Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sue camhs by myself?

117 replies

Legalhelpneed · 06/03/2023 17:35

Shamelessly posting here to get lots of replies. DD is almost 21 and was diagnosed with ASD just before her 18th bday. This was despite her being under CAMHS for 5+ years, with me constantly suggesting she might be autisitic. They did not believe me because she masked at appointments and at school (when she went... Her attendance was about 30% for years 10, 11 and 12 and she eventually dropped out of school half way through 6th form). As a result of her late diagnosis her late childhood and teenage years were ruined for her; she self-harmed and tried to kill herself several times, she missed out on education, my marriage broke down, I suffered from depression and anxiety myself. DD was bullied mercilessly by her peers and was offered no support from the school because she had no diagnosis and they didn't believe me. DD would've probably been entitled to DLA and she now gets middle rate PIP which has improved her quality of life considerably. She missed out on riding for the disabled and the local autism charity's youth groups and summer camps where she could have made friends. She missed out on going to a school for autistic kids which would've, I think, really suited her.

DD and I spoke to a solicitor today who said it's too late to bring a claim as the 3 years where a claim could be submitted are almost up. Would it be totally mad to bring a claim ourselves? Thank you

OP posts:
CurlyTop1980 · 07/03/2023 07:24

ReadersD1gest · 06/03/2023 21:50

They did not believe me because she masked at appointments and at school
So how could they have diagnosed? And given she resisted the possible diagnosis, how likely is she to have engaged with the things you think she missed out on?

You would need direct evidence of masking though. Follow my advice for a SAR. It's the best place to start.

ReadersD1gest · 06/03/2023 21:50

They did not believe me because she masked at appointments and at school
So how could they have diagnosed? And given she resisted the possible diagnosis, how likely is she to have engaged with the things you think she missed out on?

Wednesdayonline · 06/03/2023 21:48

You can issue court proceedings to protect the claim, but would need to do it before the 3 years are up. Would not recommend going it alone without a solicitor. There are a lot of rules when it comes to litigation and you could be liable for the defendants costs if certain rules aren't complied with and/or you lose. The issue fee alone can be thousands.
Take a second opinion though and ask if they could protectively issue the claim.

purpledalmation · 06/03/2023 21:18

Notimeforaname · 06/03/2023 18:04

if she successfully masked and showed no evidence at assessments and appointments how could they have given a diagnosis?
Yes I also thought this.

Agree. That alone would negate a claim.

They have to have been negligent and if they see no signs of autism how can they diagnose it. The consequences of no diagnosis can't be compensated for because they did their job.

These cases cost ££££ anyway, like tens of thousands. I know because we have a legal aid case going through and we get tranches in this region.

StripeyDeckchair · 06/03/2023 21:10

You need to focus on the now and moving forward.
A court case would take a huge amount of time & emotional energy (& cost)
I would also consider it to be a major negative drain

What would you want to gain from it?

CurlyTop1980 · 06/03/2023 20:48

Your first point is to do a Subject Access Request from CAHMS, school, social services to seek your daughters records. She is 18 and can do this herself. Once you have these you can make a clearer decision about what to do. My understanding is you can put in a complaint at any point. This will be assessed as a level 1 complaint and if you are not satisfied it will go ro level 2 etc.

You maybe able to sue then. I work in children's services and some of the older kids I supported have done this to seek thier NHS records from CAMHS and other services.

Seeing the records may give you clarity of the decision making.

BertaHoon · 06/03/2023 20:48

Masking is what we do. It's not that we don't want to get diagnosed or are sabotaging ourselves. We don't know any different. We've had to cope all our lives masking, so it's highly unlikely to slip when under a diagnosis interview situation. Nod and smile, alles klar!

Stopsnowing · 06/03/2023 20:44

the solicitor said ‘nearly up’. Ask for the precise date for the limitation period and also the date/event they are working from. There might be enough time to issue a claim.

mumda · 06/03/2023 20:39

Huge amounts of NHS (taxpayer) money goes to compensation.
None of it makes the NHS better.
Complaining in a productive and useful way might.

Sugargliderwombat · 06/03/2023 20:29

I'm pretty sure diagnosis depends on the symptoms being present in more than one setting? So they wouldn't be at fault would they ?

FlemCandango · 06/03/2023 20:27

My daughter was diagnosed with autism at 8 and ADHD at 12, it was still a battle and required me to go against the school to get an EHCP. I have repeatedly tried to get her help from CAMHs and aside from a couple of telephone triage assessments she has had no contact from them, just been discharged for being "too autistic". It was paediatric services that diagnosed DD. Not mental health. So I am not sure CAMH has much to do with the autism diagnostic pathway in this area.

It is possible to access local autism charity support without a diagnosis here as there is an understanding that the waiting lists are long. I think the obsession about what didn't happen is probably unhealthy and won't help your daughter. The diagnosis gives us a piece of paper but you can still use the vast amount of information about autism to help your daughter, and don't be put off applying for benefits related to health as they are not based on diagnosis but need, and evidence of need. Good luck.

