Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone actually like hot desking and/or open plan?

110 replies

BMXsummoner · 07/03/2023 06:51

I’ve recently started working for a company that does hot desking in a very open plan space. Prior to this I had always either had my own office (albeit entirely glassed so anyone nearby could see what I was doing) or my own desk in a cubicle type setup. Reasons I hate it:

  • wasting a minimum of 5 minutes every morning and afternoon getting everything I need for the day out of my locker (power cables, headset, notebook, water bottle etc.) and getting set up at my workstation and then packing it all away again at the end of the day
  • related, nowhere (like a set of desk drawers) that is convenient to store anything that would make my workday easier or nicer (snacks, extra stationery, painkillers, cardigan for when the office temperature is set to freezing)
  • further time wasted if the work station I choose is defective and the monitors don’t work or connect to my laptop
  • drab, impersonal workplace where no one can put up photos etc.
  • putting up with all the inconsiderate arseholes in the office (the pen clicker, the chuckler, the stinker, the guy who gets 11ty million phone calls a day with his loud obnoxious ringtone)

I fucking hate it. I get why companies might think it’s a great idea (all the bullshit about fostering team work while saving money on floor space) but do any workers actually like it??

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/03/2023 07:41

ThisMarmiteDog · 07/03/2023 07:36

I hate it because invariably there were good seats that people hogged and gave you a dirty look for daring to hot desk in their favourite spot. There was also 'reserving' seats for their favourite mates. Maybe my open plan hot desking workplace is shit but it reminded me of school where you moved from one class to the other and kids would block off seats for their mates or hog all the best spots. It made the first half an hour of the working day awkward. I prefer everyone knows where they sit in advance and stick to it or just work from home which is amazing.

This wouldn’t wash at all where I work (civil service). I can’t imagine people getting away with saving seats like this!

In my old dept you had to book desks before arriving which you’d think was similar but actually works well, because then everyone knows which desk they’re going to. It also stops the (broadly )8-4 people feeling superior to the (broadly) 10-6 people! Not saying we just work those fixed hours but as an example of equal work days.

ThisMarmiteDog · 07/03/2023 07:41

I found it harder to make phone calls and concentrate in open plan. It was so fucking noisy and interruptions all the time. Around lunch time there is a competition of hot food smells, there is a lot of chatter and noise, machines noise, phones ringing and not getting answered. Open plan are a nightmare if you're an introvert or sensitive to noise and distractions.

Aftjbtibg · 07/03/2023 07:40

The only part I like is that you get to sit with different people from your team and if you sit in a bad spot you can sit somewhere else next time. Although often people have their regular seats anyway. We’re in and out of the office in my role so I understand why they do it but I now have to wipe all equipment down too as I’ve got so many illnesses through sharing computers

TaRaDeBumDeAy · 07/03/2023 07:39

I detest open plan. I work fully remote now and will never go back.

wonderinglywondering · 07/03/2023 07:39

Never hot desked but I used to work in an open plan office before WFH and loved it. We did some personality tests at work recently and found it so interesting that people’s ideal workspace can be so different. I get quite fed up WFH so have to have radio/podcasts on in the background. But appreciate some people want silence and a cosy enclosed space to concentrate. My old office was open plan, but had “pods” and little sheds you could work in if you needed quiet and alone time.

ThisMarmiteDog · 07/03/2023 07:38

There are also colleagues who insist on sitting next to the window but then moan if we wanted it open.
There are colleagues who eat on their desk so their keyboard is disgusting.
There are colleagues to rip little tiny shreds of paper and leave their desk a mess.
There are colleagues who change the settings of computer, chair, keyboard is raised and they don't return things to how they were. They faff about in the morning setting it all up and then clock off 5 minutes early to do their packing up routine.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/03/2023 07:38

I’ve never really not had it, so it seems normal to me.

It does allow wfh so that’s one plus.

I find it quite sociable and nice to be around colleagues but that might be due to wfh the rest of the time.

WombatBombat · 07/03/2023 07:37

I’m mid 30s and have never worked in any other set up.

ThisMarmiteDog · 07/03/2023 07:36

I hate it because invariably there were good seats that people hogged and gave you a dirty look for daring to hot desk in their favourite spot. There was also 'reserving' seats for their favourite mates. Maybe my open plan hot desking workplace is shit but it reminded me of school where you moved from one class to the other and kids would block off seats for their mates or hog all the best spots. It made the first half an hour of the working day awkward. I prefer everyone knows where they sit in advance and stick to it or just work from home which is amazing.

ChilliBandit · 07/03/2023 07:35

@MajorCarolDanvers - I find that the people who are trying to recreate the old style of working take a while to set themselves up. They have laptop stands and want a specific chair and lay out snacks etc. No criticism of them making it more comfortable for themselves but I’ve definitely noticed those who are vocal about hating hot desking do take a while to set up in the morning.

Sugarfree23 · 07/03/2023 07:34

Open plan has advantages that you can hear and chat to people, removes some of the loneliness that people have. But at the same time I think they can be too big and noisy.

I don't like hotdesks. I can ever get the chair to be comfy.

Greendoorsaremyfavourite · 07/03/2023 07:34

It's the noise I struggle with in big open plan offices. I don't mind the actual hot decking as long as they're clean & no equipment is missing.

TelevisionIcon · 07/03/2023 07:32

We had open plan and then went open plan hot desk. We don't have nearly enough hot desks (there is some recommended ratio, like 80% or something, we are WELL below that), people are booking out meeting rooms to work, and often I end up working in the canteen, or another non-desk space, hunched over the laptop. Whats the point of coming in then? If I wanted to work in my kitchen or a cafe I would. I never sit anywhere near my team so still have no idea about who they are or their personalities. We do have desk booking system, but people book and then dont show up, its a disaster.

I liked open plan with my own desk - I think that can foster a lot of culture and relationships as people ask about what is on your desk, or someone chucks a ball around or something. You know who is next to you (although yeah, sucks if its next to the gross person). Even cubicles were nice earlier in my career.

One thing Ive done since going to hot desking just before the pandemic was pack a specific backpack with everything Ill need. Painkillers, extra charging cords, snacks, pens, my office pass. That way I just need to insert laptop and go. I do have a locker but I havent opened it since October 2019 and no idea what is in there anymore!

ChilliBandit · 07/03/2023 07:31

PurpleParrotfish · 07/03/2023 07:28

I remembered reading an article about research on how workers were much happier when given some degree of control over their office environment (i.e. the opposite of hot desking). I can’t find it now but did find this review of research into open plan offices. Conclusion - they’re generally not good for workers.

Yes I read something about the happiest workers had a door they could close, a window they could open and a wall they could bash their head against (that last bit was a joke obviously!). Offices/desks round the edges of the room next to windows were ideal but a lot of places now reserve these premium spots for meeting rooms etc.

PurpleParrotfish · 07/03/2023 07:30

I guess if people rarely go into the office and work from home a lot of the time then the psychological impact of having no control over one’s workspace in the office is much less.

Whycanineverever · 07/03/2023 07:29

We have an app you book your seat on - makes life easy as we have our own areas and so generally sit in the same desk each time we are in. Only issue is if I come in on a day that isn't our 'teams' I am never quite sure where to book my desk......

PurpleParrotfish · 07/03/2023 07:28

I remembered reading an article about research on how workers were much happier when given some degree of control over their office environment (i.e. the opposite of hot desking). I can’t find it now but did find this review of research into open plan offices. Conclusion - they’re generally not good for workers.

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/03/2023 07:26

Although to add I only go to the office when I need to see people face to face. Utterly pointless to go there for zoom meetings. I can do that at home.

MajorCarolDanvers · 07/03/2023 07:24

I only go to the office a few days a month.

Hot desking means it's nice and tidy instead of the cluttered nests people used to build.

I take a rucksack with the stuff I need.

I haven't noticed it taking loads of wasted time to sit down and get started.

I've worked in open plan for many years. It's normal.

Littlewhitecat · 07/03/2023 07:24

I like it but if been doing it for 10 years before the pandemic. People who cover their desk with personal stuff are just as annoying as the pen clickers (and they are usually the ones who claim to have medical reasons for needing a window desk). Only irritation with it now is that my office doesn't have many small meeting rooms so taking confidential teams calls can be difficult.

ChilliBandit · 07/03/2023 07:23

I’ve been doing it for nearly 10 yrs now although last two I mainly WFH. I don’t mind the hot desking as a principle, I found the need to have numerous pictures of children etc a bit much. Although one place I worked never had enough desks so if you got in on time but not early you could end up hunched over in a stupid armchair in a “break out zone” with your laptop on your lap.

I would love an office or booth though. I’ve read things that talk about how terrible open plan is for productivity and mental health. Probably why lots of people are so much happier WFH, me included.

Zanatdy · 07/03/2023 07:23

It makes economical sense. Especially now many companies work hybrid. They can buy smaller buildings. We have been doing it 10yrs plus and entirely used to it. I just take out my laptop from my bag and plug it in and make a brew. I don’t need a ton of stuff on my desk and neither does anyone in my team. We all have a locker and a small tub for any desk essentials but I don’t bother

PandasAreUseless · 07/03/2023 07:17

I like it, but only go into the office twice a week. I save all of my work that matters for when I'm at home because I just CANNOT concentrate. I've also had people being gobby behind me when I've been on a client call, which I found so distracting.
But I do like the 'agile' vibe of sitting wherever. I think I like that it feels modern, which is a totally twatty thing to say!
I just wish I could store salt and pepper somewhere for my lunchtime salad!

ScottBakula · 07/03/2023 07:17

I am with you @BMXsummoner , I haven't had a desk job for a few years now but I had to hot desk when I did.
I didnt put photos up or have desk toys but it made my life easier if I could leave documents out ( nothing confidential) .
I used to leave them out in order of importance so when I got in the following morning I could jyst pick up the top one and get on with it .
It also ment I could have the back support on 'my' chair and foot rest that made sitting more comfortable.

It was open plan but set up with desk walls so people couldn't spread put on to my desk , something that drove me mad when they were removed .

LlynTegid · 07/03/2023 07:13

I don't, though accept it as a by-product of only going into an office for one or two days a week.

The people with no consideration for others should be tackled. They are work colleagues not your friends and so if they dislike you for it, that's their problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread