Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone actually like hot desking and/or open plan?

110 replies

BMXsummoner · 07/03/2023 06:51

I’ve recently started working for a company that does hot desking in a very open plan space. Prior to this I had always either had my own office (albeit entirely glassed so anyone nearby could see what I was doing) or my own desk in a cubicle type setup. Reasons I hate it:

  • wasting a minimum of 5 minutes every morning and afternoon getting everything I need for the day out of my locker (power cables, headset, notebook, water bottle etc.) and getting set up at my workstation and then packing it all away again at the end of the day
  • related, nowhere (like a set of desk drawers) that is convenient to store anything that would make my workday easier or nicer (snacks, extra stationery, painkillers, cardigan for when the office temperature is set to freezing)
  • further time wasted if the work station I choose is defective and the monitors don’t work or connect to my laptop
  • drab, impersonal workplace where no one can put up photos etc.
  • putting up with all the inconsiderate arseholes in the office (the pen clicker, the chuckler, the stinker, the guy who gets 11ty million phone calls a day with his loud obnoxious ringtone)

I fucking hate it. I get why companies might think it’s a great idea (all the bullshit about fostering team work while saving money on floor space) but do any workers actually like it??

OP posts:
cobblers123 · 07/03/2023 08:59

I'm retired but when working I didn't mind the open plan so much, but the hot desking varied between being ok to being really annoying.

Some people were decorating their desks with so many pictures of their relatives, kids, pets etc., those silly tiny toys from cereal packets, fancy pen holders that took up half the desk etc. you spent about ten minutes clearing an area to work in.

Then there was cleaning the desk and keyboard before trying to adjust the chair and the footrest and eventually log on.

So glad I don't have to put up with that any more.

TheGuv1982 · 07/03/2023 08:58

Oh god, the shit people used to have on their desks and in pedestal drawers before hot-desking was vile. One of my first IT jobs involved lots of time spent trying to sort faults out at peoples desks, wading through filthy cups, mouldy fruit and tissues…so many tissues.

My view is with the widespread introduction of hot-desking, offices are certainly tidier and companies can reduce their footprint due to not needing a desk for everyone. it’s easier to maintain as well.

I’ve seen some companies do hot desking/open plan better than others. My last one had different areas for collaborative work, quite spaces and “normal” banks of desks.

My current one is just big standard hot-desking, with loads of background noise and people moving about to talk to people in their team they couldn’t get a desk next to.

I can’t imagine going back to fixed desks, or a “private” office. I would presume it would come with an expectation to be on site much more.

catshreddedthesofa · 07/03/2023 08:53

I didn't love it when we first started doing it around 6-7 years ago, but now I find it fine.

I bring what I need with me in my bag and it means I don't build up piles of stuff on a desk.

I don't even have a locker now, just what comes with me in my backpack. It's very freeing. Can work from anywhere and it's no trouble.

BeeBB · 07/03/2023 08:53

Fortunately, I still have a desk I can use in an office on my own one day a week. I have a docking station on the desk and I bring in my laptop and headphones.

However, someone else uses the office space when I’m not in and they always leave evidence of this be it crumbs, hairs, faint coffee stain rings, smells etc. I would much rather be at home in my own space or have an office or a desk that only I use. Although no office photos is a blessing.

Also the desk is meant to be sanitised after use but this person is obviously oblivious and unable to read and understand the emails and the notice in the desk relating to this.

I hate open plan offices from years ago trying to concentrate with all the inane chatter, people with loud voices talking nonsense full volume on the phone, someone taking an eternity to chomp through a massive crunchy salad, people eating sushi or egg sarnies etc etc.

nosyupnorth · 07/03/2023 08:49

I don't have any experience hot desking, but I feel like I'd hate it. I was annoyed enough when they took away our desk drawers.

As for open plan, it depends on the size of the space and the type of work. I'd be fine with sharing an open plan space with my department of less than a dozen people or even another team who does mostly quiet work, but being in a big open plan office of 50 people including phonelines to service users who frequently struggle to hear so the person speaking to them has to talk very loudly and repeat themselves a lot can be absolutely maddening when trying to focus.

megletthesecond · 07/03/2023 08:48

I like open plan as I'm essentially quite nosy and like overhearing personal and work chats. I can't focus when it's quiet.

We don't hot desk though, I'd hate that. I like working with my team, we're hybrid but we know who's in when.

Catspyjamas17 · 07/03/2023 08:40

VerityUnreasonble · 07/03/2023 07:56

I hate it for the following reasons:

Open plan office is too loud. Can't concentrate. Can't make delicate client calls.

I have chronic pain / fatigue and carrying bag with laptop / drink / notebook leaves me feeling shit by the time I arrive.

I'm short. I have to adjust every chair I sit on. I imagine whoever since on them after me hates it too.

Shoehorned more people into the office than there are parking for by a very long way.

Yes, every place I've worked has made a thing of checking your workstation set up, so that it isn't causing you eye or back problems, or RSI.

Catspyjamas17 · 07/03/2023 08:37

I've worked in several open plan offices, never had hot desking though thank goodness.

I have my own office now and you can prise it from my cold, dead hands.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 07/03/2023 08:32

I think its unprofessional to have photos and other desk personalisation in the workplace- you always got some people who took it too far.

I dont mind most of the elements of hot dealing- it's good to sit next to a variety of people etc...however we dont have lockers so I hate not having anywhere to store things like shoes (used to wear trainers for commute and change at work), hand cream (office air is v drying), deodorant in case I forgot in the morning etc. I shove some paracetamol and tea bags (I drink fruit tea and we only have builders) in my bag but if you're in the office a few times a week its irritating to not have available all the stuff I used to have in my drawers

hahahalloumi · 07/03/2023 08:30

It’s fine if you’re only in a bit. It would not be ok full time.

rampagingrobot · 07/03/2023 08:26

It's much better to be colocated with your team than each person in their own office. Greatly reduces the friction of communicating and working together.

The problem is with hybrid working, a lot of places haven't adapted their space by adding breakout spaces for people to do teams calls, so people have them at their desk which is disruptive. I do end up wearing headphones a lot which feels quite anti social, but people know they are welcome to still wave at me if they have something to discuss.

I like hotdesking when I always have the same desk 😆 it means people clear their desks and the office doesn't just end full of clutter and junk like it used to. But then I only need a laptop to work. Actual hotdesking where you have to find a random desk and would be nowhere near my team would suck, and be very detrimental to our work.

FrostyFifi · 07/03/2023 08:20

@WorkingWhileStressed totally with you on this one. ASD and worked 15 years in an open plan office and struggled for many reasons.
At least I had my own space, hot-desking would have finished me.
I now WFH and will never go back to an office environment.

gannett · 07/03/2023 08:17

I found open plan unutterably grim when I did it. Too much noise - the annoying chatter type of noise. Temperature always wrong (usually too hot). Too many people bothering you with nonsense (but somehow never around when you needed an answer to something). Never felt as relaxed as I do in my own space. Completely unconducive to good work.

I don't have any strong feelings about hot desking, I've done it but only as a short-term thing (shift work for a couple of weeks, or travel work for a for days) so it's always had an end period. Would hate it as a long-term thing as it's basically the same shit as open plan but without even being able to rely on your own desk.

Abmaniput · 07/03/2023 08:14

I’m less bothered about open-plan than I am about the shrinking space available at work pre-Covid. When I started working, if you didn’t have an office, you at least had a chunky spacious desk. ‘Desks’ now are small flimsy planks that are generally bolted to the surrounding desks in lines. As a result I’m too close to everyone around me for comfort and the bolted together aspect makes me feel like a galley slave.

I actually prefer hot-desking if I have to be in that environment as at least I won’t end up consigned to a shit desk until the next shake-up.

A crappy little plank of mdf with the option to go and sit in a booth or on a sofa when they’re available is no substitute for a decent workspace.

FrenchandSaunders · 07/03/2023 08:08

@ChristmasCakeAndGin that’s what our office set up is like …. book a desk and turn up to find Jim’s egg sandwich remains on the keyboard and facial hair 🤮

Swiftswatch · 07/03/2023 08:01

The reality is hot desking is an economic decision by businesses. If they provided desks for eveyone when they work on a hybrid or it even flexi system it would cost significantly more and would result in lower salaries.
There’s also a cultural shift away from visible hierarchies in the form of individual offices which I don’t think is a bad thing.

I don’t have an issue with open plan. I might as well just work from home if I’m going to be sat in a room by myself anyway.

I sit at an open plan desk and move to a focus area or pod if I have a video call or need some concentration time.

Brightshinylight · 07/03/2023 08:01

Hot desking is great as long as everyone is flexible.

however some people have ‘their own’ hot desk, and groups have their preferred corner. This leads to a desk is lava situation when you try a pick a desk no one wants or you may suddenly find yourself in a group where you are treated like a bad smell no one wants.

VerityUnreasonble · 07/03/2023 07:56

I hate it for the following reasons:

Open plan office is too loud. Can't concentrate. Can't make delicate client calls.

I have chronic pain / fatigue and carrying bag with laptop / drink / notebook leaves me feeling shit by the time I arrive.

I'm short. I have to adjust every chair I sit on. I imagine whoever since on them after me hates it too.

Shoehorned more people into the office than there are parking for by a very long way.

WorkingWhileStressed · 07/03/2023 07:54

Open plan and hot desking not just annoying for many people, it's indirectly discriminatory for people with neurodiversity.

I have dyslexia and dyspraxia and it even bloody says in my occupational psychologist's assessment that trying to work in an open plan office will be hugely detrimental to my productivity.

However, no employer will actually let me work mostly or entirely remote, even when I point out that it's a valid reasonable adjustment. I am always treated like a diva or not a team player and told that it can't be permitted and "everyone has to do X number of anchor days in the office, that's the rule".

What they fail to understand is anchor days in the office become masses of work that I then have to complete on my evenings or weekends because it's impossible for me to focus in an open plan office.

The pandemic was the happiest and most productive period of my working life, because I was entirely remote and could finally get my work completed within working hours. It's depressing how many employers are forcing everyone back into open-plan.

ChristmasCakeAndGin · 07/03/2023 07:49

If hot desking means that you sit down at an empty desk, using your own laptop, keyboard and mouse, then ok.
If it means you sit down at a workstation, and use a keyboard/mouse used by other people. Yuk!
Imagine the person in your office who chomps crisps at their desk, eats apples and types at the same time, doesn't wash their hands, sneezes. Aargh. I've got anxiety even thinking about it.

10 years ago we had a team of cleaners who wiped down all the desks each night, now the single cleaner runs a hoover up the middle of the office and my desk has had the same coffee ring marks on it for weeks (I'm not cleaning them off myself as an experiment to see how often they clean!)

Also it's funny how the bosses almost always either bag the same desk or just must have a private office.

namejump · 07/03/2023 07:46

I don't think employers care whether employees like it or not, it's flexible and thus more financially palatable.

redskylight · 07/03/2023 07:44

Hot desking is better than home as I don't have to clear all the tech equipment away every day! I literally turn up, plug in my laptop, take my few things out my bag and I'm away. 2 minutes at best. Much quicker than moving furniture and plugging in monitors at the beginning and end of every day (yes, I realise that some people have dedicated office spaces at home and don't have this issue).

My company has a policy that you can have a permanent desk if you are in more than 3 days a week. And we've fallen into an unspoken rhythm that people tend to work in the same hot desk every time, so get used to having their own space to some degree. I can't imagine having a total free for all hot desk area - people tend to want to sit with people they know/close colleagues?

ThisMarmiteDog · 07/03/2023 07:42

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing yeah see that's better at least there is an organised system I can work with that but arriving early and then hogging seats with your bag and coat and giving you dirty or disappointed looks that you dared sit near them is horrid. I promise I don't smell or talk loudly lol

TheBrokenCracker · 07/03/2023 07:42

I saw this recently which covered a lot of it for me. (Better on LinkedIn but for some reason I can’t copy and paste that)

LakieLady · 07/03/2023 07:42

I only go in to the office for supervision or meetings now, but we've hot desked for 16 years.

I hate it. I have some specific adaptations because of arthritis. There's nowhere to keep my keyboard (we have lockers, but not big enough for a keyboard), I have to hunt half the building for my chair, which has always been adjusted despite being labelled "do not adjust", my footrest, and unless I'm lucky enough to get a seat near a window, I end up with a migraine because of the shit lighting.

In my previous role (same organisation and building) we had an office of our own and the 2 of us with adaptations had dedicated desks.

Thankfully, we've been exempt from the requirement to be back in the office 20% of the time, because we do a lot of calls that discuss very personal stuff with clients. No-one wants to listen to me asking people how precisely their incontinence affects them when I'm doing a PIP form!