Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why so many MiL’s treat the mother of their grandchild like a walking womb?

56 replies

Mamabearprotectinghercub · 06/03/2023 15:53

Read a lot on mumsnet recently about mother in laws/grandmothers on the paternal side doing things that are completely batshit, controlling, and they seem to treat the mother of their grandchildren like walking wombs. I have my own experience of this too - partner and I split whilst pregnant but his mother treated being appallingly following the birth of my child, said I was mentally ill because I wanted to hold my child too much, shouted at me and insulted me in my own house because she couldn’t get her own way with my child (last thing I needed as a single first time mother who just gave birth) and did SO many things that made me uncomfortable and made me feel like a surrogate to HER child rather than a mother to my own child which caused me so much stress and has left me shaken.

so my question is, why are so many mother in law’s or grandparents on the paternal side like this? Why do they want control over their grandchild and not simply let the mother get on with it and have her own rules and respect that?! i know not ALL are like this but from my own experience and others I’ve read about online they are so controlling and I just don’t understand why?! The behaviour of some of them is so upsetting and distressing to the mothers.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LightDrizzle · 07/03/2023 18:00

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/03/2023 16:15

People with bad MILs are far, far more likely to post their horror stories than the ones with lovely MILs are to post paeans of praise. Hence the skewed view - I wasn’t sure I said that clearly.

⬆️ This!

Also we’ve gone through adolescence with our own mothers and the relationship has survived and is anyway unconditional, so when our mums piss us off in the emotional post-partum fug, it’s easier to snap at them and put them straight. Our relationship with in-laws is usually more polite so it is much trickier to resolve niggles and issues. There’s more agonising and seething than with our own parents, - unless you are cursed with a mother who is a champion at hypersensitive victimhood and passive aggression.

Summer2424 · 07/03/2023 18:00

Hi @Mamabearprotectinghercub i totally agree with you x

thecatsthecats · 07/03/2023 17:55

I think my MIL is going to be decent enough. She had a very traumatic birth experience with my husband so she should be understanding, and if anyone asks me an intrusive question about TTC, she snaps back before I have a chance to that it's none of their business.

However, she will be wildly, in your face excited, in a way that I'm sure will wind me up. On top of that, we have completely opposite tastes and ways of doing things.

So I'm going to try and focus on the former and not the latter. And not let anyone know about the event until it's over.

CurlewKate · 07/03/2023 17:34

Some people are shit generally. And mixing families is difficult. Particularly if one side or the other finds it hard to remember that different is not the same as wrong. And that it is possible to love more than one person at a time.

Starflecked · 07/03/2023 17:09

You hear about it more because people are less likely to post a thread about their MIL treating them well, what would the AIBU be? Plenty of mother in laws are respectful, just like any relative some aren't but the general stereotype is a bit tedious now.

Thislittlepiggy89 · 07/03/2023 17:05

I have a theory and it wouldn't be strictly related to MIL. More older mothers in general and babies. I wonder how many of these women actually held and soaked up all the baby goodness when their own children were babies. Did someone else interfer with their child and reduced the cuddles they gave them? Did they have the pressure of "not spoiling a baby" and as a result felt they couldn't cuddle them.

I say this as someone who had a velcro baby who I basically had to hold for a year continuously. I can now appreciate a baby and how cute they are (took a few year 🤣) but I have zero desire to hold a baby ever again. Some relatives have given me their baby to hold (so they can eat warm food) and yes it's nice but I most certainly got all my baby cuddles in with my own baby. Maybe if I had had the pressure to not "spoil" the baby I wouldn't feel this way and be desperate for cuddles.

Just a theory. Could be utter nonsense of course.

CovertImage · 07/03/2023 17:03

IkBenDeMol · 07/03/2023 16:34

why are so many mother in law’s or grandparents on the paternal side like this

They're not. Because the women who have a good relationship with their MIL or who have nothing to complain about do not start threads on MN.

Quite.

"Why are DiLs such power-crazed lunatics who clearly loathe older women other than their own mothers?"

They're not, it just seems like they all are once you've been on Mumsnet for 10 mins

Guis23 · 07/03/2023 16:44

I think some women feel redundant. And take it out on daughters in law. Some people might resent their DIL's. They probably don't consciously think it.

