Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People are always more generous with imaginary money compared with how they would expect someone to deal in real life

129 replies

Blueysshoes · 05/03/2023 21:00

I know I am lucky and that there is a cost of living crisis but this is more about principle than finance.

So, we send our 3 kids to private school. We can, and do, afford it ourselves but if push came to shove my parents would step in as they have a lot of capacity that way. My MIL knows this which does give us wiggle room others wouldn’t have.

My DH’s sister has a very stable job but it doesn’t pay as much (but we run our own business so that in itself is less stable) which means she can’t afford private school. Unfortunately the school her children are likely to go to isn’t brilliant. Anyway, my MIL (who always loves telling me how DH and I should share) tonight declared that if ‘she had the money’ she would not only pay for her children to send their kids to private school, but ‘nieces and nephews’ because it wouldn’t be fair that one set of kids got an advantage the others didn’t.

She then finished with the fact that if she won the lottery but could only afford to help one of her children, it would obviously be SIL that got the help. Of course, the start point of this was that SIL couldn’t do it without help (whilst the assumption is we always could) but I do wonder if this was a case of her actually thinking we should contribute, not just a daydream about what she would do with unlimited cash.

OP posts:
journeyofsanity · 06/03/2023 12:30

Coffeellama · 05/03/2023 22:25

Did she declare it was to build a bigger house than you? Why don’t you like her?

Doesn't sound like the OP dislikes SIL. Sounds more like she is sick of being told to subsidies SILs choices.

Blueysshoes · 06/03/2023 12:30

@TheVeryThing I dunno. I felt that the comment that if she could have paid for nieces and nephews to go to private school because she had had more money then she would and anyone who didn't think the same was being churlish and "selfish" was pretty pointed. Going on to specify that my children would be having advantages DIL's kids wouldn't have was also pretty specific. I get that she's upset because she can't help but it's not my job either.

OP posts:
journeyofsanity · 06/03/2023 12:29

Blueysshoes · 05/03/2023 22:15

It’s the catchment area. SIL moved to an area where they could build a bigger house than us (sacrificing garden and location - but least it’s ‘bigger’) and that’s the school.

Interesting choice. Not one I would have made but there you go. We all have different priorities. She chose hers and as a result her dc go to a crap school.

Creamcrackersandricecakes · 06/03/2023 10:05

My sister and BIL are, to put it bluntly, loaded. Their DC went to private school. My DC does not, my sis and BIL do not fund us in any way, (other than generous birthday and Xmas gifts to DD), nor would I ever expect them to. DD is the responsibility of me and DH, no one else. Just ignore MIL's obvious hint dropping.

EL8888 · 06/03/2023 09:54

People are super generous with imaginary money and other people’s money l have noticed. Your MIL’s comments seem very pointed to me, as others have said she can save up then, downsize etc. We all have choices e.g. SIL chose to have more than 1 child, chose to live where they live etc

TheVeryThing · 06/03/2023 09:49

Just to be clear, the MIL didn't actually make any reference to you subsidising your SIL's family or contributing to her children's education?
If I have understood correctly, then you've just made a massive assumption and got a load of people outraged on your behalf based on nothing but your own imagination.

SettlingForAnotherMuffin · 06/03/2023 09:46

Blueysshoes · 05/03/2023 22:15

It’s the catchment area. SIL moved to an area where they could build a bigger house than us (sacrificing garden and location - but least it’s ‘bigger’) and that’s the school.

yes, people make choices.

We have our DC at a private school. To pay for that we downsized substantially and have taken a big hit on some quality of life issues. I have a cousin who snipes about us being able to afford private school. We are luckly I know. But she has 2 more chidlren than us and played catchment area monopoly. Whatever- horses for courses, but take ownership of your own choices ffs!

KatyKlanger · 06/03/2023 09:38

There is no cost to being generous in a hypothetical scenario - only social benefit. As soon as the situation becomes real, those words cost - and most people don't want to pay up.

Cornettoninja · 06/03/2023 09:38

Mil comment about the difference in grandchildren’s education opportunities leads to people getting antsy about ring fencing their personal finances against social safety nets.

Never change MN you utter fruitloop.

OP, you’re not going to (and aren’t obligated) provide funding if any sort for your nieces/nephews so don’t give it any head space. Not sure why that’s difficult.

DaveyJonesLocker · 06/03/2023 09:38

So she thinks your parents should pay for SILs kids but if she had the money she doesn't think she should have to pay for her own sons kids. That's some impressive hypocrisy.

