Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sue camhs by myself?

117 replies

Legalhelpneed · 06/03/2023 17:35

Shamelessly posting here to get lots of replies. DD is almost 21 and was diagnosed with ASD just before her 18th bday. This was despite her being under CAMHS for 5+ years, with me constantly suggesting she might be autisitic. They did not believe me because she masked at appointments and at school (when she went... Her attendance was about 30% for years 10, 11 and 12 and she eventually dropped out of school half way through 6th form). As a result of her late diagnosis her late childhood and teenage years were ruined for her; she self-harmed and tried to kill herself several times, she missed out on education, my marriage broke down, I suffered from depression and anxiety myself. DD was bullied mercilessly by her peers and was offered no support from the school because she had no diagnosis and they didn't believe me. DD would've probably been entitled to DLA and she now gets middle rate PIP which has improved her quality of life considerably. She missed out on riding for the disabled and the local autism charity's youth groups and summer camps where she could have made friends. She missed out on going to a school for autistic kids which would've, I think, really suited her.

DD and I spoke to a solicitor today who said it's too late to bring a claim as the 3 years where a claim could be submitted are almost up. Would it be totally mad to bring a claim ourselves? Thank you

OP posts:
katieg03 · 06/03/2023 19:18

Chickenly · 06/03/2023 18:45

This would be an awful idea for many reasons.

  1. You don’t have an entitlement to many aspects of your claim. Therefore, you won’t be awarded damages for not getting them.
  2. It would be your DD who would need to bring a claim, not you.
  3. Youve admitted that their actions were completely reasonable. They didn’t diagnose until they saw sufficient symptoms, they took time to see those symptoms because she masked them. That’s completely reasonable on their part. They cannot just diagnose your DD because you say so - that would, in fact, be something she could bring a claim for.
  4. You’re time barred, you can’t bring a claim. You’re not an exception.

I totally agree with this. Think you are picking a losing battle here

BeeBB · 06/03/2023 19:11

percypercypercy · 06/03/2023 17:42

Did you post about this a couple of weeks ago?

This.

Have you posted about this before? I think you probably need to move on and spend your energy helping DD rather than wasting energy on a battle you are unlikely to win or may not win.

drpet49 · 06/03/2023 19:02

Snoken · 06/03/2023 18:08

I think this is very relevant. She did not want to be diagnosed so she did not cooperate. They can quite easily claim (quite rightly) that she sabotaged it herself. It’s such a stretched service that you would do children going through the process a huge disservice by using up their time and funding for this.

This. Your daughter sabotaged herself.

Shesinthegym · 06/03/2023 19:01

As others have said even if your dd got the diagnosis right in the beginning it does not mean she would receive all the support you mentioned. In my experience once diagnosed nothing really changes and you are pretty much left to get on with it alone.

It’s well known services are underfunded and their are not many out there.

I do really feel for you both. Even with a diagnosis your dds struggles may have been the same. I have a dd with a diagnosis and despite this she will always have struggles and barriers. It’s important to work with the child you have regardless of diagnosis. As a pp mentioned schools should support based on need not diagnosis as should DLA. You could have applied on her needs and challenged school but that’s irrelevant now.

I see why your frustrated and hurt but I have to assume part of that is your own guilt. This is not a dig at you op as I carry lots of guilt around my dd. You could have paid private for a second opinion or pushed for an alternative service to assess through the Nhs. Regardless of this my advice would be to use your energy and money to look after your well-being and mental health and work through what can be similar to grief.

I don’t know if Camhs were negligent or your dd presented differently back then but you are where you are and it’s time to focus on the future. Your dd still has years and plenty of opportunities to achieve whatever it is she wants toShe can still find support and services now. As her parent you can focus your efforts into empowering and supporting her to do this.

Quisquam · 06/03/2023 18:59

Our GP practice failed for 5 years to diagnose DD2’s physical condition. She suffered severe pain regularly, which impacted on her MH and she had to take 2 leaves of absence from university - which increased her student debt correspondingly. She was turned down for PIP.

After 10 minutes with a consultant (because I went with her to the GP and insisted she be referred), they told her she had all the classic symptoms - which were confirmed in surgery. The theatre nurse told her to change GP practice.

A firm of clinical negligence solicitors looked at her case, and said she didn’t have a case, because she didn’t suffer any real injury.

This was a condition the consultant saw in theatre; not a diagnosis of autism, something nobody can see and which you say DD masked anyway!

As for opportunities like missing riding for the disabled, there is no guarantee your DD would have got a place! DD1 did riding for the disabled until they had to sell her horse, for being uncooperative - then they said, they didn’t have a horse big enough her. She couldn’t go anymore!

