Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what your employers are doing regarding wfh?

133 replies

Starwarslover · 05/03/2023 21:23

I’ve recently started a new job which officially has no set days required in the office, although I keep hearing things that imply they want people in more. It doesn’t bother me as I’m in 60% anyway but it made me wonder if most employers are like this now, not wanting to put in minimum days but actively pushing for more than people are choosing to do.

YABU - employers are being honest and open and putting in set days

YANBU - they are saying they officially don’t mind when really they do

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Catinabeanbag · 10/03/2023 10:54

I was 100% in the office through the pandemic, then started a new job about 18 months ago which is pretty much 100% working from home. I love wfh. So much better. I do go into the office fairly regularly for meetings or just for a day to catch up with people, but the whole organisation works like that so no one HAS to be in the office (unless for occasional meetings, and even then you don't have to stay the whole day)

  • we choose to be, which makes it so much nicer.
nicslackey · 10/03/2023 10:28

2 days a month in the office and we choose when they are. Totally delighted

Starwarslover · 08/03/2023 15:52

All really interesting. Completely agree with the poster who said they wont just say what they want. My new is place seems like that, moaning behind peoples back but not making it abundantly clear that they want them in, just lots of awkward hints. My old place had a set policy but didn’t actually seem to follow up with people who didn’t follow it so that definitely caused resentment amougst some of the other staff

OP posts:
MoreSleepPleasee · 07/03/2023 17:52

In the office 100% of the time.

Smoky1107 · 07/03/2023 17:45

We are doing two days at home but they are not set, you can do whatever days you like really. I always wfh Wednesdays and use the other around what I've got on both at work and in evenings at home. Works really really well for me

ItsaMetalBand · 07/03/2023 16:00

This is all tough for the next generation of worker. Many new employees in their early twenties are missing out on the experience of face to face team-working. The negotiations, chat, role-modelling socialising after work etc. Many are starting careers either working on a laptop in their bedroom in a shared house, or going to a deserted office. I don’t think it’s great really.

Our workplace offer a 2 day WFH as optional but it's not available unless you've been with the company for a minimum of 2 years. It's primarily so that new members can be mentored better in their roles, but it's also recognising that for many younger graduates living in flat shares or coming from abroad to our city it might be quite isolating and it's a way for them to settle into their careers, make friends / connections and gives them a suitable workspace away from shared accommodation and the issues that may sometimes bring with it.

However they are also very flexible for emergency WFH situations. Just not a set schedule until you are here 2 years.

WannabeMathematician · 07/03/2023 15:02

We can choose how many days but I choose to work four days in the office for work/home life separation.

I like that people can choose but I have found it does require some odd changes. We've had to basically set up a daily chat with one new starter we had last year as he wouldn't call anyone, ever, even if he needed help and that would have been picked up in minutes if he'd been in the office. He's in his late 20's as well so not a fresh new grad.

Basically it works well if you don't take the piss and we've been lucky that there has only been one person who's done that so far.

HurryShadow · 07/03/2023 13:22

We're pretty flexible and are operating a 5 day fortnight, so 3 days in the office one week, 2 days the next. People are allowed to go in more often if they choose to, but that's the minimum attendance expectation.

If you're starting a new role and you have concerns about this, I'd really recommend ensuring the working arrangements are written in to your contract or your offer letter at least.

I'm sure most will caveat it with a "we can change your working location if business needs allow" type thing, but if you've got something in writing you'll have a bit more pushback if a week in to the job they turned around and said they want everyone in the office now.

Balloonpopped · 07/03/2023 12:34

It's interesting regarding younger people/people new to the workplace and new to their sector. I attend a lot of conferences and mentor students and its been fascinating to see the shift in desirable companies. Whereas previously in my sector it was really clear who the top companies were and the highly coveted grad schemes and apprentiships. They weren't even the best paid or whatever but for various reasons it was very clear. Now it's less so, some 'underdogs' have really upped their desirability for young grads and its those who invariably have an office presence at least for a chunk of time.

Whilst people keep saying businesses who don't adapt to remote working will be left behind, I've also seen the opposite true in some cases; highly capable assets being turned off from remote working and giving other organisations a try. I think there's a trade off probably somewhere in the middle, but it's absolutely not a plus for everyone especially specific groups who arguably are huge assets to places.

Mutabiliss · 07/03/2023 12:28

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 07/03/2023 12:24

Worth pointing out too that if you're hybrid, whole cohorts of young people (and indeed all age groups) won't be able to work for you in the first place. It's a self-selecting group. You won't see the ones who are disadvantaged by networking in the office because they haven't joined you in the first place.

That's very true, we hired on remote contracts during Covid and got a much wider range of applicants than we usually get. I would have much preferred that to remain, but the powers that be decided we need to use the expensive office space.

SpringleDingle · 07/03/2023 12:27

Me and my team are full time WFH although there are offices and some of the team do go there now and then when they want to.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 07/03/2023 12:24

Mutabiliss · 07/03/2023 11:36

In my experience the younger people seem to be in the office a lot (we're hybrid), and have made good friends and networks by being in the office. It's preferable for them to come in rather than work at their parents' homes or in shared houses. The directors and heads of department are all in a lot too, as they can afford to live near the office in central London.

The middle-aged middle management (like me) who moved out of London to have babies are the ones who are remaining WFH, and are probably missing out on networking because of it.

Worth pointing out too that if you're hybrid, whole cohorts of young people (and indeed all age groups) won't be able to work for you in the first place. It's a self-selecting group. You won't see the ones who are disadvantaged by networking in the office because they haven't joined you in the first place.

housemaus · 07/03/2023 12:21

We don't mind, really.

We have some people who do 1 day every fortnight in the office and others who are in every day, with the bulk of people doing 2-3 days in the office a week.

We trust people to make the decisions that work for them - some roles don't really need office time at all, some work best with a bit more because they're more collaborative, and people have naturally graduated toward what works for their role without us pushing it.

Our only stipulation is that people come in when it's required - i.e. we have a client visit - or, if that never happens for a particular role, 'occasionally' so we can do 1-1s in person. We don't specify an actual amount of days.

Dis626 · 07/03/2023 12:09

We are only allowed to WFH 1 or 2 days a week, which I'm happy with.

DashboardConfessional · 07/03/2023 11:42

What's annoying me is that it's often the whim of whoever is in charge. DH is 100% remote but one boss later and they want new hires to be in 2 days a week.

Mutabiliss · 07/03/2023 11:36

ProposedWarning · 07/03/2023 11:25

This is all tough for the next generation of worker. Many new employees in their early twenties are missing out on the experience of face to face team-working. The negotiations, chat, role-modelling socialising after work etc. Many are starting careers either working on a laptop in their bedroom in a shared house, or going to a deserted office. I don’t think it’s great really.

Fine for all these mums who now love doing the school run and laundry around their working day. For the next generation of young workers, not so much. (Obviously individual exceptions will apply).

In my experience the younger people seem to be in the office a lot (we're hybrid), and have made good friends and networks by being in the office. It's preferable for them to come in rather than work at their parents' homes or in shared houses. The directors and heads of department are all in a lot too, as they can afford to live near the office in central London.

The middle-aged middle management (like me) who moved out of London to have babies are the ones who are remaining WFH, and are probably missing out on networking because of it.

OnGoldenPond · 07/03/2023 11:30

Quveas · 05/03/2023 21:39

Public sector. Always made it clear that office working would return although some hybrid working was done pre-pandemic. Has sold off a lot of property to balance the budget, so hybrid being forced to a degree. In general, if hybrid is possible, then its a minimum of two office days unless.... for those who need to work in an office for health reasons, they can work as many days as they need... or for a few who are better working from home (usually disability related) they can mostly work from home but must be able to attend in person meetings. But our employer introduced an interesting variation. Anyone who moved more than 60 minutes drive from the office despite being told that normal working would resume is required to work from the office every day. No exceptions and no arguments. That was done because of piss takers who thought another county /country was commutable... then argued they couldn't be expected to get in

Hmmm would be interesting to know if anyone has challenged on that last point- can't see how treating a group of employees less favourably than the rest just because you are pissed off with them would be legal! Confused

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 07/03/2023 11:29

ProposedWarning · 07/03/2023 11:25

This is all tough for the next generation of worker. Many new employees in their early twenties are missing out on the experience of face to face team-working. The negotiations, chat, role-modelling socialising after work etc. Many are starting careers either working on a laptop in their bedroom in a shared house, or going to a deserted office. I don’t think it’s great really.

Fine for all these mums who now love doing the school run and laundry around their working day. For the next generation of young workers, not so much. (Obviously individual exceptions will apply).

This gets said a lot on here, and it leaves out all the young workers for whom office/workplace based jobs actually function to exclude them.

For young people who are neurodiverse, disabled, carers, managing chronic conditions, geographically isolated, actually more remote working opens up the opportunities and experiences that are available to them. They're no more or less important than the young people who did derive benefit from socialising after work and chit chat rather than being fucked over by their importance.

ProposedWarning · 07/03/2023 11:25

This is all tough for the next generation of worker. Many new employees in their early twenties are missing out on the experience of face to face team-working. The negotiations, chat, role-modelling socialising after work etc. Many are starting careers either working on a laptop in their bedroom in a shared house, or going to a deserted office. I don’t think it’s great really.

Fine for all these mums who now love doing the school run and laundry around their working day. For the next generation of young workers, not so much. (Obviously individual exceptions will apply).

Jules912 · 07/03/2023 11:11

No requirement but there are parts of the job that need to be done in the office and everyone is expected to do their fair share of those.

StackBlocks · 07/03/2023 10:56

I am mostly WFH but the big bosses do make some noise about wanting people to come in 2 days a week. I would happily do that if the office wasn’t so inconvenient, it’s in the middle of a city but with very little parking nearby, the train station and bus station are 20+ minutes walk away and I have 2 young DC to drop off and pick up (although DH does cover this as well as me). My job can be fully done from home. So far we’ve had no pressure to come in, just gentle encouragement but if it were to be mandated I would look for another job I think. If they would find a more suitable office then I’d happily come in every day!

Cinnamon23 · 07/03/2023 10:50

Ours is 1+ days in the office.

LadyR77 · 07/03/2023 10:50

We have complete flexibility, although some roles are lab-based so can't be done from home. I tend to be in the office 4 days per week as I prefer it to WFH.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 07/03/2023 10:47

There were a few incentives in old contract to get people to come in, eg nice coffee machine, cafes, free fruit, office snack treats bought regularly, office social etc events during/after work.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 07/03/2023 10:45

I’m currently on a 6 month contract and we’re expected in about 2-3 times a month but no specified days.

Previous contract we were expected in the office 2 days a week.

Now when I’m looking for a permanent job a lot of companies seem to expect you in 5 days a week. I’m older and have been there and done commuting, I get more done at home etc.

I really don’t get why companies do want you in 5 days a week or more as it’s almost as though you don’t trust you to work effectively at home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread