Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that at 5'8, 9 stone is not overweight, for children or adults?

86 replies

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:20

Took ds (12) to gp earlier in the week, to be absolutly crucified for him being overweight. In front of ds no less. Which Im probably more annoyed at, he has asd eating difficulties enought without restricting his food anymore. But I genuinely dont look at him and see him as overweight. Hes not a skinny thing but hes not overweight neither imo. Im 5'9, if i dropped to 9 stone (I wish, havent been that weight since i was at school) people would question whether I was anorexic. Or have I turned into one of these mothers that genuinely cant see when their kids are overweight?

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 05/03/2023 12:52

I'm 5"9 and was anorexic at around 10 stone.

Seems odd to me, that's a healthy BMI.

GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 05/03/2023 12:22

At 5ft 2 I’m fairly slim at 9 stone (at my current 11 stone I’m a definitely overweight but not exactly big). YANBU….

….But, I’m not sure how Dr’s guage a child's weight, my eldest is autistic and lives with his dad, I raised concerns over his weight a few years ago because I knew for a fact he wasn’t being fed very much at home and it was lack of food not fussy eating, the NHS calculator put him as severely underweight 1st centile, he was skin and bone & you could count every rib, the Dr said his weight was fine because he was a low centile at birth so is never expected to be high!! A a premature birth he was definitely higher than 1st centile though!!!

His school also refused to agree to childrens they believed he was underweight but were also going out of their way to make and send him home with food!!!!

The mind boggles!

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 12:15

Id describe ds as neither fat nor thin, sturdy if anything. His brother was thin, ds1 is 6'1 and weights about 10 stone on a good day. I dont worry about it as I know when ds1 hits about 30 he will fill out, going by my brothers! I see what I consider obese children at school, ds is nothing close to like them.

OP posts:
Dinersaur · 05/03/2023 12:10

It's all relative. My 5 year old was 99th centile for length and 98th for weight at birth.

At 5, 98th for height and 69th for weight (for her height and age as per NHS calculator).

Visibly taller than many peers at nursery, i was the same. Her Dad was an 11lber and is tall. I'm only 5ft5 but the women on his side are all 5ft10, 5ft11.

She looks bigger than her peers and as a result I keep a really close eye on her, I'd like her to be closer to the 50% for weight and working on her growing faster than she's gaining weight rather than losing any weight.

Neither me nor her Dad have a slim build. Even when i was underweight and being encouraged by the doctors to gain weight i still had big legs 🤷🏻‍♀️ we are all different.

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 12:10

tbh I am more annoyed at her saying this in front of ds more than anything else. If ds wasnt present I would have discussed it further with her, but I really felt for him sitting there as the gp spoke about him being overweight and criticizing his died as though he wasnt there. I'm well aware ds doesnt have the optimal healthiest diet, hes asd and eats the sum total of about 6 different foods!

OP posts:
Dibblydoodahdah · 05/03/2023 12:09

Oh and when I was 12, my mum took me to our GP and he described me as fat. I was 5ft 4 and a size 8 (size 4 in today’s vanity sizing). I was definitely not fat. I was tiny. But I did have a round face. I was born with one and I will die with one!

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 12:09

People are taller than they used to be years ago because of better nutrition as well.

My parents arent particularly tall but they are products from the 30s! I was born in the 70s and am taller than average at 5'6 but not particularly tall. My dad is only 5'8 and getting shorter and my mum is 5'2 or something like that. All her family are quite short but would be considered average I think

Justalittlebitduckling · 05/03/2023 12:08

Those are exactly my stats and have been since I was a teenager, and I’m towards the lower side of a healthy weight. Maybe he could ideally tone up a bit and turn some fat into muscle, but then likely he would gain weight, not lose it. BMI is such a blunt tool. I feel sorry for the pressure put on young boys nowadays. It used to be only girls who faced this kind of crap, but instead of making life better for girls we’ve apparently just made it worse for boys too.

Oblomov23 · 05/03/2023 12:08

I can't get my head around this. It makes no sense. How can you possibly be overweight at that height and weight. No. Just no. Nonsense.

Dibblydoodahdah · 05/03/2023 12:07

@GoodVibesHere he’s 5 ft 8. That’s not child size.

I am so pissed off with people rolling out children are tall because they are overweight…my DCs are tall because their father is 6ft3. Their cousins are 6ft4 and 6ft (latter is a girl.) It’s in the fucking genes.

Some 12 year old boys have already started puberty and their muscles are developing so they weigh morr. There is a boy in my DS’ football team who is almost 6 ft at 12. He’s definitely not overweight but I’m sure that he weighs at least nine stone because otherwise he’d look ill.

MrsDoylesDoily · 05/03/2023 12:07

You've said a couple of times that he's not thin, so would you say he looks overweight?

Either way, the GP should've bloody weighed him!

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 12:03

I took him to gps because ds said he could feel a lump in one side of his chest. i couldnt feel anything untoward but thought id better get it checked out. Ds has a little bit of gynaecomastia, he had this as a baby and now again as he has started to go through puberty. There are not 'moobs' by any stretch of the imagination, and from what Ive been told from previous gp visit, is caused by puberty, common enough and will most likely disappear as he goes through puberty. He is not flabby, but hes not thin like his brother neither.

OP posts:
Aurorabored · 05/03/2023 12:03

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:48

Im not mad for thinking that within that healthy bmi range there will be range of body types. Some will be lean and mean, some will be rounder and softer, and some will fall between the two (ifgwim). But neither is unhealthy? Its just different body types. Ds2 has a completely different body type to ds1, not more healthy or overweight, just different build.

Absolutely. It’s also true that when a child naturally hovers around the higher centiles it’s easier for them to slip into being overweight without anyone noticing it. Puberty, the change to senior school, more freedom to buy snacks…

Standbyguest · 05/03/2023 12:03

Christ, I would complain to the surgery and ask for an explanation and also ask why he didn't weigh measure him

I was always a tall child meaning I weighed more than my peers, but was also very very slim, to the point it was suggested to me I had an ED.

BungleandGeorge · 05/03/2023 12:03

You can’t compare with an adult because people should get considerably heavier during puberty and you say he’s pre- pubescent. Those measurements are well within healthy range so either your measurements are wrong or it all seems really odd that it would be mentioned at all. what did you take him to the GP for? Did he get weighed in year 6?
I agree nothing should have been said in front of the child whether there was a concern or not

ImAvingOops · 05/03/2023 12:02

I do think it's worth pointing out to the GP practice manager that the GP didn't weigh or measure height or take into account that the family generally is tall and therefore height is likely to be genetic rather than caused by too many calories at too young an age.
And that children can very easily develop eating disorders, so a little bit of tact and sensitivity goes a long way. There's a difference between warning a child that they have to be careful because they are eating too much junk food and outright calling them fat.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/03/2023 12:00

I think the overweight/over tall thing is if child isn’t naturally meant to be tall. A 5f9 mum and over 6ft male relatives will mean a tall child.
My dd was always tall and is now 5ft 11 at 17 - so being much taller than peers wasn’t a sign of being over fed just a result of tall genes on both sides.
I’d do nhs calculator for his age. If it’s fine I’d ask for a follow up call to gp.

Pd05 · 05/03/2023 11:58

GoodVibesHere · 05/03/2023 11:52

People on this thread are comparing him to an adult, but he's 12 yrs old. That seems pretty young to be weighing 9st.

But he's also 5'8, which is really tall for a 12 year old. Ive been 5'5 since I was about 10, and I was tallest in my class until we were all about 13, excluding a select few.

titchy · 05/03/2023 11:58

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:39

thinking about it, gp didnt weigh him or measure his height, this was purely from looking at him. I took him home and measured his weight and height myself as I just couldnt believe he was overweight. I have two different sets of scales and both said the same thing so my scales are fine. I'll admit ds doesnt have a six pack, hes not overly active other than rugby once a week, pe at school and general walking about to and from school and playing.

Wow that's even worse. He basically looked at a child and body shamed them. Way to encourage eating disorders Angry Complain to the practice manager.

Aprilx · 05/03/2023 11:58

GoodVibesHere · 05/03/2023 11:52

People on this thread are comparing him to an adult, but he's 12 yrs old. That seems pretty young to be weighing 9st.

It’s quite young to be 5ft 8 too but he is.

runningpram · 05/03/2023 11:56

I'm pretty sure I was around 9stone at 5,4 when I was around 13ish. And wasn't classed as overweight then on school weigh-ins. My weight hasn't changed significantly since then bar during pregnancies. For a 5,ft8 lad it seems completely fine

MrsDoylesDoily · 05/03/2023 11:54

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:39

thinking about it, gp didnt weigh him or measure his height, this was purely from looking at him. I took him home and measured his weight and height myself as I just couldnt believe he was overweight. I have two different sets of scales and both said the same thing so my scales are fine. I'll admit ds doesnt have a six pack, hes not overly active other than rugby once a week, pe at school and general walking about to and from school and playing.

Is he particularly flabby or something?

It has to be something visual then if he didn't weigh him.

GoodVibesHere · 05/03/2023 11:52

People on this thread are comparing him to an adult, but he's 12 yrs old. That seems pretty young to be weighing 9st.

Aprilx · 05/03/2023 11:51

I have been 5ft 8 and 9 stone. I am still 5ft 8 but haven’t been close to 9 stone for many years. Anyway, when I weighed that I was widely considered to be very slim.

FlounderingFruitcake · 05/03/2023 11:49

That’s my height and weight and has been since I was about 13, excluding pregnancies! By most people’s standards I’m pretty slim e.g. wear a size 8.

I’d complain about the GP. It’s unacceptable that he said it, and he wasn’t even correct, because he didn’t bother to measure or weigh him. He sounds incompetent. Contact the practice manager.

Swipe left for the next trending thread