Sceptre86 · 06/03/2023 09:34

'Shame you haven't won the lottery then' followed by a deep sigh. Otherwise move the conversation and if you are feeling brave tell her it's not up to you to pay for private school for anyone else's children.

We could have afforded it for one child as I would have stayed working full time but I found out I was pregnant with my son when my eldest was 6 months. We then decided to have another child so it's definitely out of reach for us. I wouldn't go asking or hinting anyone else should pay for our kids to go. Your sister in law might not even be aware her mum is being annoying and mentioning stuff like this.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:30

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/03/2023 09:25

‘I learned to stop being a judgmental arse years ago like that.’

I think not.

I think so, because I don’t stick my nose in other people’s affairs or carry illogical opinions or beliefs about benefit claimants, or equate £900,000 is the same as £90! 🤣

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/03/2023 09:25

‘I learned to stop being a judgmental arse years ago like that.’

I think not.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/03/2023 09:25

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:16

I don’t think some people missing out makes others frauding the system okay 🤷🏼‍♀️

It says it all about someone when one is a much bigger focus for them than the other

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:25

Because you asked me if I was a claimant.

  1. No I’m not, and if I was it would have absolutely nothing to do with you.
  2. I work with people with ‘depression’ as you put it ( it’s clearly not real in your eyes) and other illnesses that can be debilitating and i have previously suffered and am lucky enough to be well again, and you are ignorant and absolutely talking through your arse.
HTH
Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:21

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:19

Hahaha! I work in mental health. Go take your ignorance elsewhere. You clearly have no idea what you’re talking about and it’s offensive.

What’s that got to do with anything? I was curious as to whether you claim anything as that no doubt would influence your opinion.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 06/03/2023 09:21

and you hardly ever see a wealthy socialist.

😭😭😭

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:19

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:17

Depends what you mean by disabled. Unable to work due to motor neurone disease? Yes absolutely! ‘Depressed’? No, sorry.

You’re entitled to think what you like 🤷🏼‍♀️ I think my opinion is the quietly popular one.

Hahaha! I work in mental health. Go take your ignorance elsewhere. You clearly have no idea what you’re talking about and it’s offensive.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:17

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:16

So you don’t think someone disabled or Ill deserves to have one cheap holiday? Or any form of nice life whatsoever? Even though it’s not their fault? Ok.

I think your opinion is shit considering you think it’s true that being left with £900,000 is equal and equivalent to £90.

Depends what you mean by disabled. Unable to work due to motor neurone disease? Yes absolutely! ‘Depressed’? No, sorry.

You’re entitled to think what you like 🤷🏼‍♀️ I think my opinion is the quietly popular one.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:16

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/03/2023 09:12

Given the best estimates are that around 15 billion of benefits goes unclaimed we’re hardly being drowned by fraud…

Especially when the estimates are for “error and fraud” and we all know how riddled with errors the system is

I don’t think some people missing out makes others frauding the system okay 🤷🏼‍♀️

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:16

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:13

But they might have other health problems/debilitating mental illness which renders them unable to get out of bed some days? How well do you know this person?

Even if your assertions are true then it’s one person. There are more chancers, but the vast majority are deserving. There will always be some that slip through the net, it’s part and parcel of life.

The government like to vilify benefit claimants like scum, and immigrants. It’s all their fault. Meanwhile, they’re ripping us all off big style. It’s a deflection.

I’d find something else to get hung up on if I were you.

So you don’t think someone disabled or Ill deserves to have one cheap holiday? Or any form of nice life whatsoever? Even though it’s not their fault? Ok.

I think your opinion is shit considering you think it’s true that being left with £900,000 is equal and equivalent to £90.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 09:15

Are you a benefits claimant?

JudgeRinderonTinder · 06/03/2023 09:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

But they might have other health problems/debilitating mental illness which renders them unable to get out of bed some days? How well do you know this person?

Even if your assertions are true then it’s one person. There are more chancers, but the vast majority are deserving. There will always be some that slip through the net, it’s part and parcel of life.

The government like to vilify benefit claimants like scum, and immigrants. It’s all their fault. Meanwhile, they’re ripping us all off big style. It’s a deflection.

I’d find something else to get hung up on if I were you.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/03/2023 09:12

Given the best estimates are that around 15 billion of benefits goes unclaimed we’re hardly being drowned by fraud…

Especially when the estimates are for “error and fraud” and we all know how riddled with errors the system is

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/03/2023 09:11

Jeez.

never takes long for anything money related to turn into a benefit bashing thread on here these days

Swipe left for the next trending thread