Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask a 14yo to read for 10 minutes?

80 replies

TheOtherBennetSister · 05/03/2023 19:54

Reading matters. It is a huge indicator of academic success.
Ds is middlingly bright and does okay in science, math and drama, but does quite badly in essay subjects - English and social studies.

He never ever reads. He spends hours watching Youtube videos on his phone, but never reads.

We've had a chat and I've said that slotting some reading into his life would be a good idea. He agrees in principal. I'm not expecting him to plough through War & Peace. Anything he wants to read is fine. Graphic novels, younger readers, Guiness Book of Records, factual books about his interests, ANYTHING. I've put quite a lot of effort into helping him find something that he might enjoy. Nothing appeals. So I ordered the local newspaper to be delivered every morning. He agreed to try it for a couple of weeks - just flick through over breakfast and read ONE story. But no, he's on his phone watching videos again. I've even showed him how to flick through, check out the headlines, and skim through something that caches his interest.

I'm frustrated, because I can see that forcing someone to read is not going to work, but I genuinely think he needs this. His brain is atrophying as he stares for hours at his phone. Am I wrong to push this? Is there a different way?

To be clear - there is no animosity and we're not arguing about it. I'm just trying to find a way to make it work.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Crumbcatcher · 07/03/2023 17:26

Thank you, I'll see if my phone does it, sounds ideal for me!

drspouse · 07/03/2023 09:54

It's a setting on Android phones.
Screen Time does the same on Ios.

TheOtherBennetSister · 06/03/2023 22:26

Crumbcatcher · 06/03/2023 21:52

That sounds great! What is the wellbeing app? I could definitely do with limiting myself.

I'm not sure if it's an app or a setting on the phone, but you set times e.g. 30 minutes of social media per day and your phone won't let you access more than that. Dd says it works because you use your time more thoughtfully - no point wasting the only time you have scrolling while waiting to go into a lesson. Save it for the bus when you actually want to use it and reply to messages. Obviously it's self-monitored, nothing to stop you overriding the settings but assuming you set the limits yourself why would you?

The other thing it does is turn your phone black and white after a certain time. That means your phone still works if you need to send a message to sort out a lift or something, but it's no fun for scrolling. I think you can set that one to kick in either at certain times every day, or after a certain amount of time.

I'll ask dd exactly what she uses.

OP posts:
Stepuptowardsinfinity · 06/03/2023 21:54

Great update OP.

Crumbcatcher · 06/03/2023 21:52

That sounds great! What is the wellbeing app? I could definitely do with limiting myself.

DancingDaughter50 · 06/03/2023 21:37

Read update well done op

DancingDaughter50 · 06/03/2023 21:36

@justasking111

I'm extremely well read and can't spell.

My dd isn't well read and is a very good speller.

Dacadactyl · 06/03/2023 21:32

Pleased to read this OP. Long may it continue.

TheOtherBennetSister · 06/03/2023 20:24

Update:
We had a family meeting.

Item 1: I said I was unhappy with the amount of phone use for ALL of us (Dh and I included) and suggested we trial a 1 month 'absolutely no phones at the table for any reason ever, including breakfast' rule. All agreed.
I asked the kids what would work for them to cut down phone use.

Eldest says she'll install a wellbeing app that limits the amount of time of mindless scrolling apps.
Ds says he would prefer a simple time deadline - no phones before 8.30am or after 7pm.
Youngest is only 11 so she is only allowed 2 X 20 minutes to look at her phone and send messages anyway.

Item 2: Reading.
I said that reading was non-negotiable and explained why.
Everyone chose personal goals that will work for them.
Ds and I did bedtime reading together and, youngest dd joined us. It was nice.

At breakfast this morning there were no phones. Everyone flicked through the paper. Youngest read a Beano. Eldest did the crossword. Ds still doesn't particularly want to read the paper but he's being good humoured about it
(reading is breakfast only btw - at dinner we chat).

This thread has been useful for me to work out the problem and kick my butt into parenting more deliberately and actively. Thanks all.

OP posts:
Whyisitdarkalready · 06/03/2023 11:49

Have you heard of PressReader? If you're a member of your library, you will be able to use your library card number to get completely free access on your phone, tablet or iPad. It's a website. Every day you can read pretty much every newspaper and there are endless magazines. Just in our house, we read SFX, Empire, Total Film, Beano, Prima, crafting magazines, PC Pro, Gaming, football magazines, National geographic, the list goes on. All free and the latest issues, plus you can get back dated issues.

I'm sure your son could find a magazine that matches an interest he has. Then, once he is back in the habit of reading, he may be more inclined to pick a fiction book.

Gruelle · 06/03/2023 11:23

Surely all this dragging to libraries and delivery of print newspapers is hopeless when it’s the actual sensation of a phone / iPad in the hand that they’re addicted to? Grin

  1. Choose a newspaper. Ensure he has its app on his phone. Get him to read one whole article of his choosing aloud, to you, every day.