JonahAndTheSnail · 06/03/2023 18:56

I think by pursuing this and certainly not getting the outcome your hoping for, your focus is going to be on that rather than moving forward and it's sending the wrong message to your DD. Yes, it's awful that you've been through so much and had to wait so long for a diagnosis. But your daughter is still young at just 21 and has plenty of time to carve out a wonderful and successful life. Are you getting any help for your own anxiety and depression? Flowers

ittakes2 · 06/03/2023 18:55

I am sorry this happened to you and your daughter. But really my first thought is there a reason you did not seek a private referral? I am assuming if you are thinking of suing you have the funds?
my daughters school did not support her to have a diagnosis for add I had to argue and argue for them to complete the forms and she ended up being diagnosed based on the schools forms and parent / her own info. I get how frustrating it is that children can mask and those around you don’t see through it but if she was masking I can’t see how she can sue anyone for not working out she was masking?

Happydayswillcomeagain · 06/03/2023 18:55

It’s difficult to see how CAMHS can be negligent when the difficulties weren’t observable to school/ clinicians. Also, you said you mentioned it several times to camhs- did you complain/ request a second opinion- these would be normal routes to go down at the time if you were unhappy with their assessment. Were there any other services in your area that assessed for ‘ASD (it’s usually not just camhs).

unfortunately your daughters story if very common. Girls with ASD can be difficult to assess, particularly when in a mental health crisis. There’s no easy answer but raised awareness and training is a needed.

Noonesperfect · 06/03/2023 18:53

Beaglesonlyplease · 06/03/2023 18:45

OP I feel for you. But as someone who is currently suing the NHS, mostly doing it myself, and not for negligence or medical care which are very difficult to prove, I promise you it’s not worth it.
If I could go back in time I wouldn’t have bothered ever saying anything about what happened. It made my life absolute hell. I’ve been called a liar etc. Horrible Experience all round

Yes, similar experience here. I've never tried to sue, but made a complaint about a doctor once and out right lies were told about me and my husband. They all cover themselves and nobody is there to support the man on the street. Don't go there. 😞

Chickenly · 06/03/2023 18:45

This would be an awful idea for many reasons.

  1. You don’t have an entitlement to many aspects of your claim. Therefore, you won’t be awarded damages for not getting them.
  2. It would be your DD who would need to bring a claim, not you.
  3. Youve admitted that their actions were completely reasonable. They didn’t diagnose until they saw sufficient symptoms, they took time to see those symptoms because she masked them. That’s completely reasonable on their part. They cannot just diagnose your DD because you say so - that would, in fact, be something she could bring a claim for.
  4. You’re time barred, you can’t bring a claim. You’re not an exception.
Beaglesonlyplease · 06/03/2023 18:45

OP I feel for you. But as someone who is currently suing the NHS, mostly doing it myself, and not for negligence or medical care which are very difficult to prove, I promise you it’s not worth it.
If I could go back in time I wouldn’t have bothered ever saying anything about what happened. It made my life absolute hell. I’ve been called a liar etc. Horrible Experience all round

Dogsarebetterthanhumans · 06/03/2023 18:39

I read Law at UCL and specialised in medical ethics and disability law for 2 of my dissertations.

So I am guessing you want to sue for negligence? If your time is up unfortunately, it’s up whether you are represented by a solicitor or not.

Use your money wisely to get therapy and treatment for yourself and anything your DD needs but you can’t bring this claim out of time if that’s the legal advice. X

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 06/03/2023 18:39

By all means get a second opinion, but the statutes of limitation aren't going to change if you decide to represent yourselves.

neverbeenskiing · 06/03/2023 18:33

OP, you're going to get very similar responses to your other thread on this subject.

There is no definitive "test" for Autism. The fact that one professional assessed your DD and did not have sufficient evidence to confidently diagnose Autism at that time, but another professional came to a different conclusion at a later date does not mean anyone was negligent. Young people's presentation can change significantly during adolescence and young adulthood. They can also (as you know) present very differently in different settings and depending on their level of comfort with the person completing the assessment.

So you have no evidence that negligence occurred and you cannot prove that a diagnosis would have opened the door to a wealth of support and services that would have changed things for your DD. The fact that the school refused to put support in place without a diagnosis (when SEN support should always be based on need not diagnosis) suggests they would not have been hugely helpful either way. Their ignorance around masking (particularly in girls) with Autism suggests the same.

I am sorry you and your DD were let down, but I think you will be setting yourself up for more anger and disappointment if you persevere with this.

Noonesperfect · 06/03/2023 18:30

I think you very likely have been let down, but I wouldn't waste anymore of you or your daughter's life on this. You won't get anywhere, you are so unlikely to win Flowers. Invest your time and energy on positive things to make things better for you and your daughter.

Somanycats · 06/03/2023 18:22

As In pretty sure I said on your other thread, autism is not something that can be definitively diagnosed or dismissed. Professionals will often disagree. The fact that she has a diagnosis now, does not mean anyone or any service was negligent in the past. It also doesn't mean that another professional would give you the same diagnosis tomorrow.
No one is going to be found to have been negligent. Please do not pursue this.

Noonesperfect · 06/03/2023 18:22

MichelleScarn · 06/03/2023 18:03

Am sure that this was said on previous thread, but if she successfully masked and showed no evidence at assessments and appointments how could they have given a diagnosis?

Because it's well known girls mask and it's time the professionals acknowledged this more. My daughter never got diagnosed through CAHMS either. I had to pay privately, and the practitioner was astounded she'd not been diagnosed . When she finally was diagnosed with autism CAHMS read all the findings and then agreed with it 🙄. Girls are constantly under diagnosed, it's disgraceful. CAHMS aren't really interested in diagnosing anyone with autism they just like gaslighting kids and parents that everything is their fault. Feel for you OP. My daughter has been let down constantly, even with a diagnosis!

Schuyler · 06/03/2023 18:19

YABU, how on earth would you prove negligence? you cannot just sue the NHS - you have no evidence of neglect.

In my line of work, I’ve seen a significant number of large NHS pay outs but it’s nothing like this. I’m talking about women who received negligent care and thus delivered children who sadly are disabled as a direct consequence of neglect during labour or delivery. I’ve seen a couple where strokes or brain aneurysms were not treated in the appropriate timescales due to neglect and people ended up very disabled as a result.

Soontobe60 · 06/03/2023 18:18

Sadly, you’re assuming an awful lot here. Firstly, there are myriad children who receive ASD diagnoses whilst in primary school, but that doesn’t automatically get them a guaranteed place in a special school. The same goes for DLA.
If she wasn’t attending school, then ‘masking’ when she was there, they would only have been able to report what they were observing regarding possible ASD. Schools will not complete assessments using anecdotal evidence supplied by parents. Neither can case workers at CAMHS use this type of evidence. They can both report that ‘parents say X is showing …. in the home”, but also report what they actually observe for themselves.
Your DDs focus should be on what she does about her diagnosis from now on. I’m assuming a diagnosis has not changed her in any way? (Beside her getting some understanding as to why she is the way she is). The fact that she went to 6th form looks to me like she did have some successes at school - she presumably achieved good enough GCSE grades to get a place. As a parent, you need to focus on the future, not the timing of her diagnosis.

Hankunamatata · 06/03/2023 18:16

You don't need diagnosis for DLA same for state funded special schools

iklboo · 06/03/2023 18:13

They did not believe me because she masked at appointments and at school

They're not psychic. If she masked they wouldn't have been able to diagnose. She had competence & capacity so they wouldn't just take your word for it.

She missed out on riding for the disabled and the local autism charity's youth groups and summer camps where she could have made friends. She missed out on going to a school for autistic kids which would've, I think, really suited her.

There's no guarantee she'd have been entitled to or got any of these. The resources are finite. Not every child with a diagnosis gets a place at a specialist school or access to groups, camps & hobbies.

The solicitors are right. You're time barred and you're not the patient.

gogohmm · 06/03/2023 18:10

If at the appointment she didn't show signs of autism exactly what are they meant to do? They cant diagnose what they don't observe. And what "treatment" do you think the diagnosis comes with - I can tell you, it's none. You can be angry about many things but a diagnosis on paper isn't one of them. My dd was really similar to what you described and does have a diagnosis, there's not a lot of services out there and ones that exist require the young person to engage and mine wouldn't

BounceyB · 06/03/2023 18:09

I think you should listen to the solicitor. She deals with this sort of thing every day. Also, there's the question of whether another professional doing the same job would have come to the same conclusion. If your daughter was masking her symptoms then they might not have and no duty of care has been breached. I know it's hard to hear and painful x

Roselilly36 · 06/03/2023 18:08

Sorry your DD has faced such challenges, none of us can turn back the clock, sadly. So I don’t see what suing would achieve to help your DD, particularly if your DD is too late to make a claim. Why put her under further stress & expense for very limited prospects of success.

InstagramBitchWife · 06/03/2023 18:08

If you have tens of thousands of pounds to spunk on something you're not going to win then go for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread