Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand renewing wedding vows

137 replies

Namechange1011111stairs · 06/03/2023 11:10

I got an excited text from my mum this morning with a photo of a sparkly ring and announcing that she is getting remarried. She's going to Gretna Green.

I live out of country so am often missed out of news but if my parents had divorced, I'd hopefully have been told about it before now so I'm assuming she means they are renewing their vows. 😆

I congratulated her, made a fuss etc but I don't understand. What does it actually mean? Is it just an excuse for a pretty dress and a party about you? Do people treat it like a wedding?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 17/03/2023 23:46

ReneBumsWombats · 17/03/2023 18:57

It's not an update and it's not because the contract has expired. It's a refresher, a reminder, a reaffirmation. It's the exact opposite of throwing off the old marriage - you can't renew something if it doesn't already exist!

Fine not to do it, but as with others, your objection is based on something mean-spirited and not even correct; you can't renew something unless it's already established. It's just a pretzel logic way of trying to say that people who choose to do it couldn't possibly have any positive reason for it, because for whatever reason, that's what you want to believe.

I have no objection whatsoever - you do you. Crack on and have as many renewals etc as you like for whatever reason you like.

As I said, it’s just my opinion. Which I’m entitled to just as much as you are.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/03/2023 18:57

SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 08/03/2023 11:41

It’s not to do with thinking the worst , it’s to do with a different understanding of marriage.

it’s a legal contract, it doesn't need updated. I don’t renew my job contract or the deeds on my house, if nothing has changed.

If I get a new job then I’ll get a new contract with new title, salary, T and C etc.

Renewing vows seems the opposite of celebrating an anniversary to me. On one hand you are saying that you’ve been married for eg 25 years. Yet at the same time you are saying that you are throwing out that old marriage and starting a new one by saying a whole new set of vows. Like the old ones don’t count anymore.

Just my opinion.

It's not an update and it's not because the contract has expired. It's a refresher, a reminder, a reaffirmation. It's the exact opposite of throwing off the old marriage - you can't renew something if it doesn't already exist!

Fine not to do it, but as with others, your objection is based on something mean-spirited and not even correct; you can't renew something unless it's already established. It's just a pretzel logic way of trying to say that people who choose to do it couldn't possibly have any positive reason for it, because for whatever reason, that's what you want to believe.

BigFatLiar · 17/03/2023 18:19

No idea. Perhaps some people want to recapture a special time. Just because it's something you really do once (or once with that partner) doesn't mean you can't do it again if you want. Many years ago my husband told me he loved me, I know he does but it's still nice to hear him say it regularly. If they want to go over their vows why not.

ReneBumsWombats · 17/03/2023 18:07

User1990C · 17/03/2023 16:56

If your view of marriage is a contract, why bother getting married? Just draw up a will and be done with it.

A will doesn't give the same protections and can be changed without your knowledge. Marriage covers much more than a will does.

smellyflowers · 17/03/2023 16:59

It's easy to understand someone has cheated, recieved bad health news/over come bad health news, or is bored

User1990C · 17/03/2023 16:56

If your view of marriage is a contract, why bother getting married? Just draw up a will and be done with it.

IfYouDontAsk · 09/03/2023 22:09

TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 06/03/2023 11:13

They’ve had marriage troubles but have come through.

Newer trend.

In the old days couples who were in crisis would build a conservatory instead.

This cracked me up 😂 and the conservatory observation is so true!

angielizzy1 · 09/03/2023 22:07

The only vow renewal one been to is due to a death on their anniversary date. It have them the opportunity to move the date.

SoonToBeQueenCamilla · 08/03/2023 11:41

ReneBumsWombats · 07/03/2023 10:50

I'm obviously in a minority but its never even crossed my mind that couples renewing vows might have had difficulties, or there was cheating.

If you don't have a worldview that is immediately inclined to think the worst of people's relationships, why would you?

It’s not to do with thinking the worst , it’s to do with a different understanding of marriage.

it’s a legal contract, it doesn't need updated. I don’t renew my job contract or the deeds on my house, if nothing has changed.

If I get a new job then I’ll get a new contract with new title, salary, T and C etc.

Renewing vows seems the opposite of celebrating an anniversary to me. On one hand you are saying that you’ve been married for eg 25 years. Yet at the same time you are saying that you are throwing out that old marriage and starting a new one by saying a whole new set of vows. Like the old ones don’t count anymore.

Just my opinion.

Namechange1011111stairs · 07/03/2023 20:36

GloomyDarkness · 07/03/2023 11:10

Mostly, people do it at milestone anniversaries.

When I was still a child both DGP hit milestone anniversaries - family from both, hugely scattered across UK and globe, made huge effort to come - lots of food - gifts and lots of family I've never seen before or since.

When my DP hit a similar milestone they didn't want anything - my IL went away for the week.

DH says his family is a hatch matched and dispatched one and I think parents generation or one before may have been - increasingly that's not true of his or mine. Christening don't happen so it's hit and miss if you meet new kids and I have a sibling in UK who still hasn't met my youngest at 14 - weddings tend to be smaller or not involved wider family invites and even funerals aren't travelled to as they once were.

So perhaps that why renewals are getting popular an extra reason to gather.

That's an interesting point re distanced families. At my wedding 17yrs ago, I only had 8 of my family. None of my Dad's family. My brother got married a few years ago and had 6. Both were small weddings anyway but still.

I've only seen my sister once in 5yrs and that was at a funeral. Some of my family have never met my teenage children.

I couldn't imagine people putting in much effort in my family really. I hope my parents aren't disappointed if they are planning something big. 😔 Obviously I'll make a fuss/attend if they do something.

OP posts:
GloomyDarkness · 07/03/2023 11:10

Mostly, people do it at milestone anniversaries.

When I was still a child both DGP hit milestone anniversaries - family from both, hugely scattered across UK and globe, made huge effort to come - lots of food - gifts and lots of family I've never seen before or since.

When my DP hit a similar milestone they didn't want anything - my IL went away for the week.

DH says his family is a hatch matched and dispatched one and I think parents generation or one before may have been - increasingly that's not true of his or mine. Christening don't happen so it's hit and miss if you meet new kids and I have a sibling in UK who still hasn't met my youngest at 14 - weddings tend to be smaller or not involved wider family invites and even funerals aren't travelled to as they once were.

So perhaps that why renewals are getting popular an extra reason to gather.

ReneBumsWombats · 07/03/2023 10:50

I'm obviously in a minority but its never even crossed my mind that couples renewing vows might have had difficulties, or there was cheating.

If you don't have a worldview that is immediately inclined to think the worst of people's relationships, why would you?

5128gap · 07/03/2023 10:50

Staying married for a long time, raising children to adulthood is hard work. I can understand those that have gone the distance wanting to celebrate. And yes, I know that's what anniversaries are for, but no one cares about the regular ones, and at the time of the 25th/50th you might not be best placed to throw a party.
You don't have to understand people's celebratory choices. Just join in if you're happy for them and fancy the party, or opt out if you think its daft.

MissyB1 · 07/03/2023 10:49

sausage767 · 06/03/2023 11:41

This again. My DH and I eloped. So on our 10th anniversary we had a special lunch with our loved ones who were not there at our original wedding. We both stood up and made new vows based on 10 years of marriage experience, and I expressed my gratitude to DH for his unwavering love and support while I battled cancer. My niece read a poem. Eyes moistened and everyone enjoyed a beautiful meal and lots of champagne toasts.

If it’s not for you, it’s not for you.

And this is exactly why we would potentially do it. We had a secret first marriage and didn’t invite anyone (various good reasons). Since then I have had breast cancer and Dh a brain tumour. If we renew our vows it will be with a few very close friends/family and it would be to thank each other for the support and commitment through the very hard times .

Couldn’t give a flying fuck if some mean spirited people assume one of us has cheated 🙄

FarmGirl78 · 07/03/2023 10:42

I'm obviously in a minority but its never even crossed my mind that couples renewing vows might have had difficulties, or there was cheating. I know celebs sometimes do it, to put on a brave face as a show that it's all ok really. But not in real life I'd ever think it was the reason.

I think so many couples split up these days it can be sort of done as confirmation that you've achieved something admirable where many people don't manage to make it (clumsy choice of words there I know!) to 30 or 40 years etc.

My Dad wanted to renew his wedding vows for their 40th anniversary as he was so proud, and my Mum refused as she has massive anxiety (that she's in denial about!) and didn't want to be centre of attention walking up the isle. Poor Dad was devastated and has since said it was the lowest point of his life.

Another friends parents did it in their 70s, as way back they'd had a very very cheap registery office service when neither family had any money whatsoever to spare, and and they'd always wanted to get married 'properly' in a church.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 07/03/2023 10:41

I think it suggests the original wedding wasn't what they wanted in some way and they are going for a do over.

Shotgun wedding?
Very small low budget wedding?
Rushed wedding due to say military service or ill health?
Interfering parents?
Wedding not in church due to say a previous divorce but could now be done in church due to changes in policy?
Wedding not in church but have since found religion? Or a change in religion?
Wedding abroad that may not have full legal standing in the UK?
Someone not present at the original wedding that they wish was (say reunited with a birth parent in the interim)?

Alternatively doing it to mark having got over a rough patch, not necessarily an affair, maybe serious illness.

Or they were never married......

I know someone who married in their 70s, most people thought they had been married for decades but they had just lived together and been known as Mr&Mrs.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 07/03/2023 10:00

Yanbu, I always think - who cheated then?

Makingamess4212 · 07/03/2023 09:58

I never really understood it till I was in this situation. Me and my wife got married over 10 years ago. Around 5 years ago the relationship broke down, we were legally seperated, living seperately and "no longer married". While trying to figure out finances and divorce we actually ended up working things out, it took a long time, but we did it! We have moved back in together and are having a family. Neither one of us wants to put the old wedding rings back on, and it truly feels like we have started again. Which is what has promted us to want to redo our vows, just a small thing, a few family members and new rings. It just feels right.

museumum · 07/03/2023 09:54

I wouldn’t go it because of all the responses here and assumptions people make.
But dh and I have been together 19 years, married 13 this year and I think it would be lovely to celebrate our love. The fact I still love him & I believe he loves me feels pretty astounding when I actually add up how long it’s been.
I guess we should celebrate anniversaries more. Our 10th was in 2020 so very odd. We went out to eat but it was extremely covid-measures (no alcohol, tables 2m+ apart etc). Maybe we should plan a private celebration for 2025 (15yrs married), but over 20 together.

ReneBumsWombats · 07/03/2023 09:48

Luana1 · 07/03/2023 08:58

Also ancient people may not have made their vows 'for life' like we do, so renewing vows when they were not permanent makes total sense.

If modern day vow renewals are mostly just an excuse for a party, why not just have an anniversary party. The anniversary couple would still be the centre of events.

A vow renewal, an anniversary...who cares? Same ultimate purpose, why does it make a difference?

mydogisthebest · 07/03/2023 09:23

Some very nasty posters on here.

Me and DH have talked about renewing our vows. Neither of us have cheated and we haven't particularly been through tough times.

It would be just the 2 of us. Certainly don't want a big party. Didn't even want a reception when we got married but MIL was so bossy we gave in. We just wanted us and immediate family at wedding and meal after.

We have been married 43 years and both think it would be nice thing to do.

Luana1 · 07/03/2023 08:58

Polis · 07/03/2023 08:10

And people wonder why romance is dead. Vow renewal is also cultural. Celtic cultures had regular vow renewals before Christianity

Perhaps they needed them.

Also ancient people may not have made their vows 'for life' like we do, so renewing vows when they were not permanent makes total sense.

If modern day vow renewals are mostly just an excuse for a party, why not just have an anniversary party. The anniversary couple would still be the centre of events.

Womblemumma · 07/03/2023 08:35

i love the idea, getting everyone together and having an amazing day , nice food and a drink, what’s not to like?

NorthernSpring · 07/03/2023 08:32

We're planning a trip to Vegas soon. We will be renewing our vows over there, just because we can and just because it will be fun.
No cheating, just always wanted a 'typical' Vegas wedding😄possibly with costumes!

Clioma · 07/03/2023 08:29

It's not something I would do but if others want to and it makes them happy then I'm happy for them and wish them well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread