Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that at 5'8, 9 stone is not overweight, for children or adults?

86 replies

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 11:20

Took ds (12) to gp earlier in the week, to be absolutly crucified for him being overweight. In front of ds no less. Which Im probably more annoyed at, he has asd eating difficulties enought without restricting his food anymore. But I genuinely dont look at him and see him as overweight. Hes not a skinny thing but hes not overweight neither imo. Im 5'9, if i dropped to 9 stone (I wish, havent been that weight since i was at school) people would question whether I was anorexic. Or have I turned into one of these mothers that genuinely cant see when their kids are overweight?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheFlis12345 · 05/03/2023 18:29

I’m 5”8, 10 stone and size 10. I’ve been 9 stone and at that weight I am a size 8 and definitely start looking too thin.

2022again · 05/03/2023 18:25

seeing as she examined him with his shirt off, i presume, i am wondering if he shows a high degree of body fat?? BMI is a very blunt tool and as you say from this you would not presume him to be overweight (paticularly if his genetics are likely to indicate height of 6 feet plus), but is it distributed in an unhealthy pattern? Unfortunately I do see a lot of boys with moobs and stomach fat reminiscent of middle-aged men...there is a definitely a body type that could indicate potential health issues that people can be a bit blind to, mainly because boys these days are likely to be doing far,far less exercise than their parents did when young.

Pubesofsoberness · 05/03/2023 18:22

My almost 12 year old is similar, 5"7 and a bit under 9 stone last time he weighed himself . His older brother is 6"2 so I think he will probably be the same

I'd put in a complaint, totally irresponsible of the Dr to be talking like that infront of a child who isn't over weight and has a limited diet due to asd as it is

Starchipenterprise · 05/03/2023 18:15

I am the same weight-and much shorter and was warned recently not to lose more weight as it would take my BMI too low!

Saschka · 05/03/2023 18:14

@randomusername03 Fair enough! You should get him into basketball, sounds like he is going to be pretty tall and he could keep you in your retirement!

footstoop · 05/03/2023 18:12

@Saschka no I know it's normal to grow that late but I didn't think it was normal for every tall person to be normal height & then only grow later on?

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 18:12

he's definitely 5'8, well maybe a bawhair away, 172 cm. I'm 5'9 and theres nothing between us really. He is literally head and shoulders taller than everyone in his class bar one other girl who is really tall as well.

Right enough there was no referral to a dietician. As his diet is restricted she said to cut down on his portion size. Which I think he is starting to do off his own accord as Ive noticed the last few days he has not been finishing his meals and leaving about half or sometimes less.

OP posts:
Saschka · 05/03/2023 18:09

footstoop · 05/03/2023 18:03

heights a weird one, myself & DB were average height at 12 but I then grew quite a bit in 2 yrs (around 5ft 10). DB grew a bit later on & settled at 16, he's 6ft 2.

That is normal - girls usually stop growing around age 14, boys continue growing until about age 18. Look at the growth charts.

footstoop · 05/03/2023 18:08

I am so pissed off with people rolling out children are tall because they are overweight…

Is this a thing now? Some of us are just from tall families! My mum is 5ft 8 & dad is 6ft 2, uncle is 6ft 4. Similar for DH.

footstoop · 05/03/2023 18:03

heights a weird one, myself & DB were average height at 12 but I then grew quite a bit in 2 yrs (around 5ft 10). DB grew a bit later on & settled at 16, he's 6ft 2.

Saschka · 05/03/2023 18:02

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 17:59

I was my height now from 11. 5'6.

He might not grow much more in height.

You are presumably female though, and may well have entered puberty by age 11 - OP says her son has not yet started puberty, and boys usually have a big growth spurt when they do. Compare the boy/girl growth charts, they are completely different.

Choconut · 05/03/2023 18:01

TBF 150ml of apple juice has 15g of sugar in it and none of the fibre that he'd get if he ate the fruit so it's not a healthy choice BUT he has ASD for fucks sake. I was literally just talking on another thread about anorexia in people with ASD. You cannot as a doctor be saying this shit in front of any child, let alone one with ASD who will thrive on the obsession, rules and routine that anorexia brings with it.
I am the first to say just because your child doesn't look fat to you doesn't mean they aren't. But there are far bigger things at stake here. After giving him so much shit about his diet I really hope the dr referred you to a dietician, but they I bet they didn't. Why get someone help when you can just make them feel really bad instead, that'll learn 'em - not!

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 17:59

I was my height now from 11. 5'6.

He might not grow much more in height.

Saschka · 05/03/2023 17:57

Are you 100% sure he is 5’8? Because that is really REALLY tall for a pre-pubescent 12 year old. Significantly above 99.6th centile, meaning he is on track to be over 6’7 as an adult - way taller than your DS1 or brothers.

