Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Self Diagnosing PTSD and Other Mental Health Issues

129 replies

Mari9999 · 05/03/2023 20:20

Is anyone else struck by the what seems like a significantly high number of women who describe themselves as suffering form PTSD ? Is it possible that these women are all self diagnosing ? Usually they attribute these conditions to what are seemingly every day life conflicts.

Many other say that they cannot work because of their mental health. Has there been some drastic increase in debilitating mental diagnosis that render women disabled and physically incapable of working? Are these women all capable of qualifying for disability benefits?

AIBU to think that this cavalier attitude towards mental health makes it difficult for women with medically diagnosed issues to be taken seriously?

It also seems that every second woman claims to have been married to a narcissist or for their current partner to have a cheating narcissist as an ex?

What ever happened to simply coping, being responsible, and owning one's behavior?

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:41

But now people are just encouraged to draw the curtains and lie in the dark ruminating over their problems. There’s a lot to be said for basic self care.

Yep, self care has turned into a shorthand for mindfulness, candles and yoga (which have their place) but basic self care - caring for your body, home environment and sleep hygiene - is essential for wellbeing. Not always easy, and certainly not exciting but makes a huge difference to mental health.

Dodgeitornot · 05/03/2023 23:38

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 23:31

@Dodgeitornot there simply isn’t the money for the level of intervention the public need with their mental and physical health any more (and the two are very intertwined). That’s the bottom line.

My point is there never was. My family has been in the MH system for well over 20 years. There never was help aside from meds. Much reliance on charities which have all but disappeared.

Saschka · 05/03/2023 23:38

Lavenderflower · 05/03/2023 23:26

This comment is inaccurate. Some people do work and other don't.

I was replying to somebody saying nobody with PTSD should need time off work because her husband, who has Proper PTSD from being in the army (different to flakey female PTSD from personal trauma) apparently didn’t.

I am aware some people work and some people can’t, and I held down a demanding job myself following EMDR treatment (which didn’t completely cure it, but made it manageable).

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:36

So it does irk me when posters make it out to be incompetence, malice or a deliberate withholding of services. The system isn’t broken as such, we are breaking it.

The system is broken, and some clinicians are incompetent and try to withhold services. Both can be true.

The consultant psychiatrist I referred to didn’t engage with my daughter at all throughout the consultation. She ended up hiding under a chair at the age of 9. He claimed to have no knowledge of research in the area of developmental trauma and argued that she would be fine if I just loved her enough. He was also the rudest, most condescending man I’ve ever spoken to.

The system is broken, but some of the staff are shocking. My DDs therapist on the other hand, I couldn’t praise highly enough.

XenoBitch · 05/03/2023 23:33

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 23:27

I agree.

So many people neglect their health, don’t exercise, don’t try to go to sleep at a reasonable time, spend all their time on screens then wonder why their mental health is poor.

If I’m having a shit day, my first port of call is to tidy/clean the house and get some fresh air, even just a 15 minute walk. I always feel at least 50% better after this.

But now people are just encouraged to draw the curtains and lie in the dark ruminating over their problems. There’s a lot to be said for basic self care.

It is almost as like people are being told that being sad, anxious, depressed, scared..... any negative emotion.. is bad and needs therapy and medication.
Negative experiences and feelings are part of life.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 23:31

@Dodgeitornot there simply isn’t the money for the level of intervention the public need with their mental and physical health any more (and the two are very intertwined). That’s the bottom line.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:31

A close family member was sectioned at 14 and given the diagnosis then. Absolutely incorrectly, about 10 other psychiatrists also gave them multiple other diagnosis. It was like they were playing russian roulette with a diagnostic manual.

Thats appalling, I’m sorry for their experience - I firmly disagree with psychiatric diagnosis for young people, there’s simply too much going on developmentally to label a child for life.

Dodgeitornot · 05/03/2023 23:28

@Moonicorn I agree, however it was crap even when people weren't chasing a diagnosis by the million. Aside from a diagnosis there has never been much in terms of therapies available.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 23:27

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:22

Experience of traumatic event or events does not equal PTSD. A period of anxiety is not PTSD. We are essentially belittling the severity of PTSD by associating it with anxiety.

Indeed, a period of anxiety or stress is normal after a traumatic event, we do no one any favours pathologising normal human distress.

I agree.

So many people neglect their health, don’t exercise, don’t try to go to sleep at a reasonable time, spend all their time on screens then wonder why their mental health is poor.

If I’m having a shit day, my first port of call is to tidy/clean the house and get some fresh air, even just a 15 minute walk. I always feel at least 50% better after this.

But now people are just encouraged to draw the curtains and lie in the dark ruminating over their problems. There’s a lot to be said for basic self care.

Lavenderflower · 05/03/2023 23:26

Saschka · 05/03/2023 21:27

I had PTSD after a violent stranger rape (diagnosed by a NHS consultant psychiatrist), and I absolutely couldn’t work. Couldn’t leave the house, scared of all strange men (as I was excruciatingly aware of what they could easily do to me), panic attacks and flashbacks multiple times a day. I had been a high-achieving medical student also holding down a part-time job immediately before I was assaulted.

Your husband was able to work because he wasn’t encountering all of his triggers multiple times a day. Rape victims may be triggered every time they see a strange man, or have to walk alone in public, or wait at a bus stop. Would your husband have managed to hold down a full time job in a firing range, or as a fireworks coordinator?

This comment is inaccurate. Some people do work and other don't.

Dodgeitornot · 05/03/2023 23:25

@Jellycatspyjamas I wish it was just an increase in life insurance. A close family member was sectioned at 14 and given the diagnosis then. Absolutely incorrectly, about 10 other psychiatrists also gave them multiple other diagnosis. It was like they were playing russian roulette with a diagnostic manual. They've managed to get rid of them all aside from the C-PTSD one. It certainly feels like crap when you're being referred for physio but have a massive at risk patient sign on top of your file because of the C-PTSD diagnosis. Or when you've given birth and have to embarrassingly wait for a shrink to give you the ok before you're discharged in front of family members. Not to mention the amount of life insurance companies that just won't touch you.
None of this of course is mentioned at the point of diagnosis.
I completely agree, the MH system here is absolutely broken. There is very little, if any, support aside from pills.

Lentilweaver · 05/03/2023 23:24

Dodgeitornot · 05/03/2023 23:18

@Lentilweaver I think everyone will have experienced traumatic events, and may even have flashbacks or periods where they are struggling with them, but not everyone will have PTSD. I think this is the distinction we need to make. Experience of traumatic event or events does not equal PTSD. A period of anxiety is not PTSD. We are essentially belittling the severity of PTSD by associating it with anxiety. .
PTSD is life long, chronic, and debilitating. Post traumatic stress isn't. One can develop into the other but it's not the same. Neither is pleasant.

This makes sense.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 23:24

I don’t think most of you realise quite what the NHS is facing in terms of mental health.

They are facing an astronomical rise in people presenting at their GP with mental health issues, many of them complex and not fitting into any clear diagnostic box. ‘New’ mental health issues - gender dysphoria, different forms of OCD, ADHD and ASD in adults where the diagnostic criteria just gets wider and wider - have absolutely overhwhelmed the services which cannot keep up. It isn’t surprising that the NHS haven’t managed to triple their services and create five star, gold standard and timely pathways for every person turning up with a mental health complaint in the space of a handful of years.

So it does irk me when posters make it out to be incompetence, malice or a deliberate withholding of services. The system isn’t broken as such, we are breaking it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:22

Experience of traumatic event or events does not equal PTSD. A period of anxiety is not PTSD. We are essentially belittling the severity of PTSD by associating it with anxiety.

Indeed, a period of anxiety or stress is normal after a traumatic event, we do no one any favours pathologising normal human distress.

Dodgeitornot · 05/03/2023 23:18

@Lentilweaver I think everyone will have experienced traumatic events, and may even have flashbacks or periods where they are struggling with them, but not everyone will have PTSD. I think this is the distinction we need to make. Experience of traumatic event or events does not equal PTSD. A period of anxiety is not PTSD. We are essentially belittling the severity of PTSD by associating it with anxiety. .
PTSD is life long, chronic, and debilitating. Post traumatic stress isn't. One can develop into the other but it's not the same. Neither is pleasant.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:15

However, psychiatrists are mostly pill givers which a lot of people don't realise. Mostly not very nice ones.

