Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that at 5'8, 9 stone is not overweight, for children or adults?

86 replies

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:20

Took ds (12) to gp earlier in the week, to be absolutly crucified for him being overweight. In front of ds no less. Which Im probably more annoyed at, he has asd eating difficulties enought without restricting his food anymore. But I genuinely dont look at him and see him as overweight. Hes not a skinny thing but hes not overweight neither imo. Im 5'9, if i dropped to 9 stone (I wish, havent been that weight since i was at school) people would question whether I was anorexic. Or have I turned into one of these mothers that genuinely cant see when their kids are overweight?

OP posts:
Doodaadoo · 05/03/2023 11:48

Oh god. I’m shorter and that weight, and people often comment on how slender I am… (I notice / am vigilant about these things since I suffered from an ED for many years). Your gp is ignorant, and I’d actually make a gentle complaint since they should be made aware of the damage that their words can do (even in inspiring you to start this thread/question your own views!).

in children, the best things you can do is to encourage daily activity (including walking to school of doable), plus generally ensuring (regardless of any junk they eat at school) that you give them veg, oily fish, pulses, berries and other fruit, eggs now and again, etc, you know the drill!

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:48

Im not mad for thinking that within that healthy bmi range there will be range of body types. Some will be lean and mean, some will be rounder and softer, and some will fall between the two (ifgwim). But neither is unhealthy? Its just different body types. Ds2 has a completely different body type to ds1, not more healthy or overweight, just different build.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 05/03/2023 11:47

A child's bmi should be lower than an adults to be healthy. Calculating these measurements he is towards the upper end of normal, so whilst he's not overweight, it's something to consider to ensure he doesn't gain relative weight to height. A healthy diet is all he needs basically.

People do forget that children should be leaner and also if young children are given to high calorie diet they grow taller quicker than they should.

PinkFrogss · 05/03/2023 11:45

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:39

thinking about it, gp didnt weigh him or measure his height, this was purely from looking at him. I took him home and measured his weight and height myself as I just couldnt believe he was overweight. I have two different sets of scales and both said the same thing so my scales are fine. I'll admit ds doesnt have a six pack, hes not overly active other than rugby once a week, pe at school and general walking about to and from school and playing.

That’s absolute madness.

I hope your son’s okay now he can see he’s not actually overweight

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 11:45

Aurorabored · 05/03/2023 11:36

He’s right at the top of the chart for height and very near the top for weight. That might mean he’s perfectly fine and he’s going to be over 6 foot tall or it might mean that he’s overweight and that has caused him to be tall for his age (it really is a thing.) I’d look at healthy eating (as much as he can manage with his food issues) and exercise, because that won’t do any harm whatever his BMI is.

www.rcpch.ac.uk/sites/default/files/Boys_2-18_years_growth_chart.pdf

How can he be overweight if he's not overweight.

Pd05 · 05/03/2023 11:45

I'm 5'5 and my weight fluctuates between just under and just over 10 stone and although my stomach isn't completely flat, I'm definitely not fat, so if your son is 5'8 and 9 stone, I can't see him being fat at all.

AllOfThemWitches · 05/03/2023 11:43

That's mad, I'm shorter and heavier and not overweight.

Aurorabored · 05/03/2023 11:43

From what you’ve said about your height and the height of males in the family he’s going to be tall. I wouldn’t worry too much but I’d encourage family walks, whatever sports he likes and whatever veg he’ll eat - even if that’s carrot sticks on the side at dinner.

Zooeyzo · 05/03/2023 11:42

You could be overweight at that age if your belly is flabby and you lack muscle in legs and arms. But regardless I would complain that the doc should have told you without your son there.

Manicule · 05/03/2023 11:41

In the far-off days of my prime - late teens - I was 5’7 and 9st. Not a ‘petite’ frame either. I was scarily thin, looking back. OP I think your GP sounds very uninformed.

Dinersaur · 05/03/2023 11:41

Aurorabored · 05/03/2023 11:39

My level of scientific understanding is at ‘it’s a thing’. The reasons are beyond me.

I was sure the thing was "obese kids are generally taller" but this isn't an obese kid.

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:39

thinking about it, gp didnt weigh him or measure his height, this was purely from looking at him. I took him home and measured his weight and height myself as I just couldnt believe he was overweight. I have two different sets of scales and both said the same thing so my scales are fine. I'll admit ds doesnt have a six pack, hes not overly active other than rugby once a week, pe at school and general walking about to and from school and playing.

OP posts:
Aurorabored · 05/03/2023 11:39

My level of scientific understanding is at ‘it’s a thing’. The reasons are beyond me.

Dinersaur · 05/03/2023 11:39

I thought that where obese children were growing taller, they were still obese even at their taller height. Otherwise how do they know they're not just tall? This kid is not obese at his taller height.

MissDollyMix · 05/03/2023 11:37

Weird! I’m 5’3 and 9 stone and would describe myself as slim! GP sounds ignorant.

PinkFrogss · 05/03/2023 11:36

Glad I’m not going mad and didn’t invent the height thing myself! Grin

Aurorabored · 05/03/2023 11:36

He’s right at the top of the chart for height and very near the top for weight. That might mean he’s perfectly fine and he’s going to be over 6 foot tall or it might mean that he’s overweight and that has caused him to be tall for his age (it really is a thing.) I’d look at healthy eating (as much as he can manage with his food issues) and exercise, because that won’t do any harm whatever his BMI is.

www.rcpch.ac.uk/sites/default/files/Boys_2-18_years_growth_chart.pdf

ZeldaB · 05/03/2023 11:35

Complain to the practice manager that the GP does not know the NHS healthy bmi range and instead of checking it wrongly assessed your child as overweight and humiliated and upset your healthy 12 yr old who has special needs.

My DS is 95th centile for his height. He’s extremely fit and solid muscle with bones of lead, has a six pack from rock climbing and huge thighs from rugby. But apparently his weight is ‘a concern’ 🙄

PinkFrogss · 05/03/2023 11:35

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 11:28

You're really going to need to explain that comment!!!

I can’t find the exact link now, but have seen it linked on previous threads. Paraphrasing slightly but I believe it was that overweight children tend to grow taller before puberty, and then gain less height during puberty compared to non overweight children.

Either way doesn’t seem relevant as pp has posted a screenshot of a BMI calculator that shows DS isn’t even overweight! I wouldn’t be seeing that GP again OP.

HeidiWhole · 05/03/2023 11:34

My son is much older but same height and weight and skinny as anything!

Whataretheodds · 05/03/2023 11:34

Sometimes height can be an indicator that a child is overweight.

Eh?

GoodChat · 05/03/2023 11:34

Im 5'6" and I'd look ill if I was 9st. Your GP is an idiot.

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:34

I didnt know overweight children could be taller, genuinely thought height was a factor attributed directly to mother and fathers height. But both my children are tall, since birth (or a long baby as the midwife said :D ) Ds1 took a stretch about this age and Im pretty sure ds2 will be the same. I think this year will be the year I officially become the shortest arse in the house!

OP posts:
honeylulu · 05/03/2023 11:33

Gosh no. I'm 5 ft 6 and just over 9 stone and am considered slim both anecdotally and in BMI chart. I've got a bit of chub on the abdomen and waist so could lose a bit without going into underweight but I can't imagine a doctor would consider my current weight problematic. Actually racking my brains I do remember going for my contraceptive check up age 18 not long after going to uni and my weight had gone up 8 stone to 9 stone in 6 months and I was "told off" and advised to try and lose some. I think it was the rapid increase that was of concern and also being quite young (the reasoning being if you gain a lot while still in teens is hard to lose it later and establish yourself as a slim adult). Could that be true of your lad?

ArtixLynx · 05/03/2023 11:32

absolutely NOT overweight.

my 16yo ds is inch shorter and same weight and gp keeps telling me to make sure he doesn't lose any weight as he'd like him a bit heavier tbh.

Swipe left for the next trending thread