It isn’t impossible, obviously some people are 6’7, but he would be a good foot taller than the rest of his class, which is a lot.

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 17:56

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 17:47

GP said he was overweight, she emphasised overweight several times in the appointment. Demanded to know his diet and you'd think id given ds heroin when i said he gets a 150ml carton of apple juice at lunch time. I wouldnt say she was aggressive but she definitely came across as hostile. Tbh I just wanted out as I didnt want ds to hear anymore than he had.

Apple juice is well known as a gateway drink. He'll be on the pomegranate before you know it

randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 17:54

As for the height thing, Im going by all the boys on my side of the family being tall, all 6'+ . I guess ds could be bucking the trend but I very much doubt it. His cousin who is 15 is about 5'11 already and built very much like ds, solid n sturdy as opposed to being waif like (which ds1 was), not overweight neither imo.

OP posts:
randomusername03 · 05/03/2023 17:47

GP said he was overweight, she emphasised overweight several times in the appointment. Demanded to know his diet and you'd think id given ds heroin when i said he gets a 150ml carton of apple juice at lunch time. I wouldnt say she was aggressive but she definitely came across as hostile. Tbh I just wanted out as I didnt want ds to hear anymore than he had.

OP posts:
Saschka · 05/03/2023 16:23

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 16:06

That sounds incredibly unscientific. We all have genetic markers that come from further back than our parents

There’s a very wide range on either side of the estimated height. My DF was 6’4, DM is 4’10, I have a predicted height range of between 4’11 and 5’10. So anywhere within the normal adult female height range then.

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 16:06

TheTeenageYears · 05/03/2023 14:01

In the red book there is a calculation for predicting height based on parents heights. If you do that calculation and see which percentile that puts a child on at 20 (or whatever the upper age is) and they are in line with that then surely that's a good indicator of their natural height without the possibility of more food being responsible for their higher than average height during childhood.

That sounds incredibly unscientific. We all have genetic markers that come from further back than our parents

TheTeenageYears · 05/03/2023 14:01

In the red book there is a calculation for predicting height based on parents heights. If you do that calculation and see which percentile that puts a child on at 20 (or whatever the upper age is) and they are in line with that then surely that's a good indicator of their natural height without the possibility of more food being responsible for their higher than average height during childhood.

ChildminderMum · 05/03/2023 13:36

So he has a perfectly healthy BMI for a 12 year old boy Confused

I'd write to the practice manager and point out that the GP was incorrect from a health point of view, and highly inappropriate to discuss a child's body negatively in front of them.

Sarahcoggles · 05/03/2023 13:32

What exactly did the GP say?

MatildaTheCat · 05/03/2023 13:22

A lot of children around this age go through a phase of looking a little bit plump. Puppy fat used to be a very common phrase. Then they shoot up and it all settles down. Could this be an explanation?

Although your GP sounds very over zealous he will be seeing an explosion of overweight and obese children and no doubt it will affect his attitude. I’m a member of a club where I have swum for the last 30 odd years and in that time it has gone from being incredibly rare to see an overweight child to sadly common.

Clearly he got it wrong in your case but IF your DS didn’t grow any taller and continued to gain weight he would be at risk. You know that’s incredibly unlikely but your GP doesn’t.

picklemewalnuts · 05/03/2023 13:12

My sons always looked overweight, and struggled to get trousers to fit. They are teddy bear shaped. Big muscular bottoms so trousers were a nightmare. Not particularly broad in the shoulders, so their waist looked big in comparison. And a bit of a tummy.
Both quite wide.

As adults they have no trouble with trousers because of the waist/length sizing, rather than age.

They look great. They'll never be lanky, they are shorter, broader men.

Manicule · 05/03/2023 13:02

Just to add to my comment above that I was 9st and very slim indeed at 5'7 in my late teens.

I was an overweight child, no two ways about it. Always the fattest in my class. I hated it and hated myself. Friends' mothers made snide, hurtful comments to me about it. And one day I had exactly the same experience as your DS, @randomusername03 when a visiting school doctor made me strip to my vest and knickers, weighed me and cross-questioned me in a very hostile and disapproving way about what I ate and how much. No parent present or permission asked. I was desperately upset, went home and sobbed to my mum over it. Must have been about 8, maybe 9?

That sort of thing is why I lost a drastic amount of weight at 18 and became very rigid in my eating, eventually developing a full-blown eating disorder, existing on 500 calories a day and stopping my menstrual cycle for over a year. Which was hell in a different way.

All of that is past now (although I’ll never have an uncomplicated relationship with food), but that GP should not be making those remarks in front of your DS, trust me. It can do a lot of damage.