IkBenDeMol · 07/03/2023 16:34

why are so many mother in law’s or grandparents on the paternal side like this

They're not. Because the women who have a good relationship with their MIL or who have nothing to complain about do not start threads on MN.

nilsmousehammer · 07/03/2023 16:32

Chimps and gorillas also can do this: female relatives can get over involved and possessive with a new baby to the point of distressing the mother, even to the point of fighting not to give it back. In some cases one will hang on to the baby until it starves to death if the mother doesn't manage to get it away from them. Seems to be a primate thing sometimes that evolution hasn't quite left behind in humans.

123rd · 07/03/2023 16:29

Whilst I was heavily pregnant with 'her first grandchild' Angry ( don't worry about it being MY pfb) she introduced a friend to me as 'oh and here is my first grandchild' and pointed to my huge belly. Literally didn't even say my name.
Silly cow

DorritLittle · 07/03/2023 16:23

My mother in law is lovely. And my sister in law is quite desperate for my mum to fail the test at every turn. It’s sad. There is a lot of generalising on MN.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/03/2023 16:15

People with bad MILs are far, far more likely to post their horror stories than the ones with lovely MILs are to post paeans of praise. Hence the skewed view - I wasn’t sure I said that clearly.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/03/2023 16:13

Thankfully both my former MIL and my now partner’s mother live safely overseas.

FWIW I don’t know if it’s a MiL per se is it? Isn’t it more just a certain type of older woman who has only ever achieved fulfilment through children and when hers have flown the nest transfers it to the next generation?

I think these are mainly women who haven’t worked etc and are hugely over-invested in child-rearing and when their own children grow up they need to find new victims.

A mother could be just as much like this as a MIL.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 07/03/2023 16:12

I think we may be getting a skewed view of this, because the women with MILs who aren’t batshit and controlling, and ‘treating their DILs like walking wombs’ are unlikely to post about their good experiences with their MILs - so it looks as if all MILs are like this when actually there are plenty of good ones too.

My MIL was amazing - a wonderful woman, a supportive and helpful MIL and a great grandmother - she is sorely missed. When I became a MIL and a grandmother last year, I modelled myself on my MIL, and I have a good relationship with my DIL.

I understand the excitement of becoming a grandmother - I felt every bit of it - but it is not difficult to temper that and put the needs of the DIL and grandchild first.

whatadayforadaydream · 07/03/2023 16:01

Because women who make boys are evil monsters?

You are making a generalisation based on your own experience that is simply untrue. So for that reason YABU.

NextToTheRadio · 07/03/2023 15:58

I cut my MIL out many years ago for being so interfering.

Now I'm the MIL and I feel like I've got a great relationship with her. She's wonderful and a great match for my son.

I do have to stop myself from saying 'when DS was little...' too much, which feels natural to do in a conversation.

It's also hard to remember to call yourself nanny and not mum. It's like a change of name after 30 years.

Mamabearprotectinghercub · 07/03/2023 15:56

Watermelonsugarcube · 06/03/2023 20:21

I generally get on well with my MIL, this this comment still pisses me off (yes I should get over it).

At 30 weeks pregnant I came down with a really nasty respiratory infection- like really nasty- I collapsed and had to stay in hospital for a couple of days.

When DH told her what was happening her only response was “is the baby ok?”, when DH told her that yes as far as we knew baby was doing fine she says breezily “ah well that’s all that matters then” and changes the subject. Actually no MIL, I matter too!

I’m so sorry this happened to you, how awful!

Not similar, but I remember when my baby was younger she was in hospital for a few days after her breathing went funny - it was a terrible time for me and as you could imagine, I was in tears and thinking the worst. When said grandmother came to visit in hospital, she offered no support or sympathy for me, no kind hand on my shoulder or hug. She came in the hospital, picked up my baby and held/rocked her, said nothing to me, other then “I’m leaving now” once she had held her. I really needed some emotional support myself, at that point my baby was fine and just being observed, but I was still worried sick after sleepless nights and all I’d gone through, I just can’t believe how coldly she acted towards me, it was very strange…

OP posts:
Mamabearprotectinghercub · 07/03/2023 15:46

maryberryslayers · 07/03/2023 10:02

Thankfully my SIL had a baby a few months before me and MIL has always been much more interested in her child than ours.
It's a shame for my DC as MIL is pretty blatant with the favouritism but I'm aware of it and will ensure that my kids never realise, even if that means they don't see her much as they get older.

