting old people at home and checking on diabetic feet. Instead of being bitter, jaded and broken. With a bad back.

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 21:09

tunamayo81 · 07/03/2023 20:47

Yeah l,fair enough reasonable adjustments should be made. Be cautious about what you say about your narcolepsy, we have to be ‘fit to practice’ and yours could be called into question.

There's a misconception that fitness to practice means no health issues it doesn't it means you are aware of your limits and work within them . I'm under active treatment , I take medication and I've never had an issue in the workplace and I've worked for years doing shifts . I'm allowed to drive which means my condition is very well controlled . I keep myself well by following the doctors advice I work within my limits so I don't do transition from nights to days quickly it has to be blocks. I also don't drive for long periods if im exhausted. This is none of my choice uni have allocated me a placement which was far and I wouldn't choose it as a job as it would be dangerous.

OP posts:
tunamayo81 · 07/03/2023 20:47

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 20:04

I have narcolepsy, under disability discrimination I should not have unfair treatment putting my placement too far is detrimental to my health. Funny how someone got a placement which was 10 mins from my house. I never received that placement throughout training , I never told the placement it was too slow.

Yeah l,fair enough reasonable adjustments should be made. Be cautious about what you say about your narcolepsy, we have to be ‘fit to practice’ and yours could be called into question.

Sillykillbill · 07/03/2023 20:39

@Battlecat98 so sorry to hear that. You sound like exactly the type of nurse the profession needs to keep. Have you thought about moving to a different non ward based area. As much as I moaned about ICU it's the one place you can give your patient the best care without compromising your standards and pass on your knowledge to students. Also loads of opportunity to do courses and usually a decent preceptorship. Appreciate you'll probably have to drop a band but you will quickly progress after a year or so.
Hope you find a solution whatever you decide to do 💐

Battlecat98 · 07/03/2023 20:26

Sillykillbill · 07/03/2023 18:48

Absolutely.
Funnily enough I find that some nurses who climb the ladder quickly are not necessarily the best nurses, not even particularly good at management, just extremely loud, confident and opinionated, keen to look good and charm the right people.
I was a band 6 for 5 years in crit care. Good at my job according to my managers, approachable and respected for my knowledge but too bloody nice for my own good, I really couldn't stand the back biting and bitchiness, the cliques, the arse licking and above all, the bone laziness of some staff.

This is so true. I am a band 6, ward based, adult nurse, the wards are horrific and the managers do not care at all. I submit datixes as they move staff and leave us so short staffed we cannot take a full break, nothing comes of it.I am having to compromise my professional and personal values, I cannot continue like this, I very nearly had a breakdown and during counselling was told I was suffering from PTSD related to covid. I tried so many times to tell my band 8 that I wasn't coping , I was told it's the same for everyone. The trust did nothing to support me.

So,they are about to lose a highly qualified nurse with 19 years experience.
It's such a shame as I love the patients on the whole, most of my team, I love teaching the students but, I cannot in good conscience continue. I feel completely broken. I am angry as I loved being a nurse but feel I have no choice but to leave. Resilience is thrown around as a 'must have' but, this is simplistic and suggests the nurse is at fault for becoming a victim of a system that treats staff as commodities.

I don't know what to say to you, but you have come so far it would be a shame to stop now. I would never recommend nursing as a career.

Mama05070704 · 07/03/2023 20:12

I feel your pain! I’m a second year student midwife and whilst I absolutely love midwifery, I detest the politics and the chronic understaffing that’s leading to amazing, experienced midwives leaving in droves. I will absolutely complete my training but I am already looking to relocate with my family a few years post qualifying. I hope things improve for you! X

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 20:04

tunamayo81 · 07/03/2023 19:34

It isn’t about’ treat them mean’. There’s a lot of evidence that training at different trusts makes you a better practitioner overall with a more rounded knowledge, and avoids habits developing “because we’ve always done it this way” hence the need to travel. I sympathise with OP but it’s part of the training which she would have been informed of at the offset and agreed to, then she can do what she wants post qualification. Just keep your head down, avoid making arrogant comments about placements being too slow for you and work hard. It’s worth it in the end when the world is your oyster.

I have narcolepsy, under disability discrimination I should not have unfair treatment putting my placement too far is detrimental to my health. Funny how someone got a placement which was 10 mins from my house. I never received that placement throughout training , I never told the placement it was too slow.

OP posts:
9outof10cats · 07/03/2023 19:54

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 19:48

You will be an absolute asset there's so many issues of poor physical health in MH. I'm actually grateful they have changed the training to include all branch skills. All nurses should get placements in all fields. They should use their brains though if you have prior experience , you should be able to use it. I have done palliative care a lot as a HCA , I can't use it as practice experience for signing off.

Thank you, that is one of my objectives, to rebalance the poor health outcomes among people with SMI.

I think adult and mental health should be amalgamated and not taught as two separate subjects because it's a given fact that physical and mental health are intertwined.

Fifi0000 · 07/03/2023 19:53

Booooot · 07/03/2023 18:34

Im a first year mental health nurse on my first placement and im already thinking of leaving. Its been so shit. 3 hours of driving a day to a team that very clearly dont want me there. Ive done nothing in 7 weeks. Not ticked off a single proficiency. My hair is literally falling out through stress. Ive had to quit my job because they never got back to me about negotiating hours so that’s added financial stress on my husband. We have 2 kids. Can’t even submit my mileage claim ad the placement forgot I was coming so never got an assessor in so there was no one to sign off my timesheets. On top of that ive had assessments and exams during the placement. Was supposed to find out my next placement last Monday but still haven’t heard anything.

Awww lovely , my advice is lean on your cohort for support I wouldn't have got this far without my lovely student friends. I will probably be friends with them for life. I pick up bankshifts at MH hospital I do twilight's 19:15 - 0:00 when it's theory time. I get enhancements on the weekends and I still get time to spend with family. It's really helped lighten some of the load financially when every £1 counts.

OP posts:
Sillykillbill · 07/03/2023 19:50

All for whistle blowing but there's a time and a place for challenging poor care.
If you are undermining senior staff in public, big mistake and a sure fire way to piss possibly more experienced staff off.