Ginger1982 · 06/03/2023 20:19

I don't understand what you mean about suing them yourself. Once the time bar is up, it's up, whether you have legal representation or not.

Merlinsbeard83 · 06/03/2023 20:16

I have a dd who was diagnosed at 8 and has received none of the thing you said your child would of gotten . You get diagnosed and that's it . Echp for school if lucky, but very few get a decent school . We are homeschooling for this very reason .
I think you can not blame it all on them . If she masked how could they have diagnosed her? .

Reinventinganna · 06/03/2023 20:13

What about the school? Or your GP?
Why no blame on them?

LuluBlakey1 · 06/03/2023 20:09

I can understand how frustrating CAMHS can be - have experience of them over many years and their slowness and ineffectiveness with most children referred.

However, firstly, if she was masking and not showing symptoms/characteristics at CAMHS or at school, I do not know how they would have diagnosed her. Secondly I think there are things you just could not prove- it is not provable in terms of cause/effect that CAMHS not diagnosing her resulted in the list of things that have happened in her and your life over that period of time for example her poor attendance, her choosing to leave, her not getting a place at horse-riding or a summer camp, the actions of other children and the school not supporting her with that, your divorce.
It's time -limited so it's a pointless waste of money and will be dismissed.

ActDottie · 06/03/2023 20:09

Don’t sue the nhs! They’ve done nothing wrong! They can’t just diagnose autism because you say so they need to observe and if your daughter was masking then it would’ve obviously been harder.

If it was my child and I was that passionate about my daughter getting a diagnosis I’d have gone down the private route.

Butchyrestingface · 06/03/2023 20:08

Shamelessly posting here to get lots of replies

You've been shamelessly posting variations on this theme for a while now. Don't think you're going to get different answers this time.

Jellycatspyjamas · 06/03/2023 20:06

camhs do not complete assessments for autism and are not funded to do this.

My daughter is currently being assessed by CAMHS for autism amongst other neurodivergencies. Some are funded and do assess.

Absc · 06/03/2023 19:59

As others have said you stand no chance.

camhs do not complete assessments for autism and are not funded to do this.

FfeminyddCymraeg · 06/03/2023 19:58

This article may help you realise your cause is futile

www.burnetts.co.uk/blog/bringing-a-claim-in-medical-negligence-the-basics

FfeminyddCymraeg · 06/03/2023 19:53

I think you’re looking for somebody/something to hang your hat on for all the things that have gone wrong for you and your DD. That’s understandable and natural to want somebody to blame.

However, as many before me have said, your DD masked and there were no guarantees she’d have received any of the things you’ve mentioned. You only have to read the SEN boards here to see how difficult these things are to access.

Even with these things, there is no guarantee your DD would have suffered any less or your marriage wouldn’t have broken down.

Having worked in a huge clinical negligence law firm for many years, it’s a long and slow process to sue the NHS and the financial remedy isn’t often what you’d expect. You’re out of time in any event.

I would use any funds you were going to use to bring a claim to get some counselling instead. What’s happened is nobody’s fault, it is what it is.

ThreeLocusts · 06/03/2023 19:25

OP I feel your pain - I have a suicidal 13 year old ar home and things are going badly with her therapy; I doubt a lot of their decisions and invariably get dismissed as the fussy mum when I question things.

I'm beginning to think there's a massive amount of sexist bias against mothers in pediatric mental health care. You probably were subjected to that too.

But suing won't change the past and probably lose, not gain, you money. I totally understand why you want to light a fire under all the institutions that failed your daughter, but you'll just get dismissed again.

In your shoes I'd want to vent - request a meeting at the school, record camhs's failures with an ombudsman or similar - but above all, try to move on. Find the services she can access now.

Al the bestFlowers

itswonkylampshade · 06/03/2023 19:24

The concensus is obviously this would be a waste of time and energy but YANBU for wanting some accountability.

There is a total failure to listen on the part of the NHS where the mental health of neurodivergent young women is concerned. We have experienced this with my DD too and it is a scandal. 💐

cansu · 06/03/2023 19:22

yes it would be a waste of time and money.

You have made a lot of assumptions that a diagnosis would have prevented these problems from occurring. Many people with diagnosed ASD have mental health problems. My son who was diagnosed aged 3 still had many issues growing up and into adulthood. I would not waste my energy and money on something you have absolutely no chance of winning.

Oblomov23 · 06/03/2023 19:19

You have been failed many times by different agencies. I doubt suing will win. The school failed you because even without a diagnosis they should have had the child's best interests at heart, and they failed her miserably. The loss of going on camp and the Money from DLA is very painful. Worse still the fact you know no one believed you and you were actually right, and this all could've been avoided, is frustrating. I felt angry and betrayed that no one believed me. Irreparable damage was done. To feel powerless is not a nice feeling. I hope you find peace, I haven't quite managed to yet.