Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect the school to complete the syllabus

60 replies

user1456882310 · 07/03/2023 07:33

Dds School haven't managed to cover half the Physics GCSE topics and have whole chapters left to do in Chemistry and Biology. School recognise its"not ideal" but have no contingency other than to cram lessons together and pick areas the kids just do themselves.
Dd very worried as these are her chosen A levels.
Advice pls

OP posts:
ThrallsWife · 07/03/2023 18:04

The Biology syllabus is always far longer than both Chemistry and Physics, by sheer number of lessons - it has been this way since I started teaching. When schools were not under pressure to extend KS3 to a full 3 years instead of being allowed to allow us to cover the syllabus for GCSE properly after SATs in Y9 went we usually finished teaching by Christmas and revised thereafter - not always ideal either, partially as Y9 are not mature enough to understand some of the more complex Chemistry especially, but doable.

Now we're in a situation where the content has expanded under Gove, but schools have been told to spend less time on GCSE teaching - and don't forget that Y10 and 11 are not two full years; they are one year and 5 months. Then we have mock exams in all subjects (4 weeks of teaching lost), a few bank holidays and INSET days and we could easily have lost a whole half-term's worth of lessons, so are down to a year and 3 months. Then fit in mental health workshops, mock interviews, PSHE days, trips and we're suddenly down to barely more than a year in which we have to teach the content designed for two full years.

Oh, and there are no Science teachers - we have 3 current vacancies and zero applications.

Changechangechanging · 07/03/2023 18:00

They must have seen this coming as even at Christmas mocks couldn't cover a full paper one as hadn't done the topics

Not a science teacher but I rarely complete a spec before Easter. There is so much packed in, unfortunately.

It is highly unlikely that it has been planned this way - teacher illness, maternity leaves, supply staff shortages, poor pupil behaviour, timing of lessons (lessons regularly missed because of the unexpected - fire alarms, Queen’s funeral, internal drip-down days etc). can all have an impact on ability to get through things.

Approach the school carefully, OP. You have no idea what they have been dealing with. For everyone else, stop voting Tory.

Frlrlrubert · 07/03/2023 17:50

Pottedpalm · 07/03/2023 17:29

As a maths teacher I would not be happy to be ‘directed’ to teach Science. It would mean
a lot of extra preparation of unfamiliar material, and even worse if the class were revising as they could be needing help with pretty much anything!

True. I don't think the Science teachers 'directed' to teach maths at my previous school were too happy either, but in an 'oh shit they've not done half the physics spec' situation....

Fair point about some schools not doing the spec in order, I always forget that, I've always working in schools that have roughly followed the spec, precisely so they can use paper 1s as early mocks. But OP did say they'd done less than half for Physics.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 07/03/2023 17:33

MrsHamlet · 07/03/2023 16:45

The maths teacher will be teaching maths. It's not their job or their responsibility to deal with physics

Unless Things have drastically changed, all of mechanics is maths. I’m sure the maths teachers could cover that part.

Pottedpalm · 07/03/2023 17:30

I would suggest paying for tutoring.

Pottedpalm · 07/03/2023 17:29

As a maths teacher I would not be happy to be ‘directed’ to teach Science. It would mean
a lot of extra preparation of unfamiliar material, and even worse if the class were revising as they could be needing help with pretty much anything!

Abraxan · 07/03/2023 17:26

321gogogo · 07/03/2023 17:16

No, you are not being unreasonable. We have similar here in 1 subject, as the teacher has been off sick more than she's been in the last 2 years

That may not be the teacher's fault though, unless you have reason to believe they are taking advantage.
Even with an absent teacher the lessons should be covered by supply/cover person and the lesson plans followed. Not ideal but better than just not doing anything.

321gogogo · 07/03/2023 17:16

No, you are not being unreasonable. We have similar here in 1 subject, as the teacher has been off sick more than she's been in the last 2 years

redskylight · 07/03/2023 17:13

For science Paper 1 is the first half of the spec. If they couldn't do a paper 1 as a mock they'd covered less than half the spec. That's not normal by December of Year 11.

Only if they study the modules in the same order as the specification ... Not being able to complete a paper only means they have at least 2 modules left.

Frlrlrubert · 07/03/2023 17:05

Redbone · 07/03/2023 12:52

To be honest, the school are not at fault if they had not completed all of the specifications before the mocks at Christmas. I have never taught at a school yet where this has been done. Furthermore, it it very difficult to cover every little detail.
I had exactly the same issue with one of my son’s school several years ago. Several parents complained and extra lessons were given, albeit only to the boys of the parents who had complained!

For science Paper 1 is the first half of the spec. If they couldn't do a paper 1 as a mock they'd covered less than half the spec. That's not normal by December of Year 11.

Back when we were 'allowed' to start in Year 9 we'd finished the whole spec by January.

I've been in schools where how many hours in timetable a subject is allocated is a wrangle between the HoD and the Head. Sometimes science just doesn't get enough. But, OP saying they are further on in Biology and Chemistry than Physics suggests teacher shortage/illness.

Maths teacher could absolutely be directed to teach Physics (I've known it happen the opposite way a few times). Might not be the best at it but better than nothing at all.

MrsHamlet · 07/03/2023 16:45

The maths teacher will be teaching maths. It's not their job or their responsibility to deal with physics

Nimbostratus100 · 07/03/2023 15:20

lanthanum · 07/03/2023 13:23

If they've completed the maths syllabus, it might not be a bad idea for the maths teacher to do some of the science with them. They won't like it - it will be outside their comfort zone, and they'd rather be maximising the maths grades than helping out their science colleagues, but it is in the pupils' best interests. Even if it's only "helping them with their independent learning" it's likely to be better than leaving them to do it completely on their own. (And perhaps the school might allocate more time to science and less to maths next year...)

It is unlikely that the maths teacher will have the right skill set

lanthanum · 07/03/2023 13:23

user1456882310 · 07/03/2023 10:54

Thankyou All,
Nimbostratus interesting points ,its a top set in a 'nice ' girls school and the same class finished maths at Christmas so I don't think its behaviour.
I think it's more the 'we've run out of class time 'so you need to do these whole topics( SB9 ) yourself,rather than the independent learning that bothers me.
Along with no opportunity for exam prep.
I am lucky in that I can support her and will get workbooks ect.
Catonthehat its edexcel board .
I have written to the head head rather than the head of science this morning.
We will see what can be done

If they've completed the maths syllabus, it might not be a bad idea for the maths teacher to do some of the science with them. They won't like it - it will be outside their comfort zone, and they'd rather be maximising the maths grades than helping out their science colleagues, but it is in the pupils' best interests. Even if it's only "helping them with their independent learning" it's likely to be better than leaving them to do it completely on their own. (And perhaps the school might allocate more time to science and less to maths next year...)

Redbone · 07/03/2023 12:52

To be honest, the school are not at fault if they had not completed all of the specifications before the mocks at Christmas. I have never taught at a school yet where this has been done. Furthermore, it it very difficult to cover every little detail.
I had exactly the same issue with one of my son’s school several years ago. Several parents complained and extra lessons were given, albeit only to the boys of the parents who had complained!

Iyjd · 07/03/2023 12:20

My class probably won’t finish theirs either. My SOW is designed to cover it all but if I have a class that just doesn’t understand a concept it delays us because we can’t move on until they understand it, therefore something drops off the end. I used to come in over Easter and do 2 revision days but I have read so much bile about teachers recently I’ve decided not to bother. Plenty of the bile has been repeated at us by students. We have also lost days because of external reasons. A large amount of “low level” behaviour problems are another contributing factor, children doing the odd whisper builds up to hours of lost learning.

Our ofsted recently dropped too with the only criticism being that we did a 3 year GCSE instead of 2, so I’m not sure what I will be cutting out of next years SOW.

How many times a day do you hear people question “why isn’t this taught in school” we have loads of things that we have to now squeeze in that we never used to that takes up time, we have a limited amount of time a day we can’t just put extra in.

user1456882310 · 07/03/2023 11:21

Wow that sounds like amazingly proactive approach.

