Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People are always more generous with imaginary money compared with how they would expect someone to deal in real life

129 replies

Blueysshoes · 05/03/2023 21:00

I know I am lucky and that there is a cost of living crisis but this is more about principle than finance.

So, we send our 3 kids to private school. We can, and do, afford it ourselves but if push came to shove my parents would step in as they have a lot of capacity that way. My MIL knows this which does give us wiggle room others wouldn’t have.

My DH’s sister has a very stable job but it doesn’t pay as much (but we run our own business so that in itself is less stable) which means she can’t afford private school. Unfortunately the school her children are likely to go to isn’t brilliant. Anyway, my MIL (who always loves telling me how DH and I should share) tonight declared that if ‘she had the money’ she would not only pay for her children to send their kids to private school, but ‘nieces and nephews’ because it wouldn’t be fair that one set of kids got an advantage the others didn’t.

She then finished with the fact that if she won the lottery but could only afford to help one of her children, it would obviously be SIL that got the help. Of course, the start point of this was that SIL couldn’t do it without help (whilst the assumption is we always could) but I do wonder if this was a case of her actually thinking we should contribute, not just a daydream about what she would do with unlimited cash.

OP posts:
Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:02

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 08:28

I find the generosity to be a bit of a bell curve, with the most generous people being average earners.

There also seems to be huge entitlement on the part of people who don’t work and claim benefits, particularly on here. I don’t mean the very disabled, but people who are out of work ‘depressed’ or work a few hours a week and top up with UC because ‘that works better for me’. They seem to genuinely believe they deserve the same lifestyle (holidays, Netflix, nice clothes) as somebody who slogs away 40 hours a week, and what’s more, the person working should be happy to pay for them and if not they’re ‘rich and greedy’ even if they earn 27k.

I was quite seriously told by a benefits claimant on here that ‘things aren’t easy, I might have to cut back on holidays and weekends away’. I work full time and haven’t left the country since 2017 because I’m skint. Hilarious!

Well I’m sorry, but the amount of benefits that are claimed fraudulently are very small compared to the amount of tax dodged. And who is anybody to judge who is able to work and who isn’t? Who is genuinely disabled and who isn’t? Outwardly, I know loads of people who who don’t look Ill or disabled but are, unless you live someone else’s life you have no bloody clue.

Yes, in some ways the system is flawed but most people get it for a reason. Do you know how difficult PIP is to get, for example? The DWP purposely turns a high percentage of claims down in the hope some don’t appeal or have no one to help. Those that so appeal have a very high success rate. It’s a disgrace.

Why should they be denied the chance to have holidays and have some semblance of a normal nice life? Should they be miserable eating porridge every meal?

I learned to stop being a judgmental arse years ago like that.

cigarettesNalcohol · 06/03/2023 08:40

Yanbu. What planet is your MiL living on ? Life doesn't work like that. They are cousins, not siblings. It would be different if you had 3 children but only paid private for one of them. But cousins don't get the same opportunities and that is completely normal. After all, they don't share the same set of grandparents...

My cousins grew up ultra rich and have had many more opportunities than me whilst growing up and still do to this day. Does it bother me ? Not at all. My uncle married into a rich family and my cousins' grandparents (the set we don't share) were loaded... but that doesn't mean we should see some of that money come our way, does it now ? Nor would I ever expect it to.

Similarly, my brother and his wife both earn a ton of money too. And want to send their kids private. Would my mum expect them to pay/share for my kids ? Absolutely not. Would my husband and I want them to ? Of course not. Will my children do well in the local state school ? Yes I believe so... money isn't everything in life.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 08:28

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 07:53

Well, yes, technically. But somebody could do a damn sight more with the £900,000 they would have remaining from a million than someone could do with the £90 they had left from the hundred. Everything costs more when you’re poor and that’s the whole point. If someone only had £100 they would feel a 10% loss far more, so it’s a shit comparison.

This is why the tax bands are lower for lower earners.

Ironically, the ones with the least tend to be the most generous.

I find the generosity to be a bit of a bell curve, with the most generous people being average earners.

There also seems to be huge entitlement on the part of people who don’t work and claim benefits, particularly on here. I don’t mean the very disabled, but people who are out of work ‘depressed’ or work a few hours a week and top up with UC because ‘that works better for me’. They seem to genuinely believe they deserve the same lifestyle (holidays, Netflix, nice clothes) as somebody who slogs away 40 hours a week, and what’s more, the person working should be happy to pay for them and if not they’re ‘rich and greedy’ even if they earn 27k.

I was quite seriously told by a benefits claimant on here that ‘things aren’t easy, I might have to cut back on holidays and weekends away’. I work full time and haven’t left the country since 2017 because I’m skint. Hilarious!

ImAvingOops · 06/03/2023 08:26

I think your mil would have done better to not voice her musings out loud. Certainly it isn't your responsibility to pay for the education of sil's children. We couldn't afford private school, so when we were looking to buy a house, the quality of the local state schools was a priority consideration. It means living more rurally that I would ideally prefer, but that's what you do when you have kids, you plan your life around their best interests. If sil chose a bigger house as her priority, that's not your problem to fix.
To be fair to mil, she is probably seeing the disparity and just musing out loud that she would like to see her grandchildren have equal opportunities. I don't think she is seriously expecting you to pay for it.

Grumpafrump · 06/03/2023 08:13

I get it, OP. DH earns a lot and it feels like people are constantly hinting at how we should spend our money. We are actually fairly generous and spread out our donations across several different projects, but of course if people aren’t the recipients of those funds themselves, they seem to assume we aren’t giving anywhere at all. I have a particular aversion to helping anyone who gives off a whiff of sanctimonious “I deserve your money because I make less than you do” vibes.

You and your SIL made different life choices, and you have different financial positions now. If her family was starving and homeless, that would be one thing, but private education is a pure luxury. It is not your responsibility to pay for your nieces and nephews to go to private school.

Lovethatforyou · 06/03/2023 08:12

I’m sensing a superiority complex in OP…

3littlerabbits · 06/03/2023 08:11

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 22:05

I saw somebody on here say ‘if you have £100 and won’t give away £10, why should someone with £1 million give away £100,000?’ And it’s really true!

That’s really really not true 😁 Being left with £90 is not the same as being left with £900,000

riotlady · 06/03/2023 08:03

Thisisthewaywe · 06/03/2023 07:50

Erm @riotlady was that really necessary? Hmm Sorry but that really was quite offensive.

Apologies for the offence- I’m queer and it gave me quite a giggle, the Romans have a spectacular turn of phrase. Happy to delete if it’s upsetting

Vegrocks · 06/03/2023 07:55

copied aspects of our house

Oh Op. You petty petty petty person 😂

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 07:53

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 22:05

I saw somebody on here say ‘if you have £100 and won’t give away £10, why should someone with £1 million give away £100,000?’ And it’s really true!

Well, yes, technically. But somebody could do a damn sight more with the £900,000 they would have remaining from a million than someone could do with the £90 they had left from the hundred. Everything costs more when you’re poor and that’s the whole point. If someone only had £100 they would feel a 10% loss far more, so it’s a shit comparison.

This is why the tax bands are lower for lower earners.

Ironically, the ones with the least tend to be the most generous.

Thisisthewaywe · 06/03/2023 07:53

Who was it who said ‘a man who is not a socialist in his twenties has no heart; a man who is socialist in his forties has no brain?’ Words to that effect anyway.

RoyalTreatment · 06/03/2023 07:51

@Fizzadora don't think we're talking about the same thing

Wafflefudge · 06/03/2023 07:51

Doesn't sound like she's expecting or asking you to subsidise anything.
Just that she wishes she could help her daughter. People say stuff about winning the lottery all the time, that they'd pay off someone's mortgage etc. It's just imagining possibilities.

Thisisthewaywe · 06/03/2023 07:50

Erm @riotlady was that really necessary? Hmm Sorry but that really was quite offensive.

Fizzadora · 06/03/2023 07:37

RoyalTreatment · 06/03/2023 07:20

There is a reason the rich tend to vote Conservative and you hardly ever see a wealthy socialist. Everything is 'but what's in it for me?' not 'what's for the greater good?'

What apart from all the wealthy ones?

taxguru · 06/03/2023 07:29

sst1234 · 05/03/2023 22:44

Everyone’s a socialist until they are the ones paying.