  2. Get the kindle (or any other book download) app on his device. Actively encourage, bribe, force, him to download free sample extracts of any books he likes the look of. Again, get him to read, say a five minute extract, aloud, to you, every day. Eventually he’ll be interested enough in something to finish the sample - and either download the whole book or buy the printed volume.

I don’t envy you in this, I must say. It’s much easier to impose such activities when they’re younger and more biddable. It must be so frustrating!

Autumnflakes · 06/03/2023 11:10

Could you bribe him financially to read?

£1 for every newspaper/£5 per novel.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 06/03/2023 11:08

How are you buying your books? Sounds silly but mine are much more engaged with reading when they physically choose a book from a book shop rather than online.

GemmaSparkles · 06/03/2023 11:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BurbageBrook · 06/03/2023 11:03

How about he can go to bed half an hour later but he's only allowed to read in bed for that half hour?

sashh · 06/03/2023 05:17

Stealth reading.

He's old enough to cook a meal. So once a week he has to pick a recipe, write a shopping list and cook.

But he can only use cook books, either ones at home, or from the library.

One school I worked in had a 'do now' which was something on the board that the children had to do as soon as they came into the room. One thing you could put on the board was 5 mins 'silent reading'.

If every teacher put that on the board each child would have read for 30 mins.

Could you do 5 mins several times a day?

Emptycrackedcup · 06/03/2023 01:21

You just need to find the right book (suggestion on audio book is good too), what is he into?

snitzelvoncrumb · 06/03/2023 01:18

I have two dyslexic kids, a little younger so I’m not sure if this is ok for a 14yo. But they get devices taken away at dinner time. They get half an hour to read in bed before lights out. If they aren’t reading its lights out earlier. This has worked for us.
you could also find a book like Harry Potter that both your kids would like and read to the younger one and hopefully the older one might like to listen too.
Not everyone likes to read, audio books are nearly as good as actually reading so if that’s all you can get them to do that’s fine.

user1477391263 · 06/03/2023 00:32

Agree totally to coming down hard on screens, but bear in mind that reading-resisters will often do anything other than read! You may have to force this.

Every time a parent feels uncomfortable about "forcing" a teenager to do something, my response is "If your teen was at a boarding school or camp, would you be fine with the boarding school staff/camp staff forcing him/her to clean their room, do chores, shower, have set reading times etc"? Invariably the answer is "Yes, I'd be fine with them doing that, as they are in loco parentis." Sure. So parents, who are in actual parentis, should have no hesitation about doing the same things.

FridayImInLove1 · 05/03/2023 23:39

I'm a big fan of reading together. I really like mummadeze 's idea of reading your own books together in bed before lights out. But also I don't think it is ever too late to read aloud to another person. Dh has read all sorts to dd(12) over the years including Lord of the flies, Harry Potter (all) charlottes web, animal farm, watership down, lord of the rings (all) his dark materials (all) Emma etc. it's quiet a nice bonding activity for them too.

JoonT · 05/03/2023 23:01

If I had my way, there would be an hour set aside every day of a child's schooling, from age 5 to 16, when they would be read to in silence. Just one hour every day (scrap idiotic subjects like Geography to make room). At 5 or 6, it would be simple stuff like Wind in the Willows or James and the Giant Peach. By 12 or 13, they would be read to from the classics – Dickens, Jane Austen, Thomas Hardy, etc. Don't underestimate children. The majority of young teens would soon learn to process Dickens and Austen. It might take them a little time, but they'd get it.

I'd also make it a rule that the authors must be British. Children should be taught to know, and take pride in, the literature of their country. Later, of course, they will (hopefully) read books from around the world. But children need roots. And a nation is defined more by its literature than by anything else. It would never happen, of course, because the left would scream the house down. The idea of teaching British children to identify with their own writers, and be proud of their own literature! Ha, are you kidding me? The very idea! Oh my god, the left would have a collective nervous breakdown.

I'd also make it compulsory for children to read out loud to a teacher for 20 minutes, at least once a week – ideally from sections of dialogue.

backawayfatty1 · 05/03/2023 22:56

Suggestions of how to encourage more reading that we use 🙂

Trade phone time for reading. 30 mins reading = 30 mins phone

Have him read aloud to you

Let him stay up later provided he reads for that time

Read the same book & discuss it

JazbayGrapes · 05/03/2023 22:52

OH and I were talking about this today. He said that outside school he never read a book of fiction. Only national geographic and readers digest.

That is actually good enough. My DH and DS are the same. With DS, we tried everything, from libraries to Waterstones to treats for reading and even money... he suffered through popular books like Harry Potter and Hunger Games, and only things he actually enjoyed reading were books about tanks or planes or animals. National Geographic too...
at least it was easy to dress him up for the World Book Day

Beeeeeeeee · 05/03/2023 22:36

What are his interests? What’s he looking at on his phone and on YouTube? Can you obtain books which relate to his interests?

justasking111 · 05/03/2023 22:32

OH and I were talking about this today. He said that outside school he never read a book of fiction. Only national geographic and readers digest. He'd never read with a torch at night. Bed was for sleeping. He said that it was a waste of time. His spelling is atrocious for that reason I said.

I am actually horrified.

Swipe left for the next trending thread