Free science is an excellent tip and will look at primrose too

OP posts:
Catspyjamas17 · 07/03/2023 11:19

Used to happen 30/40 years ago. Or pupils got taught entirely the wrong syllabus for the exam board.

CharodNeDu · 07/03/2023 11:17

At Ds's school they fast tracked a class of 30 students to single sciences from combined near the end of year 10. They did some Saturday mornings and at least 1 lesson a week after school to cover this new content. In year 11 all the children were shuffled into a new form with a form teacher who could bring up their grade as form was 30 minutes every morning. What I am trying to say is that school was very proactive in covering the whole of single sciences. It is a state school too. They can't just throw their arms up and say sorry.

Both my sons used Free Science Lessons on YouTube as he covers all the content whether combined or single sciences, also Primrose Kitten does a run through of all topics too. Very helpful.

user1456882310 · 07/03/2023 10:56

Redbone I think that is what really bothers me. They must have seen this coming as even at Christmas mocks couldn't cover a full paper one as hadn't done the topics

OP posts:
user1456882310 · 07/03/2023 10:54

Thankyou All,
Nimbostratus interesting points ,its a top set in a 'nice ' girls school and the same class finished maths at Christmas so I don't think its behaviour.
I think it's more the 'we've run out of class time 'so you need to do these whole topics( SB9 ) yourself,rather than the independent learning that bothers me.
Along with no opportunity for exam prep.
I am lucky in that I can support her and will get workbooks ect.
Catonthehat its edexcel board .
I have written to the head head rather than the head of science this morning.
We will see what can be done

OP posts:
Redbone · 07/03/2023 09:19

I was a secondary school teacher. This is simply not acceptable and shows that the teachers, or more likely the heads of department, have not planned their schemes of work properly. I would insist on speaking to someone higher in the school to ask if they were aware of this situation as it is highly unprofessional. (No doubt they will try to blame Covid.)
Moving forward, is it possible for her to have a couple of sessions of private tuition in these subjects over Easter?

CatOnTheChair · 07/03/2023 08:35

I think a lot of it is a covid hang over. The kids have missed to much - or not taken on board - many fundamentals that were remotely taught when schools were shut that each topic is taking longer to get through, as the recap bit is requiring much longer.
If she is following the AQA syllabus, I'd get a set of the Oxford Revise books. Other boards I don't know although CGP would likely do the job.

Nimbostratus100 · 07/03/2023 08:23

It isn't shocking, or unusual

School can plan to complete the spec, but all sorts of things can prevent it

largely, no staffing, teacher absence, no funding for supply staff, school carrying vacancies it can't fill, merging classes, etc

No resources, changed to the spec, that schools can't fund

Poor behaviour, disruptive children - the number of parents that say "they are only a bit chatty, so what" well guess what, it impacts on everybody's education hugely - who'd've thought it!

Students just not working fast enough - not completing homework, lazy, or SEND, term time holidays, absences etc

In may schools, including mine, it is approached differently - we don't plan to finish the spec, knowing we will be unlikely to do so. Instead, we inform students early on which parts of the spec they will be covering independently, so they can make a start on it, and have lesson times to bring up any questions they are struggling with

It is completely normal for some of the spec to be done independently - GCSE students should know what spec they are on for all subjects, and keep track of what has been covered, what they are strong or weak on, and what the school is not covering. The only difference is whether these are planned gaps, or just the gaps left at the end of the course.

Petrarkanian · 07/03/2023 08:15

Did she do a 2 or 3 year gcse course? The school I work at decided to do it over 3 years. I disagreed at first, but over time I've come to see it really does work better.

I'd get the cgp books and start working through them. Get copies of past papers, if she's bright she'll be fine learning it herself.

WonderingWanda · 07/03/2023 08:09

Can you afford to get her a private tutor? It sounds like some dreadful planning to be honest. Can they recommend any online materials? I teach a different subject so I don't know what would be good for sciences but we use Seneca, gcse pod, quizlet and some subject specific websites.

Swipe left for the next trending thread