What always gets me is why mothers stand for it from the MILs.
If someone is rude to you, leave, tell them to leave and don't have anything more to do with them. She can see the DC with her own son, once they are old enough, at her house.

Why was your MIL even at your house if you had split with your partner?

Hello @maryberryslayers, yes I was very wrong to let my partners mother into my life when pregnant. My pregnancy was accidental and I hadn’t even met her prior to my pregnancy, however she was very determined to get into my life, I had no idea she had ulterior motives and that she was desperate to be a grandmother. She was seemingly nice to my when pregnant, although I thought it was a bit OTT that this woman I’d only just met was suddenly texting me every day asking me about my pregnancy, I am far too soft and kind to people and don’t like to offend people, so unfortunately I allowed this behaviour (massive mistake I know). She asked to visit often and I felt bad if I didn’t let her… and it was after I gave birth her behaviour got completely domineering and out of hand. and when she reduced me to tears in my home, claimed that I was mentally unwell because I wanted my child back when she was holding her, and that my behaviour was “bizarre” for having boundaries and not wanting her do whatever she pleases (she claimed it was her right to do as she pleases with my child “because I’m her grandmother”), I made it clear that she would never see me again. If it was up to me, she would never see my baby again, however Ex partner makes sure she gets to see baby whenever he is with her, and he doesn’t understand why I was so upset about how she behaved towards me after I gave birth.

sorry for long post, maybe I’m being unreasonable but I guess it’s one of those things you only know how you feel if it happens to you.

OP posts:
maryberryslayers · 07/03/2023 10:02

Thankfully my SIL had a baby a few months before me and MIL has always been much more interested in her child than ours.
It's a shame for my DC as MIL is pretty blatant with the favouritism but I'm aware of it and will ensure that my kids never realise, even if that means they don't see her much as they get older.

What always gets me is why mothers stand for it from the MILs.
If someone is rude to you, leave, tell them to leave and don't have anything more to do with them. She can see the DC with her own son, once they are old enough, at her house.

Why was your MIL even at your house if you had split with your partner?

Lollypop701 · 07/03/2023 09:38

MN is where you ask for advice… so will be weighed with problem mil. My mil was a fabulous gp, sit on floor with kids playing. Give them sneaky £1 or two . My mum is a bit more distanced in location and just never knew what to do with them, but then she never really played with me as a child. Just Different tbh but both love them. My mil did tell me I should sleep on my stomach post birth to get rid of my tummy.. I laughed at her

Nosandwichfilling · 07/03/2023 08:41

I absolutely adore my hopefully future DIL.

Both DS and her have talked openly about marrying and wanting children, I had DS at 34 and her poor Mum had a lot of losses and had started trying at about 28 but didn’t have her till she was 35. They are both currently doing their degrees, he has a clear vocational career path she will have a degree in a science subject so choices to be made regarding her actual career.

I have told her I can’t think of anyone better for DS to settle down with and as long as she doesn’t mind me buying teddy bear romper suits with ears for any future toddlers when I babysit I will always kowtow to her rules.

Personality wise she is very much like my DH and they get on very well, he helped her with her maths A level homework a few times.

WonderWoop · 07/03/2023 07:21

Sometimes I think comments are just badly judged as opposed to malicious from MILs.

Mine asked me the other day if I was enjoying putting my feet up on mat leave while my toddler is at nursery. 2.5 week old newborn not exactly relaxing!

WandaWonder · 07/03/2023 07:04

Yes it can work the other way but we only hear one side of a story, who knows if the reality is what we are told?

But I have seen enough stories on here, if true!!!! Make me think inlaws are only useful if they serve a purpose ie childcare

But yes again we only hear one side

morethanspice · 07/03/2023 06:31

My PIL were farmers and definitely classed me as breeding stock. Tried to make me move into their farm so the baby was born in their home 😱and we’re vile about breastfeeding because apparently it was me being selfish about being the only person who could feed the baby. Absolutely wonderful never to have contact now and about to be a grandma myself to my daughter. Who is already worried about the input from her in laws…..

Swipe left for the next trending thread