Absolutely, on both counts. It was clear from the outset he was meeting me to tick a box and get my DD off the waiting list. Unfortunately for him I know the system well, and have a strong understanding of trauma professionally - it shouldn’t be the case that parents need expert levels of knowledge to get the support their kids need, but realistically if you don’t know what you’re talking about and stand your ground, chances are you won’t get the help you need.

NHS mental health services are appalling, a diagnosis should mean much more than an increase in your life insurance costs.

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/03/2023 23:14

Lentilweaver · 05/03/2023 23:10

Everyone will or has experienced trauma.

See, the first line of that Julia Samuel article is that not everyone has trauma. So I am in two minds.

Potato, potato. That doesn't work written down does it?

I think she's referring to significant trauma. I mean we probably have all experienced something which could affect us. It just didn't.

Lentilweaver · 05/03/2023 23:10

Everyone will or has experienced trauma.

See, the first line of that Julia Samuel article is that not everyone has trauma. So I am in two minds.

Dodgeitornot · 05/03/2023 23:10

@Jellycatspyjamas in my opinion, it should never be up to a psychiatrist whether someone has access to therapeutic help but the routes needed to access CAMHS support are ridiculous and in itself material for another thread. However, psychiatrists are mostly pill givers which a lot of people don't realise. Mostly not very nice ones.

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/03/2023 23:08

Lentilweaver · 05/03/2023 23:03

I have no problem believing PTSD exists. But if you go on Twitter or Insta, every second young person claims to be suffering from "trauma". That can't be right. The word is being bandied about for ordinary life events like breaking up with a boyfriend, failing an exam, or being overweight.

This is the distinction I make for people.

Everyone will or has experienced trauma. Only some people experience significant trauma. Only some of those people go on to develop behaviours, thoughts or feelings related to the trauma which affect their lives significantly. These are the people who need support.

For example I have a friend whose experience of childbirth was almost exactly the same as mine, almost to the hour. She has PTSD and I don't. Because she thought her baby and she were going to die and I did not.

We both experienced trauma. Mine wasn't significant and doesn't affect my life. Hers was and does.

The same with young people. They will all experienced anxiety, situational mostly. Only some will experience significant anxiety which affects their life. Unless you're psychic or a professional, you can't tell which is which.

HappyBinosaur · 05/03/2023 23:08

I have cptsd and was incredibly angry with the diagnosis before I came to terms with it. I actually shouted at my psychologist because the thought of it was so overwhelming.
I appear ‘fine’ and am a professional with a lovely husband, 3 dc and a great job, and no one would know unless I told them. Over the past couple of years I’ve slowly started telling a few people and I’d be horrified to think that people thought I was self diagnosing or making it up.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/03/2023 23:06

So your psychiatrist, a Dr specialising in giving out pharmaceutical drugs for mental illness, not therapy, told you your daughter needs a secure home and patience and you disagree with that?

He said all she needed was a secure, loving home - and yes I did disagree with him, because there is a plethora of research showing that children impacted by developmental trauma benefit from early therapeutic intervention. A secure loving family is part of the picture but not the whole picture. Denying therapeutic support on the basis that love is enough leaves parents trying to support deeply traumatised children while also blaming themselves for their child’s distress because if they were merely loving enough, patient enough, their child would recover.

His job is to gate keep CAMHS resources, my job is to advocate for the best treatment for my daughter.

Tootsweets84 · 05/03/2023 23:04

Do you have any idea how hard it is to get a diagnosis? I am self diagnosed with CPTSD related to childhood abuse. I've had anxiety attacks since I was 9 and periods of extreme depression to the point of ending up in A&E yet the NHS has only ever offered me 10 hours of counselling (with a counsellor, so not someone able to diagnose) or antidepressants. I was discharged from hospital a few years back following a suicide attempt after a 5 minute chat with their mental health team. No follow up whatsoever. Private services are out of my reach. If anything I'd say PTSD is very much under diagnosed as people are unable to access services

Lentilweaver · 05/03/2023 23:03

I have no problem believing PTSD exists. But if you go on Twitter or Insta, every second young person claims to be suffering from "trauma". That can't be right. The word is being bandied about for ordinary life events like breaking up with a boyfriend, failing an exam, or being overweight.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 23:03

Blort · 05/03/2023 23:02

Better than gatekeeping mental health.

How can I ‘gatekeep’ it? I have no such power.

Swipe left for the next trending thread