So true. Same with taxes. People are "happy" to pay when the numbers are small and it hardly affects them. When they start having to pay bigger amounts, they change, especially when they have to make payments once or twice a year (self employed or landlords etc) or realise they'll have capital gains tax to pay on selling a property or shares! There's a lot of virtue signalling going on, i.e. when you tell someone they've a couple of hundred pounds of tax to pay on windfall, they're "that's fine, we all have to pay our share". When it's tens of thousands, their first question is "how can I not pay that!"?

The best (worst) client I saw it in action was a teacher who was also the union rep at our local comp school. He was often on local TV as the "spokesman" for his union during strikes etc. He came to me as a client because he set up a sideline business. At our first meeting, I went through options for "tax efficiency", but he did the virtue signalling saying he wanted to pay his tax IF he made a profit. For the first couple of years he made a loss and was happy to offset it against his teacher wages to get tax refunds. The third/fourth years, he made a small profit and paid his tax which was just a couple of hundred or so. For year 5, his business took off, and I remember seeing his face at the meeting when I told him his tax bill was a few thousand! He asked what he could do to reduce it and I told him it was last year and too late to change things, he was livid! We then went on to what to do to reduce the tax for the current year, and he ended up converting to a limited company, "employing" his wife and giving her shares (as she didn't work so didn't use her personal allowance), and for the next few years, he was back to paying a few hundred in tax, and happy again! (After engaging in tax avoidance!). Then he was on TV again spouting about how they should "tax the rich" more!

RoyalTreatment · 06/03/2023 07:25

This is typical the attitude of 'subsidising their choices', 'but we've worked hard!' what you've reached from success and money in your business hasn't all come down to purely hard work and personal merits, there were advantages and unfair opportunities that you too benefitted from. Life is not fair and it's a myth being about all what you chose or deserve in life. You don't reach the top without stepping over some people. I think it grates on me the lack of awareness and empathy, it's all very hard nosed and cold approach.

donttellmehesalive · 06/03/2023 07:21

Yes, people always know exactly what other people should do.

But it doesn't sound like she was having a dig or saying that you should pay was she? To me, it sounds as if she sees the advantages your dc enjoy and wishes she could provide her other gc with those same opportunities.

You do sound quite disdainful of both her and sil tbh. Yes, people make their choices in life but it doesn't stop most of us from wishing we'd done things differently from time to time, or even just feeling a bit of envy about what other people have got.

RoyalTreatment · 06/03/2023 07:20

There is a reason the rich tend to vote Conservative and you hardly ever see a wealthy socialist. Everything is 'but what's in it for me?' not 'what's for the greater good?'

Florissant · 06/03/2023 07:17

True. People are generous when it's someone else's money. And they always want other people's taxes raised, too.

pawz · 06/03/2023 07:14

We're got a nephew who's only a toddler - we don't have any DC yet, already we've had comments about funding things for him!! My husband is a high earner and I do well too, so my MIL always makes comments about us "chipping in" for things for DN.

BIL doesn't earn much because he job hops and has no motivation to earn (he's said he's happy plodding along and doesn't want a stressful job) and his partner refuses to work more than two days a week.

I always massively eye roll when the subject comes up! It got to the point we were asked for fund their first family holiday - I had to hold back a laugh. Genuinely I understand for MIL it's hard seeing one son successful in a monetary sense and the other not, but it's not her job to redistribute earnings at all.

RainbowBrightside · 06/03/2023 07:12

Prince Harry got crap grades at Eton, you can’t buy good grades. Not saying this will happen with your kids @Blueysshoes but my point is that if your SIL kids are clever and motivated enough then they’ll do well wherever they go.

Blueysshoes · 06/03/2023 07:07

My DS has done better than me so my three don’t get opportunities her kids do. That’s life. I would not expect her to subsidise my choices.

If my family didn’t exist, this type of education is not a world MIL would have considered being all socialist (of course) so would have been happy with the educational choices SIL made. That’s not my problem.

OP posts:
RoyalTreatment · 06/03/2023 07:07

Yes, most people are more generous with imaginary money because when people do have the money they actually become more greedy. The rich don't stay rich by giving their money away, after all. The tightest people I know are minted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread