Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are you doing without to overpay your mortgage?

90 replies

coodawoodashooda · 05/03/2023 21:41

Not a stealth boast. Expecting cms contribution to stop imminently and trying to get rid of as much debt as possible before then. We have enough but it's hard going. Anyone else in the same boat? Please don't be offended. I'm not trying to antagonise anyone. Just looking for moral support.

OP posts:
FrownedUpon · 06/03/2023 10:19

We’ve always overpaid the mortgage so we can retire early. We only have one car & haven’t done much in the way of home improvements. A lot of our friends keep adding to their mortgages to convert the loft, build extensions etc.

We’re frugal with clothes shopping. We do still spend money on good food & holidays though.

Porkandbeans1 · 06/03/2023 10:14

I stopped overpayments when interest rates began to rise, we have a low fix and are already under the 60pc LTV bracket. Before that I did a mix of overpayments and investing.

We have just tried to avoid lifestyle creep, so not really going without. For example I have always cut and coloured my own hair. It seems silly to pay to have it done when I've been happy doing it myself for the last 20+ years.

DancingDaughter50 · 06/03/2023 10:08

@orangepoang

I think it's about balance a family with small dc will surely want to also go on holidays with them and enjoy their childhood even if it's a short time on "holidays" eg a few nights away rather than a classic week in lanzarotte

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 06/03/2023 10:03

Kentishbornknitter · 06/03/2023 09:13

@Hungrycaterpillarsmummy The reason for us wasn’t so much to own our home but to have no debt. Not owing anyone a penny means that we have more freedom to do what we want with our money. The earlier you pay off your mortgage the more money you save on the interest that you are paying to the bank. It’s about financial freedom to us.

Yes I understand that but the OP makes it seem like she actually just can't afford her mortgage once the CMS stops so maybe something else needs to change here.
Also I think there's a balance to be had. Rather than forgoing treats or a roast dinner totally for example which I'm sure they could have even once a month if they actually wanted it. You could scrimp and pay it off then die and you've lived you're live in a stingy way. It just seems so miserable. 🤷

GnomeDePlume · 06/03/2023 09:58

We are now at the tail end of our mortgage so the vast majority of our payment is capital. Our mortgage is a base rate tracker (0.49% above base).

Just before interest rates started climbing we cut down from 2 cars to one and put the money we got for that car against the mortgage.

I am hoping we will have a decent chunk of savings at the end of this year. The question then will be mortgage or pension.

Everyone's situation is different.

CharodNeDu · 06/03/2023 09:42

Never overpaid the mortgage. Instead used the extra money to save and then extend the house, covert the garage, renovate the house into a lovely home, go on amazing holidays with the children and save the £40k needed to cover 2 children in university if they do a 4 year course each. I already have one child at uni. Maximum maintenance loan they get is £4.5k their rent in first year was over £6k then they also needed to eat. Hence the parental top up. We also have other savings for anything else.

We fixed our mortgage to cover the period that both children will be in and then out of uni. I would rather have the savings that earn more money in interest than the mortgage rate, be instantly accessible in case of any emergency and then when the mortgage is up for renewal in 2027 we can pay a chunk of it off with no penalties. We have run the numbers through a mortgage overpayment calculator, it doesn't make sense for us to overpay.

We are not going without because life it too short. My friend dropped dead of sepsis aged 39. That was a massive shock. Life to us is for living, not scrimping for a mortgage overpayment. My MIL died within a year of retiring and said that she would have been really pissed if she had not managed to have a whale of a time for 6 months before being diagnosed with leukaemia.

JustAWeirdoWithNoName · 06/03/2023 09:37

If you haven't done so already, I really recommend reading the Money Saving Expert article on mortgage overpayments!

I was going to start overpaying when DH started earning more last year but, as we're fixed until next March, we can actually do more with that money by putting it in a savings account with a higher interest rate than our mortgage! Plus those savings are accessible if we do need them for an emergency.

KatyKlanger · 06/03/2023 09:37

Bit of a loaded question isn't it? It presupposes a few things

megletthesecond · 06/03/2023 09:33

We never had a proper holiday. I over paid £10 - £20 a month.

MuggleMe · 06/03/2023 09:30

We do caravan holidays rather than abroad, spend less on birthdays etc. DH has a history of poor mental health so I'm not counting on him working til normal retirement age, and one of our DC has additional needs I anticipate we'll have to support her financially or she'll keep living with us.

Rollercoaster1920 · 06/03/2023 09:27

I have overpaid. Do get a savings buffer before doing so though, I was stuck in a job because I couldn't afford to quit, and have been made redundant so I'll always keep 6 months ready in case.

I'm now over paying with the aim of being mortgage free when the children are 18 so I can help them with university or housing costs. I'm going without doing the house up. I'd love to extend to get a bigger bedroom for my eldest, but looking at extension costs and university costs I'm thinking what is better for the family.

Nutsycuckoo · 06/03/2023 09:25

We drive old cars and have cut down on takeaways. We didn't have a family holiday overseas last year, but will be this year. It's all about balance.
We wouldn't be overpaying if we were having to go without food or necessities though.

SimplySipping · 06/03/2023 09:25

Growing kids need protein and veg, if you can get it into them, across the week.

I don't think we ever cut down on something as essential as food for overpaying, it's more that we were generally fairly frugal when kids were little. Now they are teens they are so much more expensive and it is more difficult to overpay.

So just the usual stuff really - one paid TV subscription at a time rather than several, cheaper meats and meat free days, keeping lunchboxes simple - cheese sandwich, couple of biscuits from a normal packet rather than more heavily packaged snacks, apple, carrot. I think we eat fairly simply in general. Very rarely drink alcohol. Invite friends round for dinner or drinks rather than eating out.

whatadayforadaydream · 06/03/2023 09:21

Dont get this, unless you are close to paying off your mortgage and being mortgage free, or you are close to a threshold for better rates, there is really no point in doing this. A mortgage isn't really considered a debt in personal finance terms, and is the "best" debt to have. There is no way I would be eating cheese toasties every night to pay off £50 more a month which is unlikely to be making a blind bit of difference.

We overpay most months because we can. The "sacrifice" is savings, and we are currently reviwing because it would earn is more in savings that we would saving in interest on the mortgage. You might be the same - i.e if you mortgage is 3% and you can earn 4% in an ISA you would be much better off doing that and then at some point (e.g. remortgage) using the savings to offset what you need to borrow.

I sometimes think that overpaying on your mortgage is some kind of financial viture signalling when actually, often, it's not the most sensible to improve your personal economy longer term.

Moraxella · 06/03/2023 09:21

i’m overpaying to maximise LTV brackets. But I do it at the end of the year after saving monthly so I keep a buffer for unplanned expenses because once it’s in the mortgage it isn’t coming out if you need it for an emergency ( eg a new boiler)

7Worfs · 06/03/2023 09:14

Squamata · 06/03/2023 08:17

Good nutrition is an investment in your employability and earning power if you want to see it in economic terms, op - you need nutrients to support cognition, immune system etc. And it's important for your kids in growing up healthy.

Put simply, if you live off toasties and then get sick and can't work then you'll have less money in the long run. As well as all the discomfort, stress etc involved.

There are plenty of ideas out there for cheap and nutritious food. It helps to think of food as energy dense (carbs, fatty sugary food, not many vitamins) or nutrient dense (full of vitamins and minerals). A toasty is probably energy dense but not nutrient dense, depending on what you put in it.

Overpaying your mortgage is nice but not worth harming your health for!

This perfectly puts my views.
Health absolutely is the top priority, debt/mortgage is second to it.

I also overpay the mortgage, with current inflation hoarding lots of savings is unwise. We don’t go on holidays at the moment as we have small children and I can’t be doing with that. When youngest is 4 holidays will resume, hopefully. By that time mortgage should be almost paid off.

Kentishbornknitter · 06/03/2023 09:13

@Hungrycaterpillarsmummy The reason for us wasn’t so much to own our home but to have no debt. Not owing anyone a penny means that we have more freedom to do what we want with our money. The earlier you pay off your mortgage the more money you save on the interest that you are paying to the bank. It’s about financial freedom to us.

Lovelyring · 06/03/2023 09:11

We went down to one car. But we've always looked at how much we had spare at the end of the month and paid some extra off.

We've paid our mortgage off now, which is life changing because it means we can afford for me to be a sahm. Also avoided what would have been a massive increase in interest rate from our fixed deal.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 06/03/2023 09:08

I still don't understand WHY.

Also, the kids may be happy with a toastie for now but I would feel guilty passing them up more nutritious and wholesome food in order to pay off the mortgage.
You're kind of giving them an almost pauper lifestyle so you own your home. Strange

DdraigGoch · 06/03/2023 09:06

You should only cut back on things you won't miss. I got rid of the car - for all of the turn key and drive off convenience it was also an inconvenience - no parking in the village, wondering what would go wrong with it next etc.

I would never skimp on food to overpay a mortgage.

Namechange1011111stairs · 06/03/2023 08:56

We were hoping to pay ours off before our deal finishes in 3 (4?) years. We've decided not to. We'll still be over paying and saving where we can (which is less now obviously) but decided that we weren't willing to compromise enough in our daily life to pay it off completely. It's disappointing but best for us right now.

What have we given up/stopped? Nothing that isn't obvious.

  • our house desperately needs work. We're keeping up with maintenance/necessary stuff but things like decorating have gone on the back burner (our living room was last decorated 13yrs ago and is looking VERY sorry for itself!).
  • takeaways are no more. I can't remember the last time we ate out as a family. That makes me sad actually.
  • budgeting better for food.
  • being much stricter with random spends like coffees out. We have different accounts for different things to manage this.
  • stopped all subscriptions apart from a few TV ones which get swopped and changed a lot to make sure we're using them/not overpaying. I did have a couple of craft subscriptions I enjoyed but can't justify them now.
  • I've changed my haircut to a cheaper/less high maintenance one. My daughter also happened to change hers and it now costs less than half of what it did. Unfortunately I can't cut either of them myself.
  • for a little while we both did more overtime (we're lucky to have that option) but again, it wasn't a priority for us.
Kentishbornknitter · 06/03/2023 08:41

We paid off our mortgage early, but never went without food. A chicken from Aldi and fresh veg may actually be cheaper than toasties when you look at the price of bread, cheese and butter. We did it by making small changes as others have said; no new clothes, takeaways, using libraries, going to the park, looking for free events locally, cheaper insurance deals, we used Money Saving Expert to check for deals and offers. We use a budgeting system that looks at every penny and all the extra money went on the mortgage. We saw it as a game and enjoyed the process rather than feeling we were going without.

Testina · 06/03/2023 08:39

Another one who doesn’t understand exactly why you’re set on over paying your mortgage. Yes, your CMS is stopping soon but that’s a long term change I guess? So your mortgage payment needs to be what you can afford, not over paid at the expense of eating properly.
You don’t a roast dinner to count as a proper meal, that’s your mind set so can be changed for free. But whilst there’s nothing wrong with a quick toastie sometimes, it’s not nutritionally a good option if it’s just that.
You should sort out your meals before thinking about the mortgage.

SeatonCarew · 06/03/2023 08:30

Have you checked recently that you are on the best deals for all your monthly bills OP? Obviously there's nothing to be gained on switching your gas and electric at the moment( though that might change quite soon), but if you haven't checked recently then worthwhile savings can often be made.

Power bills should be going down a bit later this year..

Good luck.

Squamata · 06/03/2023 08:17

Good nutrition is an investment in your employability and earning power if you want to see it in economic terms, op - you need nutrients to support cognition, immune system etc. And it's important for your kids in growing up healthy.

Put simply, if you live off toasties and then get sick and can't work then you'll have less money in the long run. As well as all the discomfort, stress etc involved.

There are plenty of ideas out there for cheap and nutritious food. It helps to think of food as energy dense (carbs, fatty sugary food, not many vitamins) or nutrient dense (full of vitamins and minerals). A toasty is probably energy dense but not nutrient dense, depending on what you put in it.

Overpaying your mortgage is nice but not worth harming your health for!

Swipe left for the next trending thread